Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boris Johnson ‘fat shaming’.

157 replies

Curvesinallthewrongplaces · 30/03/2022 13:23

I’ve heard a couple of times Boris Johnson comment on Ian Blackford’s weight.

How is this okay?

You wouldn’t comment to a colleague about them “eating all the pies” so why is it okay for Boris to?

In front of so many people too…I know some will say it’s “banter” but I’m sure that’s been an excuse for a lot ot negative comments about people on the past.

Am I being over sensitive to think our PM shouldn’t be making such comments?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
girlmom21 · 31/03/2022 18:22

Kier starker is at least trying to walk the line between being sensitive to the trans community and protection female spaces.

Kier Starmer is so worried about making sure he doesn't offend anyone that he's not doing anything to benefit anyone.

jgw1 · 31/03/2022 18:18

@EthelTheAardvark

He's not half as embarrassing as Starmer and his total lack of knowledge of female anatomy.It is unbelievable that the leader of a once powerful party should display such ignorance of basic biology and the consequences for women of policies based on it

Is there any topic that the obsessives won't drag trans issues into? Manifestly Starmer is perfectly familiar with female anatomy; he has a track record as DPP as being probably the most effective ever in promoting protection of female (and indeed male) victims of sexual assault, rape, abuse, trafficking and the like.. Whereas the only reason Johnson has any familiarity with female anatomy is that he views it as being there purely to sate his personal appetites.

But they are world leading appetites and so he should be applauded for them.
Iggly · 31/03/2022 17:45

He's not half as embarrassing as Starmer and his total lack of knowledge of female anatomy.It is unbelievable that the leader of a once powerful party should display such ignorance of basic biology and the consequences for women of policies based on it

If you think Boris gives a shit about female safe spaces then think again.

Kier starker is at least trying to walk the line between being sensitive to the trans community and protection female spaces.

Boris just doesn’t give a shit about the trans community and I strongly suspect would just call them men in dresses.

EthelTheAardvark · 31/03/2022 16:56

He's not half as embarrassing as Starmer and his total lack of knowledge of female anatomy.It is unbelievable that the leader of a once powerful party should display such ignorance of basic biology and the consequences for women of policies based on it

Is there any topic that the obsessives won't drag trans issues into? Manifestly Starmer is perfectly familiar with female anatomy; he has a track record as DPP as being probably the most effective ever in promoting protection of female (and indeed male) victims of sexual assault, rape, abuse, trafficking and the like.. Whereas the only reason Johnson has any familiarity with female anatomy is that he views it as being there purely to sate his personal appetites.

Hadtocomment · 30/03/2022 20:27

I don't think personal "jokes" or sneering or bullying jibes about people's bodies have any place in parliament. I don't see how it can be argued to further debate and it just adds to the not in touch and arrogant atmosphere that alienates so many from politics. You can always argue there are more important things but it's puerile and pathetic stuff and pretty unseemly for a prime minister to be acting in this way. I do wonder if the jeering and bullying vibe is part of his image. In which case - who on earth is it attracting and why do people want this in their politicians?

Blossomtoes · 30/03/2022 20:19

@Cornettoninja

I will never understand your thought process.
Nor will I but that delights me. I’d be really worried about myself if I could.
jgw1 · 30/03/2022 20:14

@Cornettoninja

It’s seems odd that someone would see a thread about Boris Johnson and be moved to comment on his policies? Boris Johnson the well known politician? Boris Johnson the prime minister? That Boris Johnson?

An unfathomable mystery indeed.

It is quite hard to defend Johnson's policies which are essentially, keep Boris in power, enrich mates by any means possible to ensure Boris stays in power. Party and have cheese and wine while everyone else takes lockdown seriously. Spaff other peoples money on enriching your mates and keep Boris in power.

Which I suppose is why his defenders so want to discuss whether or not Blackford is fat.

jgw1 · 30/03/2022 20:11

@JaniieJones

'Have MN started employing thread monitors? Do you get a badge?'

Well it just seems odd on a thread discussing alleged fat shaming to pipe up why aren't we discussing his policies..

@JaniieJones Does he have any policies for the cost of living crisis?

Surely if he did he would have articulated them in the House of Commons today, rather than throwing around childish insults?

TrickyD · 30/03/2022 19:38

I much prefer Blackford’s comfortable rotund figure to Johnson with his horrible fat legs and hideous knock knees..

Cornettoninja · 30/03/2022 19:36

I will never understand your thought process.

SueSaid · 30/03/2022 19:32

'It’s seems odd that someone would see a thread about Boris Johnson and be moved to comment on his policies'

Well yes 'ooo Bozo called Blackford fat that's disgusting!', 'nevermind that what about inflation!' Confused.

Cornettoninja · 30/03/2022 19:26

It’s seems odd that someone would see a thread about Boris Johnson and be moved to comment on his policies? Boris Johnson the well known politician? Boris Johnson the prime minister? That Boris Johnson?

An unfathomable mystery indeed.

SueSaid · 30/03/2022 19:19

'Have MN started employing thread monitors? Do you get a badge?'

Well it just seems odd on a thread discussing alleged fat shaming to pipe up why aren't we discussing his policies..

Nightlystroll · 30/03/2022 19:15

OMG. It's two grown up politicians both of which have said and done unpleasant things in the past, and both are capable of being quite nasty. They've hides like rhinos and a joke that they're both porky isn't going to bother either of them. It was said in Patliament in the cut and thrust atmosphere of the HoC and not at a vicars tea party. Let's get a grip.

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/03/2022 19:09

Pots/kettles Grin

fixyourfences · 30/03/2022 19:08

See also women dressed like bank robbers and pillar boxes.

Racism and fatism

Cornettoninja · 30/03/2022 19:08

It's a thread about him allegedly fat shaming!! Start another if you want to change the subject

Have MN started employing thread monitors? Do you get a badge?

fixyourfences · 30/03/2022 19:06

Obesity is a disease.

These days it is unacceptable to refer to or define people by their disease (see also Down's syndrome and disability)

Referring to 'fat people' or other types of fat-shaming are today's equivalent of calling people spastics or cripples or Downs kids (I know, it's offensive to even think about people in these terms any more, but that is how some unfortunate people think it is acceptable to define people with obesity). These unfortunate people probably define themselves by their slimness and fitness and this reinforces their feelings of superiority. They are wrong. People are defined by more than their weight. Personality, morals and behaviour are more defining.

BJ has probably just been listening to a certain influential person in his personal life and not listening enough to NHS or medical briefings he may or may not have actually turned up to.

SueSaid · 30/03/2022 18:56

'but rather want everyone to pay attention to people's personal appearance.'

It's a thread about him allegedly fat shaming!! Start another if you want to change the subject.

Back to Blackford. As I said earlier the 'fat shaming' was either 'The Tory leader claimed he and the SNP Westminster chief were both “a living testament to the benefits of moderation'

Or 'i don't know who ate more cake'.

Both harmless and acknowledging they're both overweight.

If the op has one that actually demonstrates fat shaming lets hear it.

Cornettoninja · 30/03/2022 18:53

Being po faced about this, distracts and detracts from the very real problems his leadership causes

I don’t entirely disagree but from where I’m sitting this is a direct result of allowing a joke of cabinet to remain running the country. There are absolutely more serious issues that require proper discussion but that’s not going to happen primarily because BJ isn’t going to engage in them - watch this afternoons committee for a word salad instead of engagement in the opportunity for a proper discussion outside of PMQ’s. It’s much more obvious without the raucous vocalisations from either side.

This is what many people warned of, he simply can’t stay in power because he’s lost so much credibility. The focus is on his insults without any real rebuttal because he didn’t actually say anything of any worth during the session. Never does.

jgw1 · 30/03/2022 18:49

@JaniieJones it is nice to see that you like the Prime Minister don't have anything to say about policies that might help with the cost of living crisis, but rather want everyone to pay attention to people's personal appearance.

SueSaid · 30/03/2022 18:31

@Notlabeled

Didn't see any outrage on here when most of the left wing internet was being pretty vile about Boris jogging on the beach a week ago, but I guess it's OK when they do it, since they are the good guys when spewing hate.
No no no. Its fine to do it at him. Call him Bozo but don't dare call Starmer Keith. Laugh at Bozo' s hair, wife, dandruff whatever you like! but we must remain straight faced at all times when faced with Angie's silly shoes and her Babyliss sponsored bouffant and Keith's whiny wibbly speeches.

Thems the mumsnettters rules.

LadyShatterly · 30/03/2022 18:11

Good point Notlabeled!

jgw1 · 30/03/2022 18:08

@Celiamary

An overweight adult male addressed a mild insult to another overweight adult male. Why is this an important topic? Why does a mild insult get raised to the status of "shaming"? It really is not important
You are right it is not important.

So why was the Prime Minister wasting his precious time on something so unimportant?

derxa · 30/03/2022 18:06

@Notlabeled

Didn't see any outrage on here when most of the left wing internet was being pretty vile about Boris jogging on the beach a week ago, but I guess it's OK when they do it, since they are the good guys when spewing hate.
Yes some of the cartoons were extremely nasty