Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Kier Starmer is spineless?

360 replies

LittleWhingingWoman · 29/03/2022 19:06

I'm a long time Labour supporter.
Not anymore.
Kier Starmer was asked if women have penises.
He couldn't answer.

I've had enough of this gaslighting.
How can I vote for a party that is led by this man?
How, in 2022, can a candidate who hopes to be pm not be able to say what a woman is?

AIBU to think he knows FULL WELL what a woman is but is too much of a coward to say. The men threatening and bullying Rosie Duffield certainly know what a woman is.

And I know a penis when I see one.

mobile.twitter.com/keir_starmer

OP posts:
knowinglesseveryday · 30/03/2022 08:57

He's spineless about everything

luckylavender · 30/03/2022 08:53

@LittleWhingingWoman - you are perfectly entitled to have whatever view you want of anyone.

My opinion is that he's not spineless, he's cautious, steady & measured.

You say he 'couldn't' answer the question. Of course he could but he chose not to (which he said) because it was a typically provocative question from the right wing media who are weaponising the issue. It's their new war on woke / Brexit / masks issue.

Drivingish · 30/03/2022 08:49

@Alexandra2001

300 babies died due to poor treatment in 2 NHS maternity units, presumably their mothers are women, their rights get trumped by a trans argument?

So we get yet another thread on what Labour say on Trans rights.

Its like re arranging the deck chairs on the Titantic by people who don't have much else to worry about, like poverty, domestic violence, lack of schooling, childcare, wage inequality, lack of access to healthcare, housing, access to justice for sexual assault etc etc.

Presumably a woman who undergoes a Metoidioplasty/Phalloplasty is a female with a penis?

Starmer is right, its a complex issue, he also stated he wants women only spaces to stay that way.

It's more like trying to organise all the lifeboats on the Titanic and ignoring the great big iceberg, it can look like ignoring the big issues unless you understand how it fits in.

Poverty - how will this be improved if no-one can say what a woman is to then understand how the pay gap, maternity leave, differences in career options can lead to poverty?

Domestic violence - if you can't say what a woman is you can't prevent the overwhelming number of domestic violence victims from the overwhelming number of abusers, they all lump in together.

Wage inequality - who gets paid less? Women? Ah but Pip Bunce is a woman, sometimes, doesn't affect Pip! If you can't define what a woman is a lot of wage inequality magically disappears.

Etc etc, the issues you listed are WHY this is such a big issue to focus on.

spacehardware · 30/03/2022 08:46

And as for media stoking - Keir starmer did this to himself by refusing to speak the truth. He could put this to bed very easily but he won't.

KatsuKatsu · 30/03/2022 08:46

This is an absolute non-issue to you maybe but clearly not to a large number of posters. Do their opinions not matter? Are they somehow less than you?

spacehardware · 30/03/2022 08:45

You meant which sex is going to be more affected. And yes the difference matters.

Alexandra2001 · 30/03/2022 08:45

@spacehardware

"Its like re arranging the deck chairs on the Titantic by people who don't have much else to worry about, like poverty, domestic violence, lack of schooling, childcare, wage inequality, lack of access to healthcare, housing, access to justice for sexual assault etc etc."

I've been a victim of domestic violence thanks, because of that experience I can imagine exactly how terrifying it would be to have a man in a women's shelter. These are not luxury opinions

As have i and under the Tories, there are less domestic violence shelters.... in some areas, over 50% of women seeking help are refused as there is no one to help them, they even taxed panic rooms!!!

There are huge issues facing women, yet whenever bad news is heading the Tories way, we get ... but Labour :( usually stoked by the right wing press/media.

What gender are going to be far more effected by stopping free parking for NHS workers?
No awkward questions from LBC on this to Javid or Boris?

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 08:42

This is an absolute non-issue and mumsnet sadly is getting a reputation for being a haven for hysterical transphobes.

People are increasingly seeing these kind of comments for the insidious gaslighting they are.

There is nothing transphobic about being concerned about the erosion of women's rights and redefinition of the very concept of womanhood. Nothing at all.

DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 08:38

This is an absolute non-issue

So go away and stop wasting your time arguing with us about it. Go and campaign about all those other issues that aren't getting your valuable attention while you try to correct us on this one.

FOJN · 30/03/2022 08:35

This is an absolute non-issue and mumsnet sadly is getting a reputation for being a haven for hysterical transphobes.

Caring about women's rights makes me a hysterical transphobe? Labour think that about me too so there is no way I'll be voting for them. Feel free to carry on insulting women who think this is a big deal. You should know that those of us who have been watching developments with increasing concern over the last few years have been called every name under the sun, we are all out of fucks to give.

I'm sure the woman who was raped in hospital and then told it couldn't have happened as there were no men on the ward doesn't feel this is a non issue.

Perhaps I'm just a very bad person because I find that abhorrent and refuse to vote for a party who would pass a law which would expose even more women to similar trauma and then fucking gaslight her after the event.

spacehardware · 30/03/2022 08:33

"Its like re arranging the deck chairs on the Titantic by people who don't have much else to worry about, like poverty, domestic violence, lack of schooling, childcare, wage inequality, lack of access to healthcare, housing, access to justice for sexual assault etc etc."

I've been a victim of domestic violence thanks, because of that experience I can imagine exactly how terrifying it would be to have a man in a women's shelter. These are not luxury opinions

SilverGlitterBaubles · 30/03/2022 08:29

@Mytholmroyd

I am so disappointed by Starmer and Labour on this. However I would also like to see Johnson and other leading Tory MPs and cabinet ministers quizzed on the same issue at every opportunity

Sunak did no better a couple of days ago - pathetic - just kept repeating 'I agree with what the prime minister said' over and over. Looked a complete idiot

Exactly this, while I agree Labour are spineless on the issue I am not convinced that the Tories are any better. This is become such a no go topic for anyone in the public eye with people falling over themselves not to become another JK Rowling. They are actually willing to deny all common sense and reality in order not to to offend particular groups. It's like the emperors new clothes, we are all being told to accept things that are not reality.
DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 08:17

@Baddit, can you tell us what a woman is?

MarshaBradyo · 30/03/2022 08:16

@spacehardware

"This is an absolute non-issue and mumsnet sadly is getting a reputation for being a haven for hysterical transphobes"

It's a non-issue for women to be told they don't exist? For our protections under the equality act to be eroded?

My vote is mine snd I'm not going to cast it to the order of someone who calls women hysterical or transphobes for thinking female people are real. Fuck off tbh

Pretty much
Papayamya · 30/03/2022 08:15

This is an absolute non-issue and mumsnet sadly is getting a reputation for being a haven for hysterical transphobes.

Ah yes, women are hysterical, and being concerned for and standing up for women's rights equals transphobia eh.

This is being used by the conservatives as smokescreen to mask their shameful and disastrous leadership of this country:

Not really, labour are doing this themselves, no one from the Conservative party forced him to go on the radio and speak absolutely shite, and no one has forced any of the other Labour MPs to spout the crap they do either- that's on them. Also curious where people have said ah the torys are bloody brilliant definitely voting for them (clue, they haven't). But for many this is understandably a hill to die on.

Andante57 · 30/03/2022 08:15

Why does everyone fear these people SOOO much? How is the UK population cowering to a "minority" who is smaller than any other group, yet exerts SO MUCH POWER

I’ve often wondered that.

Alexandra2001 · 30/03/2022 08:13

300 babies died due to poor treatment in 2 NHS maternity units, presumably their mothers are women, their rights get trumped by a trans argument?

So we get yet another thread on what Labour say on Trans rights.

Its like re arranging the deck chairs on the Titantic by people who don't have much else to worry about, like poverty, domestic violence, lack of schooling, childcare, wage inequality, lack of access to healthcare, housing, access to justice for sexual assault etc etc.

Presumably a woman who undergoes a Metoidioplasty/Phalloplasty is a female with a penis?

Starmer is right, its a complex issue, he also stated he wants women only spaces to stay that way.

PenStation · 30/03/2022 08:09

The trans thing is part of a rollback of human rights and protections for UK citizens. We’ve already had cuts to legal aid preventing people accessing justice, we’ve had a dogged determination to push through legislation curtailing protest and the rights of migrants. Now Sunak has overseen a real terms cut to the benefits of some of the most vulnerable people in the UK. Trans women are biologically men, trans men are biologically women. It shouldn’t be at all controversial to say this because it is factual, and I know it’s factual because of my professional training. And yet my rights to even state this as fact are described as a belief and had to be fought for in court.

PenStation · 30/03/2022 08:03

Starmer and Labour more generally are a disgrace. With the open corruption and contempt for the public shown by the conservatives, they should be kicking at an open goal with the electorate. They are bogged down in identity politics whilst the Tories have been mismanaging the NHS, sitting on their heels with the UK’s energy strategy, doing too little around green infrastructure, punishing the poor with their fiscal policies. I am politically homeless too.

spacehardware · 30/03/2022 07:54

Spoiled ballots are inspected by the acting returning officer, candidates snd their agents to confirm all agree they are in fact spoiled and can't be construed as a valid vote. If hundreds of ballot papers turned up in each count with "Labour losing women" on them, believe me it would get back to central office.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 30/03/2022 07:51

@JustAnotherPoster00

Abstention is a vote for the incumbent government and for the most part no one is going to give much of a fuck what you right on your spoilt ballots, so a master class in futility all round
Depends on the constituency doesn't it (abstention)? In many places it would make fuck all difference due to our shit electoral system.
Swayingpalmtrees · 30/03/2022 07:50

Yes he is spineless.

DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 07:47

I thought people were being ridiculous when they said women were being erased and that it was obvious "trans women are women" wasn't supposed to be taken literally.

Now our leading politicians don't know what a woman is, male people are taking opportunities and medals meant for women and getting opportunities to assault women in prison because they "are women", and a famous female author, and a famous female former athlete, are being threatened and abused every day because they're saying something about it.

If this weren't happening to women, you would be noticing it far more. Why is it so easy to ignore?

billycorn · 30/03/2022 07:35

It's not an obsession and certainly not a narrow issue. Trans activists are largely made up of people who were privileged white males who have now transitioned to trans women.
I see it as men's rights' activism as nolongersuprised as pointed out.

Joystir59 · 30/03/2022 07:32

The only reason he's given media time is because he's neoliberal and no threat to the Tories. The Tories are however a much bigger threat in reality to the wellbeing of women and children because they keep so many of them locked in poverty. So I will vote Labour. Boris says he knows what a woman is, but him and his party are happy to keep them living in poverty with a severely underfunded NHS, under funded education and dire benefits situation. Labour will look after women and children better. I'm not being hoodwinked by Boris cleverly stating he knows what a woman is. Will Boris actually deliver on practical steps to better support women? I doubt it. Labour will tackle the causes if poverty and improve the lots of women and children at the breadline.

Swipe left for the next trending thread