Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my Mum is favouring my sister over me?

63 replies

Rochyella84 · 29/03/2022 16:56

Ladies ... I am feeling really sad and fed up.

My sister and I both work full time and have 2 young kids. We live only a few minutes apart, and we both live 30 minutes from my Mum. I get very little help from my Mum whilst she gets considerably more. I will preface this by saying that I know getting help from family is not to be expected, and I am genuinely grateful when help is offered, but I feel totally sidelined here. I just don't understand it - my Mum and I have not fallen out, we are on good terms and we speak most days.

My mum doesn't do any childcare for me at the moment - she said she could do a short day once a fortnight if I could drop off and collect my son from her - it wasn't worth it in the end so I just did an extra nursery day. But she has my sister's son once a week for a full day, and drops him home afterwards. She also spontaneously pops over to see her and the kids to 'help her out' and always talks about how exhausted my sister is and how sorry she feels for her. She has her kids overnight too, but she never has my kids unless perhaps we have a really special occasion and then she will have them overnight (maybe 1-2 nights a year). What really stings is that my sister has great in-laws who help her out weekly too, but my in-laws live hours away and we get no support from them.

I am not an outspoken person and I don't want to cause a family argument. I have spoken up a few times e.g. when my Mum says how sorry she feels for my sister and how she needs a break I have pointed out that she doesn't have it that badly and has had quite a few breaks recently, but my Mum just tells me I'm being unfair.

My sister recognises the inequality too but hasn't said anything to my Mum.

Is anyone in the same boat? I just feel a bit dejected and sad.

OP posts:
Rochyella84 · 29/03/2022 19:12

@Laptopsandmouses

How old are the respective kids op?
Mine are 5 and 3, hers are 3 and 2.
OP posts:
Rochyella84 · 29/03/2022 19:11

@ExMachinaDeus

Have you always been the coper? I think family patterns get established very early and can be hard to break. If you feel sad or neglected tell your DM but she might be defensive.

This.

Are you the eldest?

Yes Im the eldest
OP posts:
Laptopsandmouses · 29/03/2022 19:07

How old are the respective kids op?

Underfrighter · 29/03/2022 19:06

I think you need to talk to her. You don't have to day she is favouring your sister. You dont need to say you think she is being unfair. But you can give her facts that she cant argue with and tell her how you feel about these facts.

Eg you and your sister are at similar stages, same number of kids of same ages, same support from partners (she has more support from in laws), same nursery hours so you could both equally do with a break yet your mum spends much more time with your sisters kids and offers a lot more help. And it makes you feel hurt that this means she feels differently about your sister or your sisters kids to how she feels about you.

ExMachinaDeus · 29/03/2022 19:03

Have you always been the coper? I think family patterns get established very early and can be hard to break. If you feel sad or neglected tell your DM but she might be defensive.

This.

Are you the eldest?

Charlavail · 29/03/2022 18:45

My mum always, without fail, calls DD my nieces name.

Rochyella84 · 29/03/2022 18:28

@Dillydollydingdong

Are your dsis' children easier to handle than yours, maybe? Has she got quiet little girls and yours are robust rambunctious boys?
An interesting one...

My sisters kids are challenging at home (lots of tantrums) but angels with my mum.
My kids are very easy at all times. I know I am lucky with that - they eat well, sleep well and they don't tantrum. That is part of the issue i think - my Mum thinks I have it easy.

OP posts:
Dillydollydingdong · 29/03/2022 18:19

Are your dsis' children easier to handle than yours, maybe? Has she got quiet little girls and yours are robust rambunctious boys?

BlueOverYellow · 29/03/2022 18:14

Your mum is playing favourites. Clearly.

Your sister doesn't have your back, so she is complicit in the favouritism. She has noted it, agreed with you, even talked about you behind your back with Mum, and stays silent because rocking the boat with mum might mean she doesn't get treated as the favourite any longer. Even if that means your relationship deteriorates because of it.

And it should. Both of you should talk to your mum.

You should calmly point out that by all appearances, she's favouring your sister and her children over yours. And that it makes you sad and disappointed because you always thought she was fair with the two of you until you had children.

Your sister should say the same, and add that it will cause hard feelings between the two of you (her daughters) if the favouritism continues, and surely she can't want that?!

Then listen to what she says. Really listen. She'll probably be outraged at the very suggestion. Maybe she wants you two to be at odds. Maybe she does play favourites. But you'll soon know by her reaction.

Your sister should have your back. If she doesn't, you're not as close as you think you are ... she's happy to see you struggling more at her expense, basically.

Polyanthus2 · 29/03/2022 18:14

2 people have posted that it's the difficult troublesome child who has now come good that gets favoured.
Maybe they think their child rearing skills sorted the bad child so now they feel warmer towards them.
Or maybe DM was the troublesome child in the family so she identifies with the sis.
Very sad imv. But the DCs won't be little forever.
But those saying the sis can step in when DM is old - that doesn't work as sis will no doubt still be seen as the busy/ overworked/ tired one who needs help , doesnt give help

Rochyella84 · 29/03/2022 18:12

@Maslina3

I think it may be nothing to do with you, or her favouring your sister. You said your in laws live far away, how often do you see them? How much interaction do they have with your children? Your sisters in laws live close and help out regularly. I think this maybe competitive grandparenting, your Mum is possible jealous of her grandkids being close to the other grandparents, and with you she does not have to worry about this as she knows she is the closest to your kids.
Interesting perspective. I hadn't considered this.

My in laws are 3 hours away, we see them 3-4 times a year. They speak to the kids on face time once a fortnight. They show very little interest in them (and are generally very odd people). They have never had them for us, even for an hour.

OP posts:
Maslina3 · 29/03/2022 18:07

I think it may be nothing to do with you, or her favouring your sister.
You said your in laws live far away, how often do you see them? How much interaction do they have with your children?
Your sisters in laws live close and help out regularly. I think this maybe competitive grandparenting, your Mum is possible jealous of her grandkids being close to the other grandparents, and with you she does not have to worry about this as she knows she is the closest to your kids.

Horst · 29/03/2022 18:03

Oh and dh has commented to his mum that maybe we should change the girls names to (piss take versions of the boys names) then maybe she will want to spend time with them.

Horst · 29/03/2022 18:01

This is the same between. Dh and his sister with regards to his mother and any help with the children.

He asked could you watch X 1 day a week after she had previously kept going on about helping. Oh no sorry I can’t.

Sister asks oh yeah sure full day every week for more than one child both younger than ours.

She gets regular sleep overs for her and 1 on 1 play dates.

If we need help it’s ok but drop them off by 9am and don’t take long. Sisters kids will then magically be there too because she needed to hover or some bs.

Rochyella84 · 29/03/2022 17:58

@diddl

Your sister recognises the equality but won't say anything to your Mum-like what?

"Don't have my kids so often as you never have Rochyella84 's kids?"

That's not going to happen is it?

"but I stopped when my sister told me my Mum spoke to her behind my back and said I was always whining about my kids."

Any chance this isn't true & your Mum was going to have your kids more but your sister didn't want her to?

If your Mum said that it's truly horrible.

You are totally right of course. What could she say. She is in a difficult position too in a way as she feels bad that I'm getting no help.

What my Mum said about me complaining about my kids behind my back is definitely true. She had said it to my face too in the past. For what its worth I never complained about my kids incessantly - no more than the usual 'Mum ranting' of 'He's been a real pain today'.

OP posts:
whatwasIgoingtosay · 29/03/2022 17:56

I was an only child and am the parent of one child, so I have no experience of this. BUT I simply cannot imagine as a mother blatantly favouring one adult child over another by offering more childcare, etc. What demons get into these women that they think it's OK to do this? It must be so incredibly hurtful to the less-favoured child.

Rochyella84 · 29/03/2022 17:56

@BreathingDeep

Oh OP, I get it. As someone who has always felt their sibling was the preferred child, it hurts.

Can I ask, do you know if your sister asks for help or whether it's offered? Like you, I give off the vibe of having everything under control and organised (even when I'm drowning or ill, it seems) and so help if very, very rarely offered, and I don't like to put people out by asking for help, so I don't, and then it's a cycle that's hard to break.

She doesn't ask actually, its offered. Thanks for your kind words, it does hurt. I'm pretty sensitive and this has me constantly questioning myself and whether I've done or said something wrong.
OP posts:
diddl · 29/03/2022 17:54

Your sister recognises the equality but won't say anything to your Mum-like what?

"Don't have my kids so often as you never have Rochyella84 's kids?"

That's not going to happen is it?

"but I stopped when my sister told me my Mum spoke to her behind my back and said I was always whining about my kids."

Any chance this isn't true & your Mum was going to have your kids more but your sister didn't want her to?

If your Mum said that it's truly horrible.

Chely · 29/03/2022 17:52

Well that's your DSIS with a live in mum one day, that'll be fun for her after getting rid of the kids.

My inlaws are like this. Rarely come to see our kids, eldest is 16 and refuses to call them nanna/grandad because they've been so rubbish. BIL has had his eldest looked after by them when at work and overnight, SIL is on maternity atm and she picks up eldest weekly to give her a break. My dh is military and away a lot but I have never been offered a break by them, I've got my shit together though so don't need them. She almost fell while holding our 7mth old last time we saw her, not the 1st fall or 1st with a child in her arms which I find worrying. DH has already said they can go whistle if they want help when they are very old.

lovethebedtomyself · 29/03/2022 17:51

My grandma said to me when she was in her 80's that she didn't love any of her children more than any other (and she had five) but that two of them needed her more and that all of them needed different support at different stages of their lives. She said my mum was more capable than her sisters so she knew she would manage. I didn't see my grandma as much as some cousins because of this but now I am pretty old myself and a parent and grandparent I understand more. I wonder if your mum worries about your sister's children since you mention their behaviour and your sister was the challenging one! It is hard though and worth trying to resolve I think. Good Luck!

Acheyknees · 29/03/2022 17:50

In my experience you reap what you sow. My parents never made any effort with my kids when they were young, whereas my DP's stepmother, who lived further away, would always offer to help. Now the children are older we do so much more with the stepmother than we do with my parents. We go for weekends away with DP's parents, have them over for meals etc. When I show my Mum photos of our time away, I get a cat bum face from her. She wants time with the children now they are teenagers but she never have time for them when they were younger. They just aren't that close.

Duchess379 · 29/03/2022 17:40

It sounds like your mum still thinks that DS still requires 'parental guidance' and you don't. Totally unfair on you though 😶💐

LittleOwl153 · 29/03/2022 17:39

All these folks whose sisters are getting preferential treatment for childcare/support just remember to take a very large step back when it comes to elder support... you reap what you sow after all.

BreathingDeep · 29/03/2022 17:37

Oh OP, I get it. As someone who has always felt their sibling was the preferred child, it hurts.

Can I ask, do you know if your sister asks for help or whether it's offered? Like you, I give off the vibe of having everything under control and organised (even when I'm drowning or ill, it seems) and so help if very, very rarely offered, and I don't like to put people out by asking for help, so I don't, and then it's a cycle that's hard to break.

cleocleo24 · 29/03/2022 17:31

I had this exact situation with my sister. She was working full time at the time and I was part time. But my DH was full time and hers was part-time so it balanced out. She always told me my dsis had more need- I guess she was working full time. It really annoyed me though as my mum would do loads of childcare for her in the holidays and actually ask her when to have the dcs. My sister never paid for childcare, her DH picked up the rest whereas and my mum had periods of doing it too. Apparently my sister would say how expensive it was. Meanwhile I was paying for childcare for two under 3s but apparently that didn't matter. If I asked my mum to have the dcs she always seemed reluctant.

I said something but it was dismissed and my parents got really angry with me so I had to drop it. It still annoys me now. My dsis actually had a much bigger income than us too but was paying no childcare whereas mine was wiped out by it. Later I said to my mum about my income and she looked really shocked.

I have had to let it go though but I am still resentful. But I have learned that my sister manages to put on a poor me face and has a way of manipulating a situation and asking for things in a certain way which seems to work.