Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if she’s making this up?

185 replies

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 30/03/2022 22:46

We live abroad, we hired a private tutor a few weeks ago to do some fun language teaching/babysitting with Dd, almost 4, in preparation for her new school in our new country.
She was very keen after the first visit, whatsapped extra phrases to learn and even offered to accept less pay per hour. She already charged a reasonable rate, seemed very good and was sweet with Dd, who really liked her.
She came back the next week, similar thing, very loving with Dd, they had lots of fun, she gave homework for the next week.
Sadly that weekend I got kidney stones and was quite ill, still not great by the time her day to come came and couldn’t do much more than lazy tv with Dd.
I contacted her explaining and apologising and that we’d see her next week.
She was due to come yesterday, we were all prepared, Dd very excited and she texted one hour before saying she’d been ill and was worse so couldn’t make it. I wished her to get well soon and said we were looking forward to seeing her next week, Dd was a bit sad.
Earlier tonight, she’s WhatsApped saying her school have asked her to start teaching 9-6 pm now, starting this Friday 🤷🏻‍♀️
She asked if she was able to do a Saturday if possible…this seems like an excuse to me and she possibly doesn’t want to continue the job…such a change when she was so enthusiastic, aibu to think it’s an excuse and to wonder what changed? Am I missing something?
Dd will be disappointed, was very excited about her lessons and it was her first proper introduction to a teacher.
Saturdays are more difficult for us due to kids parties/family times.
I had mentioned to her at the start, if Tuesdays went well, we might try to add some Saturdays in the future if she was available, Dh and I would go out, she was very keen and said she’d be able to do Saturdays too. I was hoping to continue with the Tuesdays for now

OP posts:
Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:12

@ravenmum I didn’t really see it as a casual arrangement, it was a set lesson at a set time each week. When I’ve taught I see it as a lesson and bit just a casual thing.

OP posts:
viques · 31/03/2022 10:11

Your dd is three. If you want her to learn some of the new language then research for yourself the “ three or four new words a week” and teach them. However it won’t do her any good because learning words at that slow isolated rate is not how children learn language, they learn it by hearing it around them in context and absorbing the vocabulary, grammar, intonation and accent! But hey, if it makes you feel better.

If you really want her to “learn” the language then find a playgroup or similar, make friends with other mums who are native speakers , put on childrens tv in the language, learn some songs in the language, read her stories in the language, all of which will start to tune her into the language.

Or wait until she starts school when she will learn it very quickly, in the meantime make sure that her exposure to English is as rich and varied as possible in vocabulary and grammar because research shows that children who have a strong first language learn second and third languages faster.

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:08

@KarenOLantern Yes, that was my thinking too. I’m a teacher myself, so can see the benefits of it for her.

OP posts:
unname · 31/03/2022 10:07

@Strawberriesonasummerevenin

Also to say when I messaged her fo say o was ill and apologise, in her reply she wrote ‘Really?’ Then said she hoped I’d get better and she see me next week (I’d written I’d see her next week) I wondered if maybe was a language thing, but I’ve not had anyone ask ‘Really?’ When I’ve said I’m ill 😅
People with abandonment fears sometimes behave the way you are describing. Her offering less and being so keen, then expressing doubt about you being sick makes it sound like she’s quite unsure of herself.

I would just tell her that you cannot swing Saturdays but that you really enjoyed the lessons with her and so did DD. That if anything changes with her weekday schedule to please let you know. Say something like “we will really miss you!”

KarenOLantern · 31/03/2022 10:06

in her reply she wrote ‘Really?’ Then said she hoped I’d get better and she see me next week (I’d written I’d see her next week) I wondered if maybe was a language thing, but I’ve not had anyone ask ‘Really?’ When I’ve said I’m ill

Is she a native English speaker who grew up in Britain? Because if not I would definitely but this down to the meaning getting lost in translation. She probably doesn't realise that in English that particularly word is often said in a sceptical tone. Perhaps in her own language it's just a way of acknowledging what you've just said, similar to "OK," or "ah, right." Why assume the worst of someone who has otherwise shown themselves to be friendly, kind and enthusiastic?

Also you definitely were doing the right thing for your daughter, becoming accustomed to a new language through chat and play is great for any child that age, let alone one who is starting school in the new language soon (although whichever PP who said it is right, she'll pick it up in no time anyway as soon as she starts school, but these sessions will still help her feel more comfortable those first couple of weeks).

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:05

@ravenmum Yes, those are the reasons I wanted to start, just a nice, gentle, positive introduction to things.

OP posts:
rurallibralady87 · 31/03/2022 10:04

[quote Strawberriesonasummerevenin]@rurallibralady87 Two hours, I’m not intense and no contracts signed (don’t tend to do that where I am for these types of jobs, I wouldn’t have been adverse to it if she wanted to) just hard when Dd liked her and we’d set it all up[/quote]
Ok so 2 hours 🙄 she isn't going to pass 9-6 guaranteed hours for your 2 hours.

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:02

@rurallibralady87 Two hours, I’m not intense and no contracts signed (don’t tend to do that where I am for these types of jobs, I wouldn’t have been adverse to it if she wanted to) just hard when Dd liked her and we’d set it all up

OP posts:
SpiderinaWingMirror · 31/03/2022 10:02

Just find someone else.
Sounds like she has found a full time job. She can't live on one day a week wages.
Just wish her all the best.

ravenmum · 31/03/2022 10:01

I can't see what real difference it makes? It was only a casual arrangement, so she wasn't obliged to come. Maybe she's found something nearer, more convenient or with less preparation required. Maybe her hours have changed. In either case, she's not doing it to be nasty to you.

I've done this kind of job before, with little children, just to get them used to hearing the other language, mainly. I don't think it makes a huge difference: when they are immersed in the other language, they still won't understand it at first. But it gives them an idea of what another language is, for example, if they haven't come across the concept yet. And if it's fun and relaxed, then the first impression is positive, so they don't only associate the new language with weird strangers coming up to them and making funny noises they don't understand in a weird new environment.

Sally872 · 31/03/2022 10:01

Not sure why you are surprised a full time opportunity could start quickly or involve working full days?

I would take it at face value and decide do you want her enough to make Saturdays work or would you rather look for someone else? No wrong answer just what works for you.

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:00

Yes @FarmGirl78 could be right if she feels like that from her side, but I don’t know, she doesn’t seem massively keen and no apology etc.
It’s for two hours every week so Saturday is a bit harder.
I had mentioned maybe adding some Saturdays also, but that was in the future and wasn’t 100%
I’ll see if we can do some Saturdays and see what she thinks, but without it being regular I can imagine it might not suit her, which I totally get

OP posts:
rurallibralady87 · 31/03/2022 09:59

You seem really intense OP. I take it was a casual arrangement and no contracts signed? I would take her at face value that she has secured better hours, she isn't going to give that up because she has worked an hour for you for 2 weeks.

SayCheeseBoris · 31/03/2022 09:55

Why not just say yes to Saturdays and see if she pulls out? That way you'll know whether or not she wants to continue. Surely you can sacrifice an hour on a Saturday either early morning or late afternoon when parties aren't as common.

Trixiefirecracker · 31/03/2022 09:55

Just let it go. I would. It’s not a big deal, people’s circumstances change. People lie.

Mummyoflittledragon · 31/03/2022 09:54

I don’t understand why you told her you can’t do Saturdays.

Did you read the post by FarmGirl78?

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 09:52

@AmyDudley You’re right, I just wanted that little extra to not make her feel completely lost with all the new language around her

OP posts:
Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 09:51

Also to say when I messaged her fo say o was ill and apologise, in her reply she wrote ‘Really?’ Then said she hoped I’d get better and she see me next week (I’d written I’d see her next week)
I wondered if maybe was a language thing, but I’ve not had anyone ask ‘Really?’ When I’ve said I’m ill 😅

OP posts:
AmyDudley · 31/03/2022 09:49

I wouldn't worry - at 4 your DD will pick up the language very quickly once she starts school and will be fluent in no time.

incognitoforthisone · 31/03/2022 09:48

I really don't see why it matters if she's 'making it up' or not. She either can't or doesn't want to tutor during the times that you want her to be available. That's it. What difference does the reason make to you? Stop obsessing over it and move on.

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 09:47

@emmathedilemma Is it really being unreasonable to hire someone fun to help introduce dd to elements of the new language in a new country, so when she starts school she isn’t completely lost? 🤷🏻‍♀️
I felt I was doing the right thing, to give a little start for her so she feels more comfortable

OP posts:
StooOrangeyForCrows · 31/03/2022 09:46

Even in the event 'she is making it up', she is allowed to. We all 'juggle' our lives and have to change things with sometimes giving 'diplomatic' reasons for things rather than the stark truth. It oils the wheels of life does this sort of thing.

If you now don't trust her, terminate her and find someone else. Speculating about her character is a fruitless exercise surely?

emmathedilemma · 31/03/2022 09:43

YABU for hiring a teacher for a pre-schooler!
Move on......

iklboo · 31/03/2022 09:43

I wouldn't believe her either. I've never heard of a teaching job that pays for a 40 hour week.

Aw, bless.

Geamhradh · 31/03/2022 09:39

@Everydaydayisaschoolday

I wouldn't believe her either. I've never heard of a teaching job that pays for a 40 hour week.

She is mugging you off OP. She doesn't want to work for you anymore. Don't angst about it. Just look for another tutor.

Then you've never worked abroad in TEFL.