Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my Mum is favouring my sister over me?

63 replies

Rochyella84 · 29/03/2022 16:56

Ladies ... I am feeling really sad and fed up.

My sister and I both work full time and have 2 young kids. We live only a few minutes apart, and we both live 30 minutes from my Mum. I get very little help from my Mum whilst she gets considerably more. I will preface this by saying that I know getting help from family is not to be expected, and I am genuinely grateful when help is offered, but I feel totally sidelined here. I just don't understand it - my Mum and I have not fallen out, we are on good terms and we speak most days.

My mum doesn't do any childcare for me at the moment - she said she could do a short day once a fortnight if I could drop off and collect my son from her - it wasn't worth it in the end so I just did an extra nursery day. But she has my sister's son once a week for a full day, and drops him home afterwards. She also spontaneously pops over to see her and the kids to 'help her out' and always talks about how exhausted my sister is and how sorry she feels for her. She has her kids overnight too, but she never has my kids unless perhaps we have a really special occasion and then she will have them overnight (maybe 1-2 nights a year). What really stings is that my sister has great in-laws who help her out weekly too, but my in-laws live hours away and we get no support from them.

I am not an outspoken person and I don't want to cause a family argument. I have spoken up a few times e.g. when my Mum says how sorry she feels for my sister and how she needs a break I have pointed out that she doesn't have it that badly and has had quite a few breaks recently, but my Mum just tells me I'm being unfair.

My sister recognises the inequality too but hasn't said anything to my Mum.

Is anyone in the same boat? I just feel a bit dejected and sad.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsJorahMormont · 04/04/2022 12:36

We've had this too. All I can tell you is I will be remembering it all when it's time for old age care.

whatstheteamarie · 04/04/2022 12:19

I think you should throw into the family conversation when both your Mum and DSis are present that X (made-up friend) is relieved that she's not having to do any elderly care now her mum is old because she received zero help with her DC whilst her sister got lots, so the fictional sister is having to step up.

Make a "joke" that it'll be the same when your DM needs help; I.e. you'll be able to do the odd hour here and there but DSis will need to be doing full days of care and having your mum over nights etc as it's only fair to mirror what's happening now with the GC.

It may make both of them think about the situation clearly and whilst your DSis is gaining both money and time now, long term that could turn on it's head if she becomes your mum's primary carer.

Stillfunny · 04/04/2022 10:51

I know but it is often the reality. Just trying to find an explanation for OP.

ntsure · 04/04/2022 10:47

I actually think it makes things worse if it’s a case of finding one grandchild easier to look after, it’s a bit harsh to reject your own grandchildren in that way. It’s basically saying she likes them better then the other and that’s awful

Stillfunny · 04/04/2022 10:38

I was a childminder for two cousins. Occasionally, their grandmother picked them up. She confessed to me that she preferred to look after one over the other .The reason was that the parents had different parenting styles and some expectations were too much for her. I knew from looking after them , that this was true. Very lively kids as opposed to much more low key kids .
Wonder if your mother just finds your sister's kids easier to look after ?
BTW , I did tell the grandmother that it could lead to people being very hurt and upset.

Lou98 · 03/04/2022 18:22

My sisters kids are challenging at home (lots of tantrums) but angels with my mum.
My kids are very easy at all times. I know I am lucky with that - they eat well, sleep well and they don't tantrum. That is part of the issue i think - my Mum thinks I have it easy.

I think this could be the problem. She may see it as your Sister needs the break as her kids are more of a handful whereas she sees it as you have it easy so don't need the break.

You're definitely not BU though, surely she knows herself how openly different she is treating you both!

eegh2120 · 03/04/2022 16:53

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Rochyella84 · 30/03/2022 19:31

Just wanted to say thanks for all the supportive messages. Its nice to know I'm not alone though sad to read that others are in the same boat. I will consider saying something but I hate confrontation and feel it would be met defensively.

OP posts:
MacaroniCheeseCat · 30/03/2022 16:15

Ooh, I really identify with a lot of this. We only have my DPs - no family on DH’s side. So it really matters. They used to help loads despite living at a distance, when we just had one DC. But then within six months, we had DC2, Covid hit - and we acquired a DN/they acquired a DGS - who just happens to live very close to them.

Putting it bluntly, it feels as though they don’t feel the need to maintain the relationship with DC1 (who had a very strong relationship with them pre-Covid) because they now have DN, who is local, younger and more compliant (DC1 may be neurodiverse and we have had some behaviour issues in the past 2 years, he’s wonderful but quite complicated). And they have just stopped making an effort.

They only see us if we visit and stay with them, which can only really happen in school holidays. They rarely ring. All the angst about not being able to see the DCs during Covid has now evaporated - they can but won’t. They still can’t see us during term time because DC1 is in school, we work in London so commute on public transport, etc. So it’s too risky. They wouldn’t even see us outside for DC2’s birthday. But they look after DN every week and do things like stay in hotels and eat in restaurants. And when we do visit, although it’s lovely to see DN, my DM often seems to have extra caring commitments for him. So I have to admit, it’s difficult not to take it personally. And while none of us are entitled to help, it’s hard when you see your DPs willingly helping one of you but not both. So I understand how you feel. YANBU.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 30/03/2022 15:49

It may just be worth asking her outright. "Mum, you help sister out a lot with the kids, but don't seem to do the same for me. Is there a particular reason?"

Mary46 · 30/03/2022 15:42

Lousy op. I find if I dont jump to my mums wishes its taken out on teens. Nothing in birthday cards that type of thing. But yes not nice if 1 sister singled out

nearlyspringyay · 30/03/2022 14:14

@LittleOwl153

All these folks whose sisters are getting preferential treatment for childcare/support just remember to take a very large step back when it comes to elder support... you reap what you sow after all.
Except mines fucked off to Oz, so it'll be me, doing it!
nearlyspringyay · 30/03/2022 14:13

@Rochyella84

Weirdly my Mum and I used to be much closer than she and my sister were. My sister was always quite challenging with behaviour growing up whereas I've always been the 'easy' one. Since having kids she has mellowed a lot and she and my Mum have become much closer.

I wouldn't say I've always been the coper though, I'd say both my sister and I are pretty capable efficient people!

I should add that my sister and I are actually very close. I don't resent her for this....I'm more upset with my Mum really and just questioning why my sister is seen as this 'victim' who needs lots of help and support whilst I apparently can cope fine on my own.

Oh my, you are me op. I've finally gone very very lc with my sister. I'm sick of being the coper. when I was in the depths of pnd with newborn twins who were extremely prem and ventilated, I nearly died too, my mum fucked off for two hours to take a call from my sister as she was worried about her job. Straw that finally broke my back. I have a relationship with my mum but it's not on an emotional level at all.
TenRedThings · 30/03/2022 13:19

Is there a difference in your DC and your sisters? I had 2 lively, active boys and got no support whereas my calm little niece is always being looked after.

CatsandDogs22 · 30/03/2022 05:37

I get it OP. My mother has told me she can’t handle 2/3 of my kids (they’re normal fairly well behaved kids but happen to be twins) even as a one off. Even though she regularly looks after my niece and nephews. So I don’t ask for help with any of them. So now she gets all sad and guilt-trippy about not Knowing my kids as well. And also jealous that they see their other grandmother more often and know her better. And I just think well of course it’s that way you made it that way. I have no idea why.

anxietyfille · 30/03/2022 04:37

We have similar situation with ils. Dh is eldest, they will have our dc every few months for overnight which is great but always moan about how much childcare they are doing (it's not us!) they have sils child twice a week for working plus most weekends often overnight. The frustrating thing is sils in-laws also have dn several times a week and on weekends plus they have bils two sisters to ask too if childcare is needed. My dm died three years ago and df is too elderly, we literally have no one else to ask. I had a work trip yesterday dh was wfh but couldn't get dc from school so ask fil who doesn't work to pick him up and have him til dh finished. Fil agreed but then complained that dh couldn't just leave work early. The last time we asked fil to pick him up from school was about a year ago. Even when my mum was ill they never offered to help and had a go at me for asking for help when I needed them to have dc during her hospital apps, once because I asked on a day they have dn (I couldn't change appointment) so they had both of them and another time because a treatment day fell on a day fil volunteers and he had to cancel. ( he gave up the volunteering when sil needed him that day every week for dn)

I think some people just come across needier than others and will also push more, sil is very thick skinned and does not take no for an answer, she's also good at getting people to do what she wants and make them think it's their idea. You could talk to your mum and ask why she thinks you need her less but it may cause fallout so it's wether it's worth it.

LolaStrange · 29/03/2022 22:58

Posted too soon*

My mum looks after sister's kids as free childcare, always has. We don't live close but she never asks about my kid or asks to see photos. She doesn't know a thing about him.

LolaStrange · 29/03/2022 22:57

My mum definitely prefers my sister. They are friends. I don't have this with her, no falling out, and over time we've naturally drifted apart and we barely speak. Favouritism is definitely a thing.

Sweetpeasaremadeofcheese · 29/03/2022 21:00

I think parents just naturally help/favour some of their kids. My mum has two favourites and me and one sister were pretty much left to raise ourselves (and are actually more successful adults now). My brother is a single dad and actually lives with my mum and they co-parent. But if my youngest sister has a baby we ALL know we won't see our mother for dust. Her baby having a baby! We joke about it more than anything. She sees them as needing her more and honestly it's a self-fulfilling prophecy, they will always be needy.

Rochyella84 · 29/03/2022 20:21

@ntsure

If your sister has involved in laws, Is it possible your mum might be trying to not be out-done in the helpful grandparent stakes? That’s the kind of thing my mum would do
Someone else mentioned this and I just discussed it with my husband and we agree this is a very feasible explanation. Her in-laws do a lot for her, and I think my Mum wouldn't want to be seen as the less helpful one. My in laws do nothing and so my Mum has nobody to compete with.
OP posts:
Horst · 29/03/2022 20:14

@Acheyknees

In my experience you reap what you sow. My parents never made any effort with my kids when they were young, whereas my DP's stepmother, who lived further away, would always offer to help. Now the children are older we do so much more with the stepmother than we do with my parents. We go for weekends away with DP's parents, have them over for meals etc. When I show my Mum photos of our time away, I get a cat bum face from her. She wants time with the children now they are teenagers but she never have time for them when they were younger. They just aren't that close.
Very true my oldest remembers being dropped like a hot potato once the sisters first messiah was born.

At best all they get from him now days is a grunt and that’s when he actually shows his face to them. He won’t even be in the same room as dhs sister or her children.

My parents he plays video games with and goes on walks with playing Pokémon go etc.

ntsure · 29/03/2022 20:08

If your sister has involved in laws, Is it possible your mum might be trying to not be out-done in the helpful grandparent stakes? That’s the kind of thing my mum would do

Christmas1988 · 29/03/2022 19:26

My mum helps my brother and his family out way more than she does for mine, I know it’s because she worries about his son and she doesn’t feel like I need the help. My mum is practically forced in to having my nephew everyday after nursery, she doesn’t like doing it but my brother has put her in an impossible situation. Perhaps your mum feels like you don’t need help and thinks you are doing a great job!

ExMachinaDeus · 29/03/2022 19:25

Yes Im the eldest

I'm not surprised! Eldest children (and especially eldest girls) are always expected to cope. We are also trained not to ask for help, because we have seen/absorbed our parents - and mothers in particular - have to cope with the next baby. So we learn to look after ourselves from a very young age (trying not to be bitter here Grin I was just 15 months old when my next sibling was born, and born as a sickly baby. I had to stop being a baby myself at that point, and from then on was pretty much developmentally 12 months ahead of other children my age ...)

Duchess379 · 29/03/2022 19:17

@Acheyknees

In my experience you reap what you sow. My parents never made any effort with my kids when they were young, whereas my DP's stepmother, who lived further away, would always offer to help. Now the children are older we do so much more with the stepmother than we do with my parents. We go for weekends away with DP's parents, have them over for meals etc. When I show my Mum photos of our time away, I get a cat bum face from her. She wants time with the children now they are teenagers but she never have time for them when they were younger. They just aren't that close.

*Cat bum face 😂🐾😆