Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed by people being early

134 replies

Isittimeformynapyet · 30/03/2022 19:52

If I arrange to do something at a given time I am always ready. But I'm often inconvenienced by people arriving "virtuously" early.

Should I just be ready early for everything?

OP posts:
Nnique · 31/03/2022 06:16

Yes...that’s what the other camp always says...🙂 Meh, it really doesn’t bother me either way and i wasn’t being snarky (is that a word? 🤨 insomnia!) with that comment, it’s just clearly that’s what the rule is for you. You turn up dead on time or you’re being incredibly rude. Which is military precision-like, isn’t it.

That just is not the case for us. It’s considered very rude to be knocking on the door exactly on the dot! And really it has nothing to do with not communicating clearly. Everyone understands the rule, everyone prefers it that way, and as I said, if I know someone is in the other camp (my IL’s are, for example...) I make allowances for that and show up dead on time at theirs and smile (through gritted teeth sometimes, I must confess) when they’re banging on the door exactly at whatever hour.

Kanaloa · 31/03/2022 06:06

@Nnique

Should’ve put ‘on time’ as paradoxically turning up 10-15 min ‘late’ is actually on time on our side of the divide! I’m sure it’s hard to get your head round it if you’ve been taught to turn up to things with military precision but it actually works just fine and makes perfect sense to those of us who were brought up this way!
I haven’t been ‘taught to turn up to things with military precision’ Confused. I just presume that grown adults know what time they want someone to arrive and will communicate that correctly. I trust that they will tell me the time that works for them and will therefore be ready by that time. Surely if they so desperately need an extra 15 minutes they’d ask me to arrive at 12.15 instead of 12.

I think it works best when people don’t expect others to understand their preferences of showing up x amount of minutes after when they’ve been asked and just clearly communicate what they want.

Nnique · 31/03/2022 05:58

Should’ve put ‘on time’ as paradoxically turning up 10-15 min ‘late’ is actually on time on our side of the divide! I’m sure it’s hard to get your head round it if you’ve been taught to turn up to things with military precision but it actually works just fine and makes perfect sense to those of us who were brought up this way!

Nnique · 31/03/2022 05:52

It’s very simple - You never presume that the host is ready and has had time to do everything needed for on the dot arrival, so you leave an allowance of time so as not to rudely impose upon them too early. It’s perfectly understood by the people who work to this rule that that’s the polite and correct thing to do.

Of course if I understand from others’ arrivals to my home (or from some other way of deducing that they are in the other camp on this) then as a guest I would definitely defer to their way of doing things and be on time, as in that case that is the polite thing to do as that’s what they expect.

TravelDreamLife · 31/03/2022 05:44

Depends. I'm used to early as DM always HAS to be first.

A friend, though, asks me to meet for lunch or coffee & then text 30 minutes early that she's there & already ordered. By the time I arrive (10 min early) she's done & ready to leave. Or, she is an hour late. Or cancels last minute. Then tells me how rude my country people are (she's foreign, been here 10+ years). Clueless. I don't bother anymore.

Kanaloa · 31/03/2022 05:44

@Nnique

Haven’t RTFT because I hate this so much I have to post straightaway.

I am in the ‘10-15 minutes after stated time’ camp and nothing will ever change my mind. There have been huge bun fights on this on MN and ultimately it’s one of those issues where the two sides are just never going to meet.

I’m cool with whatever people want to do according to what happens in their circles, according to their background/upbringing, class or culture, etc. But as far as I am concerned it’s the absolute height of rudeness to turn up early and only marginally less rude to turn up exactly on time. So it’s lucky that most people tend to mix in circles where most people do the same thing they think of as polite, as we can all just continue doing it our respective ways!

How could it possibly be rude to show up on time at the time someone asked you to come? Surely the rudeness there is on the part of the host who has asked people to come at a different time than they want them to come.

I think it’s rude to be very early or to be late. A couple of minutes either way is fine.

Nnique · 31/03/2022 05:39

And a neutral venue is also different - then you always turn up on time (which actually means planning to be 10-15 minutes early, in my book).

Nnique · 31/03/2022 05:38

It’s different if you’ve given a time frame such as a half hour window. Obviously then you’d arrive sometime within that window. I would aim to be bang in the middle, which still translates to 15 min past and is the perfect arrival time.

MissMarpleRocks · 31/03/2022 05:32

I’m a stickler for being on time. If I had turned up to court late my client would be penalised. It’s a very hard habit to break.

If I invite you for 4pm I mean by 4pm not after 4pm. My family know & generally arrive hour or so before to help. Dhs family are always late. Arriving at 4.10/20. So I’ll say 3.30-4pm & I mean exactly that. Earlier than 3.30 is fine later than 4pm absolute no no.

I find it very rude when people are late meeting at a neutral venue. Why is their time more valuable than mine? Luckily most of my friends are like me & are sticklers for being on time.

Nnique · 31/03/2022 05:17

Haven’t RTFT because I hate this so much I have to post straightaway.

I am in the ‘10-15 minutes after stated time’ camp and nothing will ever change my mind. There have been huge bun fights on this on MN and ultimately it’s one of those issues where the two sides are just never going to meet.

I’m cool with whatever people want to do according to what happens in their circles, according to their background/upbringing, class or culture, etc. But as far as I am concerned it’s the absolute height of rudeness to turn up early and only marginally less rude to turn up exactly on time. So it’s lucky that most people tend to mix in circles where most people do the same thing they think of as polite, as we can all just continue doing it our respective ways!

WriteronaMission · 31/03/2022 01:50

I grew up with the rule "turning up on time is late, turning up 5 minutes early is on time." It's a very hard thing to get out of as I got into a habit of setting watches five minutes early so I'd turn up "on time."

WomanStanleyWoman · 30/03/2022 23:56

@PotteringAlong

This! Hugely rude to arrive early at someone's house (should be 5-15 mins late when going to someone's house).*

No, @MsFogi you should be on time. Turning up 15 minutes late is also hugely rude!

@MsFogi is correct. ‘Around 8’ means no earlier than ten past.
queenjaneappro · 30/03/2022 23:41

In a work context, post covid lots of remote working still... I hate it when people start a MS teams meeting early.

I'll be in the middle of drafting something and see the notification - so and so has started the meeting (10 minutes early- where do they have the time?) and it stresses me out. I deliberately force myself to ignore it now and join the meeting bang on the start time.

Birdfooddirect · 30/03/2022 23:25

Early is every bit as rude as late. It's inconsiderate whichever way around it is

XenoBitch · 30/03/2022 23:14

I think it is ok to be early somewhere that is not someone's home. You can entertain yourself until the person you are meeting turns up. It is rude to turn up early to someone's house. I had a friend show up 2 hours early once. I was in the shower, and my house was still a tip. Was very stressful.

safclass · 30/03/2022 22:43

I like to be on time however if I arrived too earlier I'd park up somewhere for 10mins etc.
I agree 5-10mins early is acceptable. Longer than that is awkward.

bumhug · 30/03/2022 22:30

I work in a salon and it drives us potty when people turn up really early for their appointment! Especially when it's just as we've managed to carve out a 15 minute break to shovel a sandwich in. "Oh don't worry, I know I'm early, you carry on." As if I'm now going to sit and enjoy my bloody cheese sandwich Janet with you sat there tapping your foot with your handbag in your lap!!

I have one client who arrives over an hour early every time and texts to say she'll wait in the car, but she's here already in case someone before her doesn't turn up! 🤯🔫

Toothsil · 30/03/2022 22:28

FIL does this, if you tell him to come round at 2, he will turn up at 1.30. It's very frustrating!

Hollyontherampage · 30/03/2022 22:27

My MIL always does this. Turns up 30 minutes early then calls and says in a simpering voice "Im outside your house, but don't worry I can go and sit in a cafe if you like..?" Drives me mad!!

Babyfg · 30/03/2022 22:23

Oh I hate this too! And I'm an early person!
I had my daughters birthday party at the house and had 3 separate guests turn up 30 mins early! I was like a mad woman! I had to leave them to entertain themselves while I quickly got the last bits of food out!

Or when you're meeting someone and they text like half an hour early saying I'm here waiting outside venue. I'm like well why you twat, you're trying to rush me.

I'm generally early to everything but wait in the car or sit on a bench until about ten mins before. It's my choice to early why would I be badgering people!

Ionlydomassiveones · 30/03/2022 22:17

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Sunsetmom · 30/03/2022 22:16

I’m always late but hate others being late 🤣🤣 also don’t like people being early as I’m not ready for them 🤦🏼‍♀️

PotteringAlong · 30/03/2022 21:52

Assuming you’ve not had a 3 hour journey to get there, obviously.

nokidshere · 30/03/2022 21:52

I'm always early, sometimes really really early! I've never been late for anything in my life.

However, I never turn up at someone's house early, just in the general vicinity, a local car park or a cafe where I read until it's time to arrive at my destination.

PotteringAlong · 30/03/2022 21:51

This! Hugely rude to arrive early at someone's house (should be 5-15 mins late when going to someone's house).*

No, @MsFogi you should be on time. Turning up 15 minutes late is also hugely rude!

Swipe left for the next trending thread