Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Kier Starmer is spineless?

360 replies

LittleWhingingWoman · 29/03/2022 19:06

I'm a long time Labour supporter.
Not anymore.
Kier Starmer was asked if women have penises.
He couldn't answer.

I've had enough of this gaslighting.
How can I vote for a party that is led by this man?
How, in 2022, can a candidate who hopes to be pm not be able to say what a woman is?

AIBU to think he knows FULL WELL what a woman is but is too much of a coward to say. The men threatening and bullying Rosie Duffield certainly know what a woman is.

And I know a penis when I see one.

mobile.twitter.com/keir_starmer

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 30/03/2022 13:15

@Battytwatty

Here is the email I sent to my local councillor. It was sent in a rush as I was angry (and at work) so excuse any bad grammar. I will update with any response but not holding my breath ….

Good morning,
I am a life long Labour voter and supporter but I am becoming increasingly concerned about Labours stance on the definition of woman and the erosion of woman’s rights to safe spaces and the effects that will have.
As a frequent user of Mumsnet, I have noticed this topic gets discussed a lot and many users including myself find that as the Labour Party can’t define what a woman is, we are unable to vote for them. I have attached a recent thread for your attention. I would urge you to please spend some time reading the Mumsnet boards so you can see yourself how many woman feel unable to vote Labour and feel politically homeless.

I look forward to hearing your thoughts on this.

Angela Rainer says that this shouldn't be discussed on social media in case it upsets transitions.

Even the women of the Labour Party are trying to shut us up about this.

(with the exception of the wonderful Rosie Duffield - I am amazed she hasn't deflected yet).

Battytwatty · 30/03/2022 13:11

Here is the email I sent to my local councillor. It was sent in a rush as I was angry (and at work) so excuse any bad grammar. I will update with any response but not holding my breath ….

Good morning,
I am a life long Labour voter and supporter but I am becoming increasingly concerned about Labours stance on the definition of woman and the erosion of woman’s rights to safe spaces and the effects that will have.
As a frequent user of Mumsnet, I have noticed this topic gets discussed a lot and many users including myself find that as the Labour Party can’t define what a woman is, we are unable to vote for them. I have attached a recent thread for your attention. I would urge you to please spend some time reading the Mumsnet boards so you can see yourself how many woman feel unable to vote Labour and feel politically homeless.

I look forward to hearing your thoughts on this.

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 13:08

gender identity is thought to likely reflect a complex interplay of biological, environmental, and cultural factors, not just wearing make-up and a dress.

I've only ever seen it defined in terms of social/cultural stereotypes. Perhaps you'd have a crack at a definition.

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 13:07

A lot of transgender women that 'pass'

I don't mean this unkindly, but in the vast, vast majority of cases, I don't think that's true

and then if you question them how do you get them to prove that they are or are not a woman?

How is this policed currently? If a male is in a female toilet or wants access to a female support group? The same would apply.

WouldBeGood · 30/03/2022 13:03

@YouSetTheTone that’s precisely the problem, you can’t ensure those spaces. It’s Newspeak.

My MSPs say they will protect women only spaces. But also say that men can be women.

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 13:03

Transwomen should not enter female spaces as they are male
But then how do you stop them? A lot of transgender women that 'pass', and then if you question them how do you get them to prove that they are or are not a woman? Although I do acknowledge that most of the time the problems are caused by fetishists, and not real 'transwomen'.

If people want to form an identity around 'likes wearing make-up and dresses' or 'kindness and compassion' than go ahead.
I don't think that it is as simple as this - gender identity is thought to likely reflect a complex interplay of biological, environmental, and cultural factors, not just wearing make-up and a dress.

LittleWhingingWoman · 30/03/2022 13:01

@Alexandra2001

How can Boris, idiot that he is, be the only threat?
ANYONE who opposes safe spaces for women and children based on their sex and not mens imaginary gender identity is a threat to the safety of women and children.

OP posts:
YouSetTheTone · 30/03/2022 12:49

@Alexandra2001 but how can Keir Starmer protect women-only spaces when he can't define one accurately?
If, as in Keir Starmer's view, a woman is simultaneously understood to be an adult human female and a man whose gender identity is 'female', then how do you retain a space exclusively for adult human females?

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 30/03/2022 12:48

[quote Lamerexo]@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

in what context is gender actually that relevant?
I think it is relevant in that it allows people to express themselves how they choose, form communities based on likeness, etc - your gender can be transwoman or transman but you will always remain your biological 'sex'.

Female-segregated spaces are all based on sex not gender.
I agree with this. Female is a biological 'woman' as per se, so it is only right to have segregated spaces away from the male sex. But then how is that enforced when trans people want to enter female segregated spaces?[/quote]
Transwomen should not enter female spaces as they are male.

There is no evidence that gender is being expressed based on likeness. Transwomen are assuming what women feel like and believe and then imitating it. I have nothing more in common with a transwoman than a man. It's not helpful to pretend otherwise. If people want to form an identity around 'likes wearing make-up and dresses' or 'kindness and compassion' than go ahead. That does not a woman make.

hamstersarse · 30/03/2022 12:47

Starmer is an absolute total disappointment in all aspects.

I used to be a member of the LP but feel embarrassed about that now.

It is not just on women and trans issues, he offers nothing of a vision in any aspect of life. Not one issue you could pin to him and understand some sort of vision. The only people he is appealing to is the mentally ill trans people.

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 12:42

He can't protect women only spaces if he's unable to define what's a woman. Isn't that obvious?

spacehardware · 30/03/2022 12:42

"Starmer stated in the LBC interview he wants to protect women only spaces"

Under starmer people with penises are women, so they won't be women only spaces

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 12:41

I get that there are ways of behaving that are stereotypically more 'male' or 'female'. But why can't the message be its okay to present however you like regardless of your biological sex?

While ultimately sex is the only important element to enshrine in law?

jowly · 30/03/2022 12:39

He doesn't appear to have an opinion or an idea about anything other than this, and he's even got this one wrong.

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 12:37

I think it is relevant in that it allows people to express themselves how they choose, form communities based on likeness

I think that's all totally fine, but I'm not sure why any legal frameworks would be needed to facilitate it.

But then how is that enforced when trans people want to enter female segregated spaces?

They shouldn't have a right to do that. So good use of the word no.

DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 12:35

If gender identity is undefinable, fluid and changeable, it's a useless metric.

TooBigForMyBoots · 30/03/2022 12:35

@Ionsion

They will give the election away to the Tory’s if they don’t get their act together over this
I doubt the Tories will take GC votes from Labour, given that Rishi Sunak has given an equally unclear, nonsensical answer to "what is a woman?". And a Conservative MP has just come out as the first Trans MP in the UK.Shock
Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 12:33

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

in what context is gender actually that relevant?
I think it is relevant in that it allows people to express themselves how they choose, form communities based on likeness, etc - your gender can be transwoman or transman but you will always remain your biological 'sex'.

Female-segregated spaces are all based on sex not gender.
I agree with this. Female is a biological 'woman' as per se, so it is only right to have segregated spaces away from the male sex. But then how is that enforced when trans people want to enter female segregated spaces?

Alexandra2001 · 30/03/2022 12:33

@YouSetTheTone

YANBU op. Starmer is worse than spineless - he is dangerous to women. He can't define a woman accurately and wants to give away our single sex spaces as a result. A man, graciously and benevolently allowing men to adopt an 'inner feeling of womanhood' and therefore access to women's spaces/ prizes/ prisons/ rape counselling centres etc. Keir Starmer will never feel the ill-effects of his own words. Creep.
the only person dangerous to women is Boris Johnson, with a proven track record to match.

Starmer stated in the LBC interview he wants to protect women only spaces, Bojo is closing them down and forcing women who have been raped to wait 3 years before any trial (if at all)

Domestic abuse reports UP, prosecutions DOWN under his watch.

YouSetTheTone · 30/03/2022 12:25

YANBU op. Starmer is worse than spineless - he is dangerous to women. He can't define a woman accurately and wants to give away our single sex spaces as a result.
A man, graciously and benevolently allowing men to adopt an 'inner feeling of womanhood' and therefore access to women's spaces/ prizes/ prisons/ rape counselling centres etc.
Keir Starmer will never feel the ill-effects of his own words.
Creep.

JellySaurus · 30/03/2022 12:20

[quote bellinisurge]@Mytholmroyd , I think the social democrats don't have a completely ok position on a number of social issues. Genuinely can't remember what those are but recall reading some of their bumph and thinking "Nope, not comfy with that".[/quote]
But isn't that going to be the case with every political party? Unless you are a strict follower of a party doctrine it's always a best-fit, acceptable compromise.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 30/03/2022 12:18

@Lamerexo

"The World Health Organisation regional office for Europe describes sex as characteristics that are biologically defined, whereas gender is based on socially constructed features. They recognise that there are variations in how people experience gender based upon self-perception and expression, and how they behave."

So a trans-woman's sex will always be male, and a trans-man's sex will always be female. But can their 'gender' not be a 'transwoman' or a 'transman' nevertheless?

Yes but the question is so what? in what context is gender actually that relevant?

We all have multiple aspects of our identity and it is not sensible to try and legislate for all of those. It's also abusive to children to push the idea that gender identity is somehow ubiquitous, understandable without ever being defined and something you need to declare when you are very young.

Female-segregated spaces are all based on sex not gender.

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 11:53

"The World Health Organisation regional office for Europe describes sex as characteristics that are biologically defined, whereas gender is based on socially constructed features. They recognise that there are variations in how people experience gender based upon self-perception and expression, and how they behave."

So a trans-woman's sex will always be male, and a trans-man's sex will always be female. But can their 'gender' not be a 'transwoman' or a 'transman' nevertheless?

LittleWhingingWoman · 30/03/2022 11:38

@LittleWhingingWoman

Is part of the solution some sort of cross party womens group?
I'll try to make that more coherent.

We need a cross party womens group headed up by the strongest members of each party (Jo Cherry, Rosie Duffield, Baroness Nicholson, Emma Bateman etc)

We need to be able to organise and have meetings and allow women to talk freely.

If we need a secret room to do it in I'm sure JKR can magic some up 😂

OP posts:
Wheresthebeach · 30/03/2022 11:35

Its depressing beyond words. Spineless is the polite word for it.

They will lose votes, and a lot, over this. The Tories will see an opening and exploit it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread