Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Kier Starmer is spineless?

360 replies

LittleWhingingWoman · 29/03/2022 19:06

I'm a long time Labour supporter.
Not anymore.
Kier Starmer was asked if women have penises.
He couldn't answer.

I've had enough of this gaslighting.
How can I vote for a party that is led by this man?
How, in 2022, can a candidate who hopes to be pm not be able to say what a woman is?

AIBU to think he knows FULL WELL what a woman is but is too much of a coward to say. The men threatening and bullying Rosie Duffield certainly know what a woman is.

And I know a penis when I see one.

mobile.twitter.com/keir_starmer

OP posts:
LittleWhingingWoman · 30/03/2022 16:04

@spacehardware

Why what's he done?
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/wes-streeting-trans-rights-women-penis-b2047117.html?amp
OP posts:
spacehardware · 30/03/2022 16:02

Why what's he done?

Mytholmroyd · 30/03/2022 16:01

Can we have three cheers for Wes Streeting please? He's a star Star

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:50

@DrSbaitso

No ... because a case study isn't representative of all twins is it?

Then why is it representative of gender identity occurrence?

It isn't, it is just a case study alongside other case studies on this same matter that help to support the concept that gender identity is not just psychological as it can also be biological?
DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 15:47

No ... because a case study isn't representative of all twins is it?

Then why is it representative of gender identity occurrence?

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:42

@DrSbaitso

So does this mean that 39% of identical twins experience gender identity disorder? And almost no fraternal ones?
No ... because a case study isn't representative of all twins is it?
TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 15:39

Just keep saying the same thing again and again and maybe it will mean something different eventually I suppose

That's exactly my thoughts on your posts.

What are the factors? Where have you specified them? That's all I'm asking.

Thing is, I would be really interested in a proper definition of gender that would help me understand people's position on this. If you want a serious conversation, then stop all this mucking around and just state it. You give an aura of understanding it very well, so I'm asking you to share that. What specifically are those biological, cultural and environmental factors you are talking about?

The links to scientific papers about tangentially related things are not conveying to me what I want to know - and if you want to actually engage with people, you will need to clarify for us, not just post links.

DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 15:37

So does this mean that 39% of identical twins experience gender identity disorder? And almost no fraternal ones?

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:36

@DrSbaitso

I listed the factors and the cases that explained the factors

Did you?

Yes
Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:34

@TheKeatingFive

I listed the factors

Where? Where did you specify what the cultural, environmental and biological factors are.

It would be a list. What's so difficult about that?

Just keep saying the same thing again and again and maybe it will mean something different eventually I suppose !

Examples are in the links in case studies done by professionals where they can be much better explained by them than I can do justice.

DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 15:34

I listed the factors and the cases that explained the factors

Did you?

DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 15:30

Of 23 identical (male and female), 39.1% concordant for GID. but none of the 21 same‐sex non-identical male and female twins were concordant for GID, which suggests that genetic factors plays a role.

I don't follow. If genetic factors play a role, why was there a relatively high concordance in the people who share identical genes? You mean both twins in those sets had gender identity disorder? I was taking it to mean individuals.

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 15:29

I listed the factors

Where? Where did you specify what the cultural, environmental and biological factors are.

It would be a list. What's so difficult about that?

luckylavender · 30/03/2022 15:28

@spacehardware

"Does he want to be Prime Minister or not?"

I legit don't think he does no

Of course he does
Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:28

@TheKeatingFive

monozygotic - identical GID - gender identity disorder dizygotic - non-identical

I'm none the wiser, sorry.

I'd just really like you to specify the factors. That would help me understand.

I listed the factors and the cases that explained the factors, which can do it far better justice than I can in a Mumsnet reply. If you really want to educate yourself and understand more like you act you do, I would encourage you to actually read it.
luckylavender · 30/03/2022 15:27

@TotalRhubarb - yes of course the electorate should know. But I don't think being hustled into it by rent a quote Ferrari is the right environment. It needs nuance & balance.

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:27

@DrSbaitso

Ok. So there was a case where 23 pairs of identical twins were studied and 39% had gender identity disorder. 21 pairs of same-sex fraternal twins were studied and none had gender identity disorder. Is that it?

That seems to suggest that whatever causes it isn't genetic, since identical twins share the same genes. Might it have something to do with an identical twin having a strong motivation to differentiate themselves from the genetically identical person?

Still need a definition of gender to understand this properly.

Of 23 identical (male and female), 39.1% concordant for GID. but none of the 21 same‐sex non-identical male and female twins were concordant for GID, which suggests that genetic factors plays a role.
DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 15:23

Ok. So there was a case where 23 pairs of identical twins were studied and 39% had gender identity disorder. 21 pairs of same-sex fraternal twins were studied and none had gender identity disorder. Is that it?

That seems to suggest that whatever causes it isn't genetic, since identical twins share the same genes. Might it have something to do with an identical twin having a strong motivation to differentiate themselves from the genetically identical person?

Still need a definition of gender to understand this properly.

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 15:20

monozygotic - identical
GID - gender identity disorder
dizygotic - non-identical

I'm none the wiser, sorry.

I'd just really like you to specify the factors. That would help me understand.

DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 15:19

A definition of what?

Gender identity. Are you claiming to have offered a definition for something while not knowing what you were supposed to be defining?

I said that gender identity likely reflects genetic and biological, environmental, and cultural factors and provided links with case studies that provide the reasoning as to why this conclusion has been drawn, but you do not want to see it.

What conclusion? What are we talking about?

I couldn't understand the excerpt quoted by TheKeatingFive either. I'm not familiar with the terms. It may be that gender identity is indeed too complex to be explained in layman's terms, but if so, I don't think we should be creating legislation around it and encouraging people to self-proclaim their own while everyone else adapts to it. Can you explain it in a way a reasonably intelligent, albeit non-expert, person can understand?

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:18

@TheKeatingFive

the gender identity case report in twins concluded that of 23 monozygotic female and male twins, nine (39.1%) were concordant for GID; in contrast, none of the 21 same‐sex dizygotic female and male twins were concordant for GID, a statistically significant difference (P = 0.005), suggesting a role for genetic factors in the development of GID.

You're going to have to explain that in plain English

monozygotic - identical GID - gender identity disorder dizygotic - non-identical
TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 15:17

I said that gender identity likely reflects genetic and biological, environmental, and cultural factors

And I asked what those were and how they interlinked?

If you understand as well as you're making out, that doesn't strike me as a difficult question.

Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:15

@TheKeatingFive

maybe actually look into it before you badly attempt to twist it around?

We're all waiting for an actual definition from you?

Not links, a definition

A definition of what? I said that gender identity likely reflects genetic and biological, environmental, and cultural factors and provided links with case studies that provide the reasoning as to why this conclusion has been drawn, but you do not want to see it.
Lamerexo · 30/03/2022 15:14

@TheKeatingFive

All I did was define gender identity

No you didn't.

You posted a few words that may or may not be a starting point.

We've asked you to specify what the cultural, biological and environmental factors are and how they interplay to determine gender identity.

If they're in the links, please alert us to that answer yourself.

'Here's a few links in lieu of explaining my position' doesn't not make for convincing argument.

You ask what specifically the biological / environmental etc. factors are, but when presented with links to explain it you suddenly are uninterested?

We've asked you to specify what the cultural, biological and environmental factors are and how they interplay to determine gender identity.
It is impossible to fit all of the cases, studies etc. into one Mumsnet reply. I have provided links as you asked for specification, which are already shortened down to the cases and their studies, although you clearly have no actual interest into learning more about this as much as you care about arguing endlessly.

'Here's a few links in lieu of explaining my position' doesn't not make for convincing argument.
The links aid the definition that I provided, it is not 'en lieu' of it as it is an addition which you asked for.

TheKeatingFive · 30/03/2022 15:10

maybe actually look into it before you badly attempt to twist it around?

We're all waiting for an actual definition from you?

Not links, a definition