Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people keep dangerous dogs???

490 replies

Ori18 · 31/03/2022 10:23

Another little boy pronounced dead this morning on the news - the toddler who was mauled on Monday and subsequently suffered a cardiac arrest. The dogs in question are not thought to be banned under the Dangerous Dogs Act - but I'd be interested to know which breeds they were as it's quite evident that certain breeds are more dangerous to children than others - why aren't Rottweiler's on the banned list for example?

And even though Pitt Bull Terriers are banned, people still go out of their way to own them, and are then shocked when they attack small children, maul babies, tear limbs off people. It makes me so angry. Same goes for German Shepherds and Staffordshire Bull Terriers. The Bull Terrier dogs are/were specifically bred for fighting - why would you even consider having one of these types of dogs around a baby or a small child? What is going on there? Is it lack of intelligence? Lack of education? Lack of giving a fuck? Because I think there need to be more dogs on the banned list, and heavier penalties served to people who insist on breaking the law to keep these dogs.

Aggressive/dangerous dogs and babies/small children do not mix, should never be mixed and it shouldn't take more deaths for the law to change around this. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ChairCareOh · 31/03/2022 12:45

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Thisismynamenow · 31/03/2022 12:41

@AHungryCaterpillar

Here we go with the “all dogs can be dangerous” nonsense well I know I would fancy my chances more with a jack Russell/poodle/chihuahua than a staff, pit or Rottweiler... some dogs have far more ability to seriously injure or kill than others so no they aren’t all as “dangerous”
Since i've been given stitches from a Jack Russell Terrier but never been given any sort of injury from a Rottie or Staffy I'd argue you're completely wrong and go as far as saying you're part of the problem (which is not being correctly educated in dogs).

Its about raising and training dogs not the breed.

The amount of times people comment 'on how well behaved my dangerous staffy is' whilst their little yorkie is trying to bite my own dog, is ridiculous.

I'm terrified of letting my dog off the lead (despite his recall being fantastic) incase he gets attacked by another dog but he's blamed because he's the staffy.

Its the owner who causes the issues, not the dog.

VampireMoney · 31/03/2022 12:40

@Ori18

I'm genuinely curious to know - the posters who have a big dog - would you happily leave your baby/toddler ALONE in a room with your dog? Seriously, an honest question. Would you feel comfortable with this?
That's a loaded question and you know it.

But I'll answer anyway. I wouldn't leave ANY small child with ANY type of dog irrespective of size or breed. That doesn't mean I don't trust them, that just means I understand that ANY dog can be unpredictable because it's an animal, not a 'fur baby'.

Goodbyetowinter · 31/03/2022 12:38

It's obvious that dogs with powerful jaws cannot be stopped when attacking a human. Their jaws can't be prised open. A smaller breed can inflict a lot of damage in a short time, but it is possible to pick them up and open their jaws. It's a risk any parent who has a dog and small children take and should be fully aware of the risks. Unfortunately some people care less about their children than their status symbol dog.

Ori18 · 31/03/2022 12:36

Just seen @Ringmaster27's post. Thanks for your honest reply

OP posts:
NoLongerATeacher · 31/03/2022 12:36

@MatildaTheCat

Aggressive/dangerous dogs and babies/small children do not mix, should never be mixed and it shouldn't take more deaths for the law to change around this. AIBU?

No dogs are completely safe around children let alone very young ones. There needs to be a concerted campaign to address this. I believe some breeds are very highly represented in domestic attacks but there isn’t one dog I would trust 100% including my own soppy mutt.

Exactly! Ive had Golden Retrievers for years and never ever left them alone with my children when they were young. I read once that a goldie had sat on a baby’s head and suffocated it ! Vigilance, vigilance and more vigilance is needed when you have a dog and children.
VampireMoney · 31/03/2022 12:35

I was raised with German shepherds and Rottweilers. The only dog that ever injured me was someone's chihuahua - completely unprovoked because I was taught from a young age how to respect animals.

I've owned German shepherds and now own American Akitas. The only dog that ever injured my DC was someone's Jack Russell - totally unprovoked as she was taught from a young age how to respect animals.

Responsible large dog owners train their dogs and teach their children to be respectful of them. Anyone letting their child pull on the ears of ANY dog is a bloody idiot and should have neither dogs nor kids.

And then you've got toy owners who think because their dogs are small they're beyond reproach, and appear to be highly complacent about how much damage a toy dog can do to a small child's face. But somehow that's ok because at least you're not dead.

Ori18 · 31/03/2022 12:35

I'm genuinely curious to know - the posters who have a big dog - would you happily leave your baby/toddler ALONE in a room with your dog? Seriously, an honest question. Would you feel comfortable with this?

OP posts:
Ori18 · 31/03/2022 12:32

If we take the general consensus of most dog owners on here who advocate that any dog has the potential to be a dangerous dog then in answer to @oatlattetogo post I think bigger/stronger dogs such as German Shepherds and Rottweilers are more dangerous because they are bigger, stronger, more physically powerful. It's about the size and strength of the animal (or should be.)

Yes, any dog could bit you and cause you distress (potentially) but a little child is more likely to be killed in this fashion by the breeds I've mentioned, due to their power. So purely based on physical size and strength alone, I do stand by my opinion that certain breeds are more dangerous to children than others.

OP posts:
Sushiii · 31/03/2022 12:30

I don’t think it’s as easy as identifying a select few “dangerous” breeds. I have a Jack Russell who can be a bit grumpy so I never have him around my toddler niece. If I visit them I always leave him at home. It only takes a second to turn your back and something awful to happen.

wetotter · 31/03/2022 12:29

And don't be fooled by handbag/companion breeds, little dogs are good at jumping & you can get some really poorly though-out cross breeds with really bad temperament as with a dog of any size!

If it's a terrier, even a small one, it's likely to have a high prey drive, and can easily be trained to kill (look at his many try to take squirrels). You see dachshund and see small and cute? You're actually looking at dogs bred to take on badgers and boar.

A well trained, responsibly owned dog is not the problem.

Ownership without regard for training, breed traits and safety is a massive problem.

Banning breeds hasn't worked, and won't work just because you add more breeds to the list.

Ringmaster27 · 31/03/2022 12:28

Personally, I don’t think it’s about breed at all. I don’t trust any dog around young children whether it be a Pit Bill or a Cockapoo.
My Dsis has the most beautiful, gentle, puppy-like Stafford mix breed. He is a big boy and you can see the sheer power behind the muscle on him. I happily cuddle him, play with him, roll around with him. But my young DCs are never in the same room as him, and are only around him when he’s got his harness & short lead on, and is under the control of my Dsis’s DP. He’s never been aggressive, or given us any indication that he might attack, but all it takes is a noise or a touch from a child that he doesn’t like, and there would be no stopping him. It’s not a risk I’m willing to take, no matter how sure I am of his gentle nature. There’s never a 100% guarantee.

Handtwin · 31/03/2022 12:28

Anyone who allows their child to pull their dogs ears as a pp stated is a massive part of the problem (and an idiot)

I have a greyhound, he's big but the softest, gentlest most placid dog I've ever met. He literally wouldn't hurt a fly and he loves children. I still don't 100% trust him around children because he's a dog. Any dog can turn at anytime. He's always supervised around kids and there's always a quiet place for him to go if he gets fed up. Children are taught to respect the dogs boundaries. And whilst I obviously don't want a child to get hurt I do this to protect the dog too.

oatlattetogo · 31/03/2022 12:25

@CounsellorTroi Indeed.

My family have had 4 German Shepherds over the years. 3 from puppies (but not from the same breeder) and one rescue. They have all been absolutely fantastic family dogs. It might just be a) luck b) that we are responsible dog owners and have trained/treated them well or c) it might be that actually they’re not the dangerous killing machines that the OP is suggesting.

I think it’s unlikely to just be option a, to be honest Hmm

Hoppinggreen · 31/03/2022 12:24

Anyone who says they trust their dog 100% (especially with their child) is an idiot and part of the reason these things happen
Dogs are animals and as such have a certain amount of unpredictability, added to that most people can’t really ready their dogs properly so think a dog is ok with something when it’s not or don’t see any warning signs

MarrymeTomHardy · 31/03/2022 12:23

Sorry, that's in reply to ChairCareOh

MarrymeTomHardy · 31/03/2022 12:22

I don't trust children not to hurt the dog, and the dog not to naturally react to that pain.
It is my job to keep both dog and children safe hence why I wouldn't leave them unsupervised.
This is a dog who was attacked by an off lead black lab, resulting in him needing stitches & the owner gave no f*s because it's a lab!
All dogs can be dangerous...
I agree that the complacency of some dog owners on this thread is worrying at best.Hmm

WheresSpringGone · 31/03/2022 12:20

Great post WiddlinDiddlin, I know many people like yourself who are clearly responsible with bull breeds (as well as other powerful breeds), understand them and own/train them properly.

And (this is not directed at you) I have a Rottweiler and a Staffy cross (rescue) but I will not spout shit on here about nanny dogs etc. With just a few generations of breeding, poor temperaments can be bred into breeds just as they can be bred out but dogs are being deliberately bred to be powerful and aggressive by shitty people that shouldn't be allowed to own dogs.

What is the solution? because it's all very well these breeds have the potential to be owned responsibly but it is clear that all too often they are not and are like a magnet to absolute, complete and utter idiots that frankly shouldn't be allowed a pet at all and are often shitty parents too. And make it their pathetic life mission to terrorise the public.

These people are not only risking their own children but other people's children and other people's pets. A friend of mine had two puppies killed by bull breeds whilst walking in the park in Nottingham.

What can be done? We just hold our hands up and say nothing can be done? Dogs don't kill people, people do? That sounds familiar....

We're going round in circles, meanwhile more children are being attacked and killed by dogs owned by cretins and there are the headlines we see, I bet there are so many dog attacks we don't hear about.

RMS0209 · 31/03/2022 12:20

@XelaM
No I know for a fact as do you that it would cause harm if either breed of dog was to bite.
So can I take that to mean we just ban all big breeds of dogs? We just keep our Chi's & Pugs? That'll be the Labrador and Collies out too then...
No all dogs CAN be dangerous, as I say it's how they are raised. Until you've had a breed of that certain dog I don't think you can say that.

CounsellorTroi · 31/03/2022 12:19

Where are you getting your statistics from, for German Shepherds being dangerous dogs? Because from looking at the list of fatal dog attacks in the UK I can only see 3 fatal attacks from German Shepherds in the last 20 years. One of those was an elderly lady and one of those was an incident where an adult man was killed breaking up a fight between two dogs. The other death was very sadly a 10 year old boy.

German Shepherds were used as guide dogs in the past. Which says a lot about how generally dangerous they are.

mediciempire · 31/03/2022 12:16

@nearlyspringyay

Why should rotties be on the dangerous dogs list, or most of the breeds you mention? I don't think anyone has been killed in the UK by a Rottweiler. They're usually dopey sods.

Any dog can be a dangerous dog.

Kellie Lynch, David Kearney, Cadey-Lee Deacon, Archie-Lee Hirst and James Rehill were all killed by Rottweilers.
Thelnebriati · 31/03/2022 12:16

Should dog owners have to take out third party insurance?

XelaM · 31/03/2022 12:14

aren't*

XelaM · 31/03/2022 12:14

@RMS0209 So if a Rottweiler decides to bite, it's just as likely to cause the same amount of harm as if a Chi or a Pug decided to bite 🙄 utterly ridiculous to spout the whole thing about "all dogs being dangerous" when plainly some are too strong and heavy to be controllable in a dangerous situation and others are

oatlattetogo · 31/03/2022 12:14

@Ori18

Ok - let's rephrase the question. You want a dangerous dog (which does include Rottweilers and German Shepherds) and you also want a child. IS IT WORTH THE RISK to put the two together?

No is the answer. And lol to all the posters who clearly think this would never happen to them, because their dog is kind and sweet and likes it when the kids rough-handle them.

The majority of replies on this thread make me lose hope..........denial denial denial

Where are you getting your statistics from, for German Shepherds being dangerous dogs? Because from looking at the list of fatal dog attacks in the UK I can only see 3 fatal attacks from German Shepherds in the last 20 years. One of those was an elderly lady and one of those was an incident where an adult man was killed breaking up a fight between two dogs. The other death was very sadly a 10 year old boy.

In the same time span there have been 2 very young children killed by Jack Russells and a baby killed by a Lakeland terrier. So statistically they are much more of a danger to young children, yet you seen a bit fixated on German Shepherds. Is that because they look big and scary?