Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend asking to use swimming pool

839 replies

bakedbeansandgravy · 29/03/2022 16:20

a few years ago DH came into some inheritance and spent the money on a swimming pool We have always wanted one. Friends use it with us and all is good. However, my friend is asking to use the pool when we are due to be away in May. Access to the garden/pool is straight forward as we have a gate with number pad. However:

last time my friend used the pool when we were away (friend asked in advance) we came back to find the pool chemicals had not been done properly and the pool water was a lot lower than usual (can cause issues with the filter system). DH was fuming and it took him ages to get the chemical balance back.

To leave the pool heating on for my friend while we are away is going to cost us money. Money that could be saved from non-use by us while we are away but instead will be used/accrued by my friend. But I cant say we are trying to save costs ie the pool heating will be off while we are away and then turn it back on the minute we get home - if that makes sense.

I don't mind friend using the pool but it will cost us money (and I can hardly charge my friend), if we were here then the pool heating would be on anyways and last time my friend messed up the chemicals.

Any suggestions on what to do/say ?

OP posts:
princessbear80 · 29/03/2022 17:32

Hi OP, I have only read your posts not the full thread. I recently said no to a friend who was walking all over me. I didn’t think I was a pushover, but had got myself into this position where she was clearly taking the piss. Saying no was so liberating, I wish I’d done it sooner. No more cheeky requests from her anymore. If you stand up to her this once, she will hopefully stop over stepping the mark. She did come back trying to make me feel guilty about something her DC might miss out on, but it’s not my fault she can’t do what she wants for DC, it’s hers.

Maybe say by text
“Hi friend, sorry it’s not possible for you to use the pool while we’re away. It won’t be heated and the chemicals won’t be balanced.” That’s all - nothing too detailed or over the top. If she comes back and says DC will be disappointed, just reply with “happy for them to come for a swim when we’re back”. Keep it simple but stand your ground. I know how it feels.

BlueOverYellow · 29/03/2022 17:32

Tell her no.
Tell her you're turning off the heating for it.

Change the gate code.
Install a few cameras at your front door, gate and back garden.
If anyone (she) asks, say they're to protect you for insurance purposes and liability in case someone (she) tries to use your poor when you're not home.

KosherDill · 29/03/2022 17:32

"If pushed say your DH and you have decided not to let people use it while you are away as you've had issues with the chemicals not being right so you need to be there to ensure they are safe/balanced?"

This is a good ploy. And it's true.

My sister has this problem; she is very generous with her pool and neighbors have come to believe they have free access to it. Last summer I was staying at her home to dog sit while she went to visit a friend; I was working and looked out to see two women lounging at the pool complete with bags of snacks and wine. For six hours!!

After that I locked the two gates from the inside and ignored the bell.

Your friend is not going to expire if she can't use the pool.

If she protests that she'll take care of the chemicals, etc., just say "thanks, but we've decided we must be here any time it's being used and we're firm on that. Thanks for understanding."

Momto4plus3 · 29/03/2022 17:31

"Sure! but the heat won't be on"

midlifecrash · 29/03/2022 17:31

Strikeout fail

WhatyoutalkingaboutWillis · 29/03/2022 17:31

Tell her she's the 4th person to ask (include friends and family) and to be fair to all, you have to say no to all.

MindTheGapMoveAlong · 29/03/2022 17:31

No, because your household/pool/accident & injury insurance will be invalidated if you’re not on the premises. Not only does that put you in a dreadful position if anything g happened but if anything happened to anyone using the pool …

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 29/03/2022 17:31

Change the gate code, for a start, and don’t give her the new one.

You do need to be firmer with her. If you can’t tell her that she caused a problem last time then you should use the (very valid) example reason you gave of switching the heating off to save on energy costs during your absence.

CantGetDecentNickname · 29/03/2022 17:31

Hi OP

Subbaxeo Tue 29-Mar-22 17:17:51
I really wouldn’t tell fibs about the pool needing an engineer! Why would you do that? What’s wrong with the truth? You’ve decided that on occasions when you’re away, you’ll switch off the systems as you need to economise and to ensure there is no issues with maintaining the water cleanliness. So she can use it but only when you’re around. Perfectly fine to say that

I'd go with the PP above. When she pushes back, keep saying "no, that's not going to happen" or "no, I'm not having anyone use the pool while we're not there" and "no and don't ask me again because the answer isn't going to change". If she tries the sob story that her DD is going to be disappointed you could advise her not to make promises on behalf of other people that she can't keep. Write a few sentences out and rehearse them. If you're seeing her in person, try to do it when your DH is around for backup if you feel you need it. Or just text her and keep on texting "no". You will have to be firm and keep on saying it as CFs don't give up easily. Avoid the word "sorry" as you've not done anything to apologise for and no need to give excuses. Energy prices are about to skyrocket so there is nothing shocking in the idea that you won't be heating it while you are not around.

As loads of other PPs have said, you have to change the code on the gate. She may well try to use the pool anyway, could bring anyone with her and this is a security risk to your home.

I guarantee that you will feel much better after you have been assertive with her!

midlifecrash · 29/03/2022 17:31

“I’m sorry your DD will be disappointed. What a shame she was foolishly promised this by her —stupid negligent cow of a— mother”

TakeMe2Insanity · 29/03/2022 17:29

Pressed post too soon.

More, than anything she’s effectively made no holiday plans other than utilising your hospitality so thats an even bigger no.

gamerchick · 29/03/2022 17:29

Personally if you struggle with this person I'd ask your bloke to tell her no and change the gate code while you're on.

Try saying no a bit more often. It does get easier and if she pulls the poor bairn guilt trip, tell her that's a shame, never mind.

TakeMe2Insanity · 29/03/2022 17:28

Practice saying “no” and smiling. End of.

On a more serious note she doesn’t sound a good friend to have.

oakleaffy · 29/03/2022 17:28

Pools cost a lot to maintain-
Just say NO.

They can use a public pool.
Much cheaper and easier.

SofiaSoFar · 29/03/2022 17:28

I will tell her she cannot use the pool, and include whatever reason, and she will say (because I know her too well) ''my DD was soo looking forward to using the pool but now she cant and will be so very disappointed''.

I'd tell her it's a shame her daughter's not more resilient.

Branleuse · 29/03/2022 17:27

Tell her that unfortunately you are not going to be able to offer her use of the pool while youre away for several reasons. 1, that the chemicals in the pool are very specific and last time someone else used it without you, this was messed up and caused green algae and it was a lot of time and money to put right. 2. The heating will be off as its expensive to run, and 3. You actually checked your insurance recently and it is invalidated if youre not there, so after discussing it with dh, its just not worth it to allow others to use it without us.

If she tries to talk you round or guilt trip you, either ignore it completely or say " im sorry you feel that way, but im surprised as we feel that we are already generous enough with our pool and friends, but us not even being there, its still a NO im afraid.

Definitely change the code too

Jalepenojello · 29/03/2022 17:26

I would say it’s not convenient that week but maybe you can arrange something as a group when you return.

Brideandprejudice · 29/03/2022 17:26

Let this be a turning point for you. Once you've said no once, all the next times will be easier and you can stop letting her walk all over you.

aloris · 29/03/2022 17:25

To be honest, I think it is unsafe to let her use the pool given she was not able to figure out the chemicals. Unsafe for her and her daughter, I mean. Also, if she gets the chemicals wrong and she or her daughter become ill, you would be liable. If this were me, I would say something like, "I understand it seems like it would be so fun to use the pool, but getting the chemicals right is actually quite tricky and takes a lot of experience. It's not safe to use it if they aren't kept in the correct balance and as I'm responsible for the pool, I'm unable to let you use it this year. But when we get back, we'll be sure to invite you over to swim."

If you aren't able to stand up to her yourself (which I totally understand, I'm the same, especially with bossy people), get your dh to do it. After all, he is the one who will have to spend ages re-tweaking the chemicals when you get back and the pool is scummy.

BronwenFrideswide · 29/03/2022 17:25

Because I'm weak tbh and I feel selfish saying no. I have always been like that and I really really wish I wasn't. This friend walks all over me but I am not strong enough against her. She has the gate code (she wanted it for using the pool before and in case of any emergency ever).

You are not selfish at all. By saying 'No' now you can begin the process of stopping her walking all over you. Realistically if a friend treats you like this they are not your friend why do you want to keep them as such?

I will tell her she cannot use the pool, and include whatever reason, and she will say (because I know her too well) my DD was soo looking forward to using the pool but now she cant and will be so very disappointed

I wouldn't give a reason as that will open a way for negotiation or guilt tripping but if you absolutely feel you have to give some reason make sure it is one that she cannot argue against. Don't be guilt tripped, she shouldn't promise things she can't deliver on not your fault.

Finally, change the number on your gate key pad and do not tell her the new number she doesn't need it.

The insurance angle other posters have suggested is interesting it may be that you require public liability insurance if you allow access to the pool.

NataliaSerene · 29/03/2022 17:25

Tell her the truth: that you and your husband have jointly decided that no one will use the pool while you are away. She does not need any more information than that.

If she says her daughter will be disappointed, I would say nothing and leave the silence there. I cannot think of anything polite to say in response to someone actively teaching their children to expect to use other people's resources.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 29/03/2022 17:24

maybe she had a pool party whilst you were away and that’s why there wasn’t a lot of water in the pool when you came back
this absolutely!
The power of no is a really good one with people who keep pressurising you.
You already have so many suggestions of what to say to her.
Tell her the full chemical story I think its awful that she was willing to use your pool, but not to take care of it as instructed and as everyone has said change the gate code.
Also. "your daughter has had plenty of opportunities to use the pool - just not this week whilst we are away."
We had a similar thing with a friend asking again and again if they could store a vehicle on a shared area we had access to. It was impractical in every way so although I hate confrontation I had to keep saying no and she was furious with me and complained to all and sundry but somehow the ruder she was and the more she complained the less of a damn I gave about saying no to her. It was liberating. She made me feel that saying no was so mean... but it was mean of her to treat me that way in the first place.

ForeverLooking · 29/03/2022 17:23

I'd tell it invalidated my insurance. True or not she won't know.
If she's the type to sneak in, as others have said change the code and cover the pool with a padlock on the roll mechanism (if you have one, we could with ours but this is years back).

SiennaSienna · 29/03/2022 17:23

I agree about not letting her use the pool while you are away. I live in another country but we have a pool too and in addition to the reasons you listed I would personally be concerned about any potential liabilities if something were to happen while you were away (to the pool or anyone using it).

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/03/2022 17:22

YABU for considering her a friend, really. What does she do for you - or is it all one-way?

I agree with PP that, if she promised her DD something before checking that it would be possible, she is the one who has decided to risk disappointing her DD.

Ask if you can borrow her car to take away on holiday and, when she says no, start sobbing about how terribly disappointed your DH will be, as he was so looking forward to not having to pay for the wear and tear on your own car....