Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be so fed up/angry with people taking on animals they have no clue how to treat properly

81 replies

esloquehay · 30/03/2022 08:21

I'm so sick of stupid people buying 'pets' unethically/ill-informed, then re-home-ing them, as they miraculously discover they are ill-equipped to care for them properly.

Then, the almost inevitable virtue-signalling of re-home-ing.

OP posts:
Tuala · 30/03/2022 12:32

We could have sold the fish for good money instead. Hell, HE could have sold the fish for good money instead.

Or perhaps animals aren't for making money and perhaps someone could have just looked after them properly.

Cornettoninja · 30/03/2022 12:31

@fairylightsandwaxmelts absolutely agree it’s much better that someone has the self awareness to recognise they’re out of their depth and seek a suitable home, 100%.

I think I’ve still got that person a PP described earlier in the thread who has a stream of small hamsters etc. And Katie Price Angry

Itsbeenaday · 30/03/2022 12:31

Agree with @fairylightsandwaxmelts

Adore our animals (cats and a dog) but even though we'd waited, planned, researched breeds for years, visited rehoming centers, dog sat for friends, had dogs as children, lived on a farm, etc NOTHING could prepare me for the puppy blues and exactly how much training and time you have to put in to raising a happy, well mannered, socialised and calm dog. On paper we were good to go but I regretted him for the first few months, we have an amazing bond now and he's a happy family dog but never doing that again! It takes a real dedication to raising animals and if it's not there it's not right to keep the animal and add to that possible neglect, just do the right thing.

I'm shocked at some pps knowing people getting animals regularly for kids Shock

LadyLothbrook · 30/03/2022 12:29

I agree. I bought GP two years ago for DDS as they were sold to me as low maintence pets. Admittedly I had done minimal research at that time thinking it was accurate. Googling it and clicking the top search results and taken it as gospel. Everything confirmed by the pet store about how easy they are to care for. Got home with the 'starter pack' and after just a week it didn't seem sufficient for these two growing potatoes. I did more research and found out the minimum measurements for the living space for guinea pigs and how they should be set up to live a happy life. Must have cost me a further £200 quid in a new digs for them. Then cane the relentless cleaning. Oh my god looked like someone had poured a cereal box full of GP shit in the cage every single morning. I was doing full cleans every two days. And they were so skittish I didn't want my girls hodling them and frightening them with their big sticky hands. I had GP mum guilt all the time. In the end I rehomed to a single lady who essentially turned her apartment into a giant GP run. We still stay in contact now but it was a very important lesson on not getting caged animals like GPS. I was overwhelmed with anxiety when we first got our dog. I'd focused on the positives of having one and completely put the negatives out of my mind. So it's easy done, idealism. I struggled with such a huge change he made to my life but then one day I just taught myself to accept the hair, constantly muddy carpets and clothes, the following me absolutely everywhere. He's still in my eyes alot less maintenence than the bloody helpless and thankless GPS.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 30/03/2022 12:21

@Cornettoninja

People shouldn't be shamed for making a mistake and finding their pet a more suitable home

I agree shame is unhelpful, but so many people don’t seem to feel obliged to take the time and really consider what they’re signing up for. Imho that’s pretty inexcusable in an age there’s a wealth of information at our fingertips.

I agree that too many people don't do their research - but equally you only have to read a couple of "Doghouse" threads to realise that all the prep in the world doesn't prepare you for the reality of pet ownership.

If you have a dog who develops, for example, separation anxiety, or ends up reactive after being bitten or attacked - that's really difficult and I don't blame owners who acknowledge it's too tough for them.

It's okay to say that you've made a mistake/can't cope and that the dog would be better off in a different home with more experienced owners.

Fimofriend · 30/03/2022 12:10

I totally agree.

We had fish but were going to live in Britain for 6 months so let one of DH's friends have them. He had an aquarium the size of a large bathtub and liked to monologue about fish care and stuff like that. While we were away he stopped finding fish interesting so when we returned his aquarium was a large green brick and all the fish were dead. We could have sold the fish for good money instead. Hell, HE could have sold the fish for good money instead.

Cornettoninja · 30/03/2022 12:08

People shouldn't be shamed for making a mistake and finding their pet a more suitable home

I agree shame is unhelpful, but so many people don’t seem to feel obliged to take the time and really consider what they’re signing up for. Imho that’s pretty inexcusable in an age there’s a wealth of information at our fingertips.

Cornettoninja · 30/03/2022 12:03

I agree. One of the reasons I like cats is I’m fairly confident if they don’t like the home you provide they will find one they do. It might be me kidding myself but I like to think there’s an element of choice from the cat that they’re happy living with us (or maybe it’s Stockholm syndrome!).

There’s loads of animals I’d love to provide a home for but very few I’m realistically set up for or have the skills to do them justice. I find myself scrutinising the ‘con’s’ lists of guides when I start considering other animals and usually something crops up that means I would be a less than ideal caretaker.

VeganVampire · 30/03/2022 11:54

Oh yes. Pygmy goats in gardens that have to be 'sadly re-homed' due to 'changes in circumstances'. Goats shouldn't be in gardens, they should be in fields - just because you can keep them on a tiny patch of rancid lawn, doesn't mean that you should. All of the trampolines and climbing frames in the world won't make up for the fact that they should be free to roam and browse, not kept on concrete. And then people that have done it for a couple of years trying to tell everyone else that 'goats' don't eat grass' - of course they eat bloody grass - they just don't eat the piss stained rancid lawn that you're keeping them on. And while we're on that tiny piece of rotten grass, it harbours diseases too - goats should be in fields and not spending time trying to eat around where they poop.

It breaks my heart everytime I see an excited new owner buying all of the things for their new pet that they love so very much, but providing none of the space that they need to live.

AwkwardPaws27 · 30/03/2022 11:52

Circumstances change. Living situations change, Finances change. Health changes. People shouldn't be shamed for making a mistake and finding their pet a more suitable home.

This, 100%.
I have too many pets, almost all rescues, but luckily we can afford them and have space for them. If our circumstances significantly changed I would have to consider rehoming some of them.
The rabbits, for example - I have a garden with space for their big enclosure. If we moved into a studio flat I wouldn't expect them to live in the "rabbit cages" sold by pet shops, I'd look at finding them a home (or convincing my mum to have them!).
If something significant happened and I couldn't exercise my dog or afford a daily dog walker, it would be selfish of me to keep him (cocker spaniel so needs a good amount of exercise daily, throwing a ball in the garden wouldn't be enough). It'd break my heart but his needs have to come first.

rookiemere · 30/03/2022 11:42

@fairylightsandwaxmelts I tend to agree.

Posters get so much abuse if they dare to admit that getting a pet has turned out to be a mistake for them. It's true that in many cases it was a stupid decision, but some posters are so busy abusing the OP that they don't really signpost the next steps which are to surrender to a reputable breed specific rescue centre.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 30/03/2022 11:36

I really dislike how people are shamed for admitting that they can't cope.

It's okay to struggle and it's definitely okay to say the animal would be better off elsewhere.

Circumstances change. Living situations change, Finances change. Health changes. People shouldn't be shamed for making a mistake and finding their pet a more suitable home.

Vinorosso74 · 30/03/2022 11:31

Completely agree with you. I follow a couple of rabbit rescues on Instagram along with other animal rescues and the amount of neglected rabbits is shocking. If it were dogs, there would be more of an outcry. Animals kept as pets are complex beings and people should be more aware before taking them on but a lot just like the idea without thinking about the reality. I despair at the amount of people who buy from Pets4homes, Gumtree etc. They complain that the rescues wouldn't let then rehome or have "anything suitable" but they don't actually stop to think that perhaps their home isn't right and it's not Amazon where you can buy exactly what you want.
I also volunteer at a Cats Protection centre so have seen the fall out of unwanted animals (obviusly, there are also genuine reasons for rehoming). Luckily there are lots of people who want to welcome these cats into their homes.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 30/03/2022 11:17

I have two rabbits and that makes so sad. Rabbits are often seen as second-class pets and are regularly dumped because owners fail to research and don’t recognise how complex their needs are. They are not starter pets for children. So no to the OP, YANBU. It annoys me too.

We had the most beautiful little dwarf rabbit. She was so sweet natured. My DF found her, dumped, in a picnic area and brought her home. We took her to our local vet to be checked over, turned out she'd had a broken leg and the vet speculated she'd been abandoned rather than the owners paying for treatment. We'd had rabbits before, so kept her. She ended up very friendly with one our cats (also a rescue who'd been dumped by his owners) and they used to cuddle on the sofa.

I wouldn't keep rabbits again, I have to be honest. In the future I might be interested in a couple of degu or rats, but most likely I'll stick with a cat or two as I can't imagine my life without one!

AwkwardPaws27 · 30/03/2022 11:12

@PeeAche2 it sounds like you gave him a lovely life.

I had a rabbit as a child who died suddenly too, & my mum said she thought he was scared to death by a fox. It was the mid-90s and I do wonder now if it was actually R(V)HD (rabbit viral haemorrhagic disease) as it can cause sudden death.

I partly wonder this as we get daily fox visits but my two boys honestly don't give a shit. They do have a big enclosure with the hutch inside it, so can go into the back corner, intonthe hutch or on their high lookout point if they feel worried but I've seen them sit just the other side of the mesh happily munching hay while the fox looks at them.

We use fox repellent, have 6ft fences all around the garden, 16g weldmesh on the emclosure and the enclosure is on paving slabs so nothing can dig in, so maybe they just feel safe, but I was surprised by how unconcerned they are!

foxlover47 · 30/03/2022 11:10

@Feckaffoutofit 100% agree with this , I would much rather see any animal rehomed than suffering or someone keeping hold of one they clearly resent , also there will always be genuine cases where owners truly cannot cope and it is in the pets best interest ... that is doing right by the animal

Feckaffoutofit · 30/03/2022 11:02

I think it is really important not to make people feel ashamed about rehoming their animals. People who don't want their dogs any more and who feel too ashamed to rehome them end up ignoring them, leaving them alone for extended periods of time, not walking them, not being kind to them, leaving them to rot in small yards and kennels. If someone is not going to give a dog a good home or at least an adequate home they should rehome them. It is much better for the dog. If someone makes a mistake when getting a puppy or any other animal they should admit it and give the animal a chance of a good and happy life by rehoming it. It is important for animals that we encourage this. Of course, people should consider whether they can cater for an animal's needs before they get one but am animal shouldn't hands to suffer a lifetime of neglect and boredom because people are embarrassed to be seen to surrender a pet.

Purple444 · 30/03/2022 10:58

@Hoppinggreen

I was in pets at home on Sunday getting dog treats and there were a couple of rabbits there It struck me that I could just buy one (or 2) and take them home with no checks or anything. I would probably be asked whether I had a suitable hutch or something but other than that they would just be handing over these living things with no idea if I could or would look after them properly I’m not sure what the answer is
Absolutely this. The answer is to not allow shops to sell small animals. They can’t sell dogs and cats so why rabbits and guinea pigs? They frequently mis-sex them and as you say, don’t home check.

Rabbit Sanctuaries are full of unwanted rabbits. They will home check. You will get lots of advice and a pair of neutered and vaccinated rabbits.

You shouldn’t be able to pop to the shops and pick up a pair of live animals on a whim. It’s wrong.

CounsellorTroi · 30/03/2022 10:45

@Spidey66

I agree with the poster who suggested cats as a pet that is easy to look after. If they go out, and there's a flap available, the only daily care needed is feeding them. No cages, little or no mess, no grooming, no walks.
Although they may need a little help with grooming when they get older and are not quite as flexible.
EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/03/2022 10:42

@Chasingaftermidnight Is Ddog a cockapoo? My Dsis dog a Cockapoo is wracked with anxiety.

LimeSegment · 30/03/2022 10:41

I can't stand when people have birds for pets. The bigger and more intelligent the bird, the worse it is. I've seen parrot type birds in cages they can't even stretch their wings out in. It's horrible.

Cats and dogs have their ethical issues but at least they are truly domestic animals, they do feel comfortable living with humans in a human home, as they have for tens of thousands of years.

LittleSnakes · 30/03/2022 10:36

I grew up with caged animals, including birds, reptiles and rodents. I would never do it now. It seems so cruel to them. I first realised it when I learnt as an adult that hamsters will run about 2km a night in the wild. It’s so far! Yet they’re kept in tiny cages.

Hoppinggreen · 30/03/2022 10:35

I was in pets at home on Sunday getting dog treats and there were a couple of rabbits there
It struck me that I could just buy one (or 2) and take them home with no checks or anything. I would probably be asked whether I had a suitable hutch or something but other than that they would just be handing over these living things with no idea if I could or would look after them properly
I’m not sure what the answer is

Whelmed · 30/03/2022 10:23

I generally feel a bit sorry for any animal kept in a cage, though I can't imagine a hamster or gerbil could roam free all day long without getting stuck in a pipe somewhere or down the sofa. Growing up we had a couple of budgies and then a dog. Now I wouldn't really want to have a pet although we sometimes think about getting a cat as my DH loves them and grew up with cats all his life right up to his 20s. It's just extra responsibility and work that I don't have the energy for. I often wonder about my friends who seem to get pets almost on a whim. A hamster or a fish or cats usually. I wonder if they were well prepared or just hoping for the best.

thetemptationofchocolate · 30/03/2022 10:19

I love my pets but they are bloody hard work and expensive to keep in the proper manner.