Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The letter finally came. I’m really upset

485 replies

Hell0G00dbye · 29/03/2022 13:10

Long story short DD has followed the 98th centile for weight since my 37 week growth scan. She has followed it perfectly and consistently which was applauded for the 6 months I breastfed and since then has been a big issue with the HV team. She’s at school and I’ve just received the letter saying she’s very overweight.

What can I do? She eats good, home cooked food, has the odd treat but generally healthy and normal child portions. She’s very active both structured (does dance, swimming and gymnastics) every week and unstructured (walks the 40 minute round trip to school daily, parks and long walks on a weekend, runs around the garden. She doesn’t look fat (to me) but she is solid and does feel heavy to pick up.

The letter says contact the doctor or HV but I’ve taken her before. GP says she’s absolutely fine and will grow into her weight and had no concerns. HV just weighed and said she’s still overweight and to watch portions. Day to day I don’t worry about it as she looks fine and is super active but the letter has taken me right back to her 2 year check and being made to go monthly to the HV for weight checks and their disapproving looks when she continued along her centile.

NB: she has followed the 98th centile but I think the issue is she isn’t 98th for height so her BMI puts her at very overweight.

OP posts:
Fabtasticfanatic · 29/03/2022 19:21

Just opt out of anything in future. I won't be consenting to the standard weigh ins after getting a letter to say my slight, skinny child was overweight. They remeasured him a few weeks later and agreed no he wasn't overweight at all. Would have annoyed me less if I could have got any help from the HV when he was rapidly losing weight due to a medical condition.

cadburyegg · 29/03/2022 19:15

Children who are "solid" are probably overweight, contrary to popular belief it's totally normal to be able to see their ribs before puberty. I agree that many people aren't used to seeing slim children. Many people are in denial about their child's weight because children carry their weight differently to adults, if they have visible body fat then chances are they are overweight.

As for muscles, unless your child is doing weight lifting then they won't be all muscle. Running around doesn't build much muscle.

Its not inevitable that a "chubby" baby will be overweight. My ds2 was chubby as a baby and now at age 4 is slim. "Chubby" babies should grow into their weight as they get bigger and start moving, sounds like she hasn't. If she was 98th centile for height too then she'd be in proportion, but she isn't hence the letter.

It's not a pointless exercise, most kids who are a bit chubby in reception are even more overweight by y6.

It doesn't have to be made an issue - but look at portion sizes, snacks, veg/fruit etc. Try having half her dinner plate as veg. Switches like fruit/veg as snacks, semi skimmed milk over whole milk, reduce full fat dairy products, maybe leave actual treats for specific days and pick healthy, more filling ones for the rest of the week.

cantbecoping · 29/03/2022 19:02

Solid, broad, all there, big boned, chunky, heavy to lift, sturdy, muscle weighs more than fat, stocky….. but not fat, sure they go to dance class!

Excuses, denial, bullshit. The majority of fat kids grow into fat adults. Yet people are telling others to bin the letters. They mean nothing. Your kid is off the charts but it means nothing. Cop the hell on and at least take a closer look at their diet.

MaudieandMe · 29/03/2022 18:54

@NdefH81

There are load of fat kids about

On this thread you’d think there was none and it was all in the imagination of HVs

Hmm

Mumsnet is primarily dominated by well educated parents who do not feed their children a diet consisting mainly of chips, pizzas, crisps and takeaways. I bet if you ran a poll on this thread, the vast majority of posters would say they cook most of their kids meals from scratch using fresh ingredients.

In the wider world where obesity numbers are rising, cooking from scratch is not the norm for many parents of fat kids.

AgeingDoc · 29/03/2022 18:54

I'm a retired doctor who used to have a significant paediatric workload and I have mixed feelings on this. BMI is a blunt tool, no doubt about it, but I wouldn't say it was useless. It just needs to be looked at as one part of a bigger picture. It does have value as a screening tool but it should be the beginning, not the end of the conversation. A high, or low, BMI should be seen as a catalyst to have a deeper look at your health and lifestyle but as an isolated number it doesn't give the whole picture. It can be misleading the other way too. I have put on quite a lot of weight since I retired, which coincided with lockdown, but my BMI is still in the so called healthy range. I'm at least a stone overweight but could be falsely reassured by my "normal" BMI. It's not normal for me though.BMI is definitely not an absolute indicator of a healthy or unhealthy weight. I would say however that if someone's BMI is a long way out of the healthy range, in my experience there is generally something that could do with being changed, and that is often portion size.
I do agree with those who have said that a lot of people have lost sight of what a healthy weight looks like, and the deficiencies of BMI as a measure can be used as a reason to dismiss valid concerns about weight.
The type of work I did brought me into contact with a lot of overweight children and their parents, though that wasn't directly why they were seeing me. The vast majority were lovely and loving people who wanted the best for their children and I very, very rarely got the impression I was talking to a "bad parent". I think the reasons behind child obesity (and indeed adult obesity) are very complex and there is definitely no "one size fits all" answer. I do think that a widespread change of perspective around what is a healthy weight and what are appropriate portion sizes plays a real role though.
I began my career in the 1980s and there has definitely been a big increase in the proportion of the population which is overweight since then. It doesn't do anyone any good to deny it. We need to take the judgment out of the way it is talked about and have honest conversations about the problem. I don't think the school measuring programme should be stopped but work is clearly need to improve how results are communicated to parents.

newusername2009 · 29/03/2022 18:51

of course i haven't seen your child but on the assumption she eats healthily and is active then i would ignore.

I have 2 younger ones who wear same size clothes. One is so so heavy to lift - people who try to lift him always get a shock. The other is so light i could lift him with one hand.

It's such a stupid measure to base overweight on.

Nat94 · 29/03/2022 18:46

So your daughter has 40 minutes of exercise every day, also does gymnastics and eats very healthy children portions of food but her bmi would put her at clinically obese?

Something not quite adding up there.

bellocchild · 29/03/2022 18:44

"GP says she’s absolutely fine and will grow into her weight and had no concerns" Just refer them to your GP if they ask.
We had a small 2-3 hour breastfed baby boy (6lb 6) who grew and grew at surprising speed. At about 9 months, he was eating pretty much everything that wasn't nailed down...HV referred us to hospital nutritionist who suggested we feed him things like pork (considered too fatty for babies back then!) and anything else mega-satisfying. He was never fat, ribs always showed, but always very chunky, and he had limitless energy. Grew up to play 1st XV rugby, black belt judo, swimming 1500m at 8. He's still at it.

Please don't worry!

DamnUserName21 · 29/03/2022 18:44

Take it with a pinch of salt, OP.
I'm not an HV but it's likely a box ticking letter the NHS requires HVs to send out based on the height/weight/BMI stats they receive. Ignore.

Blondeshavemorefun · 29/03/2022 18:40

Assume she is in reception

Is she shorter or taller then others in her class

What weight is she

Dd is just 5 and in reception and had that check

Weighs 2 st 8

She is not as tall as some , but def isn’t the shortest

There are 2 very little girls in her class

Bignanny30 · 29/03/2022 18:39

How to give our children low esteem, stress related mental issues and eating disorders all in one little letter!!!!! That should keep the NHS busy for a few more years.

Dixiechickonhols · 29/03/2022 18:37

theyon stats for my county are 20% overweight in reception and 35% overweight in yr 6 but there are huge differences between affluent and deprived areas. Worse area in county has nearly half of yr 6 overweight.

RantyAunty · 29/03/2022 18:31

[quote Hell0G00dbye]@RantyAunty that’s so interesting thanks! DD wouldn’t look out for place in the 5 year old class picture.[/quote]
Glad it was helpful.

Children's ribs should be visible like the kids in the boat. That's the easiest way to tell if your child is overweight or not.

Cervinia · 29/03/2022 18:29

this is awful, I'd bin it. And I say that as someone whose DD was always sturdy and solid and therefore heavy but not fat. She now has body dysmorphia and is permanently on a feast or famine.

moanyhole · 29/03/2022 18:29

I've had the letter with all if my 2. Same story. Once they hit teens and grew in height they slimmed totally. They were never fat but the centiles said they were overweight

Vallmo47 · 29/03/2022 18:28

Could have nearly written your OP word for word, OP. My daughter is Scandi heritage, she’s solid and feels much heavier than other kids her age. But when you strip her down to pants, she’s lean.
I do agree with posters who (in a sensible way) say that we have got used to seeing overweight children and adults. BUT you know your child is more than a figure. Look at her whole body. BMI can be a crock.
I’m also concerned because my daughter is much heavier than many other kids her age, but she still falls into the normal weighted category. She also does both gymnastics and swimming, as well as cycling and walking. We aren’t all the same build, that goes for kids also.

TrippinEdBalls · 29/03/2022 18:23

Are there children who get these letters inappropriately? Absolutely. Is it plausible that it is all but about three children on this thread who fall into that category? It is not.

WouldBeGood · 29/03/2022 18:22

I always opt out of any medical checks/weigh ins/ etc at school.

I had one dc who was always under, one over. Both healthy.

Just ensure you do this in future, makes life so much easier

TrippinEdBalls · 29/03/2022 18:22

@MangyInseam

Yes, this. People make it sound like there's no connection between being overweight as a child and being overweight as an adult, when in fact the correlation is very strong. Of course it happens to some children but very many will not just outgrow it and every year they're overweight it gets harder to change in the future.

No, I think people understand this. But there are also many cases where that does not follow.

In an instance where the diet and level of activity is fine, that seems a more likely trajectory.

But people are such bad judges of whether diet (or portions) are fine, and really overestimate the effect of exercise, particularly when it's a couple of sessions a week of organised activity. That kind of exercise is very good for your health in other ways but won't do much at all for weight (the same is true of adults; a couple of exercise classes a week will make you much fitter and more toned over time but will make very little difference to your weight if you don't change your diet at the same time).
Incompetentatwork · 29/03/2022 18:22

Not worth the paper its printed on. Muscle weighs more than fat. Simple. Your child is active and eats healthy. Therefore has built up more muscle. This is not taken in to consideration. It is basicily height vs weight vs age to get the "norm". It doesn't account for high muscle density.

Runningupthecurtains · 29/03/2022 18:21

It's a bit of a myth that all tall children have a high BMI. DS is 99th centile for height I have his year 6 measurement letter in front of me as it arrived last week and his BMI centile is 53. To move that to a centile that would trigger an action letter he would need to put on a considerable amount of weight not a few ounces.

NdefH81 · 29/03/2022 18:17

Statistically

There will likely be a fair few parents on this thread describing their child is not under weight

That if we were actually to see them, would not hesitate to think they are overweight

NdefH81 · 29/03/2022 18:15

There are load of fat kids about

On this thread you’d think there was none and it was all in the imagination of HVs

NdefH81 · 29/03/2022 18:14

We have a massive obesity problem

I suspect that many currently obese

Were also on the, shall we say “stocky” side as 4 year olds

And if it had been picked up at 4 and support given at that stage… i imagine it would make a difference i some cases. For the better

Changemyname18 · 29/03/2022 18:13

Ignore it. If that is where she has consistently been since birth, then I would say that is fine. It would be more worrying if she suddenly dropped to the 50th centile, but most HV's would (incorrectly) think that was fine. In order to have an average, you have to have the outliers. Given the sport she does, it's likely more muscle. Most pro rugby players would be classed as obese, due to their weight. My DS was always at 95 to 98th centile for height and weight. I phoned the contact number explaining how their letter was flawed 10 years ago when I received it for him. They didn't ask for reference to their red book, and no consideration of height, shoe size (started school in size 1 shoes) or general build. They need not to send the letter based on pure stats, but actually look at the child. It was even more galling when discussing it with school that his class teacher commented that the staff doing the measuring would have been recipients of obese letters themselves...Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread