Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you are a beef / sheep / chicken farmer, are you noticing a fall in demand?

229 replies

anotherotherone · 29/03/2022 18:31

I was just travelling back down to London by train and there seem to be a lot less sheep and cows in the fields than normal. Am I imagining things?

There are so many meat / dairy alternatives in the shops now. AIBU to think (well, hope) that as people are eating less meat these days and this trend looks set to continue,
are farmers reacting by reducing their stocks?

OP posts:
likemindedarseholes · 29/03/2022 23:38

@Scrowy can't wait to see the response to your post. This utopia which veggies suggest when the meat industry is gone is just fantasy. What are you going to eat in winter as a vegan? Cabbages? The whole eat local, slow food movement rarely lends itself to plant based cuisine, despite being arguably better for the environment. Sick of being lectured by avocado, quinoa, corn tortilla, almond milk drinking vegans about how detrimental my diet of local organic meat twice weekly is to the planet.

Scrowy · 29/03/2022 23:20

What do you think the animals eat?! Do you know how much land is farmed for animal feed?

Livestock takes up nearly 80% of global agricultural land, yet produces less than 20% of the world’s supply of calories.

It always makes me smile when people try and use these sort of facts as some kind of gotcha.

I thought it was well recognised now that these stats have been manipulated/misrepresented.

None of my land is suitable for growing arable crops on any kind of scale. Its full of steep bits, rocky outcrops, walls, hedges and it 1300ft above sea level. There is limestone bedrock not far below the surface.

It grows grass quite well and we graze sheep outside on it 12 months of the year and cows outside on it 5 months of the year and 7 months inside from silage we made from it.

If it didn't have sheep and cows on it it would just be a scrubby, brackeny overgrown wilderness. Foxes and deer would probably like it. Not much else would.

My cows also eat the straw and pulp by-products of any arable crops that are leftover or rejected for crops for human consumption. Humans take the premium grade, cows get the rest.

So out of that 80% in 20% out calculation you do have to remember an awful lot of that is from pastureland that couldn't be used for anything else and crops that have been rejected for direct human consumption.

anotherotherone · 29/03/2022 23:10

Vegetarian. Must be hysterical.

I think I’ve used caps once.

But never mind. I’m hardly going to be trying to convert meat farmers to vegetarianism Grin.

To be honest, I’ve been vegetarian since I was 12. Never tried to ‘convert’ anyone. Even my husband or kids. Nor do I claim to know the ‘farming lingo’ and the specific ins and outs of meat farming. It’s probably just as well, in my case, as I’d end up vegan. But, as I said, I’ve been vegetarian a long time, so meat substitutes such as Quorn have never been part of my diet or the way I cook. However, it’s obvious to me that the variety of meat / dairy substitute products has proliferated in the last couple of years and I was wondering about any impact of this in terms of farmers scaling down herds, etc. And yes, I’d personally be happy if that were the case - obviously (what with being non meat-eating and all). It’s not “hysterical” to be appalled by the scale of animal slaughter in the UK and globally.

OP posts:
worcestersauce29 · 29/03/2022 23:03

@Fizbosshoes

Most of the milk alternatives are significantly more expensive than dairy
and of course they shouldn't even be called milk! As far as I can tell they are a liquid produced from soaking and/or blitzing grains, nuts etc. ?
Missreginafalange · 29/03/2022 23:01

@anotherotherone

It is true though that the vast majority of people live in urban environments in the U.K. and they don’t have time to go pootling off to independent butchers when there’s generally nowhere to park and it smells so bad and it’s a hassle.

In any coffee shop now, there are all sorts of milk alternatives and it’s as common to hear someone ordering soy or oat or almond as a dairy milk cappuccino or whatever. I’m not vegan, but even I have switched to oat milk in my lattes because it just tastes better.

Not true where I live, it's a 50 min commute into London to give a rough location idea.

Lots of large supermarkets and lots of butchers, I go to a local butcher for my meat and still do my big shop in Tesco.

ClaudineClare · 29/03/2022 22:57

@Patented

Probably not in the fields but millions of chickens etc. hidden away in factory farms!
I think all chickens are being kept inside at the moment, even free range ones, because of bird flu.
Fizbosshoes · 29/03/2022 22:56

Most of the milk alternatives are significantly more expensive than dairy

SofiaSoFar · 29/03/2022 22:56

@anotherotherone

People don’t think “look at the lovely animals...” They’re only there to be slaughtered. Nothing “oooh or aaah” about it.
If god didn't want us to eat animals, he wouldn't have made them taste so good.
GoodJanetBadJanet · 29/03/2022 22:53

Okay, have I missed a few posts as can't see where OP is being hysterical?!

RewildingAmbridge · 29/03/2022 22:52

Not in our house, we still eat meat higher where and no processed crappy nuggets etc, plenty of fish, have milk delivered by a milkman and I do not live rurally. Quorn makes me projectile vomit and we've discovered has the same impact on DS after he was given it by a well meaning vegetarian friend , who despite me asking said there was definitely no Quorn (we both threw up at her house and DS shat himself - he's 3). We eat veggie a couple of dinners a week with actual vegetables, pulses etc as we always have, because that's what a balanced diet is and often vegetarian meals are quick to prepare.

RampantIvy · 29/03/2022 22:49

@MythicalBiologicalFennel

OP I would venture that most people were already aware that meat comes from dead animals before you started this thread. I think you need to understand that most omnivores do not relate to your feelings towards butchers shops, dairy etc. Sneering, overuse of uppercase and clear ignorance of the British food industry are unlikely to draw people towards your cause.
Not does the use of hysterical language. We eat very little meat, especially when vegetarian DD is home. I respect people's right to a food lifestyle choice as long as they respect mine.
DdraigGoch · 29/03/2022 22:44

The snag with sheep (well, one of the snags with sheep) is that they have to be sheared, and wool is currently worth bugger all. So could all the keen meat-eaters please start buying woollen clothing?

Lots of other uses for wool too. Dags are great at keeping weeds down in your veg patch.

DdraigGoch · 29/03/2022 22:41

@anotherotherone

Interesting stats DdraigGoch, thanks. I wonder how much of the 4 MILLION TONNES of dead animals go to waste?
The total food waste by supermarkets and their suppliers is 200,000 tonnes per year (remember that this total covers all food groups, not just meat). I've been unable to find out exactly what products get wasted, though I'm sure that milk and bread are near the top. I'm sure that someone who works in a supermarket will tell us what they see being yellow-stickered and thrown.

In my household it's only milk that I struggle to ensure that it doesn't go off before it's used, but I'm getting better organised. Nothing else goes off in my house, the contents of the kitchen bucket are purely peelings and apple cores.

Patented · 29/03/2022 22:27

Probably not in the fields but millions of chickens etc. hidden away in factory farms!

MythicalBiologicalFennel · 29/03/2022 22:24

OP I would venture that most people were already aware that meat comes from dead animals before you started this thread. I think you need to understand that most omnivores do not relate to your feelings towards butchers shops, dairy etc. Sneering, overuse of uppercase and clear ignorance of the British food industry are unlikely to draw people towards your cause.

Luredbyapomegranate · 29/03/2022 22:19

[quote Fixyourself]@Luredbyapomegranate
Are you 40+?

Wouldn’t 1% growth a year be a decline seeing is the population growth each year is higher than that?

Do you know the percentage of pus allowed in milk? It’s even higher in organic milk because the cows mastitis goes untreated.

Milk (is that how boomers are signing off now?!)[/quote]
No - a 1% growth in meat consumption is a growth. People need a certain income level to eat meat, so it will not relate to population growth in some areas.

These are just facts. Neither of our personal opinions about animal products are relevant.

You chippy doesn’t serve a purpose any more than you making up facts does.

Catcrazy83 · 29/03/2022 22:15

I think the reduction in meat consumption is due to money. Many people having meat free days just because of cost of living.
My local supermarket reduced fridge is full of the fake meat stuff, real meat and fish snapped up instantly if it makes it to a price cut.

anotherotherone · 29/03/2022 22:11

People don’t think “look at the lovely animals...” They’re only there to be slaughtered. Nothing “oooh or aaah” about it.

OP posts:
5zeds · 29/03/2022 22:11

I think your vegetarianism is just colouring your perception. Tons of animals in the field and meat on plates round here.

Allusernamesalreadyused · 29/03/2022 22:04

Well look at the end of the day, if people go vegetarian and in particular vegan then what's the incentive to keep cows, sheep, pigs etc so essentially they will become extinct. Or is it that the farmers will keep the animals in fields so the airy fairy brigade can look out train windows or whilst on holidays 'in the country', look out windows and oooh and aaaah at the lovely animals. 'ohhh Look Johnny at the moo moos except there won't be any more freakin moo moos.
Jesus wept. Spare me the veggie nonsense

EdithStourton · 29/03/2022 22:01

Where I live, we lost the small dairy farms 30-40 years ago. Other than that, livestock numbers haven't changed all that much. Even the farmer who gave up sheep has started again.

Livestock and arable farming should be intertwined. Some of the local sheep have just been moved off the stubble turnips, and the field has now been drilled for cereals. It's a regular rotation on that particular farm.

The soil gets a break from cereals, which kills off various cereal-killing nasties (reducing the need to spray), and the sheep shit all over it, providing nice manure and helping to restructure the soil (reducing the need for artificial fertiliser, and improving soil quality).

If the current nightmarish price of artificial fertiliser lasts, I can see a lot more farmers going down this route in future.

The snag with sheep (well, one of the snags with sheep) is that they have to be sheared, and wool is currently worth bugger all. So could all the keen meat-eaters please start buying woollen clothing?

elbea · 29/03/2022 21:55

@Fixyourself what are you talking about? Organic cows are allowed antibiotics if they are ill. Have you ever even been in a milking parlour - cows with mastitis have their milk disposed.

Fixyourself · 29/03/2022 21:55

[quote elbea]@anotherotherone ignorant then. Get rid of all the sheep and you’ll find it much more difficult to get your oat milk and muffins. The carbon cycle is pretty basic if nothing else.

I’ll go back to managing thousands of acres of farmland though to keep you in oat milk though.[/quote]
What do you think the animals eat?! Do you know how much land is farmed for animal feed?

Livestock takes up nearly 80% of global agricultural land, yet produces less than 20% of the world’s supply of calories.

anotherotherone · 29/03/2022 21:53

Interesting stats DdraigGoch, thanks. I wonder how much of the 4 MILLION TONNES of dead animals go to waste?

OP posts:
Fixyourself · 29/03/2022 21:52

@Luredbyapomegranate
Are you 40+?

Wouldn’t 1% growth a year be a decline seeing is the population growth each year is higher than that?

Do you know the percentage of pus allowed in milk? It’s even higher in organic milk because the cows mastitis goes untreated.

Milk (is that how boomers are signing off now?!)