Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend asking to use swimming pool

839 replies

bakedbeansandgravy · 29/03/2022 16:20

a few years ago DH came into some inheritance and spent the money on a swimming pool We have always wanted one. Friends use it with us and all is good. However, my friend is asking to use the pool when we are due to be away in May. Access to the garden/pool is straight forward as we have a gate with number pad. However:

last time my friend used the pool when we were away (friend asked in advance) we came back to find the pool chemicals had not been done properly and the pool water was a lot lower than usual (can cause issues with the filter system). DH was fuming and it took him ages to get the chemical balance back.

To leave the pool heating on for my friend while we are away is going to cost us money. Money that could be saved from non-use by us while we are away but instead will be used/accrued by my friend. But I cant say we are trying to save costs ie the pool heating will be off while we are away and then turn it back on the minute we get home - if that makes sense.

I don't mind friend using the pool but it will cost us money (and I can hardly charge my friend), if we were here then the pool heating would be on anyways and last time my friend messed up the chemicals.

Any suggestions on what to do/say ?

OP posts:
Dameputtingonabraveface · 29/03/2022 19:51

As PP have said, the answer is no. Explain the pool will not be heated, you are not actually insured (which you did not realise before to cut off that line of conversation) and actually last time it was used whilst you were away you came back to it being poorly maintained and people not used to maintaining pools just do not realise how complex this is and what this damage this causes. Just be matter of fact, it is your pool after all and you own a pool for your benefit. Do not make up an elaborate lie, you will just be further drawn in and be anxious about being caught out. Send a text/what's app/email if easier than face- to-date. Just end with 'I am sure you understand-hopefully we will get some use out of it with friends this year'! Try to give her no where to go for further discussion. If DD is disappointed just a breezy 'I am sure you will find lots of other things to do. Children quickly move on!' And please change the pass code.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 29/03/2022 19:45

@RonSwansonsChair

Just say no, too many things went wrong the last time.
Winner!
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/03/2022 19:45

If her DD is that upset she can take her to a local pool or lido for a few quid. You have to tell people when they're being disrespectful.

This is a very good point indeed, actually.

She'll be expecting the apologetic, guilty-sounding response "Oh, no, I'm so sorry, I don't want to disappoint her" followed by you giving in and letting them come and use it anyway; when the correct response should be a stern "Wow, that is extremely disrespectful of you to promise something of ours to somebody else without even checking with us first - totally rude and out of order of you".

RonSwansonsChair · 29/03/2022 19:44

Just say no, too many things went wrong the last time.

silverbubbles · 29/03/2022 19:44

say pool is undergoing maintenance. Chemicals are up the creek so no swimmimg allowed

KosherDill · 29/03/2022 19:42

"Saying its having maintenance will stop her this time but no reason she can't use it the next time, or the first half of the week if the maintenance is happening at the end etc. Saying problems with people looking after the chemicals - she'll come over in advance and have a lesson so she's certain she can sort it. Insurance doesn't cover it, dont worry, she'll check for you and it does...

So just flat no, or unspecified reasons. I have used the "its all very complicated and frankly far too boring to get into, but the upshot is im afraid its a no." type answer that just doesn't quite give people like this something to grab hold of and "fix"."

These are good points. What's that acronym JADE Justify, Apologize, etc. don't do it.

Just be vague "It really doesn't work for us to have people on our property while we're away. Thanks for understanding."

NoSquirrels · 29/03/2022 19:40

I will tell her she cannot use the pool, and include whatever reason, and she will say (because I know her too well) ''my DD was soo looking forward to using the pool but now she cant and will be so very disappointed''.

And then you’ll say “Oh dear, what a shame. But you shouldn’t have promised she could, because you hadn’t checked first. I’ll invite you round when we’re back.”

Then change the gate code.

DarkDarkNight · 29/03/2022 19:37

I would say you’re not insured for people to use the pool when you’re not there and that your husband wasn’t happy that it hadn’t been properly maintained last time.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 29/03/2022 19:35

'I will tell her she cannot use the pool, and include whatever reason, and she will say (because I know her too well) ''my DD was soo looking forward to using the pool but now she cant and will be so very disappointed''.'

"Well, that was presumptuous of you!"
Go on, OP, I dare you!

As others have said, I wouldn't make/make up excuses such as it not being heated. There's always the time-honoured get-out: "Sorry, that doesn't work for us." Cctv is a good idea as even if you change the code some people might decide climbing over the gate would be a good idea.

CaptainMyCaptain · 29/03/2022 19:33

@AndAsIfByMagic

Tell her what you've said here.
Yes. It's simple.
TheNoodlesIncident · 29/03/2022 19:33

I hate to tell you this OP but your household insurance is also likely to be voided on account of your giving a third party unrestricted access. Even if there isn't a problem with the pool, which insurers would be twitchy about anyway, it's like you have given a person outside your household a key to your premises, which should be secure. And they're not secure, are they, because you've told a "friend" the gate security number. (I say "friend" because she absolutely isn't, she's a user whom you wouldn't see for dust if you stopped being of use to her!)

It's good that you recognise that you find it hard to stand up to this person, that's the first step in hardening your resolve to push back. I find the audacity of her utterly infuriating, and I don't know how you aren't getting angry at the cheek of it. Tell her "No, it didn't work out well for us last time so we're not allowing it again" and change the flipping gate security number!

Babymonkeynuts · 29/03/2022 19:33

Say no - your house insurance won’t cover you if there’s an accident. Not worth the risk.

Daffodilz · 29/03/2022 19:32

No is a complete sentence

Bedsheets4knickers · 29/03/2022 19:32

I would just say the cost . Why dance around it . It's the truth .

MzHz · 29/03/2022 19:32

I will tell her she cannot use the pool, and include whatever reason, and she will say (because I know her too well) ''my DD was soo looking forward to using the pool but now she cant and will be so very disappointed”

The oh my dd will be so disappointed gives me the rage!

Ignore, change the code or she will use it without permission and phase her out of your lives.

Leeds2 · 29/03/2022 19:30

Whatever you decide to say, and assuming it is "no," make sure you do it by text. So when one of them has an accident, and decides to sue you, you have it in writing that you told her she didn't have permission use it whilst you were away.

Does your pool have a cover? I would imagine so, as it helps to keep the heat in. If the cover doesn't have a lock already, I would look to getting one fitted.

OliveTreees · 29/03/2022 19:29

I am the first one who can never say NO to to people but on the swimming pool issue, I have said no in many instances, even before the latest rise in electricity costs. In our climates (I suppose you live in the UK?) heating up a swimming pool is very expensive, but people don't realise it unless they have one.
When I have been exactly in the same situation, I have said to people, "Feel free to use the swimming pool, but it won't be heated up as we turn it off when were are away to save costs as it's so expensive these days". I can assure you they wont want to be swimming in freezing water Grin

MzHz · 29/03/2022 19:29

@bakedbeansandgravy

thanks for all the replies, some good options here.

The pool maintenance was explained to her last time and she said she understood. When a hell of a lot of green scum started forming around the pool edges, I thought she would have realised something was wrong. But she clearly carried on using the pool. I have no idea how she managed to get so much water out of the pool. It was extremely low.

She massively takes advantage of me in many ways and I feel immensely pressured into saying yes. I'm weak and I know it and so does she.

Your last paragraph is why you say no.

Let H be the bad guy if that’s easier, but honestly just say something like “sorry, spoke to H and he’s said he doesn’t want anyone using house/pool while we’re away” and then all you have to do is say “no, doesn’t work for us, it’s our final word on the matter”

Cocomarine · 29/03/2022 19:28

It’s time to just lose this “friendship” altogether. You’ve even said, you’re weak and she knows it. Say no. Say you don’t want to have other people use it because the chemicals don’t get managed correctly, because you want to save money on heating it, and because you’ve decided you don’t want it used when you’re not there. Then put a bloody camera on it!

Fupoffyagrasshole · 29/03/2022 19:28

Just turn the heat off in it and change the code and leave it at that

JustLyra · 29/03/2022 19:28

Any suggestions on what to do/say ?

@bakedbeansandgravy "Sorry, we're not having anyone access the pool while we're away because it's not safe when it's not maintainted properly"

Then have your DH change the code just before you go and do not ask him for it until you get back. That way you can't buckle under pressure.

She will try and use it so make sure you tell her in writing by text or email as CF'ers like that won't hesitate to throw you under the bus if they/their child comes to harm when they sneak into your pool anyway.

Andacherryonthetop · 29/03/2022 19:26

And you say ‘ah sorry about that’

Don’t let her guilt you about her dd. She shouldn’t be informing her dd that she’s going to be going swimming in your pool when she hasn’t even been agreed.

I would say either the servicing thing or that the heating won’t be on sorry. If she persists just say apologies again that it’s not possible. Shut her down each time

Couchbettato · 29/03/2022 19:25

Erm, what if they had an accident while you were away?

That's a no from me.

An injury, accident or fatality on your property whilst you're not around to supervise could be very catastrophic for you. It's a small risk but not worth it.

ittakes2 · 29/03/2022 19:25

Tell her you are using the time away for a huge dose of chemicals so not suitable for swimming.

Clockstooforward · 29/03/2022 19:24

Definitely not…your insurance doesn’t cover other users if you are not present…genuinely wouldn’t want to risk an accident happening if it was my pool!