Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Carer charging me even though I didn't employ her

207 replies

NickyNora · 29/03/2022 19:42

My son is Autistic.
We use a Carer on a regular basis.
One of his friends from college had an outing recently.
The other child's parent organised the activity and the Carers.

We all use the same Carers.

The other child invited my son and 2 other boys to the outing.

I thought my son was a guest.
He needs almost no help socially now especially when he's comfortable with the environment and company.

Yesterday, I received an invoice for £160 from one of the Carers.

I checked with the parent of the child whose outing it was, that they have already paid the Carer.
The other parent didn't know I was being billed.

AIBU to say to the Carer, that I won't be paying her as I wasn't aware I was being billed?

OP posts:
Agadoodoododont · 02/04/2022 12:54

Carer, not cater!!!

Agadoodoododont · 02/04/2022 12:53

So the cater has already been paid by the parent organiser?
Got paid their hourly rate for supervising 3 young people. That’s it. That’s their wage. He/ she is just trying it on. I’d contact the agency if they work for one.

Gizacluethen · 02/04/2022 12:51

I spoke to the Carer, she seemed to presume, as my son was at the activity, that I was also paying her.

I'd feel so awkward but I'd just feign confidence and just reply "no sorry, Adam doesn't need support in that setting so we didn't feel the need to book it. We'd never expect you to care for him without checking with you first."

StaplesCorner · 02/04/2022 12:50

I'm none the wiser, so many people asking who booked the carer so we need the OP to come back. How did the carer know about the event, did she assume she was to go along to care for OP's son? Without us knowing who booked her, we can't possibly say what's fair and who might be at fault.

WisherWood · 02/04/2022 12:45

I spoke to the Carer, she seemed to presume, as my son was at the activity, that I was also paying her.

Well to start with I would point out to her that unless you explicitly ask for her care and make a booking she cannot assume you will pay her.

Effectively I'm in the situation where if I don't pay her, I will lose her as a Carer. She's worked with my son for 5 years.

Carers are incredibly difficult to recruit and keep. She knows we are near the end of our arrangement as my son will move to adult services and unlikely to get much support.

How soon is soon? I'd be inclined to get tough with her. I agree with PP that you're basically losing her either way, as she is pulling a fast one. Go back to the other parent and find out what they agreed and what they paid. Then go back to the carer and ask her her hourly rate for caring for two adolescents and her petrol costs. Take what she has already been paid off those costs and if there is a difference, pay her that. Otherwise she's chancing her arm.

And I would be very clear with her about how she is not to assume that she can bill twice in this way and assume you have booked her when you haven't. Things are difficult for everybody and she may be very stressed by this, but we all are. If she still insists on payment then frankly I'd find a way to cut her hours next month so that overall you pay her the same amount in total.

Sleepyblueocean · 02/04/2022 12:41

"The carer has assumed that both the friends parents and the OP would be paying."

That is the assumption the carer should never had made. Before you do any work you check with the person you expect to pay you. That goes for any job.

WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 12:31

SchoolChoice - good post.

ErmIDontKnow · 02/04/2022 12:28

I wouldn't pay her. Your son was invited out as a guest by another family. I wouldnt pay and I'd be really cross shes even asked considering there was no agreement between you both

Schoolchoicesucks · 02/04/2022 12:28

I don't think any of us have the full information here to be able to make useful suggestions.

OP, YANBU in not having expected to pay for a carer that you didn't book when your DC was invited to an activity that he didn't need care at.

The situation has arisen where the friend's parents arranged for the carer to come, seemingly without a clear discussion over who they would be providing support for and who would pay for that support.

The carer has assumed that both the friends parents and the OP would be paying. The friends parents say they haven't discussed the OP paying the carer. I don't know whether the friends parents have paid the Carer an appropriate amount for providing care for just their DC, for both DCs or nothing at all.

If OP has already had a discussion along the lines of "No, I didn't book care, wasn't expecting to pay for care", the friend's parents have said "No, we weren't expecting you to have to pay for care either" and the Carer has said "I provided care for 2 people and the total rate for this is £x and I've only been paid half of that. Somebody needs to pay me the difference otherwise I won't be providing future care", I'd expect there to be some discussion and potentially compromise along the lines of Carer accepting a reduced rate, friends parents contributing an additional amount, OP contributing an additional amount. Assuming that all parties want to continue a Care arrangement and relationship. And have a lesson learned about setting clear expectations up front.

Ariela · 02/04/2022 12:28

If the carer was booked and paid for Boy 1 at her full hourly rate, then how can she possibly be also available to be booked and care for Boy 2? Surely she cannot care for both at the same time.

BadNomad · 02/04/2022 12:22

Is the other carer charging everyone twice also?

WombatChocolate · 02/04/2022 12:22

I agree that the Carer should have contacted the Host or spoken to the host at drop-off.

I did say that earlier.

However, I also think it was wrong to expect to drop a 3rd boy, unpaid for. That was down to the host. I can see how annoying that would be to the Carers. He won’t have been ignored all day. To do so would be impossible and outrageous.

Charging a full rate probably is too much. It’s probably a passive aggressive protest at the Carer feeling she’s been taken advantage of in terms if unpaid care for a day. Perhaps she blames Op and thinks he knew what what was happening, when really it’s down to the Host.

In this situation, I would be offering something if after speaking g to the Host, they weren’t willing to pay or offer something. This would be due to trying to be a fair and reasonable person, not due to legal requirements. I would also be talking to Host and enquiring much more about the arrangements and probably be avoiding her in future….the lack of communication about the plan with Op and with the Carer is at the root of all this.

When human relationships and on-going human relationships that you will rely on in future are at play, often a little goodwill and flexibility is worth something, even when you feel a bit aggrieved about the costs. This rather than rigidly sticking to the letter of the law, and erring on the side of generosity and being willing to sometimes ‘suck it up’ instead of battling the corner, is just sometimes the right thing to do. In my mind, Carers have a hard job. They are poorly paid and it’s tough. People quibble all the time about exactly what they’ve delivered, cancel short notice etc etc. I’d be bearing that in mind too, in the same way I do with a cleaner. I’d give the benefit if the doubt and try to make sure they got some money - from the host hopefully, but if not, I’d be willing to lay something, even though it wasn’t an arrangement I made at all, because I’d want the Carer to get something for the effort they had put in and day they had spent with my son.

I can see lots don’t feel like that though and are much more rigidly and purely interested in the legal side. I guess I’ve known lots if Carers who are great Carers, but who I could see being caught out by this kind of thing. Their other skills and talents might not be so good and I can see how they could be essentially exploited into doing free work…and I dint like that. As a one-off I’d accept being out of pocket over this (if host wouldn’t pay) and be more careful in future. Others I can see, think Carer has zero claim to anything and if she’s done work she wasn’t explicitly contracted for…take the view it’s tough on her.

Lilac57 · 02/04/2022 12:16

Btw I do think she should be paid something for looking after your son, given that presumably her usual rate is for looking after one child. The organising parents didn’t go, so the carers are looking after every child there, whether they need much help or not. But it’s up to the organising parent and carer to negotiate what a reasonable fee is, it’s not reasonable for the carer to expect double pay (i.e. the same payment from organising parent and you), but you didn’t employ the carer so it’s not your problem.

LookItsMeAgain · 02/04/2022 12:12

I got as far as this comment in your posts @NickyNora and felt I had to reply to it:
I spoke to the Carer, she seemed to presume, as my son was at the activity, that I was also paying her. Effectively I'm in the situation where if I don't pay her, I will lose her as a Carer. She's worked with my son for 5 years.

Firstly, if she is going to be charging people for her time, she doesn't have the luxury of presuming anything. She should have started out by saying that "I'll be doing the caring for X today, are you ok with whatever that might cost?" (or words to that effect)
Secondly, if payment of this invoice is going to have a knock on effect to her remaining as your son's carer, why can't you come to some arrangement where the charge is spread over several weeks (say £10 or £20 per session, should have that worked off in a matter of weeks or at most a few months).
Thirdly, why didn't she as the carer make it clear from the start that she wasn't doing this out of the goodness of her heart, that there were costs associated with her being there and that you would be expected to contribute to those costs?

I'd be trying to come to some arrangement, if she threatens to leave your DS, based on your comment that good carers are difficult to find, to pay this but doing it over several weeks/months to suit you at this point.

EthelTheAardvark · 02/04/2022 12:09

No, there isn’t be legal come back on this. Yes, the Carer got paid for looking after 1 teen. But actually they were responsible for 2 all day. How could they have had that 3rd boy with them all day and it made zero impact? Why is it okay to expect they should do that for free?

If she felt she shouldn't be expected to do that for free, she should have raised it with the person who booked her, not assumed that someone else would pay. It's pretty cheeky to expect double pay anyway.

Lilac57 · 02/04/2022 12:09

Of course she should be paid, but by the parents who organised the outing. If they pay her rather than you, why would that result in you losing her as a carer?

Clockstooforward · 02/04/2022 12:09

TBH it is CF expecting the carer to look after an extra . Yes the parent should have :A Asked permission
B Paid the carer without hesitation….it’s awful the carer has had to ask for money!

EthelTheAardvark · 02/04/2022 12:04

But the question is, should this Carer get paid? By someone? They did the job and cared for the son. He was someone who needs care. He has been cared for on other occasions

He wasn't someone who needed care on this occasion. If the carer turned up and discovered someone whom she cared for in other contexts was there, and felt that she was inevitably going to end up caring for him also, she should have contacted the person she had the contract with and told him that she would need to be paid more. She could not reasonably have expected full pay from the extra person.

But can we expect host to lay it, given she organised a contract and sent along a teen who usually receives care from these carers? And if she doesn’t think she should pay as she didn’t book it explicitly, do we think the OP has an obligation (not legal) but by dint of her on-going caring relationship with the Carer and the fact the Carer provided the hours looking after him, to refuse?

Well, no, she doesn't. If the host doesn't think she should pay, it's up to the carer to sort it out with them - which is what she should have done as soon as it became apparent that the arrangement wasn't what she expected. She can't expect OP to bail her out because she didn't bother to clarify things with the host. Part of the caring relationship must involve recognition of the fact that people like OP's son receive strictly limited amounts to pay for care and therefore she can only expect to bill for what has been clearly agreed. Otherwise she is in effect saying OP or her son have to go without in other areas because she couldn't be bothered to sort out her business arrangements.

Or are we saying everyone should say to this Carer , ‘Sorry, no money for you. The Op didn’t ask you to look after him. The fact you did look after him, is fully down to you. It doesn’t matter that he was there and is a teen with additional needs that you previously have looked after and been paid for and that there was no other adult present to care for him or keep an eye on him and that if you ignored him totally, he could be at risk, but no we aren’t paying you’.

She wasn't the only adult present. It's quite telling that the other carer isn't demanding payment.

ImOnTheRoadAgain · 02/04/2022 12:03

Did the carer know how many children were going?

At the end of the day, they've still only done one days work regardless of how many children were there!

ImOnTheRoadAgain · 02/04/2022 11:57

And even if you did pay her (which you shouldn't), then it shouldn't be at your normal rate because she was looking after another child too so it wasn't one on one with your son!

TheNameOfTheRoses · 02/04/2022 11:55

How could they have had that 3rd boy with them all day and it made zero impact? Why is it okay to expect they should do that for free?

Wouod you say the same thing if the third teen had been NT? Would you say that it was faut for the carer to charge the parent of that 17yo?

Your argument only works of you assume that the OP is wrong and her ds needed regular support.
Did he? Or was it assumed by the carer that he did or would?

Neverreturntoathread · 02/04/2022 11:54

Sorry OP, how awkward! So the carer was booked by another parent to look after another chikd but assumed you also wanted care and is now billing you direct? She’s being incredibly cheeky / she could have easily checked with you first.

I understand that good carers are like gold dust. Is she a good carer? Doesn’t seem like it.

You didn’t hire her, you owe her nothing, I guess the question is whether she can bully you into paying something you don’t owe in order to keep her. What a nightmare.

I think all you can do is haggle with her.

Sleepyblueocean · 02/04/2022 11:52

In this situation I would offer a good will payment for the extra work ( nothing like the amount she is asking for) but tell her that she is not to work with my child again without my agreement first - which she should of obtained if she was expecting payment.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 02/04/2022 11:52

They did the job and cared for the son. He was someone who needs care. He has been cared for on other occasions.

Except @WombatChocolate the OP didn’t (rightly or wrongly) think he needed care.
The fact the ds has needed care IN OTHER CIRCUMSTANCES doesn’t mean he needed care in that specific situation.

It’s like saying an elderly person needed help to go and do some shopping therefore she had to need help when having friends over at her house.
As someone who needs support like this, I’d have a major issue with anyone assuming that because I can’t do xxx I therefore automatically need help with yyyy

fulanigirl · 02/04/2022 11:52

@WombatChocolate

How can a carer switch from being adult-in-charge with OPs son on some occasions, to simply having him there as an independent adult on another, WHEN THERE IS NO OTHER ADULT TO TAKE CHARGE?

He might have managed the day fine. He might have needed minimal input. Regardless, he couldn’t have been there by himself. He needed an adult. Fine if that’s a parent or parents friend, but if it’s a Carer, you pay for that service. Someone has to be expected to pay. The Carer isn’t there to have random extra teens hanging round with them for the day who are unpaid for.

It’s like wanting to have extra kids at a party and only to pay for a certain number and expect others to get a freebie. No.

She should be discussing this with the person that hired her, not OP. You discuss your scope of service with the person you enter an agreement with, not a third party.