Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chiropractor taking me for a ride...

92 replies

Lalaland01 · 29/03/2022 17:51

I've never been to one so I don't know what to expect. I've been having a relatively mild but annoying pain on my right side of my lower back. I decided to go see a chiropractor (good reviews on Google) to sort it out before it gets worse.

First appointment he said my pelvis was a bit "lopsided", he stretched my legs and said one was longer than the other one. He made me lie facing down on this table, he raised the table a bit and then dropped it down. He did this twice and said that had fixed it (?). He then did like 5 min with this ultrasound. That was it.

Went again yesterday and he just placed two wooden blocks behind my pelvis (this time me facing up), pulled my arms up and then again the ultrasound bit for 5 min but he did it on the other side of where my pain is (!). The appointment lasted 15 min tops.

Has anyone else been to the chiropractor??? Is this normal? I feel like he is taking me for a ride but maybe this is normal?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blueroses99 · 04/04/2022 18:23

@sashh why do I have to keep going back? I have a chronic condition. Nothing is going to make the pain go away completely with no intervention whatsoever. I have had to keep going to physio whenever i couldn’t cope with the pain for over 20 years. Why didn’t I get a placebo effect from physio?

In terms of wasting money, I now pay to the chiropractor what I used to pay for deep tissue massage in between physio stints (NHS/private) so I am no worse off financially but spend far less time on treatments.

AnastasiaRomanov · 01/04/2022 18:49

Well that wasn’t my experience. If you’re crippled you can’t do any exercises at all!! I couldn’t. I wonder how many people who are sceptical about chiropractors have been completely immobilised or in constant pain?

BatshitCrazyWoman · 01/04/2022 18:46

@gannett

And honestly the thing you need is a set of simple (but probably tedious) exercises that you can do yourself at home. A physio will tell you what to do, check you're getting on with them and leave you to it. It's about giving you the tools to heal yourself rather than having to keep going back for expensive appointments.
Exactly this. If you are travelling distance to Catford, I can recommend a brilliant physio.
AnastasiaRomanov · 01/04/2022 17:49

My back completely packed in last October. I could hardly stand and had to walk with a stick. I asked my doctor for a referral to a physio. I got a telephone appointment three months later nd an appointment to see someone two weeks after that. If I hadn’t paid for a private chiropractor I would have been housebound and in pain all that time. Given how useless the physio was when I saw him, I don’t have much faith he would have helped anyway.

chisanunian · 01/04/2022 16:46

See an osteopath.

Madre123 · 01/04/2022 16:44

Also paid a crazy amount of money for a few minutes at each appointment prior...soon put a stop to it...taking the mick

Duchess379 · 01/04/2022 16:40

[quote WiddlinDiddlin]@Duchess379 Yeah, I did say that...

I would expect any of them to have a decent understanding of where all the nerves are and how to attempt releasing trapped nerves - if you have a bad one, releasing it can feel like total magic!

But there's a degree of luck there too, presumably you'd done something unusual for it to happen, so it hasn't reoccurred - I could have mine released and they'd be trapped again within days, because chiros do nothing to address the why, just treat the symptom!

The one I saw took next to no history and didn't know I have a connective tissue disorder, which does mean I trap nerves, subluxate joints etc, pretty frequently.

He was more than happy to untrap things once a fortnight.. and never told me how to avoid them being trapped in the first place. My osteopath has, as has my physio (and they work together, private and NHS actually working together. NHS won't work with chiro's by the way.. which should speak volumes!).[/quote]

I have RA & hypermobility. Didn't know that when I trapped the nerve in my hip. Once I was diagnosed by the Dr, my chiropractor regularly adjusted me & gave me stretches & exercises to do. It's never happened again 👍🏼

Polyanthus2 · 01/04/2022 14:41

The placebo effect can work with doctors' treatments- with anything really.

Why condemn Chiros.

The thing about chiros etc is that they actually have time to give you proper attention rather than the 2 mins you get with a GP. That alone can help someone feel better.

knittingaddict · 01/04/2022 12:22

[quote AnastasiaRomanov]@knittingaddict

Common knowledge on what basis? Have you ever been to one yourself? Or just dismiss what you don’t understand?[/quote]
This might help. It's not totally anti chiropractice, so may be more balanced for you.

www.painscience.com/articles/does-chiropractic-work.php

There are loads more out there.

Lightning020 · 01/04/2022 12:03

Chiropractors are extortionate and have one eye on the mortgage. Physios are good likewise osteopaths.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 01/04/2022 11:39

I've had similar excercises done at a NHS physio but if you don't feel like it's helping then cancel the appt. Personally I'd always see a physiotherapist and preferably a sports one.

LaMereDuChat · 01/04/2022 11:35

Some are rubbish and others are great. Mine was literally the only thing that kept me able to walk during pregnancy - wonky spine plus pregnancy = huge amounts of pain in my SI joint unless regularly attemded to to stop it locking up.

AnastasiaRomanov · 01/04/2022 11:22

@knittingaddict

Common knowledge on what basis? Have you ever been to one yourself? Or just dismiss what you don’t understand?

Allergictoironing · 01/04/2022 09:31

SOME chiropractors are quacks, SOME but not all by any means.

I've heard of Chiropractors who claim to be able to cure all types of illnesses through chiropractic, which is a load of complete bollocks.

But the decent ones are definitely good at sorting some biomechanical issues, and this is recognised by the NHS

AbbieLexie · 01/04/2022 09:26

In the past I saw a physio privately with osteopath/chiropractic & acupuncture qualifications. I will recommend him. Now I have Pilates with a physio and before covid massage every 3 months. Exercises between my sessions.

knittingaddict · 01/04/2022 08:51

@Motherdare

There are some incredibly narrow-minded posters on this thread. I’ve never heard anyone insinuate chiropractors are swindlers and quacks - that’s outrageous. Twice I’ve been under the care of one and both times they sorted out ongoing back issues within a few appointments and improved my quality of life. They were both well-educated and qualified. One of them travels with Team GB to the Olympics.

You may have found a poor one OP, but I think inciting posters to slag off an entire profession based on your experience is very unfair.

Honestly thought it was common knowledge that chiropractors are indeed charlatans and quacks. I'm astonished by your outrage.

As an aside, a surprising (or not so surprising) number if them are monetised purveyors of conspiracy theories and other baseless tripe.

sashh · 01/04/2022 08:13

@Blueroses99

That's exactly how the placebo effect works. The more time taken to 'treat' you the better the effect. Injections of saline work better than pills.

I can’t believe how rude you are being, like I can’t tell the difference between pain and no pain or between being able to move any neck 30 degrees or 60 degrees. If I was so gullible, why didn’t physio have the same effect? Or any of the other treatments that I’ve had for over 30 years? Why it is only chiropractic treatment that makes me feel better if it’s a placebo effect?

I'm not being rude.

This is how the placebo effect works.

If chiropractic works why do you have to keep going back?

I was at uni with a woman who swore only Boots brand anti inflammatory worked for her. They are manufactured in the same factory as other anti-inflammatories but somehow when the pills are put in a box marked 'Boots' gave them a magical property.

If you are happy to spend your money go ahead, but don't trick yourself into thinking you are getting medical treatment.

Blueroses99 · 31/03/2022 13:29

That's exactly how the placebo effect works. The more time taken to 'treat' you the better the effect. Injections of saline work better than pills.

I can’t believe how rude you are being, like I can’t tell the difference between pain and no pain or between being able to move any neck 30 degrees or 60 degrees. If I was so gullible, why didn’t physio have the same effect? Or any of the other treatments that I’ve had for over 30 years? Why it is only chiropractic treatment that makes me feel better if it’s a placebo effect?

Allergictoironing · 31/03/2022 12:41

Almost everybody has one leg shorter than the other. It isn't a problem.

Whether it's a problem or not is a matter of degree, look up LLD on the internet. Mine is just over the 2cm mark, which is recognised as causing the pelvis to compensate, leading to pain in the back, knee, hip and ankle, & tiredness. Almost 30 years of living with this without any treatment, like shoe lifts, has caused permanent damage to my lower back - as diagnosed by my GP and consultant.

So don't tell me it isn't a problem!

JesusSufferingFuck22 · 31/03/2022 11:41

I don't see a chiropractor anymore because I had a recurring csf leak caused by a lumbar puncture. Any spinal manipulation was NOT recommended!
I had gone for years. They sorted out a neck and shoulder thingy that flared up regularly. I was practically immobilised by it. I had deep tissue massage, massage, ultrasound(which I don't think works,) some sort of tens type thing, some suction type thing, western acupuncture and manipulation of joints...not all at the one appointment. Appointments were 30-45 mins. I went every 6-8 weeks as I did a physical job and this kept me moving.

Since then I do stretches (shown to me by chiropractor) plus exercise from physio and from nhs website (eConsult.)
I don't physically feel much different though could maybe benefit from a massage every now and then. It's too expensive nowadays though!

So yes, some chiropractors are really good but I think some of what they do is unnecessary and in my case dangerous. They couldn't tell me if it was ok to get an adjustment after my csf leak had sealed. I went back a couple of times and they modified my treatment. They used a clicky ball thingy. I've not been back for years.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 31/03/2022 11:28

As others have said, very much depends on the individual chiro/osteo/physio.

I DO definitely have one leg shorter than the other, due to a bad accident when I was 20

Almost everybody has one leg shorter than the other. It isn't a problem.

Every single chiropractor is a quack. It is not medicine.

Allergictoironing · 31/03/2022 11:21

As others have said, very much depends on the individual chiro/osteo/physio.

I DO definitely have one leg shorter than the other, due to a bad accident when I was 20 - this has been measured by more than one healthcare professional e.g. doctors, physios, orthotics guys. However due to NHS ignoring any problems for years, I'd adjusted to it so well that many flatly refused to believe me until they measured it for themselves.

Over the years I have seen good Osteopaths and some very bad ones. I had a brilliant Chiro and luckily found another (with some trial and error) when she retired. The good ones have all taken the time to do a very detailed medical history, and have shown me exercises etc to do at home. There are 2 main schools of chiropractic, and I have seen good and bad from both schools.

I've also seen a few physios through the NHS over the years, some of whom have been OK but a few have been dreadful. I think the worst was the one who asked me "well what do you expect at your age?" when I was just tuned 50! My concern at the time was that I'd gone from a keen hill walker (typically 10-15 miles a day) and a professional (well trained) sports massage therapist to someone who was in constant pain in the space of 2-3 years.

I have had acupuncture from two (as well as from a previous GP), and others tell me they don't do that on the NHS as it's woo. Apparently massage isn't part of the physio's remit on the NHS either, despite it being an essential part of the private physios armoury. I've had one who told me my back pain was "all in the mind", despite MRI scans showing the arthritis in my spine, the 2 prolapsed discs and the vertebra out of place.

So to reiterate - very much down to the individual practitioner!

sashh · 31/03/2022 11:18

There are some incredibly narrow-minded posters on this thread. I’ve never heard anyone insinuate chiropractors are swindlers and quacks - that’s outrageous.

No it isn't.

Claiming a dead Dr told you how to move joints to cure deafness - that's outrageous.

Evenstar · 31/03/2022 10:24

I have a wonderful chiropractor, I have an adjustment 3 times a year normally but if I have any bad pain an appointment gets me back on my feet straight away. I have been seeing her for 12 years and she helped me enormously with whiplash after an accident.

My GP’s during that time have approved of me getting treatment and encouraged me to continue. I used to get extremely bad episodes of back pain which would go on for several weeks and that doesn’t happen now.

darlingdodo · 31/03/2022 10:10

Was completely floored by lower back pain several years ago to the extent that I could sit or stand, nothing else. And getting from sitting to standing was excruciating. Osteopath and sports physio were useless. Chiropractor fixed the problem in one visit. Maybe it depends on the chiropractor?

Swipe left for the next trending thread