Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The letter finally came. I’m really upset

485 replies

Hell0G00dbye · 29/03/2022 13:10

Long story short DD has followed the 98th centile for weight since my 37 week growth scan. She has followed it perfectly and consistently which was applauded for the 6 months I breastfed and since then has been a big issue with the HV team. She’s at school and I’ve just received the letter saying she’s very overweight.

What can I do? She eats good, home cooked food, has the odd treat but generally healthy and normal child portions. She’s very active both structured (does dance, swimming and gymnastics) every week and unstructured (walks the 40 minute round trip to school daily, parks and long walks on a weekend, runs around the garden. She doesn’t look fat (to me) but she is solid and does feel heavy to pick up.

The letter says contact the doctor or HV but I’ve taken her before. GP says she’s absolutely fine and will grow into her weight and had no concerns. HV just weighed and said she’s still overweight and to watch portions. Day to day I don’t worry about it as she looks fine and is super active but the letter has taken me right back to her 2 year check and being made to go monthly to the HV for weight checks and their disapproving looks when she continued along her centile.

NB: she has followed the 98th centile but I think the issue is she isn’t 98th for height so her BMI puts her at very overweight.

OP posts:
mamabear715 · 30/03/2022 17:55

Not RTFT, no intention of, I really can't be doing with stuff like this. Bloody Big Brother watching us all, trying to cover their backs.

You have a healthy child, OP, throw the damn thing (letter, NOT child!) in the bin, & no more worrying. Hugs.

Carpedimum · 30/03/2022 17:51

We had that letter about DS when he was about 10, although it didn’t say we had to take him to the GP. He was a bit chubby/solid but not excessively so, I wasn’t remotely concerned. It lasted maybe a year and then he shot up and became a long streak with a 28in waist, broad shoulders & a six pack. BMI measurements should only be a very rough guide, not gospel.

EdenFlower · 30/03/2022 17:49

@BigWoollyJumpers

A 16 year old should not be their full adult weight yet and I would expect one that looked like you on their 16th birthday to be on track to become an overweight adult

This is so wrong. I would suggest (looking at DD's set), that most of her cohort are indeed fully grown at 16. I think this could also be an issue in the modern world. These charts have not been updated since the 1950's. Children and teens are completely different from that era. There will always be difficulty in using "averages" as well, as there will always be outliers. From personal experience again in both DD's cohorts (and in leafy Surrey), more girls are underweight than over, and many of them are 5'10" and completely fully formed adult women by 16.

It is not wrong! Fully grown and full adult weight are not the same thing! Yes, most 16 year old girls will have stopped growing, but they usually continue to gain weight slowly until they are in their 20s. Not many adult women will weigh the same as they did at 16, even though they may be a perfectly healthy weight. 16 year olds on the whole will weigh less than women in their 20s.
BigWoollyJumpers · 30/03/2022 17:44

@AgeingDoc

I agree with a PP the charts need updating to a degree. We know children are now on average hitting puberty earlier The current girl's growth chart (introduced in 2009 in England, so not exactly the Dark Ages) states the normal range for the start of puberty is 8 to 13 years and has a shaded area to allow for variation in normal height according to whether a girl is prepubertal or in puberty during those ages. I doubt there has been further significant change in the last few years.
I might be wrong, and have misinterpreted, but I understand that the new charts from the WHO only go up to 5 years, and that the years after that, the `"curve" follows the same trajectory as the original system, and therefore does not reflect the "modern" era for children older than 5.
lilstarr99 · 30/03/2022 17:42

I had the letter when my daughter was in Y6. She’s always been solid (like me) and muscular (did gymnastics) and when they weighed/measured her she was an adult size 8 with bust and hips, had started her periods and looked like a small, petite woman. Not fat in the least! I never told her, didn’t change anything and she’s still got a lovely figure now she’s 16 and has no body issues.

Take no notice!! You know if your child is “overweight” (as in chubby) and if you have no concerns, ignore it. The BMI system is out of date.

Thefsm · 30/03/2022 17:40

My middle child has always been 99th percentile weight, height etc. His siblings are more around 75% and the oldest is about 55% now. He's always been massive compared to classmates, not particularly fat, just huge.

He is 16 now and 6ft 4" and still growing. He weighs about 245lbs which I know is overweight, but honestly he doesn't have much to loose - his bones, head, shoulders etc are all proportional. He's just built like an ox.

So long as you know the portions are fine and she's healthy, don't stress.

MsMarch · 30/03/2022 16:46

@lljkk

The parent I knew buying age 9-10 yr trousers for her 6 & 7 yr olds -- that parent said she paid £8/pair to shorten the trousers.

I do an activity where I help kit kids out (non sport activity). I wear (loose fit) a men's medium size shirt -- there are yr6s & yr7s who need larger size shirts than me . They are much shorter than me. We struggle to keep larger sizes in stock.

Iv'e been this parent. And agree, it's a problem that should be recognised. DS has sensory issues and being overweight seems to be a common complaint for children with SPD. Doesn't change the fact that he was wearing clothing 2-3 years too big for him and it was too long because his waist to length ratio was wrong.

On plus side, I've barely bought him clothes in ages because as he's lost weight heading towards the teenager years, he's gained some height but most of his clothes still fit him - just in a different (better) way. Grin

AgeingDoc · 30/03/2022 16:40

I agree with a PP the charts need updating to a degree. We know children are now on average hitting puberty earlier
The current girl's growth chart (introduced in 2009 in England, so not exactly the Dark Ages) states the normal range for the start of puberty is 8 to 13 years and has a shaded area to allow for variation in normal height according to whether a girl is prepubertal or in puberty during those ages.
I doubt there has been further significant change in the last few years.

Philisophigal · 30/03/2022 16:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

Ljmumun · 30/03/2022 16:11

I agree with a PP the charts need updating to a degree. We know children are now on average hitting puberty earlier. My DD started period 2 days before her 11th birthday. My mum similar body type was 15. DD is now fully grown and has an adult body shape and type. Over weight on child charts bu normal on adults. Peadiatric team who she sees for something non weight related have confirmed she's fully cooked at 14! And a healthy weight.

AgeingDoc · 30/03/2022 16:11

There's a bit of misinformation about growth charts on this thread - not updated since the 1950s, all based on formula fed babies etc.
That is no longer true, and hasn't been for over a decade now.
From the Royal College of Paediatrics website:
all our growth charts are based on WHO Child Growth Standards, which describe the optimal growth for healthy, breastfed children
The WHO Child Growth Standards were derived from the WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study, the data for which were collected between 1997 and 2003.
There is a huge amount of publicly available information on the study available on the WHO website if anyone wants to know more.
They are probably not perfect - what is - but the charts are definitely not based on data taken from only white, formula fed babies from the middle of the last century as is sometimes claimed.

lljkk · 30/03/2022 15:38

The parent I knew buying age 9-10 yr trousers for her 6 & 7 yr olds -- that parent said she paid £8/pair to shorten the trousers.

I do an activity where I help kit kids out (non sport activity). I wear (loose fit) a men's medium size shirt -- there are yr6s & yr7s who need larger size shirts than me . They are much shorter than me. We struggle to keep larger sizes in stock.

Dixiechickonhols · 30/03/2022 14:56

Drinks are huge issue by yr6. I have Guides routinely turning up with bottles of sugary milkshake or Starbucks Frappuccino or hot chocolate drinks. Hundreds of calories on nothing much.

Dixiechickonhols · 30/03/2022 14:53

Theycallmejune I used to worry about that as DD in primary was much taller than peers. It wasn’t an issue ultimately she’s 5ft 10 age 16 and healthy weight. But very tall genes in family she was never going to be short. I think it’s probably if child is much taller than you’d expect.
I’ll also add that they wouldn’t come into DD’s primary school to do these checks or reception vision check etc as it was private so I do wonder if stats are just based on state educated children.

AlternativelyWired · 30/03/2022 14:36

How much does she weigh?

TheyCallMeJune · 30/03/2022 14:34

Those of you that are saying "but my child is tall!" I think it is important to remember that overweight kids do often grow more quickly and reach their adult height earlier. So the 'height' may be due to being overweight/overfed

OfstedOffred · 30/03/2022 14:28

Clothing isn’t a good measure. Lots of shops very generous sizing.

This. Kids waistbands are huge from almost all shops these days. They size for fat kids.

Esmereldapawpatrol · 30/03/2022 14:27

I'd ignore the letter. It sounds as thought your DD is active and healthy to me.
I had the same with me two DC, born on the 98th centile and have stayed there. Both really tall for their ages and like you say they are solidly built. After my sons came through he had a hospital appointment (about something unrelated) and I brought it up with them. They weighed and measured him and said he was still on the 98th centile (at 5 years old) so all was fine but they said the school system use BMI which isn't accurate. I have to agree it's a stupid system for adults as well!

OfstedOffred · 30/03/2022 14:27

I never understand how kids get so heavy.

My DS is 95th% for height, 40% for weight. He eats more than me etc but is a healthy active boy. I think some people can't see just how chunky their kids are.

BigWoollyJumpers · 30/03/2022 14:21

A 16 year old should not be their full adult weight yet and I would expect one that looked like you on their 16th birthday to be on track to become an overweight adult

This is so wrong. I would suggest (looking at DD's set), that most of her cohort are indeed fully grown at 16. I think this could also be an issue in the modern world. These charts have not been updated since the 1950's. Children and teens are completely different from that era. There will always be difficulty in using "averages" as well, as there will always be outliers. From personal experience again in both DD's cohorts (and in leafy Surrey), more girls are underweight than over, and many of them are 5'10" and completely fully formed adult women by 16.

Dixiechickonhols · 30/03/2022 13:32

www.next.co.uk/style/st179631/195989#195989
Clothing isn’t a good measure. Lots of shops very generous sizing. Joggers and leggings stretch. Even more formal clothes like school trousers now have elastic. Plus size options in lots of childrens ranges. In link waist is 2 inches bigger. Other option is called slim. Easy to think he’s fine he’s 8 in age 8 trousers he just needs that option as he’s not skinny.
Obviously good options are available but lulls people into sense of it’s normal.

Loubylooooo · 30/03/2022 13:21

Clothing isn’t a good measure. Shops vary with their sizes and children’s clothes are mostly measured on height. My 7 year old is average height and needs age 7-8 clothes but they are massive around her waist and she can’t even really wear trousers as they fall down . She’s absolutely 50th centile for weight too.

Doggirl · 30/03/2022 12:31

Haven't RTFT, but unless the DC is tall for her age surely the obvious check is whether she fits comfortably into relevant-age clothing.

My DD 6yo is around 20% heavier than a similar age and height relative--the relative is elfin and my DD scores marginally higher on BMI centile than on height centile. However, she still fits widthways into clothes for 4yos.

Teapacks · 30/03/2022 11:59

@GrannyBloomers

I always expected the letter as I have broadly let my DC eat whatever they want - biscuits if they asked for them, sweets on a Friday etc etc. None of mine have been overweight at any point to date (now all mid teens onwards). The eldest is thin but not skinny at 16 - you can see all his ribs. DD is a powerful build - I would say little chunky (NHS child BMI calc = 56Th centile) youngest is 60th centile and chunky.

I think metabolism plays a part as does perception.

I'm with @AgeingDoc My bmi is 24 - I am a stone overweight though - there is more fat around my middle than is acceptable.
As a history, I have been tall and am built like a carthorse - my hands are bigger than most mens and have been since I was 10, my feet are big and wide. I have very wide hips. So "big boned" "chunky" etc . Now as a teen I shot up and was a then size 14 from the age of 14 (by comparison that is a modern size 10-12 as I have kept some of my clothes!!). I was never fat, you could always see my ribs at a size 14, I carried all my weight on bum and thighs.
I was a bigger adult - with bmi 24-26 for years. Then I got fat. Really fat - size 20.
As an adult i lost weight down to a size 6 (at 178cm). I still had chunky thighs despite a bmi of 15. This shocked me though. How I had been carrying so much extra weight with me. I put weight on and it didn't stop at the planned bmi of 21 - it's 24.

I consider myself a proper fatty at the moment despite being slimmer than I was when younger. I may exercise 12 hours a week (all very aerobic) but I eat too much. I also don't have a great metabolism.

That is the second point. My Dc's dad has a super fast metabolism and can eat whatever he wants and never puts on weight. Another observation - he never ever snacks.

I think we are all individuals, some will have larger frames than others, some will just burn off calories faster but it's very easy to deny some obvious facts - snacking is just not needed at all. (I love it though). Exercise doesn't burn off as many calories as people think and often makes think we can treat ourselves. Our relationship with food is personal and complex. Food should never be used as a reward but we all do this sometimes and there is a mult-billion pound industry built around treating ourselves.
All that said, OP is doing her best. She's not just thrown the letter in the bin but she's questionning and thinking about food. If you are prepared to have those conversations, that's always a really good start.
(I know it would be easy for me to think I'm ok my bmi is normal but in reality I have to change to get back to a healthier me with less fat. )

A BMI of 15 is severely underweight. As in severe health risk territory. And that, at that weight, you were saying you had chunky thighs?

And that you consider yourself a 'proper fatty' despite having a BMI of 24 and being naturally of larger build?

I mean this nicely but to me this sounds like serious body dysmorphia and eating disorder territory that you've been dealing with. Your body perception sounds very askew and it sounds like you need to be a lot kinder to yourself. If you had a BMI of 15, you had way more serious problems than the size of your thighs.

Puzzledlook · 30/03/2022 11:25

@Weekendtobegin it was the health visitor at his 7 month check.

Swipe left for the next trending thread