Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Kier Starmer is spineless?

360 replies

LittleWhingingWoman · 29/03/2022 19:06

I'm a long time Labour supporter.
Not anymore.
Kier Starmer was asked if women have penises.
He couldn't answer.

I've had enough of this gaslighting.
How can I vote for a party that is led by this man?
How, in 2022, can a candidate who hopes to be pm not be able to say what a woman is?

AIBU to think he knows FULL WELL what a woman is but is too much of a coward to say. The men threatening and bullying Rosie Duffield certainly know what a woman is.

And I know a penis when I see one.

mobile.twitter.com/keir_starmer

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 15:09

the gender identity case report in twins concluded that of 23 monozygotic female and male twins, nine (39.1%) were concordant for GID; in contrast, none of the 21 same‐sex dizygotic female and male twins were concordant for GID, a statistically significant difference (P = 0.005), suggesting a role for genetic factors in the development of GID.

You're going to have to explain that in plain English

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:09

@LittleWhingingWoman

"I don't think that it is as simple as this - gender identity is thought to likely reflect a complex interplay of biological," - what precise and factual biological aspects are you talking about here? Are you talking about intersex people because most Transwomen are not intersex.)

"environmental," what does this mean exactly?

"cultural factors," you mean that men are told if they wear dresses they must be women rather than "Hey Jamie, it's ok for you to wear a dress, we accept you as the man you are." Or do you mean something else?

"not just wearing make-up and a dress." Well what is it then? What else makes these MEN magically women?

Rather than making assumptions of what a definition of gender identity means, maybe actually look into it before you badly attempt to twist it around?
LittleWhingingWoman · 30/03/2022 15:07

@DrSbaitso

I hadn't realised the term wasn't being used anymore - you see it everywhere in Transactivist postings!

That's because a key part of this movement is the exploitation of people with DSDs, despite the community having asked repeatedly not to be drawn into this because it's nothing to do with them and involves misguiding people about what it means to have a DSD. The TRAs who do this effectively use people with DSDs to "prove" that there's no such thing as sex and they aren't really male or female. Even if this were true, it would be irrelevant in the case of the overwhelming majority of people who don't have one, but as it happens, it's not true. People with a DSD are male or female.

Thank you so much for this clarification!
OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 15:07

All I did was define gender identity

No you didn't.

You posted a few words that may or may not be a starting point.

We've asked you to specify what the cultural, biological and environmental factors are and how they interplay to determine gender identity.

If they're in the links, please alert us to that answer yourself.

'Here's a few links in lieu of explaining my position' doesn't not make for convincing argument.

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:06

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee
Societal norms and expectation stop a great deal of people from invading spaces they are not invited to. In some instances there will also be legal recourse. The fact that it is not possible to 100% stop anyone from entering spaces they are not welcome does not invalidate the aim.

That is very true, I was just asking a hypothetical question rather than trying to invalidate the aim as a whole as I do agree with it.

. There is no evidence for anything with relation to gender identity as there is no clear definition of it.
If you look at what I have linked (hopefully if it has sent), the gender identity case report in twins concluded that of 23 monozygotic female and male twins, nine (39.1%) were concordant for GID; in contrast, none of the 21 same‐sex dizygotic female and male twins were concordant for GID, a statistically significant difference (P = 0.005), suggesting a role for genetic factors in the development of GID.

DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 15:04

Time was, if a man entered a female space, women would be presumed to have authority in that space and there'd be strength in their justified and supported order to him to leave or even try to force him our if necessary. Now he can enter, and he is presumed to have the authority and moral righteousness, and women will be castigated if they say no. And that's on the power of cultural allowance alone, because legally, they've still got the right to boot him.

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:01

@TheKeatingFive

My definition comes from the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism and it is also established in The Journal of Sexual Medicine

Was that it though?

What you've already posted?

It wasn't very helpful in answering the question. What specifically are those biological/environmental/cultural factors? How do they interplay to determine gender?

All I did was define gender identity, if you want to learn about the various studies into gender identity and causation I will list a few links below :

www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Transsexuality-Among-Twins%3A-Identity-Concordance%2C-Diamond/6f1bf4e467577434ede5a4f588dda9e41d86322e

academic.oup.com/jcem/article/99/12/4379/2833862

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 30/03/2022 14:58

@Lamerexo

Transwomen should not enter female spaces as they are male But then how do you stop them? A lot of transgender women that 'pass', and then if you question them how do you get them to prove that they are or are not a woman? Although I do acknowledge that most of the time the problems are caused by fetishists, and not real 'transwomen'.

If people want to form an identity around 'likes wearing make-up and dresses' or 'kindness and compassion' than go ahead.
I don't think that it is as simple as this - gender identity is thought to likely reflect a complex interplay of biological, environmental, and cultural factors, not just wearing make-up and a dress.

Societal norms and expectation stop a great deal of people from invading spaces they are not invited to. In some instances there will also be legal recourse. The fact that it is not possible to 100% stop anyone from entering spaces they are not welcome does not invalidate the aim.

There is no evidence for any biological factors impacting gender identity. There is no evidence for anything with relation to gender identity as there is no clear definition of it. MN has repeatedly asked for evidence to counter my assertion but it has never been forthcoming. If you have some, I would genuinely be interested to see it. In the meantime we have to treat your statement here as a fallacy and therefore base no legal rights on it.

DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 14:36

I hadn't realised the term wasn't being used anymore - you see it everywhere in Transactivist postings!

That's because a key part of this movement is the exploitation of people with DSDs, despite the community having asked repeatedly not to be drawn into this because it's nothing to do with them and involves misguiding people about what it means to have a DSD. The TRAs who do this effectively use people with DSDs to "prove" that there's no such thing as sex and they aren't really male or female. Even if this were true, it would be irrelevant in the case of the overwhelming majority of people who don't have one, but as it happens, it's not true. People with a DSD are male or female.

LittleWhingingWoman · 30/03/2022 14:29

@DrSbaitso

Are you talking about intersex people because most Transwomen are not intersex

Nobody is intersex. There is no such thing and it's why the difference of sexual development community asks for this term not to be used.

Everyone, but everyone, is male or female, however they identify. A very small number of people have a difference of development along their sexual development pathway, but all of these variations have to occur along the male or female ones. There's no third option. Each DSD is recognisable and diagnosable precisely because it has to occur in a male path or a female path.

There is no third gamete.

I hadn't realised the term wasn't being used anymore - you see it everywhere in Transactivist postings!

Thanks for the clarification!

OP posts:
spacehardware · 30/03/2022 14:20

"Has he checked his wife for a penis? maybe she can help him out with this."

Wonder which of Sir and Lady Starmer impregnated the other to produce their children? Maybe they took turns? Who knows.

DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 14:19

Are you talking about intersex people because most Transwomen are not intersex

Nobody is intersex. There is no such thing and it's why the difference of sexual development community asks for this term not to be used.

Everyone, but everyone, is male or female, however they identify. A very small number of people have a difference of development along their sexual development pathway, but all of these variations have to occur along the male or female ones. There's no third option. Each DSD is recognisable and diagnosable precisely because it has to occur in a male path or a female path.

There is no third gamete.

LittleWhingingWoman · 30/03/2022 14:04

"I don't think that it is as simple as this - gender identity is thought to likely reflect a complex interplay of biological," - what precise and factual biological aspects are you talking about here? Are you talking about intersex people because most Transwomen are not intersex.)

"environmental," what does this mean exactly?

"cultural factors," you mean that men are told if they wear dresses they must be women rather than "Hey Jamie, it's ok for you to wear a dress, we accept you as the man you are." Or do you mean something else?

"not just wearing make-up and a dress." Well what is it then? What else makes these MEN magically women?

OP posts:
WouldBeGood · 30/03/2022 13:53

@spacehardware quite!

FOJN · 30/03/2022 13:31

I don't think that it is as simple as this - gender identity is thought to likely reflect a complex interplay of biological, environmental, and cultural factors, not just wearing make-up and a dress.

The word likely is doing more heavy lifting than Laurel Hubbard there.

Fluffycloudland77 · 30/03/2022 13:30

Has he checked his wife for a penis? maybe she can help him out with this.

Dumblebum · 30/03/2022 13:28

@Kreuzberg

Surely a long time labour voter couldn't vote tory just on the basis of one issue ? The whole ideology is different. Why would you consciously vote in a party whose ideals you don't espouse ?
Because it’s a massive issue impacting half the population, the man doesn’t know if a woman has a penis. It’s not even yes they do or no they don’t. And he’s owning it. Apparently he can’t even say either way. How can anyone vote for that?
spacehardware · 30/03/2022 13:27

I don't mind what someone's gender identity is. I don't use a women's toilet because of my gender identity. I use it because I have a female body.

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 13:24

My definition comes from the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism and it is also established in The Journal of Sexual Medicine

Was that it though?

What you've already posted?

It wasn't very helpful in answering the question. What specifically are those biological/environmental/cultural factors? How do they interplay to determine gender?

FOJN · 30/03/2022 13:23

Starmer stated in the LBC interview he wants to protect women only spaces,

The phrase he used was "safe spaces" which could be interpreted any number of ways. He also refused to answer a question about whether a woman can have a penis and thought it was for sporting bodies to decide whether transwomen should compete against women. What exactly would his idea of safe spaces for women look like and would women with penis's be permitted? I suspect his safe spaces for women would be like Labours women only shortlists, open to anyone who identifies as a woman. This is nothing like single sex spaces.

"And that's not picking on any individual at all, but I don't like intolerance, I like open discussion."

He also said this whilst standing by and doing bugger all to protect Rosie Duffield from bullying within the Labour party so we know the man is as much a lying misogynist as BJ. He did not condemn some Labour MP's calls to expel women from the LP for refusing to repeat TWAW. He wants open discussion with people who won't make him look a fool by disagreeing with him. And if I hear one more Labour MP claim we need more light and less heat on this issue I'll scream, it's just another way of telling women to stop making a fuss although I'm sure they think they sound clever and measured when they spout this crap.

He can fuck off to the furthest reaches of fuck off.

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 13:21

@DrSbaitso

But then how do you stop them?

Before it became culturally acceptable for them to come in, this was rarely a problem. There was a lot of expectation that they wouldn't try it, and the weight of the law and public feeling against them if they tried.

If you're going to flap about over what a woman is and whether single sex spaces are acceptable, and attack and victimise those who have an objection, then yes, it becomes harder. If I didn't know better, I'd think it was deliberate...

That is very true
Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 13:20

@TheKeatingFive

gender identity is thought to likely reflect a complex interplay of biological, environmental, and cultural factors, not just wearing make-up and a dress.

I've only ever seen it defined in terms of social/cultural stereotypes. Perhaps you'd have a crack at a definition.

My definition comes from the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism and it is also established in The Journal of Sexual Medicine
DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 13:16

But then how do you stop them?

Before it became culturally acceptable for them to come in, this was rarely a problem. There was a lot of expectation that they wouldn't try it, and the weight of the law and public feeling against them if they tried.

If you're going to flap about over what a woman is and whether single sex spaces are acceptable, and attack and victimise those who have an objection, then yes, it becomes harder. If I didn't know better, I'd think it was deliberate...

lifeturnsonadime · 30/03/2022 13:15

sorry that should have said 'upsets transitioners'.

Won't we think of the poor males!

Mytholmroyd · 30/03/2022 13:15

@bellinisurge thanks! I will have a look - the 'social' made me hope they weren't a looney party. Wish we had PR. Or that all the decent honest MPs with integrity across all parties would form a new party!