Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if she’s making this up?

185 replies

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 30/03/2022 22:46

We live abroad, we hired a private tutor a few weeks ago to do some fun language teaching/babysitting with Dd, almost 4, in preparation for her new school in our new country.
She was very keen after the first visit, whatsapped extra phrases to learn and even offered to accept less pay per hour. She already charged a reasonable rate, seemed very good and was sweet with Dd, who really liked her.
She came back the next week, similar thing, very loving with Dd, they had lots of fun, she gave homework for the next week.
Sadly that weekend I got kidney stones and was quite ill, still not great by the time her day to come came and couldn’t do much more than lazy tv with Dd.
I contacted her explaining and apologising and that we’d see her next week.
She was due to come yesterday, we were all prepared, Dd very excited and she texted one hour before saying she’d been ill and was worse so couldn’t make it. I wished her to get well soon and said we were looking forward to seeing her next week, Dd was a bit sad.
Earlier tonight, she’s WhatsApped saying her school have asked her to start teaching 9-6 pm now, starting this Friday 🤷🏻‍♀️
She asked if she was able to do a Saturday if possible…this seems like an excuse to me and she possibly doesn’t want to continue the job…such a change when she was so enthusiastic, aibu to think it’s an excuse and to wonder what changed? Am I missing something?
Dd will be disappointed, was very excited about her lessons and it was her first proper introduction to a teacher.
Saturdays are more difficult for us due to kids parties/family times.
I had mentioned to her at the start, if Tuesdays went well, we might try to add some Saturdays in the future if she was available, Dh and I would go out, she was very keen and said she’d be able to do Saturdays too. I was hoping to continue with the Tuesdays for now

OP posts:
unfortunateevents · 31/03/2022 11:21

Gosh you sound like way too much work. You were the one who asked for Saturdays originally, then when she offered you said no, not now, too difficult with other things, now you are asking for Saturdays to work somehow?! She doesn't know whether she is coming or going or what you want! Presumably English is also her second language and I suspect cultural differences are coming into play here too.

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 11:20

@SpaceFarce Noooo now I’ve replied properly to her first message, I said at first last night that it could be tricky on Saturdays and would have to think

OP posts:
SpaceFarce · 31/03/2022 11:18

What?! Now you’ve asked for Saturdays again?! Confused If she’s any sense she’d run a mile at this chopping and changing

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 11:13

I’ve texted her to ask if we could arrange somehow, would Saturdays be good for her, no reply.

OP posts:
OakRowan · 31/03/2022 11:11

Saturdays were your idea. If you want to keep her coming book her in according to when she has availability and around your existing ballet activity. Ask her when she could come according to what times you have free.
Pay for cancellations, as much notice as possible. Her reasons for cancelling aren't really any of your business to believe or not, stop thinking about that. She hasn't ended the arrangement, instead she is offering an alternative bcausese now has a full time job. She could've just quit completely if she doesn't want to continue. Find someone else if your 4 Yr old DD is genuinely too busy year round attending parties. Saturdays are a totally normal day for extra teaching/tutoring/lessons and activities.

shssandhr · 31/03/2022 11:10

I pay her weekly, each lesson she comes, would have paid her for the missed lesson when she came

Did you tell her that you would pay her for the missed lesson?
Perhaps she thought you were going to be a flaky customer.
I do a similar job and after just two weeks a cancelled lesson for the Mum being ill would be the first warning that the customer might be flaky - and most people don't see why they have to pay when they cancel just a short while before the lesson, so I have to tell them.
I would never assume that the client intended to pay the next time I saw them because the vast majority of them try to get out of it (despite my very clear terms and conditions).
So unless you said "I'm sorry I'm ill and have to cancel but we'll see you next week and you'll receive payment for the missed lesson too of course" then she might have thought you were going to be unreliable.

But it does sound like her working arrangements have changed, or perhaps she wants to take on other clients on a Tuesday instead who might be more reliable (not saying that you weren't going to be, but she might have got that impression due to the cancellation).

If the Saturdays don't work for you then just tell her that and say you will look for someone else.

These things sometimes just don't work out even though the first couple of lessons might go really well. In my experience (13 years of this kind of work), this working relationship looks like it isn't going to work out and you should find someone else who meets your needs better. My guess that the Saturdays wouldn't end up being very regular - you'll have things on and need to cancel and she'll be tired after all those long hours working and will also want her free time on Saturdays.

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 11:04

@Geamhradh She can have breaks whenever she likes, snacks are left out, they go in the garden etc

OP posts:
Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 11:03

@Geamhradh I know. It’s to play and converse in the language, hence the babysitter/tutor title. She follows DD’s lead in whatever she wants to play with and gets words from the country we now live in, into the conversation, so little bits are picked up. It’s not formal, Dd loves it as she sees it as having another playmate and she likes learning a few new words.

OP posts:
PlainJaneEyre · 31/03/2022 11:02

[quote Strawberriesonasummerevenin]@PlainJaneEyre Yes, I was worried about cancelling, but genuinely had to. I’ve also been cancelled a few times by families in tbe past and it is really annoying, the first time/one time hasn’t bothered me though as these things happened, this was with one family every few weeks and is it hard when you rely on that money. I would’ve paid her at the last lesson.[/quote]
Yes but did you TELL her that when you cancelled? That is important.

Geamhradh · 31/03/2022 10:58

@Kuachui

who would choose to work saturdays over other days
Saturday is a normal working day in some places. #newsflash.

OP- please tell me you aren't having a 2 hour lesson (no matter how play oriented) with a 4 year old? A group of 4 year olds (which would be much more fun) would at most do 45-60 minutes in a reputable language school. Including breaks and a change of language activity every 5-10 minutes.

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:56

@PlainJaneEyre My reasons weren’t pathetic, I was vomiting from kidney stones, didn’t want to get dressed and house ready etc. I genuinely didn’t feel well enough to.

OP posts:
Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:55

@PlainJaneEyre Yes, I was worried about cancelling, but genuinely had to. I’ve also been cancelled a few times by families in tbe past and it is really annoying, the first time/one time hasn’t bothered me though as these things happened, this was with one family every few weeks and is it hard when you rely on that money. I would’ve paid her at the last lesson.

OP posts:
Kuachui · 31/03/2022 10:53

who would choose to work saturdays over other days

PlainJaneEyre · 31/03/2022 10:43

I think she was really keen but you cancelling the third lesson has cheesed her off a bit ( the reasons you had said are a bit pathetic really re the house etc) and has emphasised to her how on/off this relationship might be. She isn't going to prioritise you if you don't her. When people are earning in a situation like this it is a real PITA when people start getting flaky and last minute cancelling. Did you tell her you would pay her for the day you cancelled? (Sorry if I missed that) I suspect she has potentially lots of other work.

Catrice · 31/03/2022 10:38

Hi. I personally think it's lovely that you want to help your 4 year old fit in in readiness for school op and it seems like you found the perfect person to do so. I would agree with others though that as she can no longer tutor on a Tuesday, she is still keen to do so by suggesting Saturday's (maybe as you had mentioned you would like for her to work some in the future). If your dd is looking forward to seeing her again and from what you've said it sounds as if she most definitely is, could you maybe sacrifice a birthday party or whatever she you had planned just this once and ask her to tutor your dd either this or the following Saturday? See what her response is? If she can do it then great but if she makes an excuse not to then maybe she isn't so keen after all (as you suspect ). Give her a definite date and time and enough notice and see what happens.

Malalaa · 31/03/2022 10:37

@SofiaAmes

And could I just add....why on earth are you giving your poor 4 year old homework?
Not even 4 yet! So still a 3 year old being given tutoring and language homework! Poor kid!
Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:34

@ravenmum I know, it’s very common where I am, no one would make a contract for a weekly short session of teaching/babysitting
For me, it’s fine to do but the employees wouldn’t want one as it’s not worth their time for the job in most cases

OP posts:
ravenmum · 31/03/2022 10:30

I'm not in the UK; I'm in Germany, which is even more fixated on contracts :) Here, "cash in hand" = "tax dodger" Shock

Branleuse · 31/03/2022 10:27

i dont know why youre worried about whether she really wants to do it. Most people work for the money, not because they desperatly want to look after your 4 year old.
Id give the saturday sessions a go and see if you can fit it in. Surely your kid isnt busy all day every saturday

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:16

@CatherinedeBourgh Yes, not Spanish

OP posts:
Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:16

@ravenmum It’s different to the U.K., barely anyone has a contract, especially so for this type of work. I’ve always received cash in hand, I still didn’t class it as a casual arrangement, it was a job and I treated it as such.

OP posts:
Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:14

@viques Yes, I know how they learn language, she does all of the above, but I wanted an extra one on one with her.
We do do the words ourselves and read books to her in the language etc, but meeting a nice teacher and having that extra one on one, I thought would be beneficial to her,

OP posts:
ravenmum · 31/03/2022 10:14

Sounded like it was without a contract? That would be my main definition of casual.

Strawberriesonasummerevenin · 31/03/2022 10:12

*Not just a casual thing

OP posts:
CatherinedeBourgh · 31/03/2022 10:12

If her native language is Spanish, 'Really?' is an expression of sympathy.