Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people keep dangerous dogs???

490 replies

Ori18 · 31/03/2022 10:23

Another little boy pronounced dead this morning on the news - the toddler who was mauled on Monday and subsequently suffered a cardiac arrest. The dogs in question are not thought to be banned under the Dangerous Dogs Act - but I'd be interested to know which breeds they were as it's quite evident that certain breeds are more dangerous to children than others - why aren't Rottweiler's on the banned list for example?

And even though Pitt Bull Terriers are banned, people still go out of their way to own them, and are then shocked when they attack small children, maul babies, tear limbs off people. It makes me so angry. Same goes for German Shepherds and Staffordshire Bull Terriers. The Bull Terrier dogs are/were specifically bred for fighting - why would you even consider having one of these types of dogs around a baby or a small child? What is going on there? Is it lack of intelligence? Lack of education? Lack of giving a fuck? Because I think there need to be more dogs on the banned list, and heavier penalties served to people who insist on breaking the law to keep these dogs.

Aggressive/dangerous dogs and babies/small children do not mix, should never be mixed and it shouldn't take more deaths for the law to change around this. AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Ponoka7 · 31/03/2022 13:22

I had GS and found them to be even tempered and a lot more 'sane' than smaller dogs, probably due to intelligence and their ability to bond with us. That's what is lacking in the XL Bull breeds, they don't have the same reasoning and bonding. If you can't control your large breed verbally then it is a danger to everyone, including yourself. GS is a breed that can be completely trained and controlled.
Small terrier types are more dangerous than a GS. The main danger with a GS is when you have sibling mating down the line. I've had my GSs (I've had many over 40 years) attacked by smaller dogs. One was permanently scared by a cairn terrier. My GS didn't retaliate but looked at me to sort it.
I had designed my garden with a big walk in kennel and run, so at school getting ready time and other manic times, my dog would have peace.
The issue is that people are Ill equipt to have any dog.

Bcs174 · 31/03/2022 13:21

I think owners of dogs that attack should be charged with whatever the dog does. If it kills someone, then the owner gets charged with manslaughter. I have a large dog but never let it off it’s lead as if it ran to a child to play, it would knock the child over and probably make the child scared for life. 99% of the time it would come back on recall but I don’t take the risk.

Reading that list of deaths caused by dogs, one woman has drunk 2 bottles of wine and had 10 spliffs whilst in charge of a kid but no charges despite clearly being incapable of making rational decisions.

FTEngineerM · 31/03/2022 13:21

why aren't Rottweiler's on the banned list for example

Because they’re not dangerous..

They’re large and fiercely protective, that does not equal dangerous.

ButtockUp · 31/03/2022 13:21

@nearlyspringyay

Why should rotties be on the dangerous dogs list, or most of the breeds you mention? I don't think anyone has been killed in the UK by a Rottweiler. They're usually dopey sods.

Any dog can be a dangerous dog.

There have been a few deaths attributed to Rottweilers, sadly.
TortugaRumCakeQueen · 31/03/2022 13:20

I look after dogs for a living.

I've looked after Rottweilers, German Shepherds, Huskies etc, and they have all been very sweet. I did look after one dog that attacked me every day, for no apparent reason. I still have the scars to this day (some 9 years later) - this dog was a tiny Shih Tzu. I have met several Shih Tzu's since, and they have all been viscious.

To my mind, if you have small children, you should not have ANY dog. The Shih Tzu that bit me, only got as far as hands and feet, but if I was 2 years old, he could have reached my face and neck.

Toddlers are especially erratic in their movements, which dogs hate, and they can pull at dogs ears and tails. It's understandable that many dogs won't like this and may snap. They also hate drunk people for the same reason!

I used to have a Husky, who was the softest girl ever, but I could tell she hated the unpredictability of toddlers, so if any small children came over, she was locked away - just to be safe.

If I was the Queen of the World, I'd make it is against the law to own a dog if there were any children in the house that were under the age of 7.

TiddleyWink · 31/03/2022 13:20

I don’t get it. What do people get out of a dog that is worth risking the safety of their children in their own homes? Even if it’s a 0.000001% risk?

Why would you have anyone or anything in your home that you acknowledge should never be left alone with your child? I find it utterly mystifying that people would choose to have an animal that has the potential to kill their child, and which can never be trusted 100%, in their home.

Clearly I’m missing something because I simply don’t understand it.

Something needs to be done, I feel sick every time I open the news and read of yet another child’s death - and what about the countless unreported injuries? It’s unforgivable that we as a society are allowing this.

InkySquid · 31/03/2022 13:19

First off, 25kg can be a large Labrador does that mean labs go onto your ridiculous list of dogs that should be kept in kennels away from kids?

25kg is actually a small labrador!

biscuitbreak · 31/03/2022 13:19

I haven't read the full thread but the original post is very ignorant. OP you are mistaking powerful dogs for dangerous dogs. Yes it stands to reason that a German shepherd or Staffie is harder to control than a jack Russell but smaller dogs can be nasty too. The issue is bad ownership.

BitOutOfPractice · 31/03/2022 13:17

@DameHelena

OP, you're very ignorant/prejudiced about dog breeds. Have a quick google perhaps.
Perhaps you should!

I knew everyone would be on here saying “Staffies are just big softies, mine wouldn’t hurt a fly, did you know they were known as nanny dogs?”

Yet they crop up with monotonous regularity on the lists of fatalities over the years.

Some breeds ARE more dangerous because they have been bred with physical characteristics that can do more harm.

SirChenjins · 31/03/2022 13:16

DO YOUR RESEARCH A DOG MOST LIKELY TO BITE IS A CHIHUAHUA. What a shock to you

Pretty sure the last figures showed it was a Labrador. Fatalities are a different story though - no surprises for guessing which breeds are responsible.

pinkstripeycat · 31/03/2022 13:15

Hoppinggreen

Anyone who says they trust their dog 100% (especially with their child) is an idiot and part of the reason these things happen

I agree with you totally. We have a rehomed (no ill treatment) weimarana, soft as putty, daft as a brush and 2 teenagers. STILL wouldn’t trust the dog and always tell the kids not to shove their faces in the dogs face because it only takes one snap

BoodleBug51 · 31/03/2022 13:14

Let's be honest, most people who have dogs and children take appropriate action and keep both safe.

It's only the very small minority that are too thick/arrogant/ignorant to. And unfortunately their kids are the ones who pay the price.

Sleepy86 · 31/03/2022 13:12

YABVU

As the owner of a German Shepherd and having been brought up with a Rottweiler I know first hand what these dogs are like!

I will tell you that years ago my mum and stepdad got a Labrador when my brothers were little 6&7 maybe, and that Labrador was awfully aggressive! He used to bark and snarl at us all until we were up against a wall, yet you don't list labs as being aggressive?

My dad and step mum have a GSD who is soft as muck and a Springer Spaniel who is awful! The last time I visited their house the spaniel jumped up at me and bit my clothing and put a huge rip in it, but again, according to you not an aggressive dog? I would rather my daughter be in a room with 10 GSD's that have the temperament of mine and my dads GSD than that Spaniel as I don't trust it as far as I can throw it!

I would never leave my 4Y/O DD alone with a dog as they can turn on a dime, but I have also taught my DD to respect dogs and to not poke or prod, jump on, pull fur, approach whilst sleeping, approach strange dogs etc, because that's what a responsible pet owner & parent does.

I'll be honest though and you sound like you've got some sort of vendetta against big dogs and I doubt anyone will change your mind, despite lots of anecdotal evidence of how great these dogs are. You're convinced they should be banned just because of their size and had you read up on these breeds you will know that they are very rarely to blame for deaths, but yet you have your blinkers on and refuse to listen 🤷‍♀️

senschoolhelp · 31/03/2022 13:11

[quote Pops100]@Infinitemoon

First off, 25kg can be a large Labrador does that mean labs go onto your ridiculous list of dogs that should be kept in kennels away from kids?

Secondly, you do not have the right to say someone cannot control two dogs at once as an overall picture , yes someone people can't I give you that but it's not everyone BUT just like SOME people with small breeds can't socialize their dogs correctly hence why so many small dogs have the so-called "little dog syndrome".

I am a working dog handler and female. Does this anger you? I mean according to you I simply cannot do my job correctly.

I think you should seriously consider yourself as an incompetent dog owner because people like you are what give dog breeds a bad name.

DO YOUR RESEARCH A DOG MOST LIKELY TO BITE IS A CHIHUAHUA. What a shock to you.

Get back in your box. [/quote]
👍

senschoolhelp · 31/03/2022 13:10

@monkeysmum21

I've had German Shepperds in the past. I know lots of people who have them and never heard a problem. I don't know why you label them as dangerous, I have the feeling that your are just against dogs.
I think people see them as police dogs so think there dangerous. In fact they are used for there intelligence not because they are aggressive. Our German shepherd is an amazing family dog, who is well exercised and mentally stimulated, I agree they need this but because they are intelligent, no my dogs are never left alone with my children but that's because I'm a responsible owner and no dog can ever be trusted 100%. German shepherds have really got a bad reputation but in reality they are amazing, loyal, loving dogs, ours literally lives for his family, he loves people and other dogs, in my experience it's small dogs we have had problems with owners allowing them off the lead, no control over them and then they are nipping and barking at our dog, owner can't get them back because they have no recall, we have also had this with cockerpoo's again no control over them, our dog is always put back in the lead when another dog is approaching and we have full control over him.
pinkstripeycat · 31/03/2022 13:07

I remember as a child my dad talking about renewing the dog licence so they did exist. It’s just difficult to enforce them. Some people don’t microchip their dogs so no way if tracing who they belong to.

worriedatthistime · 31/03/2022 13:07

We have a collie and also had two before , that were 2 and 3 when we had kids
We always kept the kids and dogs apart if we were not there
My first 2 collies were very gentle and good with kids but you never know
My kids were also not allowed to pull them around or climb on them etc
Our current collie is a bit more nervous and he is fine around my teenagers and ok with kids but if kids are here too long he will take himself away from them as he seems to only be able to tolerate them for a few hrs
When he does this we then take him to another room and close door so he is not disturbed as he is telling us enough is enough
Very subtle warnings dogs give when uncomfortable and so many don't know wjat they are of think they arebeing cute

RMS0209 · 31/03/2022 13:06

[quote Pops100]@Infinitemoon

First off, 25kg can be a large Labrador does that mean labs go onto your ridiculous list of dogs that should be kept in kennels away from kids?

Secondly, you do not have the right to say someone cannot control two dogs at once as an overall picture , yes someone people can't I give you that but it's not everyone BUT just like SOME people with small breeds can't socialize their dogs correctly hence why so many small dogs have the so-called "little dog syndrome".

I am a working dog handler and female. Does this anger you? I mean according to you I simply cannot do my job correctly.

I think you should seriously consider yourself as an incompetent dog owner because people like you are what give dog breeds a bad name.

DO YOUR RESEARCH A DOG MOST LIKELY TO BITE IS A CHIHUAHUA. What a shock to you.

Get back in your box. [/quote]
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Pops100 · 31/03/2022 13:04

@Infinitemoon

First off, 25kg can be a large Labrador does that mean labs go onto your ridiculous list of dogs that should be kept in kennels away from kids?

Secondly, you do not have the right to say someone cannot control two dogs at once as an overall picture , yes someone people can't I give you that but it's not everyone BUT just like SOME people with small breeds can't socialize their dogs correctly hence why so many small dogs have the so-called "little dog syndrome".

I am a working dog handler and female. Does this anger you? I mean according to you I simply cannot do my job correctly.

I think you should seriously consider yourself as an incompetent dog owner because people like you are what give dog breeds a bad name.

DO YOUR RESEARCH A DOG MOST LIKELY TO BITE IS A CHIHUAHUA. What a shock to you.

Get back in your box.

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 31/03/2022 13:03

Many people just don't have the intelligence to be able to own a dog, any dog. They can't understand the species, know how to train them and to correctly assess any risks involved when taking them out, having children nearby etc.

Dogs are complex creatures and don't do well with thick people.

senschoolhelp · 31/03/2022 12:50

@Infinitemoon

Sorry this thread is ridiculous. No one should own two rottweilers with young children. GSDs should also be kept away from young children and kept in a secure kennel when you are not able to supervise around children.

I cannot understand why and it is mainly women are oblivious to the potential of their dogs.

Countless times whilst walking my dogs recently have I seen large breed dogs off the lead, no way would the owner be able to control two 25kg dogs should something happen.

What is it you think a German shepherd is going to do different to any other breed of that size? You clearly know nothing about the breed! I never leave any of my dogs unattended around my children they are always with me but you are being ridiculous saying they should be kennelled. Whatever dog you have is just as likely to attack someone.
oatlattetogo · 31/03/2022 12:47

@Ori18 I’m not disagreeing with you that a bigger dog has the potential to do more damage and is harder to physically restrain/remove than a smaller dog. I just don’t understand why you’re focusing on certain large breeds that you have ‘decided’ are dangerous, rather than asking why anyone would have any large dog around children. Labradors are (or were until recently) the breed of dog responsible for the most dog bites. I would struggle to drag an adult Labrador off someone if it decided to attack them.

And in answer to your second post no, I won’t be leaving my baby unattended with the German shepherds. I also won’t be leaving her unattended with my small, ‘middle class’, socially acceptable family friendly dog either though. Because as I said in my earlier post, any breed of dog is capable of causing serious injury to a young child.

Thisismynamenow · 31/03/2022 12:47

@Ori18

I'm genuinely curious to know - the posters who have a big dog - would you happily leave your baby/toddler ALONE in a room with your dog? Seriously, an honest question. Would you feel comfortable with this?
You're asking a leading question.

But i'll play your game and answer. No I wouldnt leave my Rescued Staffordshire/English Bull Terrier Cross in a room with my baby (who is due in 3 weeks).

Why, because he's an ANIMAL.

Would i leave a Spaniel, Collie, or any other dog you deem 'safe' in the room with my newborn? No.

Why, because their ALSO AN ANIMAL.

Leaving any animal (remember cats like to smother babies!) in a room with a baby is a stupid thing to do, and if any child gets injured or killed as a result their parents should get prosecuted for manslaughter and child abuse - because its an injury or death caused by neglectful parenting.

Responsible pet owners and parents should know this, and ensure their never left alone together. Take one or the other with you when you leave the room.

Also teaching the child the animal is AN ANIMAL is vital.

That would solve like 99.9% of all babies/children deaths due to dog attacks.

monkeysmum21 · 31/03/2022 12:47

I've had German Shepperds in the past. I know lots of people who have them and never heard a problem. I don't know why you label them as dangerous, I have the feeling that your are just against dogs.

VampireMoney · 31/03/2022 12:46

@Thisismynamenow I had my lip ripped open by a chihuahua when I was very small. Needed stitches and have a scar. My DD1 was bitten by a Jack Russell when she was 2, needed stitches. Both completely unprovoked attacks by random dogs. But because it was 'just' a small dog apparently that's ok. The complacency of small dog owners is worrying quite honestly.