Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The letter finally came. I’m really upset

485 replies

Hell0G00dbye · 29/03/2022 13:10

Long story short DD has followed the 98th centile for weight since my 37 week growth scan. She has followed it perfectly and consistently which was applauded for the 6 months I breastfed and since then has been a big issue with the HV team. She’s at school and I’ve just received the letter saying she’s very overweight.

What can I do? She eats good, home cooked food, has the odd treat but generally healthy and normal child portions. She’s very active both structured (does dance, swimming and gymnastics) every week and unstructured (walks the 40 minute round trip to school daily, parks and long walks on a weekend, runs around the garden. She doesn’t look fat (to me) but she is solid and does feel heavy to pick up.

The letter says contact the doctor or HV but I’ve taken her before. GP says she’s absolutely fine and will grow into her weight and had no concerns. HV just weighed and said she’s still overweight and to watch portions. Day to day I don’t worry about it as she looks fine and is super active but the letter has taken me right back to her 2 year check and being made to go monthly to the HV for weight checks and their disapproving looks when she continued along her centile.

NB: she has followed the 98th centile but I think the issue is she isn’t 98th for height so her BMI puts her at very overweight.

OP posts:
OnceuponaRainbow18 · 29/03/2022 15:37

This is why I didn’t give consent for my son to take part in this school Weighing BS

Dixiechickonhols · 29/03/2022 15:37

Would school tell you what she’s had a lunch for a few weeks given you’ve had the letter. It may be she’s having seconds daily or choosing bread in the ‘salad’ bar.
The issue with the throw it in the bin is the stats are awful and have risen unsurprisingly in covid. The yr 6 stars in some areas are more overweight than not so the does she look
Ok compared to peers doesn’t work.
No one will tell you outright. If you watch do you notice any habits dd has that peers don’t eg is she always eating at parties, does she have a snack after activities when others don’t.
The upping veg for all of you is a great idea.

Hornetfarmer · 29/03/2022 15:36

My SIL and BIL are both overweight. They had the letter when their DD was in reception. They have dismissed this the same as most people on this thread and they are removing her from the program in year 6. She is now 9. She is very visibly overweight or "big boned" as they call it. Research suggests that overweight children will become overweight adults which is masked by puberty.
My SIL really hates her weight and struggles to keep it down. At this rate they are setting DN up for the same battle and they just don't see it.

Teapacks · 29/03/2022 15:36

BMI isn't useless. But it's crude and a statistical and not a diagnostic measure. It should be indicative that there MIGHT be problem not definitive that there is one. But a high BMI centile shouldn't just be ignored as it is very likely (statistically) that the individual IS overweight or obese. Not definitive but a high probability. Why people get so angry and annoyed about the BMI I don't quite get. Just accept it for what it is, it's not a judgement, it's just a (crude) metric.

MangyInseam · 29/03/2022 15:35

@Namesrus

My DS was the opposite very tall and thin from birth, got referred to a nutritionist and investigated by the GP. We were told to increase the fat content of what he ate, encourage snacks etc basically the opposite of healthy eating. It didn’t work he still managed his sports and activities but never bulked out. As a young adult he’s still tall and thin, can drop lbs in weight if he’s unwell it’s just the way he is. He really doesn’t get his metabolism from either me or his dad.
Yes, I had this with my first. They wanted me to be adding butter to her cereal as an infant, giving as many mashed bananas and avacadoes as possible, stop breastfeeding her to get more solid fatty food in.

She looked indistinguishable from baby photos of me, or of my dad, to the point that apart from photo quality it would be easy to mix them up.

When I pointed this out to the pediatrician after months of trying to get her to eat more (she already ate plenty and just didn't want more) the silly bugger told me that she'd end up with deficits, and also that I was keeping her in the high chair for too long which was bad for her.

After that I washed my hands of the whole thing and also ignored it when the others all had the same issue. Interestingly my eldest now could possibly be said to have put on a bit too much weight and the others are all beanpoles and make the doctors happy.

bluestarthread · 29/03/2022 15:34

Ignore it, and don’t share it with her. If you’re happy that her diet and exercise are OK then she is what she is. My daughter had the same and was a bit heavy as a child but when she hit puberty that has all disappeared. I’m sure these interventions are very well meaning but are also often unwarranted. Simple measurements so not give the whole picture.

Anjo2011 · 29/03/2022 15:29

I agree with the majority, throw the letter in the bin and give it no more thought. Bodies are all different shapes and sizes and different body shapes can be healthy too . I think the system they use to determine this is extremely outdated. Don’t give it any more head space.

Papayamya · 29/03/2022 15:27

[quote Bostonbullsmumma]@Papayamya I get so defensive as why should my child be humiliated in to being given a letter in front of his mates saying he's overweight. No support was offered to me after either. What was the point in the letter? It's impossible to make a GP appointment and his HV, since we moved, never returned my calls. If he was overweight I'd have sucked it up and done something about it. Please do tell me what the benefit of the letter is? [/quote]
I agree it shouldn't have been given in front of the rest of the class, but the point is that it makes you aware and hopefully assess what he's eating and activity levels- why would you need to see a GP? Self responsibility for your child isn't a bad thing, lots of people (seemingly yourself included) are oblivious to the fact their child is overweight so it's good it's highlighted.

Teapacks · 29/03/2022 15:27

My DD is very overweight too. You don't see it on her. Like yours, she is solid and certainly heavy but you wouldn't pick her out as the fat kid. Of course, part of this is because kids have all got bigger (the reference population for the centiles is from 1992 I believe). Perhaps 40 years ago she would have stood out. She generally fits the right size for her age but certainly she will outgrow waist before height.

The thing is, especially for girls, is that it is a constant tightrope between not making food an issue and trying to address the weight. We limit treats, usually home made food, try to control portion size and encourage her to fill up on less calorific food like veg rather than carbs, ecnourage exercise. She does swimming twice a week, martial arts three times a week, PE at school and we try to get her running around during weekends and other times. We had to try diffrent sports until we finally (thankfully!) found the marital arts that she really enjots.

The thing is that I see that
a) she likes food more than her friends. She isn't picky thankfully but she does polish off her plate and doesn't seem to have a natural off switch that her siblings have and that her friends have. She could easily eat an adult meal and then ask for dessert. She just never really seems full and this makes it hard for her to naturally control her meals
b) she's a bit of a couch potato. She's a kid who'll naturally prefer to sit and read, play lego, do a jigsaw etc. She's not a kid who is full of beans (physically, it's not that she's sitting on screens all day - she's always busy doing something, just not running around). Other kids her age (and her siblings at her age) just seemed to naturally be more physically active

So I feel we're fighting these two natural tendencies that are just part of who she is. In a less obescogenic environment it wouldn't matter so much but these days it does make a difference. We're doing our best with her but at the same time don't want to make her miserable or for food/activity to be an obsession. She'll never by skinny but hopefully we can instill in her as many healthy habits as possible to stand her in good stead in adulthood. Although maybe we're failing as she's still overweight, I don't know.

By the way, we've had visits to the GP and there's no real advice other than what we're already doing. It's really hard.

PinkSyCo · 29/03/2022 15:25

I got one of those letters re my youngest son. I spent approx 7 seconds perplexing, 10 seconds walking said letter to the recycling bin and have wasted not even one more second thinking about it since. You should do the same.

Cstring · 29/03/2022 15:24

I threw my letter out that said my DD was overweight. She was 75th ventile, although not for height, and from age 10 has leaned out, and now aged 13 is a completely normal weight and height.
The only suggestion I will make, is have a critical eye on portion sizes and don’t allow too many snacks.

Bostonbullsmumma · 29/03/2022 15:22

@Papayamya I get so defensive as why should my child be humiliated in to being given a letter in front of his mates saying he's overweight. No support was offered to me after either. What was the point in the letter? It's impossible to make a GP appointment and his HV, since we moved, never returned my calls. If he was overweight I'd have sucked it up and done something about it. Please do tell me what the benefit of the letter is?

NdefH81 · 29/03/2022 15:21

[quote Workinghardeveryday]@NdefH81 something amiss? Like what exactly?

One twin weighs 12 pounds more than the other but they both look healthy and not overweight.

What could be wrong?[/quote]
How old are they?

WhatNoReally · 29/03/2022 15:19

I know most people on here are saying ignore the letter, but in DD's class there were 2 children (1 girl 1 boy) who got that letter. The parents were outraged and everyone supported the in the same way as on this thread (big boned/will grow into it). Both of those children are now very significantly and very visible overweight. It's an early warning sign for you that shouldn't be blithely dismissed.

DoWhatYouLike · 29/03/2022 15:19

You know what I'd do if it were me - throw the letter in the bin, don't see the HV ever again, and carry on with everything you're doing. Your daughter is fine, your GP has confirmed it. HVs are just box-tickers.

My sons are adults now, but Son2 was big from the start - 10lb 13oz born. HVs used to tell me to cut down on his milk/only feed him at set times, etc. I ignored all that bollocks and started him solids from the age of 6 weeks, on pureed apple. He stayed big (compared to other kids who'd been 7lb from birth etc) until he was about 5, and by the time he'd settled in at school, he was fine. He's now 38, tall and slim.

Saz12 · 29/03/2022 15:19

Some people are more inclined to being overweight than others. I don’t believe simple “calories in calories out” stuff - it depends on other things like gut flora, hormones, ratio of brown fat to white, etc etc.

But none of that changes the fact that overweight children will typically become overweight adults and their weight will typically impact their health.

So I’d keep a food diary over a couple weeks, (don’t make it obvious to dc that that’s what you’re doing!), then make an appointment to take her to the GP.

If dc is at a state school then I’d be surprised if the school meals were as nutritionally balanced and healthy as the LEA would claim - ours say all the right stuff, but then give them pizza and chips followed by a cake for school lunch, and the fruit that’s “always on offer” is very (very) far past it’s best.

cantbecoping · 29/03/2022 15:18

OP are you or your husband overweight?

Workinghardeveryday · 29/03/2022 15:17

@NdefH81 something amiss? Like what exactly?

One twin weighs 12 pounds more than the other but they both look healthy and not overweight.

What could be wrong?

irishfarmer · 29/03/2022 15:17

I am only expecting my 1st so I haven't had any experience in this yet. I think doing the food diary is a good idea. Keep track of what she eats in a typical week. The aren't sending out these letters to me mean/ cruel/ give children complexes. They are sending them because a shocking amount of children are over weight/ obese. Many studies show those traits are carried into adulthood.

Phyllis321 · 29/03/2022 15:16

DS was always less lean looking than his friends and nudged into the overweight category at times. At 15 he is tall and slim, almost skinny.
If you're confident she is active with a good diet, don't worry.

Papayamya · 29/03/2022 15:14

@Bostonbullsmumma

I had the same letter- I was really upset and also angry. You only had to look at my DC to see they were healthy and fit. Play sport constantly. If you saw the size of their dad you would understand they are very broad build. I felt my parenting was being judged. My youngest DC is even broader- I'm sure I'll get the same letter. If I'd known, I would have refused him being measured and weighted to avoid him being a government statistic!
Why would you get so defensive about it, perhaps as you know deep down its true?
roseinthegarden · 29/03/2022 15:14

I would just throw the letter out. Stop weighing her and don't make a big deal about food - it may well cause problems down the line.
If she eats well, exercises regularly and fits into clothes made for her age group or thereabouts then she is absolutely fine. As a family you can set a good example for lifelong healthy eating by eating together, encouraging her to help cook meals, make smart food choices and having fun exercising together. Have treats occasionally and don't make them seem naughty or secretive.

Post babyhood I have no idea how much my DC have weighed or where on the growth charts that would put them. Once I got worried when DD1 bulked up about 11 years old but then she suddenly stretched.

Everyone is different, but whatever body type and metabolism you have, it's attitude towards eating that is important. Eat when you're hungry, stop when you're full. Don't fill up on empty calories or sugary drinks.

Trust yourself. The GP has seen her and says she's absolutely fine. She's fine.

MyDcAreMarvel · 29/03/2022 15:13

Can you see her ribs op? With a 4/5 year old you should clearly be able to. I don’t agree with weighing children in school but I do think we have lost sight if what a healthy weight should look like. Google some imagine of school children in the 1970’s/1980’s she should look like the majority of those will.
Healthy food is great but not too much, a 4/5 year olds dinner should not fill much more than a side plate. The melamine plates toddlers use with characters on are the perfect size.

Chasingaftermidnight · 29/03/2022 15:13

I really sympathise because I have a son who was born just over the 99.6th centile for weight and has remained there ever since. He’s lower for height - 91st centile. And the BMI chart puts him as obese. Like you say his weight was a cause for applause from the health visitors when he was a baby. It confuses me to be honest - are babies who are born on the 91st upwards supposed to fall down the centile lines before they turn two?

Anyway, he’s now 2.5 and I took him to the health visitor and the GP recently about it and neither of them were concerned. They said you have to look at the whole picture. My husband is over 6ft 5 and I’m not short at 5ft 8. My son’s head circumference is measuring off the chart and the head is one of the heaviest parts of the body. And he’s tracking the line he’s always tracked. Are you or your husband unusually tall? Does your DD have a large head?

Also, you say she’s on or near the 75th for height. The HV told me that they don’t get worried unless there’s more than two lines difference between the height and weight (so in my son’s case, being on the 91st for height and above the the 99.6th for weight is fine). On that basis, if your daughter’s on the 75th for height and the 98th for weight, that checks out doesn’t it?

Bostonbullsmumma · 29/03/2022 15:12

I had the same letter- I was really upset and also angry. You only had to look at my DC to see they were healthy and fit. Play sport constantly. If you saw the size of their dad you would understand they are very broad build. I felt my parenting was being judged. My youngest DC is even broader- I'm sure I'll get the same letter. If I'd known, I would have refused him being measured and weighted to avoid him being a government statistic!