Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Kier Starmer is spineless?

360 replies

LittleWhingingWoman · 29/03/2022 19:06

I'm a long time Labour supporter.
Not anymore.
Kier Starmer was asked if women have penises.
He couldn't answer.

I've had enough of this gaslighting.
How can I vote for a party that is led by this man?
How, in 2022, can a candidate who hopes to be pm not be able to say what a woman is?

AIBU to think he knows FULL WELL what a woman is but is too much of a coward to say. The men threatening and bullying Rosie Duffield certainly know what a woman is.

And I know a penis when I see one.

mobile.twitter.com/keir_starmer

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 31/03/2022 12:31

That's sounds entirely plausible.

The more you look into it, it's an absolute stitch up.

Swayingpalmtrees · 31/03/2022 12:31

No man has ever suffered from this new movement, so why should they care? They made a few tweaks to protect themselves and shrugged their shoulders and swallowed the narrative.

Many men do care passionately about this subject, and understand it well, sadly they are not the ones making the laws or the big decisions. Which is why it is so so infuriating to have Keir Starmer failing us so spectacularly. And he is not the only one. No major party is showing any leadership on our human rights/protection/right to life.

This will be a key battle ground for the elections next year, lets hope they wake up and see what is at stake.

SpinningTheSeedsOfLove · 31/03/2022 12:29

Isn't there a religious provision as well about women not identifying into being bishops or something?

TheKeatingFive · 31/03/2022 12:24

There is not a fucking chance any man would put up with any of this, so why are we?

What I didn't realise, before reading it on here, is that there is specific provision in the GRA for estates entailed in the male line. They are exempted from the act in that females can't self identify as male to usurp their brothers in the line of succession.

So men have already protected themselves from the one small way in which they could be disadvantaged by this.

Given that, it's absolutely disgusting that women are being asked to hand over their own rights and #bekind.

MarshaBradyo · 31/03/2022 12:16

@Swayingpalmtrees

I think we have allowed this to continue and balloon into something dangerous, and it is time we simply said no. It all stops now.

You can't use our toilets, changing rooms and spaces. No we will not allow you to erode at our identity with revolting labels such as chest feeders or cervix havers. You will not strip out our dignity, take over our sports and brainwash our children.

There is no easy way out - we need to be clear and concise. We are taking back our rights, we are taking back our voices and you do not get to 'shape' who and what we are. There is not a fucking chance any man would put up with any of this, so why are we?

We need to shout a lot louder. Otherwise we will be railroaded by the #bekind brigade and silenced.

Absolutely and agree re JKR who has led the way on this and received huge personal backlash.

We need more clarity still. Labour hedging bets to a large degree with a mash up. Blair is right they need to get it together with clarity.

It would need to be in electoral promises too, eg around future policy and what will not be introduced. Not sure if it would be enough though as they’ve gone in so strongly on original position.

TheKeatingFive · 31/03/2022 12:14

We owe so much to women like JK Rowling and others. She will go down in history now for more than her amazing books and films and imagination.

Abso-fucking-lutely

Alexandra2001 · 31/03/2022 12:10

@TheKeatingFive

I think we have to be stronger as society. No it is not okay for you to put thousands, perhaps millions of women and girls at risk because you want full access. End of.

Exactly. They need to be told no.

We can't just pretend it's possible to change sex or make out that it doesn't matter. There is ample evidence already of the problems this causes (also, facts of biology).

If they don't want to be in men's sex defined spaces, they need to campaign for their own. I'd be supportive of that - not making women's sex defined spaces less safe for women.

Labour via Racheal Reeves have said today exactly that.

i.e Biology matters, women's spaces have to stay as women only spaces and its not ok to ask everyone going for a scan if they are pregnant.

'bout bloody time too

Swayingpalmtrees · 31/03/2022 12:09

We owe so much to women like JK Rowling and others. She will go down in history now for more than her amazing books and films and imagination.

Swayingpalmtrees · 31/03/2022 12:07

I think we have allowed this to continue and balloon into something dangerous, and it is time we simply said no. It all stops now.

You can't use our toilets, changing rooms and spaces. No we will not allow you to erode at our identity with revolting labels such as chest feeders or cervix havers. You will not strip out our dignity, take over our sports and brainwash our children.

There is no easy way out - we need to be clear and concise. We are taking back our rights, we are taking back our voices and you do not get to 'shape' who and what we are. There is not a fucking chance any man would put up with any of this, so why are we?

We need to shout a lot louder. Otherwise we will be railroaded by the #bekind brigade and silenced.

TheKeatingFive · 31/03/2022 12:05

And now, weirdly, are trying to find a biological proof for gender identity which, if ever found, must be held up as gospel while the far more overwhelming proof of sex is made out to be nothing significant.

I think (hope) that sensible people will ultimately see this for the utter nonsense that it is. Any arguments I've ever seen on this are more flimsy than a pack of cards.

So I am very cautiously optimistic that when these arguments are scrutinised properly, as they're starting to be, then the tide will slowly turn.

God bless those who have withstood the appalling bullying and threats to speak the truth thus far.

TheKeatingFive · 31/03/2022 11:59

I think we have to be stronger as society. No it is not okay for you to put thousands, perhaps millions of women and girls at risk because you want full access. End of.

Exactly. They need to be told no.

We can't just pretend it's possible to change sex or make out that it doesn't matter. There is ample evidence already of the problems this causes (also, facts of biology).

If they don't want to be in men's sex defined spaces, they need to campaign for their own. I'd be supportive of that - not making women's sex defined spaces less safe for women.

DrSbaitso · 31/03/2022 11:56

Someone up thread nailed it when they said the issue is conflation of sex and gender.

Exactly what JKR has been saying from the off.

And exactly why TRAs spend so much time being offensive, misleading and exploitative of people with DSDs. To try to "prove" that sex isn't a thing. While at the same time claiming that gender identity is, more so than something with hard, physical, scientific fact about it. And now, weirdly, are trying to find a biological proof for gender identity which, if ever found, must be held up as gospel while the far more overwhelming proof of sex is made out to be nothing significant.

And that's why a third, open space for people who for whatever reason do not wish to use the correct single sex one, is never enough. Sex must be absorbed, Borg like, into the concept of gender identity.

Swayingpalmtrees · 31/03/2022 11:52

It makes sense to me thekeating but transwomen are unlikely to agree with that division and will insist on being treated like a 'real' woman even if that puts children and women at risk in a huge way.
But they are going to have to compromise with unisex I am afraid.

I think we have to be stronger as society. No it is not okay for you to put thousands, perhaps millions of women and girls at risk because you want full access. End of. It is the pussy footing around that is creating uncertainty. Safety comes first it should not even have got to this.

SleeplessInEngland · 31/03/2022 11:41

"He is a disgusting man and should not be in any position of power."

But enough about boris.

TheKeatingFive · 31/03/2022 11:37

Someone up thread nailed it when they said the issue is conflation of sex and gender.

The idea of having an innate (rather than socially constructed) gender identity is nonsense to me. But there's nothing inherently problematic about it for society so long as we're clear where it's important to classify according to sex rather than gender.

So spaces, sports, quotas - these remain sex classified. A transgender person has no more rights to these than anyone else of the opposite sex.

Pronouns, clothing, lifestyle, etc can be the sphere where gender identity has a prominent role to play.

scorpiogirly · 31/03/2022 11:29

He is a disgusting man and should not be in any position of power.

Rainbowshit · 31/03/2022 11:28

These questions to Labour MPs are so revealing. Being unable to answer shows they will put ideology before reality. That's not what I want in a politician, I want laws to be made based on material reality, not what they would like reality to be.

Rainbowshit · 31/03/2022 11:27

@Crcohetmonster

I’m confused. If no one can define woman, how do we know transwomen are women?
Well quite. Labour seem unable to define what a woman is but they seem absolutely certain that a transwoman is a woman.

This whole ideology is just full of such inconsistencies.

SleeplessInEngland · 31/03/2022 11:23

Labour definitely need a firm line on this, whatever it is. I doubt Starmer could give less of shit about the issue, but it's going to be a constant gotcha question for him now.

Alcoh · 31/03/2022 11:21

Emily Bridges competing against our national treasure Dame Laura Kenny was obviously too much to handle. A few more like that will do the trick.

DrSbaitso · 31/03/2022 11:17

I think most people aren't well informed on the issue. They see it's red hot and, understandably, try to stay away from it. We probably needed some absolute absurdities to gain traction so people could see exactly what the end game of this is, and that it's a lot more serious than just respecting preferred pronouns.

Swayingpalmtrees · 31/03/2022 11:15

The subject needs sensitivity and integrity, seemingly beyond the current LP at the moment.

spacehardware · 31/03/2022 11:01

Seriously can you imagine Tony Blair making such a bollocks of things as the current shower

Swayingpalmtrees · 31/03/2022 10:59

Tony Blair has waded in now telling the LP that they need to get clarity on this issue immediately.

Rachel Reeves on R4 at 8am this morning when asked if she knew what a woman was, she said 'most women share biological similarities. Some 'people' are born in the wrong bodies and may not have the same biological similarities' she did to her credit offer to detail those similarities should any of us not know that women have breasts and vaginas et al.
Michelle declined to obtain a list but there does appear to be a softening, a change in tone after the Keir car crash. I think we are starting to see a rowing back - a slight detection and chink of light.

It is hard to believe in 2022 we are even having this conversation. Even in repressed states like Saudi, they are allowed to be called women and have private areas to use the loo and change. It is quite unreal that we are here at all.

NotBadConsidering · 31/03/2022 10:30

@nolongersurprised

I’m going to add as well that’s it’s fucking disgusting to use “well, CAH” as an explanation for healthy people deciding they want to “be” the opposite sex.

Classic, salt-wasting CAH is life threatening before it’s identified. There will be life-long medication and the risk of cardiovascular collapse at times of stress. Hormone levels will normalise with treatment but the genital changes are permanent.

For a healthy trans individual, without this disorder, to cherry pick some aspects of it, wildly speculate and overreach and say, “yeah, me too” is abhorrent

Agree, it’s disgusting.

There have also been studies on trans people looking for variations in sexual development which have unearthed exactly nothing.

The whole argument that “trans is biological” is based on the possibility that there is a biological marker waiting to be discovered that will settle this once and for all. It’s pie in the sky stuff.

But let’s for one second imagine it to be true. I for one would welcome it! Let’s get a blood test sorted. Then let’s get all the people who say “I am trans/a woman/non binary because I say I am” and get them all to take the test. Will be fascinating to see the results.

I vote we test all the middle aged male AGPs first, see where that gets us Hmm. Let’s see what Stonewall’s trans umbrella looks like once we have a confirmatory test to see who falls under it. Will the cross dressers pass the test? How exciting to find out! Let’s watch the whole movement destroy itself while it argues who is “true trans” (like they do already anyway but with something to actually go on).

Let’s get a test in place for children to determine whose bodies should be rendered sterile and asexual by puberty blockers and cross sex hormones, rather than just their expressed feelings at the age of 12 or their adherence to diagnostic criteria that demand a belief in sex stereotypes to get a diagnosis.

Let’s study if the marker is positive and then negative years later in the thousands of detransitioners who regret their decisions and the damage done to their bodies.

Let’s see if the marker is “half” positive in people who feel “non-binary”.

We will still continue to keep spaces segregated by sex, not “newly discovered invisible marker of transness” of course, because a marker in blood that explains an “identity” doesn’t remove the male body, effects of testosterone, male socialisation, and male rates of offending.

But it would be fascinating to watch the fall out 👀 🍿

However, given that this is science fiction, let’s not waste energy on it. Let’s not make any changes to society until such marker is discovered, then we can have a debate about it. Let’s pay attention to the perfectly good markers we have now that determines our sex, which are evident to everyone. Let’s absolutely not start making changes to society on the basis that some people think vaguely that transgender might be biological that might become evident in the future so ergo we should mess everything up now in anticipation of that, because that’s just nuts.

When you’ve got something to actually go on, then we can talk Hmm.