Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBu to think kids can't be brave and strong anymore?

239 replies

vbnm89 · 30/03/2022 16:23

AIBuU to think that being brave and strong is now frowned upon?? I have noticed this generation of kids having very little resilience. My kids and their friends are always moaning they have something wrong or something hurts or they can't do something. If children fall over now you aren't allowed to say be brave and teaching them to be strong could be bad for their mental health. I only ever keep my kids off school for a temperature or being sick - I tell them to suck it up and get on with it - you can't just miss school every time something hurts.

When I was a teenager I wanted to be strong and tough but now it seems that you can't bring your children up to be strong as you may damage their mental health. Children seem to want to be weak and dependable on others rather than strong and independent. They don't seem to have any get up and go and if anything is a bit tough the mental health card is used to stop them having to do anything they can't or don 't like doing!!

OP posts:
RichTeaRichTea · 01/04/2022 20:43

“ You're talking about the aftermath, during a crisis it served people but without the support once the war finished (which of course was not forthcoming/no debrief/had to clear up and get on with it) thats the damage caused, not the 'getting on with it while it happened'”

That’s not fashion though - everyone gets on with it during a war it while it happens everywhere and throughout time, it’s not a “fashion” for “stiff upper lips”

purpleboy · 01/04/2022 19:40

@Hospedia

For those who think kids today lack resilience, what exactly is it about kids today that makes you think this? Because having mental health issues is not a sign of lacking resilience, they're a health issue in the same way a broken leg or diabetes doesn't represent a lack of resilience.
I don't want to speak in general terms because it's inaccurate, but from my own experiences, Running a business, I have staff members calling in sick because: The car has broken down, they live less than a mile away but it's too far to walk. Can't come to work for an 8 hour shift because they have a dentist appointment 6 hours into the shift. Can't get in because mum can't drive them, and obviously can't get public transport at 18 Have to leave work early because their lift can only get them at x time and again couldn't possibly take public transport. I need a break after 1 hour, then 2 etc.... Can't expect me to work on my own, I need help. (5 customers) Can't carry a tray of glasses. Can't come in on time because I'm going out the night before.

Dc (19) school friends:
Didn't get into 1st choice uni, didn't want to apply anywhere else, has now decided not to bother reapplying because they might not get in again.
Can't go to prom because their date was sick and didn't want to go alone (despite the majority going solo)
Refused to go to school for 2 weeks because they didn't get head girl position.
Tried to quit course because they had to do 4 hours extra work a week.
Want to quit uni because they have to go in every day.
Want to quit uni because they don't have any money, and don't want to get a job.
Needed to take a week off school after they didn't do as well in their mock exams.

Dc (8)
Crying because they left a piece of artwork at school.
Cried because they weren't picked for the first team, parents went into school to demand they were put in.
Refused to go into school because they weren't main part in school play.
Refused to do work on zoom (lockdown) because they didn't like the topic.
Won't get in the pool because it's not heated.
Need a packed lunch because they don't like school food,(no packed lunches allowed and about 10 different food options every day)
Won't go to trampolining party because they can't jump as high as x.

That's just a few examples, but as I say I don't want to generalize, this is only my personal experience with some young people, and in most of these cases the parents supported the kids decisions, but honestly I think it's doing the lm way more harm than good.

The kids who has suffers real trauma, parent dying, medical conditions etc... are the most resilient by far, it's the ones who have never really had anything go wrong that seem to have the most problems with coping with the small stuff.

bellac11 · 01/04/2022 19:13

[quote ldontWanna]@bellac11 and that is why generalisations don't work.

Your way sounds exhausting and overwhelming to me. Not just that, but it would probably send me in a pretty unhealthy (overthinking)spiral.

I cope and manage my issues in completely different ways, I also am confident in my feelings and I know when I am distressed,angry,sad ,happy etc ,why and more importantly that they are real and correct.I also know what needs to happen to sort it out. 99% of the time is just space to vent,acknowledgment/validation. As I process them and allow myself to feel them,they diminish in intensity and fizzle out.Then I'm over it and it's done and dusted.

Having to justify how I feel,overanalyse it, unpicking it ,questioning them etc, even to myself, would just breed frustration and resentment, which just prolongs the situation and is counterintuitive.

I'm not saying I'm right and you're wrong. Just that some people might be like me,some like you, and millions others deal with things in other different ways. And some ways can be harmful to some,even if they work very well for others.[/quote]
Perhaps Ive explained it differently to you but I would agree that what you describe is what I do!

I need to explore, unpick and work out, you use the terms, vent, acknowledge and validate and process and as you say they then diminish intensity over time.

Same thing, different words.

Hospedia · 01/04/2022 19:10

For those who think kids today lack resilience, what exactly is it about kids today that makes you think this? Because having mental health issues is not a sign of lacking resilience, they're a health issue in the same way a broken leg or diabetes doesn't represent a lack of resilience.

ldontWanna · 01/04/2022 19:05

@bellac11 and that is why generalisations don't work.

Your way sounds exhausting and overwhelming to me. Not just that, but it would probably send me in a pretty unhealthy (overthinking)spiral.

I cope and manage my issues in completely different ways, I also am confident in my feelings and I know when I am distressed,angry,sad ,happy etc ,why and more importantly that they are real and correct.I also know what needs to happen to sort it out. 99% of the time is just space to vent,acknowledgment/validation. As I process them and allow myself to feel them,they diminish in intensity and fizzle out.Then I'm over it and it's done and dusted.

Having to justify how I feel,overanalyse it, unpicking it ,questioning them etc, even to myself, would just breed frustration and resentment, which just prolongs the situation and is counterintuitive.

I'm not saying I'm right and you're wrong. Just that some people might be like me,some like you, and millions others deal with things in other different ways. And some ways can be harmful to some,even if they work very well for others.

bellac11 · 01/04/2022 18:43

@RichTeaRichTea

“ it was all 'stiff upper lip' and that may have served people well in extreme situations like during the war”

Not sure that has served people well at all. The trauma not being dealt with has reverberated down the generations, I see it in my work

You're talking about the aftermath, during a crisis it served people but without the support once the war finished (which of course was not forthcoming/no debrief/had to clear up and get on with it) thats the damage caused, not the 'getting on with it while it happened'

There are different stages to coping and resilience, you can only build resilience by coping but thats if there is room to understand what happened to you. I think thats the bit that got missed although one of the mitgations was a shared experience for many.

RichTeaRichTea · 01/04/2022 18:34

“ it was all 'stiff upper lip' and that may have served people well in extreme situations like during the war”

Not sure that has served people well at all. The trauma not being dealt with has reverberated down the generations, I see it in my work

Ballcactus · 01/04/2022 18:14

It’s the opposite, acknowledging real feelings and actually feeling them makes much more emotionally resilient children who grow up to me emotionally intelligent and self aware adults

freckles20 · 01/04/2022 18:09

I would say that some of the bravest and strongest young people that I know are those who have bravely spoken about their MH difficulties, and asked for help to explore and overcome them.

So no OP I don't think being brave and strong is frowned upon, but I have a feeling that my interpretation of those adjectives is different to yours.

freckles20 · 01/04/2022 18:01

@vivainsomnia

Yet the number of referrals for mental health support for kids suffering from anxiety has never been so high.
There's been a pandemic @vivainsomnia!

In my county of Leicestershire this meant young people couldn't socialise, see their friends, play sport, visit a play park, attend clubs, meet anyone outside of their household, explore, learn, climb, take risks, begin relationships, etc etc etc for 6 months solid, followed by intermittent months of the same.

It was brutally hard for adults, never mind young people who are still in the process of growing up, developing social skills, understanding emotions.

Teenagers in particular need to pull away from their immediate family, explore their environment, form close friendships, experiment, learn and grow so that they can get a sense of self outside of their caregivers. They couldn't do gnus and the effect of their MH and development has been huge.

bellac11 · 01/04/2022 17:57

[quote ldontWanna]@bellac11 do you apply that to positive feelings and emotions as well?[/quote]
I think it depends what you mean by positive. I like to explore what a situation is so I examine everything so I will pick things apart.

I get a bit frustrated with a stance of 'it will be alright'.

Well it might be alright, but I need to check it out first, make sure all the things are in place to make something alright, then I can feel good about it because then Im sure about it.

But there is a reason to check whether distress is distress, it needs to be checked out, you might not want to check whether positivity is positivity, you dont need to be so cautious I suppose.

Hagpie · 01/04/2022 17:52

Masking your emotions is a lot easier and requires a lot less bravery than opening up tbh. How can you consider today’s kids less resilient? They’ve just been through a pandemic, a lot of them will be very cold this winter and some of them won’t be eating that much this half-term. Yet they will show up to school and do the best they can; with whatever tools they have in their tiny arsenals. Absolute rubbish!

ldontWanna · 01/04/2022 17:44

@bellac11 do you apply that to positive feelings and emotions as well?

georgarina · 01/04/2022 17:42

We absolutely still tell kids to be brave and strong when it comes to things they can deal with on their own.

Difference is we're also learning to listen and help kids through serious issues rather than ignoring it and telling them to toughen up.

bellac11 · 01/04/2022 17:36

@TheNameOfTheRoses

But then my up bringing was very different than yours and taught me something different so maybe this is where the difference in opinion is coming from.
It was a complete eye opener for me, and unfortunately my mum wont ever really be able to recognise, she will continue to feel that if she feels something, it is therefore 'true', and everyone else needs to go along with it no matter what.

Balance is needed as with all things

bluebellsandcustard · 01/04/2022 17:33

I don't agree, it's not my experience at all.

Plenty of children play contact sports, Pony Club has record member numbers, there are loads of brilliant, really tough kids out there.

bellac11 · 01/04/2022 17:31

[quote TheNameOfTheRoses]@bellac11 that’s an interesting take.
I can’t say that’s what I took/am taking from my work with a psychotherapist.
But rather that my feelings are often the signals for something going on that I need to have a look at.

Does it mean that how I feel is then set in stone and there is no changing them? Of course not. But, for me, it doesn’t mean they are unreliable. Or certainly not that others don’t have to take them into account at all.[/quote]
I think by their very nature emotions cant be reliable, unless the evidence and the unpicking of them leads to rational and logical evidence that they are reliable.

I absolutely agree feelings need looking at but not with an automatic assumption they need acting on in the way it 'feels' but equally not to say that they shouldnt be acted on in the way they feel, they need unpicking first with reason.

bellac11 · 01/04/2022 17:29

@RichTeaRichTea

I agree with you about feelings generally bellac11, and your mother sounds incredibly difficult to grow up with. When you say fashions do you think there were a lot of people of her generation who behaved similarly?

In my experience you have people who exhibit a range of behaviours in all generations, it might be expressed slightly differently as society changes or due to particular common experiences, but the whole “kids these days have no resilience” thing is also just a variation of the same moaning every generation has always directed at younger people.

Theres a lot of truth in that yes.

When I talk about fashions, I mean that during the 17th/18th centuries for example is when we started to be more introspective and look at the individual needs, but there have been period of time last century and at the end of the Victorian age when it was all 'stiff upper lip' and that may have served people well in extreme situations like during the war and the fashion has now changed again. It will change back again

ldontWanna · 01/04/2022 14:59

@ReadyToMoveIt

The number of referrals for adult MH services is huge, they're the DC of yesteryear, when did their resilience end

Very good point

Not to mention the vicious circle of undiagnosed,struggling,barely functioning people raising kids in abusive,toxic,chaotic homes , them raising their own kids and so on.

My grandma (and her mum) was stressed,overworked,worn out, abusive ,set in her ways and rather selfish. My mother was the same way. I was headed the same way but managed to break the cycle. DD won't ever have to carry years of generational trauma and abuse on her shoulders.

ldontWanna · 01/04/2022 14:50

@vivainsomnia

Yet the number of referrals for mental health support for kids suffering from anxiety has never been so high.
Well what was available in terms of help,support,diagnosis and mental health treatment for children or the population at large 20 years ago,30 years ago, 50 years ago?

It's like saying people can't drive anymore because there are more accidents today than 50 years ago.

ReadyToMoveIt · 01/04/2022 13:51

The number of referrals for adult MH services is huge, they're the DC of yesteryear, when did their resilience end

Very good point

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/04/2022 13:48

Yet the number of referrals for mental health support for kids suffering from anxiety has never been so high.
It wasn't available years ago.
There is so many adults suffering with MH problems, anxiety, agoraphobia, morbid obesity, drug addiction, alcoholism.
Maybe if these people had health or a mental health referral as a DC they wouldn't be in the situation they are now.

The number of referrals for adult MH services is huge, they're the DC of yesteryear, when did their resilience end.

I had undiagnosed PMDD it was awful as a teenager leading into anorexia.
That was the 90's the only in care help was on a adult psychiatric unit, it's no wonder people suffered in silence.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 01/04/2022 13:22

@TheNameOfTheRoses

That trend started before covid.

Imo it’s a society issue. Whether we want to acknowledge it or not, we’ve created a society that is harsh. Harsh for us so adult MH issues are going up and up. Harsh for children too.

And I don’t think it’s going to be better soon. Not when so many more people will live in poverty and wonder where to find enough money to eat and warm their house. Unfortunately people are still (or is it already?) putting their head in the sand telling posters it’s their fault if they are struggling. I can’t see it changing (but more people will struggle MH wise that’s for sure)

Well said.
ReadyToMoveIt · 01/04/2022 13:20

I agree @TheNameOfTheRoses, it did start before covid but has been massively exacerbated.
Society is harsh, and we just expect kids (and adults) to get on with it, and not moan, because moaning means they aren’t resilient.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 01/04/2022 13:16

That trend started before covid.

Imo it’s a society issue. Whether we want to acknowledge it or not, we’ve created a society that is harsh. Harsh for us so adult MH issues are going up and up. Harsh for children too.

And I don’t think it’s going to be better soon. Not when so many more people will live in poverty and wonder where to find enough money to eat and warm their house. Unfortunately people are still (or is it already?) putting their head in the sand telling posters it’s their fault if they are struggling. I can’t see it changing (but more people will struggle MH wise that’s for sure)