Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS (5) ASD eating items before we have paid for them

138 replies

Mouk · 30/03/2022 20:38

I live near a small supermarket. For the past 7 years. It is 2 minute walk away and we have always encountered polite employees in this supermarket. I'm actually close pals with one of them. We'll call her Susan. The manager, we'll call Tom and the employee who spoke to me today, we'll call him Dave.

My son (5) enjoys accompanying me to the shop and his little routine is that he picks up a Fruit Shoot (takes the lid off) and sips on it, we then go to the ice cream freezer and he selects one, I remove the wrapper and hand the ice to him. I then place the wrapper in my basket and we continue on around the shop. When we get to the till I place all the items on the counter and pay. The cashiers always smile and offer to place the wrapper in the bin behind the tills. We have done this for at least 2 years. The staff are always friendly to my son and myself and my daughter (8) too.

Today we went over to the shop for a few items. As usual my son got his fruit shoot and his ice cream, I kept a hold of the empties and duly paid for all my items at the till (as I always do). I have never stolen anything in my whole life and don't have a criminal record. Go me! At the ripe old age of 45 I'm not gonna start now. At the till, the gentleman serving me remarked that my 2 litre container of milk was leaking. After paying he said I could go back down to the milk fridge and select a different one. I did so.

As I was selecting the milk, employee Dave approached me and said "Just to let you know, you can't do that anymore - you cannot eat items before paying for them" He of course was referencing my non verbal son but talking to me. I said "I'm sorry, I didn't know that". I then said that my son was autistic and it was his routine. Dave said "that doesn't matter, you still can't be doing that". I then said "he's 5, it's not hurting anyone". Dave said "it's what the big boss man has said". I said ok, and we left the store with the items we had paid for. I went bright red and actually felt like a criminal. When I think back, when we walked in Tom looked over at us and made eye contact with me - perhaps I'm being paranoid in hindsight.

I rang Susan afterwards to get her opinion. She is astonished that I was treated that way. She said I'm one of the long time regulars and if they had a problem with this, then why didnt they say something before now. I asked her if this was a rule. There is a secondary school 4 minutes walk away and they do not allow the teens to eat what they have purchased inside the shop as they have to limit the numbers at lunchtimes or the shop would be jam packed with students. They allow about 10 in at any one time. She said it's different with younger kids or so she thought.

I'll add that us shopping at this small supermarket has greatly helped my son with his social skills. He's learned road safety on our walk there. He knows we have to queue up to pay. He's able to walk around the shop with me without needing to hold my hand, he's no longer a flight risk, FGS he even knows how to social distance in a queue from our outings to this wonderful shop.

Susan has advised me to approach Tom politely on Monday when he's next there and ask to clarify a few things in a private area. Not in view of the general public. I wish I would have been awarded some privacy today when Dave spoke to me. Anyone could have overheard, I regularly bump into my neighbours at this shop.

  1. Will it be ok for us to pay for the fruit shoot and ice cream, let my son eat and drink them while we shop, then I get to the till and purchase the rest of my items.
  1. Will I always be looked at with suspision?
  1. Is my son welcome in the shop. What is their policy on people with a disability. Hidden or otherwise.

YABU? (It's effectively stealing the item (i.e. eating it) before paying - son will just have to learn.
YANBU? He's 5 years old and is autistic. It's his little routine and we always pay. Manager needs to cop himself on.

OP posts:
Getoff · 31/03/2022 09:07

It's not theft if you fully intend to pay every time, but it is a bit anti-social.

It's more accurate to say that it is theft, but shops are unlikely to call the police, presumably because there's zero chance a large supermarket will want to exercise their legal right (that you've deprived them of) to refuse to sell you the item.

elfycat · 31/03/2022 09:01

I agree that it's probably best not to start a habit like this for a child. I always explained to my children about the point at which the transfer of ownership happens - when my money has been accepted the goods are ours. They're still interested in the concept. This week I took my 11 year old to a cafe, and she waited until the second the payment went through, asked 'do we own it now?', before starting.

Maybe that's a concept you could play with as a new habit/discussion point?

I'll add that several times when I was pregnant I could not wait to eat or drink. I had hyperemesis half the time and would have mini-faints from not eating at other points. I used to apologise at the till for the open chocolate milkshake bottle and fruit bag, but no one minded. It's not theft if you fully intend to pay every time, but it is a bit anti-social.

Gowithme · 31/03/2022 09:00

Why don't you just take a fruit shoot and something else for him to have with you? Or buy them before you do your shop? I don't think it's a huge deal either way. It's not really a very healthy routine every time you go to the shops to have though - does he really have an icecream all through the winter?? - so maybe see it as a good time for a change even if it's tricky for a bit due to him having ASD.

I'd always take some bread sticks every where for mine with ASD to munch on. Why not take a fruitshoot or other drink and bread sticks with you if he will eat them perhaps.

Getoff · 31/03/2022 08:55

so long as you are planning to pay for something it isn’t theft to open things before you have paid for them

It is theft. If you think it isn't, there's a barrister on Youtube ("Black Belt Barrister") you need to email to tell him he doesn't understand the law.

The way he explained it, if you consume an item before it passes through the till, you are denying the shop the opportunity to refuse to sell it to you, you are taking away their right to control the disposal of their property.

TangledNemo · 31/03/2022 08:44

I worked in a supermarket over 10 years ago but I still remember the day a woman ate a chocolate bar walking round the shop and got caught walking out without paying for it. She got caught and claims to have forgotten about it (genuinely I think), but she still got banned from that supermarket.

I’m sure you don’t intend to forget, but you or your son could take sick walking round the shop. You could get an emergency phone call and have to leave. You could have forgotten your purse. Or get to the tills and realise the card machine is not working.

I think the supermarket have been very accommodating up to now, but I don’t think people should be able to eat or drink things in the supermarket before paying.

Holly60 · 31/03/2022 08:35

@OutlookStalking

I think YABVU. I would instead buy the 2 things he wants and then do your shopping.

Although this kind of thing has come up on mumsnet before I can't imagine thinking eating things before you had paid for them is okay! If it happened once with my kids I'd have been so apologetic. What if someone did htis then realised they'd forgotten their wallet or their phone died or card declined etc. Also its good to know we can't just take stuff in the supermarket and eat it but we have to pay for it.

Oh so stop being so uptight. No one’s going to die, for goodness sake. I did this with my own and do it with my DGC. Why on earth would anyone care precisely WHEN in the process you pay for a few of the items? It’s pence, usually, I’m not hoisting a flat screen telly out the shop, blithely declaring I’ll pay for it later. And if in the very unlikely event i found myself without means to pay, I’d pop back with the £1.25 later in the day.
ididntevennotice · 31/03/2022 08:33

[quote username9871028]@ididntevennotice no. usually he is already hungry whilst we are shopping, hence the tears. Confused[/quote]

So step up, be a parent, ensure he isn't going to get hungry when shopping and stop rewarding a tantrum with food.

username9871028 · 31/03/2022 08:14

@ididntevennotice no. usually he is already hungry whilst we are shopping, hence the tears. Confused

Bibbetyboo · 30/03/2022 23:31

@Blimecory - sure I’ll take your reference to an article over the internet over my legal training.
S6 of the Theft Act relates to actions where there is no intention to permanently deprive but the actions still amount to a taking or disposal, e.g grapes or bananas sold by weight, or if you damaged the packaging such that it couldn’t be scanned or something.

Not that anyone should be trusting the advice of randoms on the internet in forums - but it isn’t theft.

The shop is entitled to have rules saying you can’t do it, but that’s separate to the question of whether it is theft.

Dou8hnuts · 30/03/2022 23:28

I’ve worked for some large supermarkets and little shops and I’ve never once stopped a customer doing this or witnessed it happening. A bin behind each checkout often was filled with empty fruit shoots, banana peels, chocolate wrappers and sandwich boxes that customers put on the checkout conveyor and paid for before asking me to dispose of the wrapper in my bin. Having two children with ASD shopping can be a difficult and often traumatic ordeal for us as a family and anything I can do to help get my sons from store front to checkout without people thinking I’m skinning a cat is implemented. I was also told until you pass the last point of service it’s not classed as stealing so as long as you don’t walk past a checkout and not pay for the items or the wrappers then there’s not a lot can be done. Some people will have one view, some will have another but it’s down to the shop to be more upfront with signage stating items banisters be paid for before consuming them or items cannot be consumed on premises rather than s as sting it in peoples faces. It’s not been made clear before now and word of mouth isn’t sufficient when even your friend wasn’t aware of this policy. He needs to have it clearly pointed out to all customers not just sporadically telling customers on the shop floor it’s not very professional.

ididntevennotice · 30/03/2022 23:01

@username9871028

Yabu. If my toddler is having a tantrum and I am already at the checkout I may pull something out of a multipack and will mention it to the cashier whilst they are scanning the items. That is as a last resort though and I am aware it isn’t ideal. You sound entitled saying that it’s “his routine” …

You reward your toddler tantrum with some food?

username9871028 · 30/03/2022 22:55

Yabu. If my toddler is having a tantrum and I am already at the checkout I may pull something out of a multipack and will mention it to the cashier whilst they are scanning the items. That is as a last resort though and I am aware it isn’t ideal. You sound entitled saying that it’s “his routine” …

RozHuntleysStump · 30/03/2022 22:48

My son was non verbal till he was 10. You’re doing him no favours at all going through life letting him do what he wants because he’s ‘autistic’. No. We choose the things, we pay for the things, we consume the things. That’s it. Make a story board.

Theunamedcat · 30/03/2022 22:42

One thing you learn very fast with children never start something your not willing to continue for a very very long time special needs doesn't even come into it really

saraclara · 30/03/2022 22:34

It's great that you've taken people's comments on board. That's really refreshing and bodes really well for you always doing the best for your lad.

I taught children like your DS in a special school for decades, and agree that it's really important not to set up routines that can't be maintained when the child is older (or in different circumstances like a class visit to the supermarket or a respite carer taking him to a shop). It's infinitely harder to change a learned and expected routine (especially when it involves treats) when your child is a lot older, stronger and louder in their meltdowns.

To be honest, your new plan (which is basically the same but you pay first) is still a bit tricksy. Having a froot shoot and an ice cream every single time he goes to a shop isn't ideal. But baby steps. You will probably come up with something that still occupies and rewards him that eventually leads to him coping with shops without involving eating and sugary stuff. (Welcome to the world of star charts and stickers with rewards when he gets home!)

All the best with the new routine.

Springhassprung86 · 30/03/2022 22:29

YABU so so unreasonable. Just pay for his fruit shoot and lolly before you begin to shop? Don’t see why your son being autistic has any bearing on the situation whatsoever! You paying first won’t have any impact on his routine. How entitled, wow.

Mumwithapub · 30/03/2022 22:28

I have done this with my asd toddler I don't see the problem especially as it's a local small supermarket that supposedly knows you. As most people with ASD children know it is a spectrum and every child is different so for those saying yeah I don't allow it then great but then some of us are dealing with more meltdowns and less communication than others. I will say have a word with shop manager and then explain to head office the way it is. You are not stealing until product is taken out of the store you are willingly paying for it. I can't see a problem. Would a diabetic who needs sugar quickly be penalised for doing the same?

Coffeencrochet · 30/03/2022 22:28

DS6 is the same as yours, so I send DH off with him to pay for what he wants to eat while I carry on with the main shop.

Figgygal · 30/03/2022 22:23

I hate seeing people doing this its just unnecessary
Its become habit because youve allowed it to be the shop arent wrong in asking you politely to stop it now.....better to now otherwise will you still be saying it is ok because its his routine in 5/10 years?

Blimecory · 30/03/2022 22:18

[quote Bibbetyboo]@Blimecory

«You are very much in the wrong. You have to buy the things before you eat them in a shop. It is actually against the law, too.«

No it isn’t. Theft is the intention to permanently deprive someone of their property. If you intend to pay, it is not theft.

It would be theft of e.g. grapes but that’s not what we are talking about.[/quote]
No, that’s not correct. It’s theft under the Theft Act 1968.
www.newsshopper.co.uk/news/18766027.supermarket-habit-illegal-uk/

runsmidgeOMG · 30/03/2022 22:16

OP you're a good mum and I'm sure your son will learn his new routine no probs. I particularly liked the idea of him handing over the money/ tapping the card for his food at the beginning of the shop. Educational and fun. Good luck with the new diagnosis. Sounds like you're way ahead of the game and will ace each curveball thrown at you Thanks

lanthanum · 30/03/2022 22:12

People have been very kind in allowing you to do this, but it's a bit difficult for them to have it set up so that every member of staff knows you're allowed to. Also, whilst your son is little at the moment, it's going to be more difficult when he's the same age as the older kids they don't want doing it, so perhaps it's better to break the pattern now rather than later.

It's also possible that they've had some less honest customers see what you were doing, and do the same but without paying. That's difficult for them to clamp down on - until they get to the till they can't tell whether they're going to pay or not, and then it may be too late to tackle the issue.

While he is little hopefully they can allow you to buy the items and then let him have them to eat/drink while you shop - perhaps they can put some sort of sticker on to show they're already paid for.

lanbro · 30/03/2022 22:12

I don't routinely do this but I definitely have, I remember breaking a bit off a warm baguette then paying for the whole thing, or give the kids something if they were sat in the trolley, no one ever said a thing.

My GF used to eat his grapes on the way round, which is obviously wrong as they weighed less at the end so I wouldn't do that.

However, they are well within their rights to say you can't do it. Definitely buy his fs and lolly first, then shop

ihoeihoeihoe · 30/03/2022 22:11

I let my DS who is NT do this at 2 of our local supermarkets. I always check I have enough cash/ battery to at least be able to let him pay for what he opens. Normally a £1 ice-lolly. He sits nice and eats it making it an enjoyable outing for all. I honestly have no idea why people care about this kind of thing, I’ve never been asked not to do it 🤷🏻‍♀️.

I’d speak to the manager, what gave you got to lose? People on here need to get out more if they think a drink and an ice lolly are theft or a health hazard 😂

WeCouldBeSpearows · 30/03/2022 22:09

I work in a supermarket, on the till. If I have one pet hate, it's getting empty crisp bags to put through, as they are invariably greasy and unpleasant to touch.

Having said that, most people take a bag from a multipack, so I don't have to handle the individual bag. For anything else, I really don't mind, and I'm happy to bin empty wrappers. I would rather a happy child with a fruit shoot than a child having a meltdown because they couldn't have one.

I don't think it's fair that people are comparing their child to ops. We all know that every neuro atypical child is different. Op, I hope you find a suitable way forward.

Swipe left for the next trending thread