@ClaudineClare - no, at that age I was being asked how to win a siege on both sides, with plan for destroying morale in the besieged and how to kill as many of the opposing people as possible. Plus points if you used innovative methods not in the textbook (which meant an everloving trip to the library to read up back then).
It’s gross. I had to try and work out how to kill as many people as possible, and break their spirits in the process. I still remember it now as one of my favourite homeworks, even better than that one class in biology where they let us play with a live virus 😍.
It may be distasteful to some people, it seems like you fall in that camp, but it won’t be to all. I don’t think it’s wrong to react in that way but not everyone will. I find it interesting to see how horrified some of the reactions are on here. It’s an intellectual exercise, nothing more. There may be discussions happening in class that talk about the morality and efficacy of torture, that encourages them to develop empathy and critical reasoning. That wouldn’t necessarily come across in the homework.
On the off chance that someone’s parent has been the victim of sustained torture (not the most likely thing, but an outside possibility), then obviously it could be triggering. But I’m not sure you should set homework based on ‘what if this causes a trauma to a parent’.
Ultimately, I think that the marks should go to any kids who work out that the information you extract using torture is rarely reliable and therefore the best thing to do would be to try and turn them, with kindness not cruelty.