Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Carer charging me even though I didn't employ her

207 replies

NickyNora · 29/03/2022 19:42

My son is Autistic.
We use a Carer on a regular basis.
One of his friends from college had an outing recently.
The other child's parent organised the activity and the Carers.

We all use the same Carers.

The other child invited my son and 2 other boys to the outing.

I thought my son was a guest.
He needs almost no help socially now especially when he's comfortable with the environment and company.

Yesterday, I received an invoice for £160 from one of the Carers.

I checked with the parent of the child whose outing it was, that they have already paid the Carer.
The other parent didn't know I was being billed.

AIBU to say to the Carer, that I won't be paying her as I wasn't aware I was being billed?

OP posts:
WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 11:51

Haven’t we all had to pay for things at some point, that happened and we hadn’t been quite aware we’re going to happen and be charged for?

It is bloody annoying.

It’s a legal thing but is also about doing the right thing too and not just thinking about our own strictly legal definition rights, but what’s right too.

How can it be right to have a teen who has special needs that the Carer has previously looked after and been paid to do so, to be expected to be the only adult present with him all day, looking after other teens with similar needs, and to not get paid. That’s what people are saying should happen. It’s what has happened.

No, there isn’t be legal come back on this. Yes, the Carer got paid for looking after 1 teen. But actually they were responsible for 2 all day. How could they have had that 3rd boy with them all day and it made zero impact? Why is it okay to expect they should do that for free?

There may well be scope for negotiation on price. Hopefully host will cover this as part of their ‘hosting’ the day. That’s what I’d hope if I were this parent. By more than that, as the parent of this DS, I’d be keen to know that the Carer who had care of him for the day did receive some financial recompense for the efforts she’d put in, even though I hadn’t know it would be her doing the caring in advance. I would t be worried about legal comeback if I refused as there was no agreement, but I’d have an uncomfortable conscience about it…and in this kind of thing, I think it’s best to do the right thing. This woman took the responsibility for the son for the day. He cannot be wholly responsible for himself. That needs paying for by someone.

EthelTheAardvark · 02/04/2022 11:51

This all comes down to poor communication. However, given that Carer was the adult in charge, and spent a day looking after the OPs son, should she really be denied the pay for the job she delivered?

OP and host and Carer need to learn lessons in communication from this. The Carer should not lose out financially. They did provide a service. Ideally host will pay

It's not up to OP to learn lessons in communication, @WombatChocolate. She didn't ask for care, her son didn't need care, she wasn't consulted about any of this arrangement. It's not a case of "ideally host will pay": it a payment needs to be made, only the host should pay because OP has no liability whatsoever.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 02/04/2022 11:48

@WombatChocolate in that case, the carer should have contacted the host and ask what was going in with the third teen. She shouldn’t have agreed to look after someone else when it’s not in her contract, at the very least for insurance purposes.

Imagine something had gone wrong and the carer had stepped in in a way the OP didn’t agree with. Imagine that there is some lasting damage/physical disability afterwards. But the OP didn’t know said carer was there, she never agreed to her looking after her ds etc…. That would be a horrible situation to be in right?

So why did the carer agree to that and not contacted the host? Or the OP (seeing that she knew very well who she was).
Is there a chance she would have done that with a child she didn’t know? I very much doubt it….

So either the carer is taking a chance there or she is incompetent. I mean in hat vase, who is saying that she is looking after other teens whilst allegedly having a 1-1 with the OP’s ds for example?

WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 11:43

Sleepy, I agree. There can’t be a claim without a prior agreement.

But the question is, should this Carer get paid? By someone?
They did the job and cared for the son. He was someone who needs care. He has been cared for on other occasions.

Op thought the friends parent would be the adult in charge. She didn’t know about Carers being involved. That was the hosts failing. Carers were involved and they billed for the son. So no, there’s no legal entitlement to expect Op to pay the bill. But can we expect host to lay it, given she organised a contract and sent along a teen who usually receives care from these carers? And if she doesn’t think she should pay as she didn’t book it explicitly, do we think the OP has an obligation (not legal) but by dint of her on-going caring relationship with the Carer and the fact the Carer provided the hours looking after him, to refuse?

It’s not just about legals is it, but what is the right thing?

The Carer looked after 2 boys. Looking after them was different to just having 1. They were both there and ignore if OPs son all day simply wasn’t possible or viable. Therefore, does she deserve to be avoid for her time?

She too needs to learn to communicate better. But she didn’t either. Instead she did a day of work being the responsible adult for a boy who regularly is looked after by her and who she gets paid for. So having done that and found herself doing that due to poor communication all round, is some financial recompense unreasonable?

Or are we saying everyone should say to this Carer , ‘Sorry, no money for you. The Op didn’t ask you to look after him. The fact you did look after him, is fully down to you. It doesn’t matter that he was there and is a teen with additional needs that you previously have looked after and been paid for and that there was no other adult present to care for him or keep an eye on him and that if you ignored him totally, he could be at risk, but no we aren’t paying you’.

EthelTheAardvark · 02/04/2022 11:42

@Afterallsbeensaidanddone

you are almost at the end of your agreement then surely it doesn't matter so much anyway.

No I think the carer becomes more needed as a result of moving to adults.

That may be the case, but OP is recognising that the reality is that support for her child is gong to be substantially cut when he qualifies for adult services. So if the carer is going to have to go at that point anyway, it's reasonable to query if it matters that much if she goes now? Particularly if she goes because OP doesn't want to pay for something she never asked for.
mcmooberry · 02/04/2022 11:35

I understand how awkward this is but the carer can't think she can charge double here? Did you son actually get any support from her during the activity? Maybe he got some even if not needed as she thought she was getting paid?
Could you come to some compromise with her, you would never have agreed to blow half his monthly budget on this had to thought for one second she would charge you?

WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 11:35

So, did the host genuinely expect to send 3 teens who all receive care from these carers on other occasions, and to only pay for 2 to be looked after? Did they really think it was okay for a 3rd to tagalomg and not be charged for, even though they would be for the group and were unable to have an independent day out without adults present?

If so, that was cheeky fuckery.

And had they spelled it out to the Carer in advance - we are booking 2 of you for X and Y. Oh snd Z who you often look after will also be there, but on this occasion he is independent and just with the group. You aren’t caring for him and won’t be paid for him, even though he’s the same teen with same needs as usual and will be with you all day.

Or didnt they say…and he was just there?

It’s all down to communication.

And with caring arrangements, you do need to smooth and keep good relationships. Sometimes that involves spending a bit more cash that you’d like and being willing to pay for something where actually there’s been a miscommunication error. You learn that sometimes laying is just the best way because maintaining those relationships is really important…and especially if you can see the other side too and accept that somewhere along the line, communication hasn’t been brilliant and is what’s led to the confusion.

And you learn to pin absolutely everything down in advance first, so you do t get this kind of thing again.

Sleepyblueocean · 02/04/2022 11:33

WombatChocolate the OP did not employ the carer on this occasion. All hours worked have to be agreed between carer and employer. There was no agreement made with the OP. She does not have to pay her. If the carer tried to make any sort of claim for this, she would get nowhere.

BoredZelda · 02/04/2022 11:29

This doesn’t make any sense. Why would you start off saying “I hope you’re well”? What’s her health got to do with anything.

It’s a polite opener.

WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 11:27

I agree that she can’t insist you any for services you didn’t request.

However, it’s reasonable to expect to be paid for services which were provided and it would have been impossible to avoid providing. What if something g had happened during the day that required adult input, however small? The Carer would have provided that support. It could have been as simple as reassurance about an aspect of the day or instructions about how something worked or timings…..but something OPs son couldn’t manage or would struggle with alone. Instantly, care has been provided. It’s impossible to be with a child with additional needs likewise and totally ignore them, especially when you already have a caring relationship with them. You cannot out Carers in a position to have to do that - to not have any responsibility or Be paid for it…..but actually to be left as the sole adult with a teen who is likely to need some support.

This all comes down to poor communication. However, given that Carer was the adult in charge, and spent a day looking after the OPs son, should she really be denied the pay for the job she delivered?

OP and host and Carer need to learn lessons in communication from this. The Carer should not lose out financially. They did provide a service. Ideally host will pay.

MRex · 02/04/2022 11:25

A swimming teacher teaches 2 kids a 2:1 lesson for an agreed price. One day a 3rd child is brought along too. They go into the pool. The swim teacher cannot ignore them as there would be safety issues and a hazard. When the bill is sent, they bill for an extra swimming lesson for that day.
Of course they can, they ask whose child it is (removing kid from the pool if necessary and telling them to bring back their adult), then ask the adult if they are paying for a lesson. Get them out of the pool if they start to drown, return to parent if they're disruptive, involve the lifeguard etc.

Its basic law, you have to agree to pay for a service, however oblique that agreement may be, and it is only that way that you can be billed. Otherwise it comes under unsolicited goods and services: www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1971/30.

Mummyoflittledragon · 02/04/2022 11:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MostlyOk · 02/04/2022 11:20

I could be wrong but she can't legally charge you for services you didn't ask for. You'd need to enter into some kind of written or verbal contract but you were unaware and didn't ask for or need her services.
But it might just be an honest mistake!

WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 11:20

It’s one thing to be an independent autistic teen on a day out, with a parent, or with the parent of another autistic friend.

It is quite different being out with a paid Carer. It is irrelevant how much care he actually received or had. He’s a teen who needs care sometimes and actually receives laid for care by this particular Carer. Why should she be expected to be the adult in charge all day and not get paid for him. And unless he should go there alone and spend the full day without any extra help or support from any adult, it’s a daft thing to even suggest.

Are you also suggesting that those carers who take the elderly out for a day, should have other non-paying elderly along for the ride and not charge for them - because they’ve already been paid for their hour of work?

Yes, the water is muddied by the fact OP didn’t organise and book this. The Host did and that’s why they really ought to pay. We’re they really expecting that the Carer would be the adult in charge of a teen who regularly needs care, without invoicing for them too? I find that hard to believe and if they did, this is where it all went wrong.

If I’d been the Carer, I’d have billed the host for 2x teens.
I do wonder if the host told the Carer to bill OP instead, or has just always assumed OP would foot the bill.

Surely the bill cannot be a surprise to host?

Maverickess · 02/04/2022 11:17

I think you need to find out from the host family exactly what was booked and paid for with the carer.
Did they book and pay for 1:2 care and then your ds went as well without the carer being aware he was until the event? If that's the case then points to raise would be why the carer didn't flag this up to the hosts who booked and if she did, what was their response?
And why didn't the hosts inform the carer at the time of booking who would be there and who would require care? So if your son didn't require the input of the carer at all, that should have been made clear to the carer at the time of booking, as you do use this carer regularly to support your son.

If the carer was aware at booking who would be present, then she should have billed those booking her accordingly.

And just a thought, if the OPs ds had needed any kind of support during the day out, and had not received it from the carer as she wasn't booked/paid for him, would it be acceptable for the carer to refuse to support, even at the detriment of the ds?

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 02/04/2022 11:16

I disagree. I don't think she can bill you for this when she was appointed to care for one child and has presumably been paid for that. She has misunderstood but she wasn't employed by you on this occasion so I don't think you owe her the money. Could you offer to pay her something as a gesture but make it clear that it's just to retain the relationship and not because you agree that you owe her.

Seraphinesupport · 02/04/2022 11:15

Carers are paid per hour NOT Per person cared for.

Shes been paid shes trying it on

WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 11:13

How can a carer switch from being adult-in-charge with OPs son on some occasions, to simply having him there as an independent adult on another, WHEN THERE IS NO OTHER ADULT TO TAKE CHARGE?

He might have managed the day fine. He might have needed minimal input. Regardless, he couldn’t have been there by himself. He needed an adult. Fine if that’s a parent or parents friend, but if it’s a Carer, you pay for that service. Someone has to be expected to pay. The Carer isn’t there to have random extra teens hanging round with them for the day who are unpaid for.

It’s like wanting to have extra kids at a party and only to pay for a certain number and expect others to get a freebie. No.

Sleepyblueocean · 02/04/2022 11:11

The carer cannot expect to be paid by 2 different people for the same working hours. That is not how it works. The OP did not ask her to work those hours. Not the OP's responsibility legally or morally.

WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 11:08

Here’s a similar situation.

A swimming teacher teaches 2 kids a 2:1 lesson for an agreed price. One day a 3rd child is brought along too. They go into the pool. The swim teacher cannot ignore them as there would be safety issues and a hazard. When the bill is sent, they bill for an extra swimming lesson for that day.

Parent objects. They say, the 3rd child was a good swimmer and didn’t need input. A specific lesson wasn’t requested for them.

We would think the parent was a cheeky blighter and of course they should pay.

This is the same. The Carer became the adult responsible for OPs son. They were there caring for other teens and it would have been impossible to not be impacted by his presence. It’s not possible to have a day out like that with 3 autistic kids who all receive care at other times and who have received care from these previously, to treat them differently and charge differently, when there is no other adult there to take responsibility. They did a job. They now need to be paid.

With care, there will be times when you feel you’ve got a slightly raw deal. Perhaps that you didn’t get the full minutes paid for, or you had to pay for a bigger slot than needed, or that the circumstances were such that your DC didn’t really need a carer or receive much care. That will happen. Care is expensive. It’s someone’s time and crucially caring for more teens is more responsibility than caring for 1. They must be paid for it.

Childminders are spending the same hour looking after 1 child as much as 1 hour spend looking after 4. They will all pay. It isn’t an hourly rate regardless of the number of kids.
You might get a cheaper rate for larger numbers…but unlikely if you dint book it as that.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 02/04/2022 11:03

Because that’s the question isn’t it?
Did the carer did ANY work for the OP’s ds? The OP thinks he was independent hence nit checking carer etc…
The carer seems to think that because they are caring for them some of the time, then they couldnt be independent.

Who is taking a chance there?

I suspect the carer, simply because I can’t imagine the OP being happy to leave their ds in a situation they would struggle with Wo checking the ins and outs first.

MRex · 02/04/2022 11:01

Imagine if this was a thread from the Carer.
'My fellow Carer and I were booked for 2 teen boys on a day out, one being billed for each boy. On arrival a 3rd boy who we also care for sometimes turned out to be there too. We looked after the 3 boys all day and a good time was had by all. At the end of the day, we billed all 3 parents for the care their sons received. But now the one who was there but wasn’t booked in is saying she doesn’t want to pay for my services and hadn’t booked me. Is this reasonable to have received my services all day and not pay me’
The carer would have everyone quite rightly saying "why on earth didn't you call the person who booked you to ask why you had an extra child?" and saying it's unfortunate, but next time you really need to talk with the person booking as soon as a problem arises.
It also isn't factual, because all 3 boys were expected. The carer has just decided on her own to bill twice, but 1:2 care would be a different rate usually anyway. It's not defensible.

Hankunamatata · 02/04/2022 11:00

So one parent paid for 1 carer. The second carer - is she charging both you and the 3rd parent? Seems bit off at most her fee for the day should be split between the two parents

Flame76 · 02/04/2022 10:59

10:21sonjadog
The OP says in the opening post that the carer has been paid by the family who organized the day.

No, she just says that she checked with the other family and their response was that they didn't realise she would be billed. She hasn't said if the hosting family paid or not.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 02/04/2022 10:59

@WombatChocolate that would be true of the third child needed supervision too.
As the OP said he didn’t, so the fact the carer knew him is no different than if he had been NT and had happened to be there. They wouldn’t have ask for payment for the NT child. So why for one that didn’t need support (but happened to be ND)