Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBu to think kids can't be brave and strong anymore?

239 replies

vbnm89 · 30/03/2022 16:23

AIBuU to think that being brave and strong is now frowned upon?? I have noticed this generation of kids having very little resilience. My kids and their friends are always moaning they have something wrong or something hurts or they can't do something. If children fall over now you aren't allowed to say be brave and teaching them to be strong could be bad for their mental health. I only ever keep my kids off school for a temperature or being sick - I tell them to suck it up and get on with it - you can't just miss school every time something hurts.

When I was a teenager I wanted to be strong and tough but now it seems that you can't bring your children up to be strong as you may damage their mental health. Children seem to want to be weak and dependable on others rather than strong and independent. They don't seem to have any get up and go and if anything is a bit tough the mental health card is used to stop them having to do anything they can't or don 't like doing!!

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 31/03/2022 06:17

Although to me resilience is being able to deal with the thing that’s worrying you and move on. Of course you can tell your child to shut up and suck it up when they have a blood test, but you can instead give them a sticker and tell them they’re brave. Both kids have had to be resilient in learning to have a blood test, but I can wager which one will feel sad and worried and which will feel proud and happy. And the proud happy one will associate that with blood tests and feel less worried in the future. Result, resilience.

Kanaloa · 31/03/2022 06:15

@vbnm89

At my nieces school they are not allowed to now use the word "brave" because they say it indicates that a child can't express their true feelings. I think just think this is taking away a child's resilience to everyday problems - obviously if they are really hurt that is totally different. She went for a blood test yesterday and she got a certificate for being brave and a sticker and she couldn't wait to show me how BRAVE she had been!! I just feel that resilience is being compromised in society today .
But she was brave, wasn’t she? She got a blood test. Many adults dislike doing this.

And this is not some new fangled this generation nonsense. I remember as a child being given sweets at the hospital when I had to have tests because I was a ‘big girl.’ I was given packs of stickers to put on my bandages etc. That’s just normal.

But congratulations for telling your kids to suck it up when they say they’re unwell because only vomiting or a temperature is worthy of being unwell.

Meatshake · 31/03/2022 06:07

Being allowed to feel your feelings isn't a sign of not being resilient.

Feeling your feelings and then getting back up, brushing yourself off and trying again is basic emotional literacy.

As a child who experienced severe trauma in the 80s/90s, I was probably considered resilient. However it's a house of fucking cards and my life came crumbling down a couple of years ago and I've worked hard to rebuild.

From what I can gather, resilience of the archetypal 70s meaning tends to be a cobbled together hodge podge of unhealthy coping mechanisms. It mostly means "don't inconvenience me with your bullshit emotions".

I'm proud not to parent like that.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 31/03/2022 05:58

How old are your kids OP?

RichTeaRichTea · 31/03/2022 05:43

@Morfil

I believe there is research (I do not know how robust) that does indeed suggest that children are less resilient today than in previous generations (although the differences aren’t that significant).

It strikes me as a mixed bag though - the ‘stiff upper lip’ approach breeds it’s own, special kind of harm.

My first question when I hear things like this is “what is the definition of resilience?” What does it look like, what measurable outcomes are we talking about?
Morfil · 31/03/2022 02:39

I believe there is research (I do not know how robust) that does indeed suggest that children are less resilient today than in previous generations (although the differences aren’t that significant).

It strikes me as a mixed bag though - the ‘stiff upper lip’ approach breeds it’s own, special kind of harm.

BoredZelda · 31/03/2022 00:52

At my nieces school they are not allowed to now use the word "brave" because they say it indicates that a child can't express their true feelings. I think just think this is taking away a child's resilience to everyday problems

This is absolute tosh.

Stompythedinosaur · 30/03/2022 23:52

I think this is a very uninformed post.

Children do not become resilient by not having their emotional needs met, quite the opposite, actually.

I work in a healthcare area where I have regular experience of quite traumatic stuff - like all my colleagues I am very able to "dig deep and keep going" when I need to. But we all also access supervision, reflective practice and other settings to talk about hour feelings and experiences, and we do that because it helps us to stay resilient when it counts.

It is the same with dc. Meeting their needs, helping to co-regulate emotions and build string attachments and safe relationships, helps them to be resilient when they need to be.

IGotAVaxAndILikedIt · 30/03/2022 23:44

My children are (like me) pragmatic.

Bad shit happens, you have to deal with it.

Thing is though, they don't have to deal with things alone do they? No-one should have to deal with stuff alone if they need help. The fact that some people do, doesn't make that right.

They are resilient and strong and ready to face the world and they also know that they can ask for help when they need it.

And thank fuck for that.

Calandor · 30/03/2022 23:38

So tell them to be courageous. Courage is doing something even when you find it scary or hard. Meaning it's OK to be afraid or feel frustrated, but overcoming it is admirable.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/03/2022 23:37

Being weak and a victim is now seen to be something to strive for.
What a load of tosh.
Teenagers are under far more pressure these days than ever before.
Anxious DC have always been a part of every generation alongside the striving DC.
DC are probably more protected than they were in the past however given child sexual abuse was rampant across families and child friendly environments the safety precautions aren't a bad thing.
DC understand grooming unfortunately, social pressures, the constant news from covid and now war.
I grew up in the 80's NI was in crisis the news was shown at 6pm not constant streaming and discussions in school.

ddl1 · 30/03/2022 23:23

@Ladywinesalot

Op you’re getting a rough ride here…

I agree with you, children now are very weak and don’t have much back bone to them.

They are anxious and stressed about everything!!

Being weak and a victim is now seen to be something to strive for.

Being anxious and stressed is nothing to do with lacking backbone.

And nobody strives to be weak or a victim. What is perhaps true is that weakness and strength are less gendered than in the past. In the past, girls were often expected to be weak and dependent, and boys to be strong and independent. Now it's more acceptable for both sexes to be sometimes one, sometimes the other,

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/03/2022 23:19

Aibu to think adults can't be brave or strong anymore.

Some are and some aren't depending on life experiences.

A tad ridiculous to generalise all adults kids on your experience of kids.

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 30/03/2022 23:14

@MrsPsmalls I mean these days it is illegal to explicitly discriminate on the grounds of disability. It wasn't in the past. That is just a fact. What it means in practice can vary - sure, you have to cope at work etc and employers often don't make that many accommodations - but, for example, it is immeasurably better to be disabled now than it was in the 60s.

ZenKaleidoscope · 30/03/2022 23:09

Children seem to want to be weak and dependable on others rather than strong and independent.

Children are dependents though. Also I think it's a sign in of strength to express your negative emotions because that's not easy.

Prescottdanni123 · 30/03/2022 22:57

There is nothing wrong with teaching kids to be strong and independent, but it is also important to teach them that it is OK not to be OK sometimes, that its alright to cry, that mental health struggles aren't something to be ashamed of, that sometimes it is good to reach out to others and say 'I need help'. There is nothing wrong with needing to lean on someone else sometimes.

I do think that it is important that people can stand on their own two feet, but the approach needs to be balanced. Encouraging kids to be too stoic can be just as bad as letting them be too dependent.

MrsPsmalls · 30/03/2022 22:55

[quote pucelleauxblanchesmains]**@OfstedOffred* But isn't the problem that while "most NT, able bodied people shouldnt constantly need support with everything down to the most basic things", a lot of the people who say kids lack resilience don't believe in neurodiversity and think autism and ADHD are made up excuses for being "weak". I'm not NT. I have* needed more support in my life. In the past nobody would have recognised autism especially in a girl, so I'm not one for hearkening back to the good old days.[/quote]
I'm not sure how helpful this attitude is really. Sure you may NEED more support but realistically you are not going to get it. No one cares. Or no one outside your family and possibly friendship group cares. I do believe in neurodiversity. Adult DS has ADHD. No one cares. No one really cared even at school and they certainly don't care now he is at work. In fact he even has a job that actually forbids him from being on medication. So he either finds ways to shape up at whatever cost to himself or he ships out. He is kind of resilient. I don't really know how. But if he couldn't cope he would be sacked. And that's just how it is for most people. I do think we are leading young people astray if we let them believe that they will be supported. They won't be.

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 30/03/2022 22:38

@OfstedOffred But isn't the problem that while "most NT, able bodied people shouldnt constantly need support with everything down to the most basic things", a lot of the people who say kids lack resilience don't believe in neurodiversity and think autism and ADHD are made up excuses for being "weak". I'm not NT. I have needed more support in my life. In the past nobody would have recognised autism especially in a girl, so I'm not one for hearkening back to the good old days.

Fcuk38 · 30/03/2022 22:36

Mine are as strong as fuck after loosing their dad to a brain tumour aged 6 and 9. They can also be emotional wrecks. 🤷🏼‍♀️

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/03/2022 22:31

Nah. My DC have overcome obstacles that I never thought possible.

DC are resilient when faced with pressures, look at the DC suffering all over the world.

Two Ukrainian 13 year olds started in DD's class, they're brave, strong and resilient.

I think DC are able to discuss fears these days unlike olden days, my DM was a sensitive person, the coldness of her
generation had a negative impact on her forever.

If anything I'd say the lucky DC excluding those neglected have a much better chance at a successful life.

Rosewaterblossom · 30/03/2022 22:23

In the last school I worked at, the library at lunchtimes (it was a little school) was like A&E. A kid would only have a bump in the playground and they'd be sat inside with an cold compress.
I recall at primary school regularly being hit with a football if you ran across the playground whilst the boys were playing football! It hurt but it never hurt enough to need to be sat inside with a cold compress.
I do believe kids are being taught to wimper at every opportunity. Of course If a child is genuinely hurt then treat them with sympathy, but half of it is just babyish behaviour that's being overly pandering to.

daisyjgrey · 30/03/2022 22:14

The irony of parents on here complaining that children have no resilience. YOU'RE raising them! Are you a grandparent complaining about the same thing? Guess who's raising them? Children that YOU raised!

Just give it a rest and let people live. Try being more resilient, it might not bother you then...

OfstedOffred · 30/03/2022 21:13

kids are actually a lot braver and stronger because they can admit when they have a problem

The issue though is that too many think everything is a problem!
It's an inability to distinguish between a little problem you can solve yourself without always needing support, and a bigger problem where you need support. The key being that most NT, able bodied people shouldnt constantly need support with everything down to the most basic things.

OfstedOffred · 30/03/2022 21:06

I think we disempower kids to an extent these days- lots of emphasis on struggling and the idea that your mental health is at the mercy of other people and circumstance, rather than something you can take charge of yourself. That it means strategies and support to deal with things that are anxiety-inducing, rather than an excuse not to do those things at all.

I think this is a really good way to describe it

OfstedOffred · 30/03/2022 21:05

But we do seem to be wrapping our kids in blankets a bit too much for my liking and I question how they'll cope with life's challenges as they grow into adulthood.

This. Some of my kids school friends get kept home if they tell mum they are tired/have "tummyache" or some other vague ailment. This was unheard of when I was at school! When I was a child you basically only stayed off for

  • vomiting
  • chicken pox/measles
  • something involving hospitalisation