Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS inviting girlfriend to DH BIG birthday family dinner

367 replies

reynardette · 29/03/2022 20:29

Here's the thing. We have a nuclear family tradition (parents, 2 DCs) of going out together on birthdays. We have a small family. My parents live abroad. My sibling dead. DH's mum died almost 30 years ago. His dad is not engaged and on wife 3. It is DH's BIG birthday. DD is student as far away in the UK as it is possible to be from us and I have secretly arranged for her to fly back, get a train and meet us in a lovely restaurant to surprise him. It is a big deal. We do not do this often. Meanwhile, DS has lost his 4th job this year (really) and from two days ago currently home with us. This evening told me he has invited current girlfriend to come on DH's birthday evening. They have been together for 6 months. I hit the roof. AIBU

OP posts:
NewYorkCityDreamer · 30/03/2022 09:51

You do seem very controlling but I suppose the transition to adult children can be difficult. The only thing I wasn’t invited to by my partner’s family was a wedding (partner’s cousin) that was arranged before we got together (19 when we got together, 23 now and it’s happening this summer thanks to COVID).

We’ve lived together since we were 21 but even before that I was always welcome. All meals, all holidays, Christmas!

shockthemonkey · 30/03/2022 09:49

Just explain he should have asked, and tell him to disinvite her.

No need to hit the roof.

DirectionToPerfection · 30/03/2022 09:46

@whyayepetal

Both partners were invited on the holiday, and both are attending - all good.

Neither partner was invited to the meal. If you are not invited by the host, you don’t get to come. “ Sorry DS, this one is just the four of us as that’s what your Dad wants for his birthday. Will be lovely to see your GF and DD’s BF on the holiday, but this booking has been made for the four of us”

Ok, but any parents taking that approach shouldn't be surprised when their adult children and their partners exclude them from similar gatherings further down the line. OP and her DH won't be part of their nuclear family if they marry and have kids.

You can be warm and welcoming or petty and insular.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 30/03/2022 09:44

that’s what your Dad wants for his birthday

No, this is what OP wants for her DH's birthday. No mention of if the poor bloke has any word in it anyway!

CounsellorTroi · 30/03/2022 09:41

I think you’re getting a hard time here OP. Given that your DD is abroad, opportunities for you to get together as a family are rare. I think it’s only natural that you’d prefer it to be just the four of you. Your DS should have asked you and not taken it for granted you’d want her there, especially as he doesn’t appear to be that serious about her.

SomethingVexesThee · 30/03/2022 09:40

The huge divide of opinions on this thread is really interesting!

cantbecoping · 30/03/2022 09:39

This is just plain weird. Nothing as strange as folk.

SomethingVexesThee · 30/03/2022 09:38

Also, I'm not saying I wouldn't have invited the girlfriend and boyfriend. I might have done. But OP didn't, she wanted a family-only meal, so it's rude of the son to invite someone else, IMO.

whyayepetal · 30/03/2022 09:38

Both partners were invited on the holiday, and both are attending - all good.

Neither partner was invited to the meal. If you are not invited by the host, you don’t get to come. “ Sorry DS, this one is just the four of us as that’s what your Dad wants for his birthday. Will be lovely to see your GF and DD’s BF on the holiday, but this booking has been made for the four of us”

Maighnuad · 30/03/2022 09:37

So when your children find a partner and settled down they will be excluded ?
You come across as a potential MIL from hell. perhaps take a look at it from your sons angle.

SomethingVexesThee · 30/03/2022 09:37

@DearlyBeloathed Yes I do think a holiday is less of a big deal than for instance a 50th birthday. I know it's a longer amount of time and larger cost, but it's less unique, if you see what I mean? But a normal meal out, not on a special occasion, that would be not a big deal particularly and I would expect girlfriend to be welcome. I'd still expect the son to ask first though!

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 30/03/2022 09:33

Of course you're being unreasonable. What has flying your DD back got to do with your DS's jobs?

How would you feel if your DH's family had excluded you from family gatherings?

What if your DD wants to bring a boyfriend?

gannett · 30/03/2022 09:31

If money was an issue I might think the son was rude to expect his gf to be paid for. However the OP is already shelling out for plane and train tickets for the daughter - the cost of an extra meal for the son seems only fair in that context. And given that she's paying for them to all go on holiday I don't get the sense that money is tight, or anywhere close.

The reason people are giving the OP a hard time is because of her disproportionate response. Raise an eyebrow, tell her son he should have asked first but that they'd love to welcome his gf - that seems normal. Hitting the roof, posting on the internet and banging on about nuclear family traditions - completely out of whack.

Nuclear family traditions that refuse to expand tend to contract. Agree that it's obvious the OP (and probably her husband) see their son as a disappointment compared to their daughter and this will be obvious to him as well. Most flaky, aimless 20yos tend to find their direction eventually and when he does those family traditions of 4 people only will be down to 3.

Roselilly36 · 30/03/2022 09:30

@MiddleParking

Oh they’re both adults! Yes, you’re BU and really weird. They’re not ‘DCs’. Do you intend for them to leave their partners and then spouses at home for birthday dinners forever?
This ^
mumonthehill · 30/03/2022 09:24

Family traditions have to change. Ds 21 is bringing his girlfriend of 7 months home for Easter and I am excited and delighted and if he loves her then she is welcome to be part of anything we do as a family.

GoFishandChips · 30/03/2022 09:19

Holidays are a bit different as there are other people to bounce off and lots of space.

That's so odd, a meal a few hours at most. On holiday your much more trapped with other people.

Seadad · 30/03/2022 09:19

He should have asked - but 'hitting the roof' is totally unreasonable- and lays a very poor foundation for any future daugher-in-law!

Flippy87 · 30/03/2022 09:16

This is just weird, feel like I can really picture the family dynamic. Can’t understand how it’s more okay to take a partner on holiday than to a meal. A week with someone is less serious than a 2 hour meal?! Yeah right

silverbubbles · 30/03/2022 09:13

He should have asked you and then you should have said yes.

Sounds like you need to loosen up a bit and try to be a bit more outward facing.

Bookworm20 · 30/03/2022 09:12

But that's such an odd presumption when he's known all his life that his dad wants his birthday dinners to be just the 4 of them

See the thing is, I don't think his dad probably minds. OP hasn't even asked him. I think its OP that minds because DD flying in is actually the big event. Which is why she 'hit the roof'. It will detract from dd's grand entrance, or something weird like that.

It makes no sense. If DH was so insular and hated anyone else being family dinners, DS must know this and would know to ask. The fact he assumed it was ok to bring GF suggests he really had no idea it would be an issue for his father.

Plus they are all going on holiday. But of course the holiday includes dd and her bf. So I really think its more that OP doesn't want to upset dd because her bf isn't able to attend the meal and she might feel put out if ds's gf is there? OP seems fine to upset DS and his gf though.
Its all very strange.

rhowton · 30/03/2022 09:12

I think there is a reason why your daughter has chosen to go to university so far away.

ToxicBuns · 30/03/2022 09:08

@WindyKnickers I completely agree! That's exactly how I read the situation. It seems kind of kick hom whilst he's down. For all we know OP and husband might be on at him not having a job etc.. and he is taking the GF for moral support.

marqueses · 30/03/2022 09:05

@helpfulperson

Although I sort of agree with those saying he should have asked I imagine he just presumed she was invited. When I've organised family things I've just presumed that an invite to a family member is a couples invite and counted appropriately.
But that's such an odd presumption when he's known all his life that his dad wants his birthday dinners to be just the 4 of them

That's what I don't get, he can't be that stupid or ignorant of his dad's personality can he?

What is the thought process that gets from I know my dad doesn't like this to I'll tell my mum I've done something I know dad will hate? Did he not live with his dad growing up?

NewtoHolland · 30/03/2022 09:03

Sure fire way to damage your relationship with your son. Maybe chat calmly about it and apologise. It's not going to bode well if this ends up being his wife.

Bookworm20 · 30/03/2022 08:57

I’m confused.
You say dh wouldn’t like it if she’s there but you haven’t asked him because it’s a surprise.
Then it’s not a surprise he knows there is a dinner, because tradition, but thinks it’s just the 3 of you.
So on that thinking surely it would be nice to have ds gf there?
Perhaps ASK your dh? That is not ruining any surprise.

The surprise is actually dd flying in.

It sounds more like YOU don’t want her there because it may detract from the surprise of dd arriving?
Oh and because it is difficult for dds bf to be there. Because flights.
So really all this sounds very much centered around dd.
Ds can’t bring gf because dd is coming, and without her bf. So not fair on dd or her bf?
So you’ve made ds tell his gf she isn’t welcome at the meal. That’s going to make for an uncomfortable holiday tbh because however nice about it she’ll be, she will definitely be feeling like you don’t want her around deep down.
I expect you’ll also fawn over dd and her bf on the holiday, because you actually don’t like your ds that much.

I expect ds knows this I’m afraid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread