Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Carer charging me even though I didn't employ her

207 replies

NickyNora · 29/03/2022 19:42

My son is Autistic.
We use a Carer on a regular basis.
One of his friends from college had an outing recently.
The other child's parent organised the activity and the Carers.

We all use the same Carers.

The other child invited my son and 2 other boys to the outing.

I thought my son was a guest.
He needs almost no help socially now especially when he's comfortable with the environment and company.

Yesterday, I received an invoice for £160 from one of the Carers.

I checked with the parent of the child whose outing it was, that they have already paid the Carer.
The other parent didn't know I was being billed.

AIBU to say to the Carer, that I won't be paying her as I wasn't aware I was being billed?

OP posts:
WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 10:59

I do t think this is fraud.

3 teens who require care and receive care from these carers on other occasions were on a day out with 2 carers.

It probably isn’t possible to have scenarios where the carer is the adult in charge and being paid as carer sometimes and other times to teen who needs care is treated as an indenpendnt adult who is just along for the ride and totally independents of the carer. There were no parent helpers there to take responsibility. Therefore the paid carer became responsible for him. That responsibility has to be paid for.

Given Op thought the hist would be doing the care, she didn’t expect carers involved. It’s odd the host didn’t tell Op she would use carers instead of being there herself. Or perhaps she did.

Either way, the host and OP between them need to accept the Carer spent the full day with 3 boys and so the bill needs paying. The fact the host didn’t clarify what price would be charged for looking after the 3 (or 2 the Ops son was in a group with for carer purposes) is her error. It smacks of an tremor to not pay for the full care to be honest.

Op, speak to the host. Together, recognise the fact that the Carer looked after OPs son. The exact level if care isn’t so relevant but the fact is she was the supervising adult with him. Accept that this bill has to be paid. Come up with a plan - host pays, op pays, they split it….whatever.

It’s irrelevant that OP will find it hard to fund this. The fact is, the service has been provided and now it needs to be paid for. Clearly she’d like host to pay and in the circumstances, I think host should probably - she abdicated responsibility for looking after the teens to carers and didn’t mention it, so she should foot the bill, but if she won’t, Op will have to suck it up.

I’d be cross with host about this I’m not the Carer.

And OP, please can you be clearer about:

  • What was agreed with host beforehand about who was looking after kids and any charges
  • What host has now said about how many kids she booked carers for
  • If she to,d the carers there would be 3 teens or just sprung a 3rd on them
  • Exactly what she and other parent have been billed for
  • Exactly what they have already paid.

The Carer did the work. They should be paid.
In the absence of host arranging a special 2:1 rate and especially if a 3rd teen was sprung on them, charging th standard 1:1 rate seems reasonable.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 02/04/2022 10:57

So if you don’t pay her, you loose her as a carer.
If you pay her, the trust will have gone and you will end up loosing her anyway. I mean, are you going to wonder all the time if she will try to trick you again on payment?

Your ds is 17yo. He is getting more independent. I’d say don’t pay. She took a chance and what she did is basically theft. Tough.

WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 10:48

I think this needs to be sorted by the hosting parent.

Speak to them about the confusion. Ask them exactly what they booked - ie a career for how many boys and how many boys did she pay for.

If she paid for 2 (and other parent paid other carer for her son) then the carer has been fully paid.

If she paid for 1 (her own son) but then your son was there too, there has been a booking error on her part. In that case, the Carer would be expecting to deliver 1-1 care, but turns up to find 2 boys needing care (assuming 3rd cared for by other carer) and on that basis billed for it. She billed Op because she knows OP.

If this is the case, it was a booking error.

It’s impossible to say Op’s DS didn’t need care at all - he needs adult supervision of some level presumably.

In this situation, really the host ought to be footing the bill. They made a booking for care and then sent more teens than she had booked for, but didn’t pay. What did she think would happen - that the Carer would look after Teen 3 without charge? Did she think his own parent would be billed?

Why was carer wrong to charge for the OPs son, who is regularly cared for by her and spent the day with her. Perhaps the usual 2:1 rate is less than 1:1 but given. 2:1 doesn’t sound like it was booked for at all, I think the Carer could be irritated by this - not u reasonably.

So the problem sounds like it lies in the booking. Only 2 boys had carers booked, but 3 were there. The bill needs paying and Op needs to sort that with the host, not the Carer so much.

Imagine if this was a thread from the Carer.
‘My fellow Carer and I were booked for 2 teen boys on a day out, one being billed for each boy. On arrival a 3rd boy who we also care for sometimes turned out to be there too. We looked after the 3 boys all day and a good time was had by all. At the end of the day, we billed all 3 parents for the care their sons received. But now the one who was there but wasn’t booked in is saying she doesn’t want to pay for my services and hadn’t booked me. Is this reasonable to have received my services all day and not pay me’

This all comes down to poor communication mostly in part of the hosting family. Someone needs to pay the Carer. You’d hope the host will offer, having organised the day and organised carers without checking with Op. if however she doesn’t want to, I think OP should pay. Chalk it up to experience - communicate clearly in future.

And sorry, but son needing ‘almost no help’ in the day doesn’t mean that Carer doesn’t need paying. Looking after 3 teens is more work than 2.

It’s unfortunate this has happened, but it really wasn’t the fault of the Carer…they found themselves with more teens to look after than they’d been booked for.

Personally, I’d Id been them, I’d have texted the host and pointed out there were 3 boys and all 3 would be billed for. However, given all are known to them, simply billing for services received (and 3 boys were clearly there) seems reasonable too.

NorthSouthcatlady · 02/04/2022 10:48

I wouldn’t pay her, she’s trying it on

MarvelMrs · 02/04/2022 10:46

I am a bit confused as to why the carer has billed you and not the person who booked her? And also why the person who actually booked her hasn’t just paid her automatically?
The parent who booked the carers is the person who needs the bill and is responsible for paying. Unless organised and communicated in advance, if you book someone for any kind of work you then pay them.
Did you say in one of your follow up posts OP, that you had spoken to the organising parent and they said they didn’t know you were being billed? But what did they say? If they hadn’t received and paid and they booked where on earth did they think the bill went?
You need to discuss this further with the organising parent.

JemimaTiggywinkle · 02/04/2022 10:40

I’m confused.
So the parent organising the activity booked and expected to pay for one carer (for their DC presumably).
So who booked this other carer that is now billing you?

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 02/04/2022 10:33

Surely she can’t think she can be paid twice for the same work? If she wanted to be paid more than her usual amount for the birthday event as she was supervising two young people then she should have had that conversation with the parent who bo owed her for the event and not just assumed.
There’s almost an element of fraud there. I know she’s classed as self employed but works through an agency, can you ask them what their usual process is?

lunar1 · 02/04/2022 10:28

I really don't think you should pay her.

sonjadog · 02/04/2022 10:21

The OP says in the opening post that the carer has been paid by the family who organized the day.

drpet49 · 02/04/2022 10:21

* I can’t believe you’re even debating this OP the carer is trying to commit fraud. She has already been paid by the other parent. TBH I’d be questioning why you’d want to employ this woman as a carer for your son ever again. I wouldn’t want someone that dishonest anywhere near my child.*

^This. I wouldn’t be able trust her after this

Flame76 · 02/04/2022 10:18

OP, you need to clarify if the carer has been paid by anyone so far. If not, I feel for you. You absolutely shouldn't have to pay as you didn't book her. She's silly to not check this with you first, if she assumed that's what would happen. You risk losing the carer by not paying or falling out with the host family for insisting they pay, as they booked her. But still, not your fault at all. Both carer and host parents have acted stupidly here, assuming no payment has already been made.

nettie434 · 02/04/2022 10:07

I would normally be very supportive of care workers who are generally underpaid and under appreciated. However, it is not reasonable for her to want to charge you. It is not treble the work to support 3 people doing the same activity.

It would have been reasonable for the worker to have charged slightly more the joint activity and to have sorted this beforehand.

It's a hard decision for you to have to make given that your son is used to her and that this seems to be the first time in 5 years that there has been a problem. Do you think she would really decide not to support your son if it came to the push. She would have to find another client if you did not use her again. Surely if she is self employed and your son receives a direct payment from Adult Services there is no reason why she could not carry on if you were both satisfied with the arrangement?

I agree with the suggestion of using an agency to do payroll for the payments. My friend does this after a worker she no longer uses said he had not been paid when he had.

Walkingalot · 02/04/2022 10:05

Well she presumed wrong! Tell her that you didn't organise this, you didn't ask for care and anyway, she didn't give 1-1 care for either of the 3 boys. The onus was on her to negotiate maybe a higher rate than her normal fee with the parent who organised this, as she had more responsibility, keeping an eye on 3 instead of the usual 1. She can't simply triple her rate either. Also, like any kids party, you don't charge the parents. If there are any extra costs, you state upfront and get agreement.
Don't part with the meagre funds you have because she's being a CF and depriving your DS of money that you have a better need for.

NWQM · 02/04/2022 10:03

@NickyNora as another poster has said there is a bit of confusion.....I am not sure if its us reading things differently or you arent sure. If its the latter then I think your starting point is to get formal with everyone and its reasonable to say you are looking into it.

Dont be tempted to pay and get into financial difficulties to keep the carer happy. You can rebuild the relationship based but only if you all feel their is an equitable compromise. Be hard if any of you harbour resentment.

I think you are saying that the commissioning parents are paying the usual hourly rate. For a second child though she charges not double but 50%. You are clear that the other carer was employed to provide 1:1 and isnt querying that 2 others were there. If you pay one carer an uplift that actually isnt necessarily logical.

All comes down to the law but if she can take out a civil claim the usual arrangements would be considered.... On other occasions what happened? Would one parent commission on behalf of you all?

On other occasions do you act as if the children have been invited as guests and the host sorts or do you make arrangements?

I would recommend - if you havent - talking to a Disability Rights Group who advises on personal budgets. You are the custdoian of it for your son. What is it reasonable or right that you pay on his behalf?

Its such a stressful situation for you to be in. There is an assumption in the system that parents can be all knowing about employment law etc etc. Its so very rubbish.

Happy - and potentially able to help more - if you would like to DM.

Do not be tempted to pay until you are sure. This may not go just go away

AlisonDonut · 02/04/2022 10:01

I spoke to the Carer, she seemed to presume, as my son was at the activity, that I was also paying her.

Who asked her to go/who told her the activity was even happening?

Babyvenusplant · 02/04/2022 10:00

@Soontobe60

Blimey, all these replies criticising the carer! The carer has not been paid. By anyone. She assumed that she was there to support OPs son which is understandable. Now she wants to be paid for the hours she’s worked. It’s between the parents to work out who’s going to pay her. It’s not the carers fault that the parents can’t sort it out.
She has been paid! Go back and read the updates properly, the other parents has paid the carer for what she was employed to do
Blimecory · 02/04/2022 10:00

The hosting parent may have paid her, but just their normal hourly rate for one person. If there were more people there to care for, the carer could well assume she needs to be paid more. That’s up to the hosting parent to sort.

MRex · 02/04/2022 09:49

It's very simple in replying to her: "I didn't book you for that day because I felt that DS didn't need help, you need to talk with whoever booked you about payment based on what you agreed with them."

I would also have a chat with both other sets of parents; it's unclear who booked her, what they said and how much she has been paid. If you had to contribute anything then it should be via whoever booked her if they somehow got confused about what your DS needed.

Straysocks · 02/04/2022 09:46

OP, I absolutely sympathise with you not wanting to lose the carer - I am also responsible for booking care for my sister and it is incredibly hard to find another trusted person. I absolutely could not agree to spend their budget this way and would explain that you are only able to pay for care that you have actually booked and not retrospectively. Perhaps offer to explore this with the people who issue the budget together with the carer, 'let's talk to the funders to make sure we are both doing the right thing in these circumstances'.

However, do what you need to do based on how it will help you until you can put something else in place. For those that don't depend on this kind of help it may seem crackers to consider agreeing but it is not something you can easily replace and the need for it does not abate. I would start the process of recruiting someone else following this though, for me the trust would be damaged and it is all about the trust.

It is common for 3rd parties to do the admin for budgets/direct payments - often charities get an hr added onto the budget and they take over payroll/hr/insurance for the person who needs care. Your local authority could tell you who they work with. I couldn't do it without this service, it's too time consuming, there are huge legal responsibilities as an employer and put you in this awkward kind of role.

ivykaty44 · 02/04/2022 09:38

AIBU to say to the Carer, that I won't be paying her as I wasn't aware I was being billed?

if you didn't employee this carer then you do not have any type of contract, therefore they don't have to be paid. Id speak to them and explain you didn't employee them and are not paying for services you haven't requested

NotNotNotMyName · 02/04/2022 09:36

“She is working in an area where people are very vulnerable to financial abuse”

OP this carer needs to NOT be a carer anymore. She needs reporting. Who regulates carers?

I’m surprised the other parents involved aren’t as outraged as you.

nightfairy · 02/04/2022 09:29

That is rotten. He was a guest, and she has been paid. You don't invite someone to an outing, or a party, and then ask them after the fact to pay for themselves. Both host and carer are way out of line.

NotNotNotMyName · 02/04/2022 09:28

I can’t believe you’re even debating this OP the carer is trying to commit fraud. She has already been paid by the other parent. TBH I’d be questioning why you’d want to employ this woman as a carer for your son ever again. I wouldn’t want someone that dishonest anywhere near my child.

Is she self-employed? How are such carers regulated? Unless there’s been some kind of genuine mistake for which she is able to offer a full apology, you need to report her.

How many other people has she tried to do this to?

saraclara · 02/04/2022 09:20

I don't get it. Did the organising parent book her or not? If they did, they pay. If they didn't, why did she turn up?

The organising parent can't just say "I didn't know you were being billed" and leave it at that. None of this makes any sense.

Blimecory · 02/04/2022 09:20

@Soontobe60

Blimey, all these replies criticising the carer! The carer has not been paid. By anyone. She assumed that she was there to support OPs son which is understandable. Now she wants to be paid for the hours she’s worked. It’s between the parents to work out who’s going to pay her. It’s not the carers fault that the parents can’t sort it out.
The carer has been paid by the hosting parent.

The question is, how much did they pay her? For caring for one, two or three people?

Swipe left for the next trending thread