Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The letter finally came. I’m really upset

485 replies

Hell0G00dbye · 29/03/2022 13:10

Long story short DD has followed the 98th centile for weight since my 37 week growth scan. She has followed it perfectly and consistently which was applauded for the 6 months I breastfed and since then has been a big issue with the HV team. She’s at school and I’ve just received the letter saying she’s very overweight.

What can I do? She eats good, home cooked food, has the odd treat but generally healthy and normal child portions. She’s very active both structured (does dance, swimming and gymnastics) every week and unstructured (walks the 40 minute round trip to school daily, parks and long walks on a weekend, runs around the garden. She doesn’t look fat (to me) but she is solid and does feel heavy to pick up.

The letter says contact the doctor or HV but I’ve taken her before. GP says she’s absolutely fine and will grow into her weight and had no concerns. HV just weighed and said she’s still overweight and to watch portions. Day to day I don’t worry about it as she looks fine and is super active but the letter has taken me right back to her 2 year check and being made to go monthly to the HV for weight checks and their disapproving looks when she continued along her centile.

NB: she has followed the 98th centile but I think the issue is she isn’t 98th for height so her BMI puts her at very overweight.

OP posts:
opalescent · 30/03/2022 22:47

[quote Hell0G00dbye]@user1471457751 she’s between the 50th and 75th for height I think.
She’s in the correct size clothing (mainly 4-5 currently and moving into 5-6) and doesn’t have any rolls or anything anywhere. To those saying don’t talk about it to her/in front of her- I am very careful to never mention anything to do with weight with her. We talk about eating healthily To be fit and strong rather than to do with weight.[/quote]
Based on this, plus your description of her diet and exercise, I'd throw the letter away and never think of it again (Specialist Paeds & Public Health Nurse).

pixie5121 · 30/03/2022 22:47

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

pixie5121 · 30/03/2022 22:41

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

pixie5121 · 30/03/2022 22:40

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

The1andonly11 · 30/03/2022 22:37

:33NochocolatE

The best thing you can do is throw these letters in the bin. You know your child. You know what she's fed and how active she is. If they want regular HV weigh ins, do them, smile, nod and quietly tell them to FO in your head and carry on as you were.

This 100%

Sidge · 30/03/2022 22:12

I can’t believe people are writing “muscle is heavier than fat”. Did you not go to school?!

A pound of muscle weighs the same as a pound of fat. A pound. It just takes up less space as it’s denser.

No wonder we have an obesity crisis…

doitwithlove · 30/03/2022 21:50

OP - disregard the letter as long as you know your child is eating healthy with potion control in place and exercising that is all you need to do.

No wonder youngsters suffer with mental health issues and weight problems when letters like this are sent out !!!

Brieandcamembert · 30/03/2022 21:46

It escapes me how so called medical professionals don't acknowledge that muscle is heavier than fat

That's because it doesn't. It's denser than fat.

Still return to very few children being muscly enough for it to skew a BMI chart. Rugby) swimmer kids have broader shoulders by puberty but ore puberty kids are really not so muscly it's making their BMI falsely fall into an overweight category.

Stocky kids are pretty much always overweight. Parents just prefer the term solid to fat. If a child's tummy is up against its t shirt it's fat not stocky.

BodgertheJogger · 30/03/2022 21:37

I'm actually amazed that BMI is still around. It's quite dangerous when used wrongly.

loopsdefruit · 30/03/2022 21:30

I don't have children (yet). I do have a fiancee with a significant and long-standing eating disorder, contributed to by being raised in an environment where 'fat' was feared and degraded.

She has been battling her own brain telling her to fear weight gain, to restrict food, that her body is something that cannot be trusted and must be controlled and that hunger is not a neutral signal but a dangerous trick that is going to ruin her if she listens to it.

Her BMI is in the 'healthy' range, yet she is exhibiting symptoms suggestive of being in a chronic semi-starved state. Her BMI has never dropped low enough that she ever met the criteria for ED services, yet she has done possibly irreversible damage to her bones.

BMI is bullshit as a way of measuring health, all it does is provide a ratio between height and weight. It was designed as a tool to measure averages, and the population it was based on was adult white men...and not many of those.

Children are born naturally intuitive eaters, with body trust, able to respond in a natural way to hunger and fullness cues. Unless there are medical conditions that disrupt those cues (Prada-willis, ADHD/ASC etc...) their bodies will, when provided with a healthy and varied diet that does not restrict any food groups, regulate themselves.

Restriction, whether that's a 'diet' or just banning certain foods, will lead to inevitable craving of those things and then likely lead to a level of bingeing. That's if you're lucky, unlucky people with a genetic predisposition to an ED could end up triggering that by an initial innocent period of restriction which might not seem that bad to other people.

Diet culture, fear of food, mistrust of our bodies...it's so incredibly damaging. Food should be joyful, fun, can fulfil a ton of different requirements in life both to nourish our bodies and in a social capacity,

Bodies naturally have a set point range that is different for everyone, that's true for children and babies too...otherwise all babies would be born the same weight would they not?

Weight /= health

If the diet being provided to a child is varied and in appropriate portions, and they are active and taking part in varied activities then the likelihood is they are healthy even if their body is larger than someone else's body.

If 100 people were given the same diet and had the same amount of exercise they would not end up all the same size, and some people would have a 'normal' BMI but not be healthy.

PurdeytheDog · 30/03/2022 21:12

My son looked like the Michelin man when he was a baby. Rolls of fat because he was bottle fed, because according to weaning, I had to wait until he was 6 months to eat solids. He was starving (in hindsight) and used to consume minimum 4 large bottles of milk in one sitting.
He was so large (tall as well as big) that they couldn't record his weight on the 'relevant age related page' in the red book, and refused to enter his weight overleaf, where it could be recorded.
We had a letter, and a follow up appointment. In the end we gave up listening and carried on. It was upsetting.
He's 1/4 Dutch. All his relatives are over 6ft.
He's now 6, not an once of fat on him and he's the tallest in his class.
Forget what they say. Go with your gut. You know your own child better than anyone.

user1493559472 · 30/03/2022 21:01

Evening
I am so sorry to hear that you have had the letter about your child's weight.
Has anyone measured their height?
I am a Health Visitor and I try to explain to a parent if I have concerns about a child's weight etc. How old is your child? I would make an appointment with the Health Visitor and ask them to do the weight and their height.
Then you will be able to compare the measurements.
Health Visitors etc are here to support you etc and we don't judge parents/ carers.
It is a Health Visitor's role to highlight any concern we have about a child etc.

Booboobagins · 30/03/2022 21:00

My 15 yo 5'2" daughter (curvy) was told Mt a consultant that her bmi was too high (27),. I blew my stack professionally held in the bite! 2 medical students in tge room I asked them if tgrg thought she was overweight, thry both said no - no flab - flat stomach with abs all on show via crop top, big boobs, slim legs, curvy hips. I askedtge pediatrician if it was appropriate tell a child with anxiety she was over weight when clearly she isn't- BMI does work when yiu have muscle and she did.

It's timethey binned BMI and focused on fat pinching which is a more accurate measure. Even fat monitors are nit great- I am 5'8", weighed about 10.5 stones, was super fit, muscles, size 10 and it said my body comprised 28% fat until a sports trainer adjusted it fir me. I was actually 21% fat and she still wasn't sure that was right either.

You can see if people are overweight by looking at them. Noone needs a measure. If docs are worried about blood fat content/vein or arterial narrowing/ cholesterol etc they can do a blood test! I fir one amsick of this fat shaming of people who are not fat! It's esp disgusting if we're talking about kids.

ToffeeMamma · 30/03/2022 20:57

We received a call while on school holidays to tell us our DC was overweight. I was gobsmavked mainly because doctor was treating him as underweight due to his height. When I looked at the height measurement it was totally wrong and had him marked down as smaller than he was height wise. I asked for a remeasure they did it but still didn't take a new height.measumenet insisting it was right. I pointed out he was very tall for his age and had some snotty nosed woman on the phone telling me his weight was the issue and his height was irrelevant. I removed his data from the database and asked that they didn't measure him again. Doctor spoke to them and made them aware that he was far from overweight and you could see his ribs and had I followed Thier advice it could have been dangerous. Hi estky I wouldn't take any notice of any of it. Ask your GP if they aren't concerned I can wouldn't be

Howareyouflower · 30/03/2022 20:52

@NochocolatE

The best thing you can do is throw these letters in the bin. You know your child. You know what she's fed and how active she is. If they want regular HV weigh ins, do them, smile, nod and quietly tell them to FO in your head and carry on as you were.
Yes!
Pinkfluff76 · 30/03/2022 20:50

Ignore it. She sounds fine and you said so yourself. It’s the size that counts not the number on the scale.

yzed · 30/03/2022 20:49

Of course these letters can't all be wrong. But statistically some of them must be! We, as parents, need to decide for our own child.
And alongside all the advice not to allow our children to become overweight, there's a huge load of advice to avoid our children become over-conscious of their weight.
Meanwhile, we're all encouraged to feed our children a healthy diet. Good advice of course, but unless you spend a couple of years full time studying nutrition, what is a healthy diet? Certainly not the stuff advised on TV/magazine/etc advertising. Maybe these (over?) zealous health visitors could spend some time ensuring that everything advertised as "healthy" actually is. And that companies peddling their "c..p" be prevented from saying it's "good for you".
Then we parents could believe some of the advice coming our way, rather than needing to rate self esteem above all else.

Carol44 · 30/03/2022 20:38

It's nonsense, put the letter in the bin and forget about it. Mum knows best.

JackieLou · 30/03/2022 20:24

Just bin it and forget about it.
You’re her mum and you’ve known her size since the moment you pushed her out!
I refused to let them weigh my DS - he’s fine, he doesn’t need to be a statistic in a pointless national database.

robocracker · 30/03/2022 20:13

I had the same with my middle girl, she's actually always been the most active and eats the best diet. I just ignored it, she is a stocky build but I could see she wasn't fat.

She did always look bigger than her friends but she was also one of the taller ones and she's always been really strong and into sport like climbing and cycling.

She developed early and at the age of 13 is a size 12 and the same height as me. She looks much bigger than all her friends (they're still in the stick shape stage which she never had!) none of her friends are woman shaped like she is. I expect if you looked at average weight for a 13 year old she'd be way heavier than them but she's still really active, more so than a lot of her friends.

I was the same at 13. By 18 I was average amongst my friends. (although she has much bigger boobs which she hates!)

TimandGinger · 30/03/2022 20:13

@pixie5121

OP, I haven't read the thread because it's so long, but before you even mentioned the swimming and gymnastics, I was going to ask if she does either of these sports.

I was classed as having a high BMI as a kid too, and it was ludicrous, because I was a competitive gymnast and swimmer. I too looked 'solid', because I had so much muscle! Thankfully my parents told me the letter was a pile of crock and ignored it but imagine if they had taken it seriously...it could have easily triggered an eating disorder.

It escapes me how so called medical professionals don't acknowledge that muscle is heavier than fat. If a child is very sporty then yes, they're going to be heavy! What is worse, a child with a 'normal' BMI who never gets up off the couch or a child who does muscle building sport on a daily basis?

That’s really really not true. My son does tons and tons of sport and is officially underweight. All the sporty boys in his year are the same.
cadburyegg · 30/03/2022 20:03

@Brieandcamembert

Good grief. None of you have heavy bones. There is not a group of people trotting about with a Titanium armoured skeleton.
🤣🤣🤣

Heavy bones aren't a thing. In fact, bones are relatively light compared to everything else in the human body.

People can have bigger frames than others but that won't make them weigh more. I have a pair of jeans that fitted me between having DS1 and DS2. After I had DS2 they no longer fit, even though I weigh less than I did then, presumably because my hips have got bigger then or I'm carrying fat in different places. But the difference isn't noticeable to anyone other than me.

Lianne1977 · 30/03/2022 20:01

I got the opposite (and a phone call) as my son was so underweight below 0.2th centile. I actually laughed on the phone and said you need to read his medical notes to which she said sorry I have but I had to ring. 🤨

Jacopo · 30/03/2022 19:59

And “big boned “ is a ludicrous myth unless your child has gigantism.

Jacopo · 30/03/2022 19:57

So much denial on this thread. Can you see your child’s ribs when they raise their arms over their head? You should be able to.
Some very blinkered parents here who seem to think the health visitors are just out to get them.
We are raising an obese generation. Open your eyes for goodness sake.

Swipe left for the next trending thread