Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be so fed up/angry with people taking on animals they have no clue how to treat properly

81 replies

esloquehay · 30/03/2022 08:21

I'm so sick of stupid people buying 'pets' unethically/ill-informed, then re-home-ing them, as they miraculously discover they are ill-equipped to care for them properly.

Then, the almost inevitable virtue-signalling of re-home-ing.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lanbro · 30/03/2022 22:04

Totally agree...my cat came from a woman who rehomed a dog she couldn't manage, rehomed the cat when she moved in with a new partner, then got a puppy and last I saw she was enquiring about a kitten.

My cat was 1, and had been raised as a house cat, when I got her. Unspayed. She is now spayed, chipped and loves her adventures in the fields catching mice. She hears my car coming home and comes to greet me. I'm not a cat person at all but mine us lovely, and loving, and deserves so much better than being discarded for convenience

Cattenberg · 30/03/2022 21:35

We had guinea pigs. i felt so bad that they were stuck in a (very large open top cage) and then put out in a large run on the grass on dry days.

Don’t feel bad. At least some guinea-pigs like the security of their enclosure. I’ve visited an animal sanctuary where the guinea-pigs have a lovely shed (with a heat lamp in winter) and are free to go out into a large, grassy enclosure during the day. Some choose never to go outside, which seems a shame.

Although one of my guinea-pigs did escape from his run, briefly. He was trying to get at a large tuft of grass the other side of the netting and eventually managed to squeeze through. I found him sitting just two inches from his run, eating.

AwkwardPaws27 · 30/03/2022 15:43

I dont think people should have animals unless they are working animals (and well looked after).

I don't agree with this; well cared for companion animals are easily as happy if not happier than working animals. If you choose a species and breed that is well suited as a pet and that you are capable of providing good care to, then pets and owners can have wonderful mutually beneficial relationships. For a canine companion breed, being with their human(s) is their job.

I've worked with older adult mental health services and in a vets at different points in my life, and seen some really beneficial relationships where a pet has been an isolated older person's reason to keep going, & in return that pet has really been well cared for & enjoyed their warm lap and doting companion.

What do you think happens to working animals at the end of their "useful" life? Some are lucky and kept well in retirement but many aren't so lucky unfortunately. Dogs from working lines do need a job but this need can be met through a dog sport or other activity too.

I'm not keen on the keeping of exotic species as they are some of the hardest to provide for, but guinea pigs in a large cage, with warmth, food and shelter, are usually very happy little creatures. I have two (rescues) and they are currently zooming around their enclosure as I just topped up their big hay pile and added some forage. They'll be even happier when I chop up a pepper for them later.

My rabbits (also rescues) live in a big enclosure, I'd love to let them run free but they'd be eaten by a fox within hours here. I popped out to see them a little while ago; they are snuggled up together grooming each other. They have safety, food, water, tunnels, protection from disease, and a dig box to enable them to enact natural behaviour.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 30/03/2022 14:35

Pets make me really really sad. I dont think people should have animals unless they are working animals (and well looked after).

I don't really see my cat as a pet, or as belonging to me. He belongs to himself, what belongs to me is the responsibility to keep him as healthy and happy as I can. And that's been my belief with all the cats I've lived with. None of them have moved out so I have to assume I've done ok.

Lillyhatesjaz · 30/03/2022 14:34

I kept rabbits for many years, my oldest lived until she was 8 I often miss them but won't be getting any more. Mine lived in a hutch at night but I let them out into the fully fenced garden every morning so they had plenty on space. They would come back to the hutch themselves when I called them to come in. I didn't pick them up much but any time I was in the garden they would come to see what I was doing. I thought the only real downside of having rabbits was it was difficult to find someone to care for them if we went away, you can't put them in kennels like a cat or dog.

BrieAndChilli · 30/03/2022 14:15

Pets make me really really sad. I dont think people should have animals unless they are working animals (and well looked after).
We had guinea pigs. i felt so bad that they were stuck in a (very large open top cage) and then put out in a large run on the grass on dry days.

We have a dog and i feel sorry that he is stuck in the same couple of rooms/garden while DH works from home. he does get walked but even prisoners get yard time! We are going away in a couple of weeks so he will have to go to kennels. he was a rescue so I'm worried he wont cope well with it. its just not fair, unless you are a farmer and the dog is out working with you all day or its an assistance dog then its not fair on the dog. I read that the reason pet dogs sleep half the day is because they are bored out of their brains!! it would be like expecting a 9 year old to sleep half the day!

SexiestDogWalker · 30/03/2022 14:00

I will never get another dog, they're too much work and I know I will not be happy to have to be bothered with it again. When my dog's time in this world is done, so is mine as a dog owner.

I much prefer cats- ones that are allowed outdoors that is. They can decide where they want to be.

Fimofriend · 30/03/2022 13:57

@Tuala My point was that the idiot could easily have gotten someone to take them off his hands. He could have sold them or given them to mutual friends who had fish as well and would probably have been interested. He could have advertised them for free. No reason for the fish to die a slow death.

We didn't sell them because we loved the fish and wanted them to go to a good home.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 30/03/2022 13:30

I haven’t come across anyone like this. We have a working cocker and he’s ideal for us - he has a big daily walk plus couple of trips out to poop plus games in the house. It’s not an effort though, just part of family life for us (which dogs don’t need a walk each day?).

We also had 2 rabbits - one from a baby but was single birth litter then a year later he was joined by a second who we adopted, gradually introducing them. They had a big run in the garage for night time, then on the grass for daytime but now we’re down to one so he’s in the house and has freedom to roam (although usually moves very little because he’s now 9), the one that died had just turned 10. In not sure how they cost more than cats though and they were both happy to be handled and ideal pets for our young dc. Vet used to comment how affectionate they were but that was dh’s experience of bunnies as a dc too.

ukborn · 30/03/2022 13:28

We had rabbits. Did plenty of research and got a big double storey hutch and a huge run (about 120sq ft). They lived outside year round and we had them for 8 years then we moved to a city so found them a home on a farm with other rabbits (month long introduction program and now all happily running around together). I have to say they were the easiest pets ever. Not very cuddly but if you sat in their run they would hop over you and liked getting strokes. Never ill and only once did one of them need their nails trimmed. Bomb proof - we had dogs and they were fine together and even foxes didn't bother them.
Doing research and taking your responsibilities seriously is key.

upanddownandupanddown · 30/03/2022 13:25

Also, to add, he is a rescue that we got aged 7. We would never had got a kitten; far too many adult cats needing homes. He costs a bloody fortune mind; good quality food, vets bills, yearly vaccinations, fleeing and worming, etc etc. I think many people seem to not realise how damned expensive they are!

upanddownandupanddown · 30/03/2022 13:19

Outdoor CAT, not car

upanddownandupanddown · 30/03/2022 13:17

We’ve had Guinea pigs in the past, but never again. The kids lose interest and they are a lot of work.
We have a cat that lives the life of Riley. He is an outdoor car so could easily wander off if he wasn’t happy but he doesn’t. He is fed, kept warm, loves human company and cuddles and is very affectionate. And is able to live his life as independently as he wants; we never force him on to our laps, he chooses it!

CounsellorTroi · 30/03/2022 13:17

People who get cockapoos are usually the worst offenders. Why on earth someone ever chose to mix two highly intelligent and demanding breeds is beyond me. There are so many 18 month olds on rehoming sites. Someone in our village has one, it's walked on a lead wearing a jumper and is hyperactive as a result. I feel so angry that they're not letting it be a fucking dog and run free.

I agree. Same with Labradoodles which seem to be very fashionable at the moment.

RampantIvy · 30/03/2022 13:11

My sister's friend has two dogs, one of which is a boxer. The dogs never get walked enough and get put in cages when the friend is at work.

The dogs are bored and have licked the paint off the walls, eaten the lino off the kitchen floor and eaten her work headset.

If you can't devote the time and attention a dog needs you shouldn't have one.

BoodleBug51 · 30/03/2022 13:09

I get so angry with dog rehoming threads on here.

Someone gets a dog, then has a baby and boom the dog is out the door..... making every excuse under the sun as to why.

I've got 2 spaniels. Both are very clingy, suffer from separation anxiety and aren't breeds for people who aren't willing to walk 2 hours a day in all weathers - and play lots of mental games at home. Ours are little angels and come to work with us, and so are never left.

People who get cockapoos are usually the worst offenders. Why on earth someone ever chose to mix two highly intelligent and demanding breeds is beyond me. There are so many 18 month olds on rehoming sites. Someone in our village has one, it's walked on a lead wearing a jumper and is hyperactive as a result. I feel so angry that they're not letting it be a fucking dog and run free.

Cornettoninja · 30/03/2022 13:06

They hunt wild birds and small mammals. Nice

You’re looking at it from a human perspective, from the cats that’s exactly what they’re wired to do.

Besides which, birds are brutal. I regularly watch magpies stealing chicks from smaller birds nests during the spring with them going absolutely bonkers trying to stop them. I’ve also had the misfortune of seeing a group of seagulls tear apart a (live) pigeon. There’s nothing ‘nice’ about nature.

Rodents are less of an issue for cats to be hunting. We’d have a pretty big(ger) problem with undesirable ones if we suddenly got rid of all the cats.

Iheartmysmart · 30/03/2022 12:59

Couldn’t agree more. I was out walking my show cocker spaniel the other morning and bumped into a woman with a working cocker puppy. She commented that we both had the same dogs and was quite surprised to find out that they were entirely different. She was also heavily pregnant and apparently had three other children at home, all under 5! Not saying that people with children can’t be very responsible pet owners but it was quite obvious that she had no idea of the needs of the dog she had.

I also work in a pet supplies shop and get really cross with the amount of people who are willing to spend hundreds on a designer dog then complain bitterly about the cost of decent food and treats for them.

Do your bloody homework please.

Cattenberg · 30/03/2022 12:55

I have caged rodents (although they do have a separate run) and maybe it’s wrong of me to support this trade.

However, I was once shocked by a colleague who gave away her family’s white rabbit after her children lost interest. My colleague said she disliked the rabbit as it had “evil red eyes” and “always looked miserable with its ears drooping down”. The poor rabbit could hardly help being a lop-eared albino.

OrlandointheWilderness · 30/03/2022 12:51

But completely agree with working dog breeds! I have a springer and a sprocker. Any dogs bred to work need to work, be it as gundogs or agility or anything that taxes the brain and gives them something to do! They need serious exercise but they also need a lot of thought out into to keeping their mind busy and having the right environment etc.
Yes cockerpoos are the latest designer fad I've seen with real issues. Yes they are cute, but both cockers and poodles are high energy, intelligent dogs so it's no wonder your bored frustrated pooch is running off on it's half hour walk!

Fritilleries · 30/03/2022 12:46

@Tuala

Cats are best because they can choose to stay and have freedom to roam
They hunt wild birds and small mammals. Nice.
OrlandointheWilderness · 30/03/2022 12:44

Rabbits are the one. We have two mini lops (although they are bloody big buns to my eye!). I hate them in small cages. When we first got them for DD the shine quickly wore off. They have a massive run in the garden - approx 25 foot square with two big connected hutches. But obviously it took serious effort to do the run, with buried wire etc. they have soft fruit trees in there and raspberry bushes etc and they get a wide range of foliage etc every day. They don't like being picked up (rabbits don't really!) so I don't pick them up! They are friendly and will interact and have a stroke but they aren't toys. We adore them, they pretty much do whatever they want as they have access to the run at night (it's netted etc) and they are incredibly healthy rabbits. But owning them has made me sad for less fortunate bunnies.

Gowithme · 30/03/2022 12:43

I think the difficulty is sometimes people just don't realise just how much work a pet is until they get one. We purposely adopted old dogs because we didn't know if we wanted to commit to 15 years but we knew we could commit to 4 or 5.

I disagree though that cats are great pets - the huge number that are run over round here, the antisocial behaviour of shitting in all the neighbours gardens plus the awful impact they have on wildlife. My neighbour keeps adopting more (now on 4 or 5) and I am constantly having to chase them out my garden so they're not sitting under my birdfeeder, digging up my veg patch or shitting everywhere.

Doglikeahorse · 30/03/2022 12:40

I wouldn’t have caged pets again. It’s seems so cruel not to allow them the space and freedom to move around properly.

In the same breath I can’t stand people who don’t research anything they get. I work with dogs and the amount of working active breeds I see living in crates or in families with no time is astonishing. Why buy a dog bred to work all day and then walk it for an hour and wonder why it’s behaviour isn’t great.
At the moment it’s cockerpoo/poodle mixes.
Totally batty, need loads of exercise, super intelligent and yet so many of them are tootling to the school run and back Hmm
There’s also a beagle for sale online at the moment who’s for sale as it’s owner has 7 children and no time. Why if you have 7 children get a beagle of all things!

Tuala · 30/03/2022 12:34

And whoever said hamsters won't survive running free. Well they would survive quite well in their natural habitats if we hadn't decided we wanted to cage them for our entertainment