Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The letter finally came. I’m really upset

485 replies

Hell0G00dbye · 29/03/2022 13:10

Long story short DD has followed the 98th centile for weight since my 37 week growth scan. She has followed it perfectly and consistently which was applauded for the 6 months I breastfed and since then has been a big issue with the HV team. She’s at school and I’ve just received the letter saying she’s very overweight.

What can I do? She eats good, home cooked food, has the odd treat but generally healthy and normal child portions. She’s very active both structured (does dance, swimming and gymnastics) every week and unstructured (walks the 40 minute round trip to school daily, parks and long walks on a weekend, runs around the garden. She doesn’t look fat (to me) but she is solid and does feel heavy to pick up.

The letter says contact the doctor or HV but I’ve taken her before. GP says she’s absolutely fine and will grow into her weight and had no concerns. HV just weighed and said she’s still overweight and to watch portions. Day to day I don’t worry about it as she looks fine and is super active but the letter has taken me right back to her 2 year check and being made to go monthly to the HV for weight checks and their disapproving looks when she continued along her centile.

NB: she has followed the 98th centile but I think the issue is she isn’t 98th for height so her BMI puts her at very overweight.

OP posts:
DameHelena · 29/03/2022 16:22

@Teapacks

Yes but if a kid is very overweight then it's highly likely that they are either eating more or moving less than their peers somehow (although there possibly may be other factors). The OP seems to be doing all the right things (which I guess is what you're saying) and, at some point, it could just be how the child is. And it's REALLY frustrating!!
Sure. In this case though that doesn't sound likely – as you say, she does seem to have a healthy diet and lifestyle. I would guess that it's a combination of BMI being a bit of a vague 'one-size-fits-all' measure, it being just be how the DD is –and maybe there is such a thing as puppy fat! Many (anecdotal I know) posts on here about 'overweight' kids growing thinner as they grow up seem to suggest that.
Teapacks · 29/03/2022 16:19

@Teapacks

Yes but if a kid is very overweight then it's highly likely that they are either eating more or moving less than their peers somehow (although there possibly may be other factors). The OP seems to be doing all the right things (which I guess is what you're saying) and, at some point, it could just be how the child is. And it's REALLY frustrating!!
This comment was for @DameHelena
TrippinEdBalls · 29/03/2022 16:19

@Fridafever

I’m intrigued that everyone thinks they all even out/ shoot up / whatever. That’s obviously not true is it? There are loads of fat teens and adults. I’m a fat adult myself.
Yes, this. People make it sound like there's no connection between being overweight as a child and being overweight as an adult, when in fact the correlation is very strong. Of course it happens to some children but very many will not just outgrow it and every year they're overweight it gets harder to change in the future.
Teapacks · 29/03/2022 16:17

Yes but if a kid is very overweight then it's highly likely that they are either eating more or moving less than their peers somehow (although there possibly may be other factors).
The OP seems to be doing all the right things (which I guess is what you're saying) and, at some point, it could just be how the child is.
And it's REALLY frustrating!!

Ariela · 29/03/2022 16:16

We had same letter for DD1 who was 2nd youngest yet 2nd tallest in her class at that age. She was also the fastest runner over any distance over 100m and could lap the entire year group in the 600m. She's never looked fat, but is sporty and slim.
She's never been skinny size 8 (and nor was I) but has settled at 10/12 and looks very healthy.

DomesticatedZombie · 29/03/2022 16:13

Ach, mothers will be blamed for doing it wrong whatever we do ... should come as no surprise!

DameHelena · 29/03/2022 16:12

[quote Teapacks]@DameHelena

I didn't say my daughter eats adult portions. I said she could eat them if we let her. There's a difference.[/quote]
Yes, I know. My point was the OP doesn't seem to suggest that her DD has a particularly large appetite. (I do recognise that we don't know for sure.)

Teapacks · 29/03/2022 16:11

@DomesticatedZombie

Maybe, Teapacks, but look at the letter in the context of the OPs post:

...a big issue with the HV team...

... HV just weighed and said she’s still overweight and to watch portions

... being made to go monthly to the HV for weight checks and their disapproving looks when she continued along her centile.

I've had similar disapproving, stern talks from the HV (admonishing me for breastfeeding, etc) although in the opposite direction as my DD was always light and small. I think many others have had the same. Fine to use BMI to flag potential issues; not fine to use it as a stick to beat people with.

Of course not. It shouldn't be a stick for anyone. Funnily enough, my DD was exclusively breastfed until 6 months. Then baby led weaning - she fed herself. Still overweight by 2!
Teapacks · 29/03/2022 16:09

@DameHelena

I didn't say my daughter eats adult portions. I said she could eat them if we let her. There's a difference.

DomesticatedZombie · 29/03/2022 16:08

Maybe, Teapacks, but look at the letter in the context of the OPs post:

...a big issue with the HV team...

... HV just weighed and said she’s still overweight and to watch portions

... being made to go monthly to the HV for weight checks and their disapproving looks when she continued along her centile.

I've had similar disapproving, stern talks from the HV (admonishing me for breastfeeding, etc) although in the opposite direction as my DD was always light and small. I think many others have had the same. Fine to use BMI to flag potential issues; not fine to use it as a stick to beat people with.

JoeGio · 29/03/2022 16:08

BMI doesn't take into account frame size. DS is 98th percentile for both weight and height (so even though he's perfectly in proportion the NHS website says he's overweight) - there isn't an ounce of fat on him but he has wide shoulders and chest, wide hips, muscly bum and thighs and a massive head, just like DH. His cousin is exactly the same height but has a smaller head, narrow shoulders, almost no bum and is only about 75% as wide as DS. They are both very active very healthy boys with good diets but no doubt I'll be getting a letter when it's school weighing time.
I do agree that some people are confused or in denial about portion sizes/obesity in children but bmi is a very blunt tool to define health.

SamphiretheStickerist · 29/03/2022 16:06

Why people get so angry and annoyed about the BMI I don't quite get. Some of us it's because we know how out of date the measure is - as in it is 100 years old and has had very little/no updating, depsite the obvious changes in population measures.

www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/255712#is-it-too-simple

And don't suggest fat calipers, cos I have a tale of horror about that. The measure was 'invented' by a gorup of men who went round Texas morgues and pinched the inches of dead Texan men. That formed the fat caliper measure. So forget all about user error and think about how adipose tissues separates from skin after 12 - 24 hours of death; Texan men? Men? When was it recalibrated for a modern society, maybe even for women? Answers on a postcard please...

God how I miss that era of my life - lecturing on health measures and how to laugh at them!

Fridafever · 29/03/2022 16:06

I’m intrigued that everyone thinks they all even out/ shoot up / whatever. That’s obviously not true is it? There are loads of fat teens and adults. I’m a fat adult myself.

BlingLoving · 29/03/2022 16:02

I think people get annoyed when HCPs take the BMI as gospel, rather than as a crude metric, and ignore the various other indicators of health that are also important to consider. @DomesticatedZombie yes this.

After DS lost all his weight, he had his year 6 weigh in. Officially, his BMI is too high. 10 seconds investigation on the NHS website and I discovered they ADMIT that for children who are unusually tall or short, applying age as part of the BMI measurement can give readings that are not accurate. In DS' case, if I stick his exact measurements into the NHS calculator but change his birthday so that he is 12 (I chose this age based on the fact that he wears age 12 clothes, all of which fit him perfectly in both width and length - age 13 tend to be a bit baggy but are also wearable) .... his BMI is considered absolutely fine.

It's a tool, not a bloody diagnostic certainty and it annoys me that so few people see that.

DameHelena · 29/03/2022 16:02

@Hornetfarmer

*MangyInseam*

Have a read of Teapacks post. Really insightful. It's about instilling good habits and being aware of individual circumstances.

But the things said in that post simply don't apply to the OP's DD, who does a lot of sport/activity as well as non-formal exercise like a lot of walking (so is definitely not a couch potato); and there's no indication that she doesn't have a natural off switch or that she eats adult portions.
Teapacks · 29/03/2022 16:02

@DomesticatedZombie
Yes, but the letter the schools sends out is just BMI and, iirc (left the UK so got the letter only with my older DC) just says that your child is on x centile and this is the x category and that you might want to consider taking action if it's not in the normal weight category.

It's such an a valuable public health resource to see changes in children's weight. It would be a real shame if it were scrapped because parents get upset about being told their child is in the overweight category.

Personally, I know my DD is overweight. I know her weight approximately, I know her height, i see her build. I don't need a letter to tell me that. But I have no problem if it will help contribute to the population stats on children's weight.

DomesticatedZombie · 29/03/2022 15:57

@Teapacks

BMI isn't useless. But it's crude and a statistical and not a diagnostic measure. It should be indicative that there MIGHT be problem not definitive that there is one. But a high BMI centile shouldn't just be ignored as it is very likely (statistically) that the individual IS overweight or obese. Not definitive but a high probability. Why people get so angry and annoyed about the BMI I don't quite get. Just accept it for what it is, it's not a judgement, it's just a (crude) metric.
I think people get annoyed when HCPs take the BMI as gospel, rather than as a crude metric, and ignore the various other indicators of health that are also important to consider.
BlingLoving · 29/03/2022 15:49

Assuming your DH is a doctor with some knowledge of this stuff, what does he think?

There is no doubt in my mind that many parents are in denial about their children's weight. Having said that, there's a limit to what you can do when your child is this young and you have to be realistic.

DS was overweight. We knew it. Not crazily so, but clearly overweight. I discussed with the doctor. Her point was that at that age, restricting food is not advised. Exercise, healthy, varied diet is more important.

A few years later, we did have to take a more proactive approach because by then he was more overweight. He was also old enough to understand this. Part of fixing the problem was me and DH, as his parents, taking a long hard look at our OWN behaviour and what WE were doing.

We had to acknowledge that that he WAS having more treats and food that was high in sugar and/or fat than was good for him.

But we also had to acknowledge that as a tall child who genuinely has bigger bones than others, he needed more/different exercise than other children. I came to realise that he wasn't always incentivised to keep moving when he was outside and that he was more of a burst of activity type of kid. But that wasn't going to help him with the weight.

We also looked at his "healthy" food. And had to realise that traditional kids food wasn't good for him. If DD eats something like shepherds pie its a good dish for her - protein, carbs, veg (on side and hidden). But for DS, who loves food, he will eat a big plate of whatever is served to him. if that's shepherds pie, it might be very nutritious but a b ig plate is too many calories. As a good eater, we could switch to serving him the kind of meals many younger children wouldn't eat - a piece of salmon with rice and piles of steamed veg or baked chicken with salad and new potatoes etc - allowing him to have a large portion but without the same number of calories.

None of these things would have happened if we'd continued to be defensive : "but he eats normal healthy food" or "but he does lots of activities and is out and about all the time."

Aubree17 · 29/03/2022 15:45

@WhatNoReally

I know most people on here are saying ignore the letter, but in DD's class there were 2 children (1 girl 1 boy) who got that letter. The parents were outraged and everyone supported the in the same way as on this thread (big boned/will grow into it). Both of those children are now very significantly and very visible overweight. It's an early warning sign for you that shouldn't be blithely dismissed.
I can understand it being an early warning but in this case I don't think it applies. The parents are a healthy weight and monitoring the child's diet and exercise. That's enough.
EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 29/03/2022 15:44

I threw it straight in the bin, didn't help that I'd refused permission but some how he was weighed anyway.

He's like his older brothers who as adults are very tall, well built and perfectly fine bmi

littleangel50 · 29/03/2022 15:43

Best info my children are grown up now centile never heard of it my kids ate healthy with the mantra..eat what you want that I've cooked, none of this eat it all up ..no after school clubs as I worked full time so after school time was my time where we would go out walking playing football they have carried on healthy eating and both weigh look fine..There only complaint was why did I let them have fizzy pop occasionally SmileFootball

Hornetfarmer · 29/03/2022 15:42

MangyInseam

Have a read of Teapacks post. Really insightful. It's about instilling good habits and being aware of individual circumstances.

Aubree17 · 29/03/2022 15:41

@PositiveLife

Chuck it in the bin and forget about it.

My dd was on the 4th centile consistently. She got one of those letters saying she was obese. You could see all her fucking bones, she was so skinny. If anything, she was underweight.

Best advice here - Chuck it in the bin.

Continue the healthy lifestyle.

MrOllivander · 29/03/2022 15:40

I know bones aren't heavier etc but there is different builds
My friend is a petite size 6. If I stripped all the fat off my body, I will still have a bigger frame because I'm 5ft 10 and my shoulders are twice the width! My uncle is a heavyweight boxer and my grandad was a wrestler. I was never going to be a ballerina build Grin
Even age 14/15 and lean, I was a size 12 because my shoulders have never fitted in a size 10 in my life

MangyInseam · 29/03/2022 15:40

@NdefH81

And the Dozens saying “just ignore” are being a little reckless with their health advice I think
Realistically, what other option is there?

Her mum knows what she eats, knows that the portions are fine and the food is healthy, and also that the child is active, that she isn't eating empty calories or snacking much.

She's hardly going to put a child that age on a diet or give her an exercise regime, that would be totally inappropriate.