Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS healthy food guidelines - confusion

118 replies

beatrixpotterspencil · 29/03/2022 12:35

And it isn't just the NHS, there are countless health bodies throughout the western world who still believe we ought to choose trans fatty oils in margarine over butter.
As far as I am aware, margarine has long since been considered a franken-food, yet the NHS is still advising diabetics and those with cardiovascular disease to swap butter for marg, meat for white bread and full fat yogurt for the reduced fat, sugar filled monstrosities.

I am 48, very slim and eat butter, virgin olive oil, meat (usually poultry or fish), full fat yogurt, avocado, cheese, cream, greek yogurt, olives, stuff that is going to kill me apparently since reading about saturated fats on the NHS last night.

I thought the saturated fat = bad cholesterol had been debunked, but according to most health bodies, recent research still posits it as a major contributor to cardiovascular disease and diabetes. It seemed odd to choose to choose a low fat, processed alternative to an already 'healthy' food? (yogurt). So my natural Greek stuff is inferior to a sugar stuffed muller light?

I'm one of those spectacular wankers who makes their own pesto Grin
I must definitely be unreasonable!
So I am well and truly one foot in the grave according to the health service.
When looking for their suggested alternatives to sat fats, most of the recommendations were for white, sugary breads and cereals. It is apparently better for me to chuck down a ton of rice crispies than some microwaved scrambled egg with a splash of milk.

Is this confusing anyone else? My family tended to eat similarly to me and were always healthy/slim. Perhaps it is just genetic luck and we have been juggling with an early death Shock

I don't read a lot about nutrition, but do love cooking and following tasty recipes, so was surprised to read this. Over the years, and especially on MN I have picked up some great ideas and wasn't aware that people were still pushing hydrogenated oils as healthy.
And if they are not, why the heck are so many health bodies promoting it?
Even my own GP said my diet was excellent. I am confused!

OP posts:
WulyJmpr · 29/03/2022 18:49

As a size 8, lifelong whole milk drinker, I was pleased when this research came out s couple of years ago

Times article on study which showed that children who drink whole milk are likely to be skinnier due to feeling fuller and snacking less

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/5dc709f0-2cc3-11ea-a2d1-c31ad393952a?shareToken=1aee84c308f2cf2aabd22c7e09279b70

WulyJmpr · 29/03/2022 18:34

Yes you're completely correct, OP.

It also says choose low fat yoghurts which are in fact full of sugar and calories instead.

I believe it's because the government is lobbied by processed food companies who would rather sell you margarine than butter etc.

Saracenia · 29/03/2022 18:23

I was told by a dietician that rapeseed oil is one of the good oils as it has a good ratio of omega3 to omega 6. It came second after olive oil on a chart she gave me rating oils good to bad.

hihellohihello · 29/03/2022 18:16

I think some of what is good for you depends on your individual requirements. As has been said upthread specific health conditions sometimes require low fat or low sugar.

And everybody develops individual tastes too.

Really the NHS is squewed a little bit because they focus on treating people when something has gone wrong. They can talk about prevention all they want but generally the time a patient would be asked about diet would be in connection with a health issue. A diet for someone with a specific health issue can look very different to a diet a healthy person should be eating.

MyDcAreMarvel · 29/03/2022 18:15

It’s “what are we feeding or kids”

MyDcAreMarvel · 29/03/2022 18:15

vimeo.com/557580047 You should give this a watch @beatrixpotterspencil it was on the bbc.

Gonnagetgoing · 29/03/2022 18:03

I drink skimmed milk as I prefer it and eat flora pro active as it’s supposed to be good for me. Plus cathedral city lighter. I eat low sugar jellies as a snack.

I do like plain normal fat yogurt etc but it’s tricky because people tell you to do lower sugar and fat things.

I can’t stand the Muller Light yogurts they’re tasteless. But some of the lighter options do taste better.

beatrixpotterspencil · 29/03/2022 17:59

@RealBecca

"My family tended to eat similarly to me and were always healthy/slim."

Well then the advice doesnt apply to you. Why dont you ask the NHS, he ones who issued the advice. Perhaps you can educate them..

Touched a nerve?
OP posts:
beatrixpotterspencil · 29/03/2022 17:59

@vivainsomnia

Not all low fat yogurt is full of sugar. I eat fromage frais. This has very low fat and very low sugar.
I'm referring to the stuff like marg, containing god knows how many odd things. I used to love fromage frais, never been able to find it for years!

Of course many low fat foods are delicious and healthy, but sadly I think a lot of the 'advice' out there fails to mention the sheer proliferation of frankenfoods that make up 95% of supermarket shelves. Even 'healthy' low fat (and especially gluten free) crackers and organic packaged foods are often stuffed with hydrogenated oils and whatnot.

OP posts:
RealBecca · 29/03/2022 17:57

"My family tended to eat similarly to me and were always healthy/slim."

Well then the advice doesnt apply to you. Why dont you ask the NHS, he ones who issued the advice. Perhaps you can educate them..

beatrixpotterspencil · 29/03/2022 17:54

I agree someone might wish to reduce fat, but it is important not to replace it with more chemicals and sugar. They also like to make it difficult to work out what some of the ingredients are on packaging. It's definitely worth reading up on if wanting to reduce fat and stay healthy.

Thanks for all of the info and links, I do like a good documentary!
Will check them all out.

Someone mentioned a recent doc on channel 4? Can anyone tell me what it's called or where I could watch it?

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 29/03/2022 17:01

Nothing wrong with skimmed milk, fat free natural yogurt or reduced fat hard cheese if you are trying to reduce your fat intake, as many have a medical reason to do.

lightand · 29/03/2022 16:55

NHS, British Heart foundation, WHO, American heart foundation, Centre for disease control, British nutrition foundation, all agree natural fats especially saturated (like butter) are worse than margarine.

Ah. You mention WHO.
I steer clear of them.

Common sense, for those that have it, make it obvious that butter is going to be best. In moderation of course.

Juniper68 · 29/03/2022 16:49

Have any of you heard of the Pioppi diet?
www.bbcgoodfood.com/howto/guide/what-pioppi-diet

Calandor · 29/03/2022 16:31

Also vegetable oil usually is rapeseed oil. Just check the back.

Calandor · 29/03/2022 16:28

@beatrixpotterspencil

This from NHS regarding reducing fats - it does suggest some obviously healthy stuff but also swapping most natural fat stuff to 'reduced fat' alternatives (so marg, spreads, low fat yog). I've seen the ingredients in some of that stuff and they are ....interesting to say the least.
Obviously a section on how to reduce fat in your diet would tell you to choose lower fat choices.

That's not general 'how to eat better' it says 'how to reduce FAT'.

BIWI · 29/03/2022 16:24

@beatrixpotterspencil

Nina Teicholz

vivainsomnia · 29/03/2022 16:20

Not all low fat yogurt is full of sugar. I eat fromage frais. This has very low fat and very low sugar.

Worldgonecrazy · 29/03/2022 15:36

@pandora206. There is no money in encouraging healthy living, but a lot of money in keeping people unhealthy.

Everyone has been shouting ‘protect the NHS ‘ for the last two years, yet if we really wanted to do this, promoting true long term health should be our main focus. Unfortunately I think many people want a quick fix rather than longer term solutions.

pandora206 · 29/03/2022 15:29

@Worldgonecrazy there has been very interesting research into healthy living over the last couple of decades that hasn't reached the mainstream for some reason (possibly related to commercial interests). It's no wonder people are confused.

EdithStourton · 29/03/2022 15:29

[quote QforCucumber]@EdithStourton

Rapeseed oil isn't good for you anyway.

I thought vegetable and sunflower oils were the 'bad ones' and rapeseed and olive oils were 'good'?[/quote]
According to DH, though it's high Omega 3 (which we tend not to get enough of), it's also high in Omegas 6 and 9 which we tend to have too much of in our diet.

He's not an expert though. He just read a lot about how to improve his diet.

Mangogogogo · 29/03/2022 15:00

@Cluelessmouse

Nhs nutritional advice is horrific My understanding is that the main concern is obesity So ‘less calories’ is the only thing they can focus on Advising people to consider a holistic approach is too much for our stupid brains, and we can’t be trusted to have smaller portions. so they simply go with ‘low fat, low calories’
This is what I wanted to say.. but said better than I could have
Worldgonecrazy · 29/03/2022 14:55

@pandora206 I agree health isn’t just about obesity but it is one of the most visual clues that people may be insulin resistant.

Our understanding of what healthy food is and why certain foods are healthy has expanded greatly in the last 10 years. We now better understand why intermittent fasting works, we know the effect artificial sweeteners have on the brain, we know why combining certain foods is bad, yet unless a person is willing to invest the time and effort to find out and apply the information , very little messaging hits the mainstream.

pandora206 · 29/03/2022 14:47

I agree with OP.

Have a look at documentaries and lectures on the University of California television channel, e.g. The Unsweetened Truth and What We Can Do About It; or FoodGate: The Break-in, the Cover-up, & the Aftermath and various other presentations.

Being healthy isn't just about obesity (in fact it isn't about obesity primarily) - it's about health span and longevity.

Anonymous48 · 29/03/2022 14:44

@beatrixpotterspencil

This from NHS regarding reducing fats - it does suggest some obviously healthy stuff but also swapping most natural fat stuff to 'reduced fat' alternatives (so marg, spreads, low fat yog). I've seen the ingredients in some of that stuff and they are ....interesting to say the least.
This does specifically say it is tips to reduce fat, and to be fair the suggestions would probably reduce the amount of fat you are consuming. The issue of course is whether that is something we should be aiming for, and it does seem to be a rather outdated goal.

But is this advice for people who do need, for whatever reason, to reduce their fat intake, or is it advice that they suggest everyone follow? There's a big difference between the two.