Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Kier Starmer is spineless?

360 replies

LittleWhingingWoman · 29/03/2022 19:06

I'm a long time Labour supporter.
Not anymore.
Kier Starmer was asked if women have penises.
He couldn't answer.

I've had enough of this gaslighting.
How can I vote for a party that is led by this man?
How, in 2022, can a candidate who hopes to be pm not be able to say what a woman is?

AIBU to think he knows FULL WELL what a woman is but is too much of a coward to say. The men threatening and bullying Rosie Duffield certainly know what a woman is.

And I know a penis when I see one.

mobile.twitter.com/keir_starmer

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 30/03/2022 07:23

but honestly the obsession about this one narrow issue on here is a bit strange?

I used to agree with you.

Rinatinabina · 30/03/2022 07:17

I used to be on the other side of this because I didn’t understand how some men us these fudges to exploit and attack women or breach their boundaries. If I’m honest I kinda assumed that being trans was so hard no-one would do it just for kicks and assume the fetishists wouldn’t risk getting a kicking by doing things like walking around butt naked in a womans changing room. I was absolutely wrong. So wrong.

The big thing that changed for me is that you don’t need dysphoria to be classed as trans, you can be a transvestite, a drag queen etc, bloke with a fetish basically any man in non gender conforming clothes can now be classed as a woman. It got really silly when men in mens clothes claimed to be women and lesbians. I think it exposed the absurdity to me

The demanding access to lesbian sex lives really started tipping me over the edge (the infamous cotton ceiling and calling homosexuals genital fetishists - obviously specifically lesbians).

Then the fact that people with actual convictions for sex offences were being put in the womens estate in prisons. I mean if that isn’t a clear fuck you to women I don’t know what is. His feelings are more important that your increased likelihood to be sexually assaulted..

Thats why its not a single issue as some people are claiming, it touches on all those times and places that women need to be in single sex places for their safety, dignity and privacy. Once those rights are gone they will be impossible to get back.

Clearly this stuff is happening under a tory government so it’s not that they are in the clear but they are not proposing to go full pelt self ID. Which will completely and utterly destroy womens rights to single sex services/spaces. There is still space under the tories to push back whereas the impression i get is voting for labour will guarantee these changes.

MsDataPotata · 30/03/2022 07:16

I'm in a labour heartland & women here are realising this is the tip of a very large iceberg of pushback against women's rights. We're not even anywhere near equality yet (the subject of covid vaccines affecting periods still not being officially acknowledged & investigated due to inequalities in medicine to name one of many very recent issues). How can anyone who doesn't understand that our biology is the root of our oppression properly represent our interests? It's a massive issue with far reaching repercussions. I'm a menopausal single mother. Those 2 issues are shaping & dictating my life choices & chances. They're also issues that affect a huge number of women but not a single transwoman. If men are allowed to throw feminine presenting men out of 'manhood' it'll only further entrench & reinforce the patriarchy. Woman have had to absorb stereotypical male activities into their lives (I work full time time, I'm financially independent) so why shouldn't we expect the same from men? It shouldn't be a case of whomever rocks the cradle is a woman. You'll never convince me this isn't just a way for men to slope out of their fair share of unpaid labour.

pilates · 30/03/2022 07:06

YANBU

spacehardware · 30/03/2022 07:00

"This is an absolute non-issue and mumsnet sadly is getting a reputation for being a haven for hysterical transphobes"

It's a non-issue for women to be told they don't exist? For our protections under the equality act to be eroded?

My vote is mine snd I'm not going to cast it to the order of someone who calls women hysterical or transphobes for thinking female people are real. Fuck off tbh

JustAnotherPoster00 · 30/03/2022 07:00

Abstention is a vote for the incumbent government and for the most part no one is going to give much of a fuck what you right on your spoilt ballots, so a master class in futility all round

NashvilleQueen · 30/03/2022 06:59

Labour have made a total mess of this and I'm appalled at how we have ended up in this place.

That said there's not a chance in hell I would vote Tory and the fact that Johnson has this issue right doesn't excuse every other wrong he has been responsible for.

Instantnoodles · 30/03/2022 06:55

I'm a lifelong Labour voter and they lost me. Why would I vote for a party that won't protect women's rights? It's too fundamental an issue. I won't vote Tory so am politically homeless.

nolongersurprised · 30/03/2022 06:51

but honestly the obsession about this one narrow issue on here is a bit strange?

I used to think this but now I see the trans rights’ activists as a subset of men’s rights’ activism.

Women and girls have different needs to men and boys. There are sex specific biological differences and, because nearly all violent offenders are male, women and girls need separate toilets, crisis centres and prisons. A male puberty confers athletic advantages so, to celebrate and encourage women and girls in sport, they (we) have a separate category.

As soon as “woman” also includes “men” then there are no female only categories anymore, everything is mixed-sex.

tobee · 30/03/2022 06:12

@Baddit

(And yes I know the thread is about Starmer and that my views won't be well received on here but honestly the obsession about this one narrow issue on here is a bit strange?)
You know this is actually happening? And yet you minimise it.
tobee · 30/03/2022 06:08

@Baddit

This is an absolute non-issue and mumsnet sadly is getting a reputation for being a haven for hysterical transphobes.

This is being used by the conservatives as smokescreen to mask their shameful and disastrous leadership of this country:

brexit was a sham that has flatlined our trade and diminished us on the world stage
millions of children are going hungry in this country due to cruel policies
the prime minister is a security risk who ignores MI6 advice
he also broke the law and partied while people died
double the NHS entire annual budget was chucked away on useless covid decision making

This culture war on woke is literally the only thing the conservatives have to take your attention away from their mess in every area of governance.

But not this.
tobee · 30/03/2022 06:08

@LittleWhingingWoman

It's about you, if you are raped by a man, who now says he is a woman, being told that no rape happened and the NHS, The police... saying no rape happened.

No rape happened because no men were here. I'm sorry I can't assist you, our records show that no man was here in the ward last night, you must be mistaken, you are certainly wrong. That's not pain you are feeling because no rape happened. The blood is your period surely?

No rape could have happened because no men are here.


This is happening under a Tory government. Women are not under an illusion that if they vote Tory it won't happen. We are politically homeless UNLESS we decide we will only work cross party with people who are still adults.

Yes yes this!
Baddit · 30/03/2022 05:43

(And yes I know the thread is about Starmer and that my views won't be well received on here but honestly the obsession about this one narrow issue on here is a bit strange?)

Baddit · 30/03/2022 05:40

This is an absolute non-issue and mumsnet sadly is getting a reputation for being a haven for hysterical transphobes.

This is being used by the conservatives as smokescreen to mask their shameful and disastrous leadership of this country:

brexit was a sham that has flatlined our trade and diminished us on the world stage
millions of children are going hungry in this country due to cruel policies
the prime minister is a security risk who ignores MI6 advice
he also broke the law and partied while people died
double the NHS entire annual budget was chucked away on useless covid decision making

This culture war on woke is literally the only thing the conservatives have to take your attention away from their mess in every area of governance.

LittleWhingingWoman · 30/03/2022 05:25

It's about you, if you are raped by a man, who now says he is a woman, being told that no rape happened and the NHS, The police... saying no rape happened.

No rape happened because no men were here. I'm sorry I can't assist you, our records show that no man was here in the ward last night, you must be mistaken, you are certainly wrong. That's not pain you are feeling because no rape happened. The blood is your period surely?

No rape could have happened because no men are here.


This is happening under a Tory government. Women are not under an illusion that if they vote Tory it won't happen. We are politically homeless UNLESS we decide we will only work cross party with people who are still adults.

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 30/03/2022 05:25

He lacks the feeling of a leader.

LittleWhingingWoman · 30/03/2022 05:17

It's also not about Starmer being an "ass"

It's about a potential Leader of this country fucking with reality.

It's about women being able to organise as a political class.

It's about your reality as a woman.

OP posts:
LittleWhingingWoman · 30/03/2022 05:12

@beatrixpotterspencil

On a serious note, I think Starmer is being a serious ass about this, but to use it as an excuse to keep voting for this corrupt, disgusting government is a tad weak imo.

I have this one, single issue with Starmer.
Yet the sheer ignorance, lying, corruption, law breaking, boundary changing, friend-funding horrors of the current conservatives leaves me utterly cold.
At least consider how many right wing rags have poked this story to the front today, it sure takes one's mind off the covid parties, eh?
You honestly believe these reporters or the tories care one solitary fuck about women's rights or safety?
This is election tactics, plain and simple.

I could slap Starmer, and I strongly disagree with his stance on this issue, but if people can overlook what the tories have done to this country because of it, god help us.

I also heard that the tories are planning to turn away voters without photo ID. Interesting. How people continuously overlook their corruption astounds me.
With the boundary changes and photo ID issue you wont have to worry about an opposition party, we won't really be left with much of a democracy anyway.

I suppose, perhaps, there are things that I find much more terrifying that Starmer being an ass.

No one is talking about voting Tory. It's not an either/or. It's that if women withdraw or spoil their vote they are not voting Labour. Which means Labour gets less votes. Which means Labour won't get in.

The women who aren't voting Labour aren't suddenly going to become Tory voters. They will exclude from the vote, set up a private Island somewhere and disappear. Like the Ent wives did.

OP posts:
beatrixpotterspencil · 30/03/2022 04:39

And before i go, finally Grin

dont forget the plan to scrap the human right's act. Anything they (Patel) can do to 'manage' refugees which has bloody dreadful consequences for us all in the UK. We surely felt this after the policing bill. I am far more worried about the stuff that isn't on the rag front pages.

worth a thought, sadly.

beatrixpotterspencil · 30/03/2022 03:45

On a serious note, I think Starmer is being a serious ass about this, but to use it as an excuse to keep voting for this corrupt, disgusting government is a tad weak imo.

I have this one, single issue with Starmer.
Yet the sheer ignorance, lying, corruption, law breaking, boundary changing, friend-funding horrors of the current conservatives leaves me utterly cold.
At least consider how many right wing rags have poked this story to the front today, it sure takes one's mind off the covid parties, eh?
You honestly believe these reporters or the tories care one solitary fuck about women's rights or safety?
This is election tactics, plain and simple.

I could slap Starmer, and I strongly disagree with his stance on this issue, but if people can overlook what the tories have done to this country because of it, god help us.

I also heard that the tories are planning to turn away voters without photo ID. Interesting. How people continuously overlook their corruption astounds me.
With the boundary changes and photo ID issue you wont have to worry about an opposition party, we won't really be left with much of a democracy anyway.

I suppose, perhaps, there are things that I find much more terrifying that Starmer being an ass.

beatrixpotterspencil · 30/03/2022 03:16

agree he's crap though Grin

beatrixpotterspencil · 30/03/2022 03:15

we must keep voting tory because they are champions of equality, progressive values and feminism, lol.

Papayamya · 30/03/2022 02:18

@SuitcaseOfWhine

I was expecting a thread on this today due to the Partygate fines being in the news today 🤔
Start one on the fines then, not that most people are arsed anymore. As for starmer, fucking ridiculous.
LittleWhingingWoman · 30/03/2022 02:09

@DdraigGoch

Angela Rayner today stated that it is degrading to people going through the process of changing their identities to have discussions about genitals.

We don't need to have a discussion. The word "no" is a complete sentence.

"Should males be in women's prisons?"
"No."
"Should males be permitted to attend women's rape crisis group therapy?"
"No."
"Should males be given carte blanche to cheat in sport?"
"No."

You get the idea.

Thanks for this post. Also - without having these conversations how can we ensure safeguarding around everything you just mentioned.
OP posts:
jkrfan · 30/03/2022 01:56

@DontBlameMe79

The trans movement = the most ambitious and successful gaslighting operation in history. Beggars belief where we are. I couldn’t vote for Labour now despite being inclined that way.
Read George Orwell's '1984 'to further understand some of the techniques being used on us: “The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.”

― George Orwell, 1984

Swipe left for the next trending thread