Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want DH talking to his female friend about this stuff?

233 replies

changedtheusername · 30/03/2022 03:44

Not sure if I'm being unreasonable here. DH and I have been married 2 years and are in our early 30s, he has a female friend in her early 20s which is okay, but he's recently been there a lot for her and her emotional problems, although he's very open about this with me. However she was starting to talk about the guys she has had things with and at least going a bit more in detail than I think is really ok? He is fine me reading it and says it was relevant in one part of the story but I'm not sure.. he also wakes up to a good few messages from the woman. I have met her in passing and she seems pleasant enough but is this sort of situation something you'd be ok with?

OP posts:
Parth · 30/03/2022 11:10

You are not being unreasonable. If you husband is talking to a younger woman about her emotional problems and giving her support, then that is acceptable, but the minute it starts to include discussions about anything physical it becomes inappropriate and he should put a stop to it.

lovescats3 · 30/03/2022 11:06

Why is he waking up to messages from her ? Why is she discussing sex with him ? Trust your instincts.this sounds like an emotional affair and she is trying to make it sexual

2bazookas · 30/03/2022 11:00

She is being inappropriate with an older male married work colleague. He is exchanging inappropriate discussions with a younger female colleague. It will all end in tears.

It's time to knock it on the head before it develops into summat else
(charitably supposing it hasn't yet). Put your foot down.

Thewindwhispers · 30/03/2022 10:56

I wouldn’t be ok with it. Sounds like she has a massive crush on him and he’s enjoying the attention. If he’s waking up to several messages from her, that’s weird and ‘emotional affair’ type territory. She may be having sex with others but he is the real ‘man in her life’ - the person she talks to first thing in the morning, the person who she turns to for support and affection… But he’s your husband.

I wouldn’t be ok with it and would ask him to stop acting like her boyfriend.

Sprucewillis · 30/03/2022 10:56

My rule about 'friends' is if that's what they actually are, they will be in both your lives. E.g they will be invited over for dinner, birthday parties etc. there will be nothing to hide.

If they 'always' meet privately then it is not a friendship. You DH seems open and honest about the friendship so should be no problem there. It could be a problem if the friends thinks or hopes this is more.

Why not invite her over for dinner as his friend?

DarkCorner · 30/03/2022 10:56

This is not OK.

My exH had an affair that started off as a friendship and (as far as I can tell) edged gradually towards the line between friendship and more. At no point did exH apparently realise he needed to put boundaries in, I think by the time he realised they'd crossed the line they were so far beyond it.

I'd feel seriously ick about talking in detail about sexual experiences with a man unless I fancied him. Not to mention worried about him getting the wrong end of the stick and having a super awkward situation. I think you really need to spell it out to him. I bet he'd feel annoyed/anxious if you had a similarly boundary crossing friendship with a man!

MakeMineAdoubleChocolate · 30/03/2022 10:54

I wouldn't be happy with this. My dh has zero female friends but is polite and friendly to my female friends. I don't have friends of the opposite sex myself because it's unnecessary and I don't want to. Why do I need that when my dh is best friend, comforter and companion and support. I know I am different not having male friends but it's just the way we are and its fine.
I dont even call my female friends partners my friends just associates etc....
I would not be OK with this and if she needs a friend there are plenty of lovely women about, she doesnt need to ply your husband with inappropriate messages. I would not be messaging another man about my exes. How bizzare is that.

BulletTrain · 30/03/2022 10:54

I do also find that some people say it's fine as long as you trust your partner but it's not really the point. When it's work colleagues, or an organised group, if it even looks like something is going on then it can cause issues if one is more senior.

My DH had a friend like his at uni and, just before he eventually had to turn her down on a night out, I made it clear that I knew what she was up to which cut down the messages and visits by maybe 70%. I think it forced her hand a bit.

SartresSoul · 30/03/2022 10:53

I wouldn’t be comfortable with DH having a close female friend who messaged him multiple times a day and told him all about her sex life, no. I don’t think many women would be ok with this, it just isn’t acceptable.

Dragongirl10 · 30/03/2022 10:52

so inapropriate and he is enjoying the attention. I would tell him to shut it down.

Gowithme · 30/03/2022 10:51

She's telling him about a sex act that she hasn't had enough confidence to do with anyone else? That's dodgy as hell. So she doesn't have the confidence to do it but she has enough confidence to tell your DH all about it? More likely she's hoping he'll give her advice on how best to do it, just to improve her confidence of course......and it's a very slippery slope from there.

HallucinatingHilda · 30/03/2022 10:49

Sorry, that was to @LndnGrl!

HallucinatingHilda · 30/03/2022 10:47

Probably not, if this is how she is around men.

MamaNeedsTea · 30/03/2022 10:47

Nope, she's upto something.

Would you ever message another man about your sexlife. 🥴

Early 20s I couldn't imagine being bestfriends with someone's 30YR husband, what's that about!!!

hidethetoaster · 30/03/2022 10:47

@Faevern

Nah if I'm lying next to my DP and he is texting another woman and I feel uncomfortable about it then him showing me her messages is not reassuring me, that would be him patronising me.

Reassuring me would be putting his phone down and making me his priority and asking me how he could make me feel better. Me saying to him I would feel better if you stopped this level of contact and intimacy with this woman is not controlling, it's him respecting me and accepting that its affecting me.

It's not about having a friend who is female it's about the frequency of contact and how and when it is happening and you not being part of the equation.

Well said
IncompleteSenten · 30/03/2022 10:46

It could be genuine friendship or it could be hiding in plain sight like this.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/relationships/4515139-Needing-support-for-those-days-after-first-finding-out-about-husbands-infidelity

PiperPosey · 30/03/2022 10:45

She doesn't have anyone to talk to, but an older married man?

Boy he is eating it up! ( No matter what he tells you) his ego is being pumped up.

I truly believe that women and men can be friends. Under these circumstances she is testing him. Discussing her sex life? Puhhhhhlease... she is trying to get a reaction out of him.
Letting him know she's not a prude..

I would just let him know that you're not happy with this friendship. He will give every excuse to continue. If he refuses he is putting her needs before yours.

He can even let her know that his wife isn't happy with their friendship so it will have to end. ( He is letting you know that he is putting your being uncomfortable about it before her being so comfortable) Flowers

hidethetoaster · 30/03/2022 10:43

I think she's into him.
But the main point is that you aren't comfortable, and you are entitled to your feelings on this. AIBU isn't really the issue. You feel this way and that's a fact.
The next step is with him and how he responds to your honestly held feelings. Is he willing to put some boundaries in place that you feel more comfortable with?
And if not, is this a deal breaker for you?

Whatever you decide isn't a lifelong commitment. If you say ok today, but tomorrow you have concerns whether you can trust him, then you're both having the conversation again. Communicating and listening.

Working through this in a constructive way could be really healthy for your relationship. Can you communicate and listen; can you hold to your own boundaries even if the other disagrees and stay respectful/loving/trusting; can you mutually agree boundaries with friends and others that you both are ok with?

ItsYabbaDabbaDoTime · 30/03/2022 10:40

Isn’t it odd how these men are always friends with younger, attractive women rather than dear old Irene in Internal Audit ?

No - having female friends is fine but discussing intimate details of her sex life amounts to flirting, which is disrespectful to you OP.

Ask him to desist. If he refuses, then he’s the sort of DP who clearly enjoys flirting with other women. If you don’t like this in a partner life is too short to put up with it, so time to bin him off.

Notwithittoday · 30/03/2022 10:40

I wouldn’t tolerate my husband having this kind of convo or this closeness. Luckily we’re both on same page.

UniversalAunt · 30/03/2022 10:39

For OH to be the good friend he be,ie se himself to be, he’d be guiding his friend towards

Is OH generally ‘tone deaf’ when it comes to boundaries in relationships? Does he usually get where the edge of acquaintance/hobby friend/good friend/best friend/loved ones begins & end?

To go from hobby acquaintance through to ‘friend’ discussing sex/intimate matters & making contact outside ‘office’ hours is too much, too close, too fast. Can or does OH understand that?

Hiddenvoice · 30/03/2022 10:37

My dh and I have friends of the opposite sex. I will message my male friends to moan and vent but that’s because I’m closer to them. I wouldn’t message them anything sexual based because I find it a little odd to be sharing thag with them and I wouldn’t expect them to share that with me. We did when we were younger but now we’re all married and partnered off that it kinda seems like it would be crossing the line.
I think she’s mentioned this stuff to try turn the conversation to be more flirty. She’s asked about you to make herself look like a nice girl but I think it’s all weird. She’s relying heavily on your husband, she has no other friends she can go to?
My husbands friends message him about troubles in their relationships but the moment any of them bring up their sex life in the group chats he always makes a joke and bows out until the conversation has passed because he doesn’t want to be part of it and feels is not relevant to him.

Flopsy145 · 30/03/2022 10:36

Honestly I wouldn't be ok with this, and as a woman I personally wouldn't have these conversations with a male friend. Some people are quite chilled about stuff like this, I myself am quite a jealous person tbh and my partner would also not like this roles reversed. Also if I'm being really honest and this is truly awful to say so don't come for me, it would really depend on what she looked like. If she was ten years younger than me, beautiful, perky, etc, then hard no, if she was not then I'd probably be fine.

I would in your situation tell my partner I didn't think it was appropriate to discuss those things, and see what he says

Chely · 30/03/2022 10:35

Nah, not for me.

LBFseBrom · 30/03/2022 10:32

I think I would be OK with that but, honestly, your husband shouldn't be sharing things that are told to him in confidence. If the girl knew that you knew, she would probably be mortified. If he cannot keep things to himself it might be better if he gently extricates himself from the friendship or keeps it lighter. Not everyone is equipped for intense confidences.