Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this is unfair to DP?

80 replies

CornflakesWithSugar · 29/03/2022 10:48

DP & I were having this discussion last night, looking for some wider views. Apologies if this is long:

I'll start off by saying DP's parents were always quite strict with him growing up, he had a lot of chores/work he had to do, rules to follow as they believed in hard work but they were never quite as strict with his brother.

My DP and I bought our house and moved in together a couple of years ago. When DP was staying at home, he paid £400 dig money per month. His parents didn't need the money as they were financially comfortable but I can understand they wanted to teach DP financial responsibilities etc. DP's parents were very much "do it on your own" people so we got no help from them towards deposit or furnishings when buying our house (my mum is worse off financially so would not have been able to help) but this was fine as we had saved ourselves and were proud of getting our house off the back of our own hard work (I took on an additional part-time job around my main full-time job and DP signed up for all the overtime he could get).

However this is where DP's brother comes in. He is 25 yrs old, a few years younger than DP, but very much a free spirit. I've known him since he was 16 and to be honest he hasn't grown up or changed at all since then. He acts like a child, swings back on his seat in restaurants, plays a lot of silly pranks like you would expect from a teenager and does a lot of stupid dares (I think his friends are of a similar mindset).

Anyway DP's brother never did very well at school, failed most of his exams, he didn't like classroom learning, never did homework/studying and he was always the class clown. Since leaving school he has bounced about various jobs as he wouldn't stick them out i.e. working somewhere for 3 weeks then quitting because he didn't like it. He also did a 5 month stint in the Army but didn't like it either. For the last couple of years he's worked part-time in retail and hasn't paid dig money. All the while DP's parents haven't been as strict with him as they would with DP if he had a similar experience.

After DP moved out his brother decided he wanted his own place. So DP's parents helped the brother look for a flat to rent, helped with deposit and first months rent, furnishing the flat etc. Keep in mind DP was told he couldn't move out until he had worked hard and saved enough of his own money.

Now DP doesn't drive and wants to learn, he mentioned this to his parents a few weeks ago how it would be quite expensive for lessons etc with now paying a mortgage, bills and they said well if you can't afford it you'll just need to stick to the bus. Fast forward to last weekend and we found out DP's parents are paying for the brother to get driving lessons.

DP & I feel like this is unfair. DP spent years paying £400 per month dig money and also saving most of the rest of his wages for a mortgage so couldn't really afford driving lessons and now DP's parents are paying for the brother's driving lessons? Bearing in mind the brother never paid digs and they also substitute his living by paying for his weekly shop etc

Are me and my DP being unreasonable to think this is unfair?

OP posts:
BadBear · 29/03/2022 12:31

I knew a family that was like that with their two children, I was close enough to one day ask why they were treating their two children with such a different approach (obviously phrased it much better to them) the answer surprised me quite a bit. They said that the child they never helped was the one they were actually the most proud of because they felt that she could do it all on her own like they had done. She was strong, she didn't need them. Unlike her brother who was helpless so they felt that they had to constantly support him and hold his hand. They thought that by helping her, they would be somehow destroying the perfect image of their perfect child.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 29/03/2022 12:25

I have a similar situation with my sibling, who if I added up how much they have had off our parents over the years I would probably be very cross.

HOWEVER, the sibling has major mental health issues and is not really capable of professional work. I think that my parents are just doing whatever they can to try and help my sibling to live independently.

There is no point in being bitter about it. One day you might have children with very different needs and I doubt you would be interested in your DIL judging how you manage that. Yes it is annoying, but ultimately Id much rather be me than them.

Ellie56 · 29/03/2022 12:23

I think it is perfectly reasonable to ask PILS why they are paying for DB to get driving lessons instead of telling him to get the bus too, and that on the face of it is seems very unfair.

Imperfectp3rf3ction · 29/03/2022 12:23

What are his parents like as people towards him ?

IF the case is they've actually pushed him because they know he can do it alone vs his brother cannot then I think it's fair. If they seem to favour his brother in any emotional way I would say unfair.

Brefugee · 29/03/2022 12:22

I think the outcome for the parents will be that they are shocked that they are being asked. They have a reason in their own minds why this is which probably seems perfectly fair and reasonable to them.

I really think a lot depends on their answer (my DPs just gave a chunk of money to my bro, then have sent me a similar amount - that i told them i don't need - to me in the name of fairness, which is fine by me, and I would have been fine without it. I appreciate that they thought it through though). If i were DP? I'd mention it, because it may come up in the future that they are relying on DP to step up for them, if they see him as the competent one etc. I would then probably point out to them that their investment in one child and not the other has consequences. Not that I'd leave them destitute or severely struggling, but that the brother should always be the first port of call. Probably. I'm not sure, tbh. It really would depend on their reasoning.

Bethany7 · 29/03/2022 12:18

It's totally unfair O.P
I feel for your husband, he must feel very hurt.

MichelleScarn · 29/03/2022 12:17

I would be swithering as to whether to bring it up. They don't sound like they'd suddenly see the disparity and say 'yes, yes we are treating you differently, apologies'
You'd either have them blow up and the how dare you shouting, or as my friends mum did when similar was happening, broke into huge sobbing tears about how awful the friend was so it became all about comforting the mum, telling her how amazing she was as a parent, and the actual thing for discussion was never allowed to be raised again.

Gimlisaxe · 29/03/2022 12:09

I would have the conversation with them, but keep in mind the fallout of it all,

Like PP have said, this might filter down if you all decide to have children, so if that is in your life plan at all, I would decide how much you want to keep your distance, especially if you are the first, with a friend I saw them have a much wanted baby (and grandbaby) spoilt till 4/5 years later golden child has one and now they dont see their eldest at all. Child suddenly lost their grandparents overnight.

user1488622199 · 29/03/2022 12:07

@whenwilliwillibefamous

OP the phrase, "talk me through why..." may be useful if your DH does decide to talk to his parents. He could say, "one day I'll be raising my own kids, so it's good to understand things like these". As PPs have said it's their money and their choice so there's absolutely no point in him complaining to them, but, that said... once he's heard their side of the story, it's his choice as to how he behaves to them from then on!

If he approaches it thinking there might be a side to it he doesn't appreciate, a positive outcome (or at least not having a huge row) is more likely. Ofc he should then be free to rant and vent to you - I get the people saying it's his business not yours, but to an extent he must be glad you have his back.

This is great advice
autienotnaughty · 29/03/2022 12:01

It is unfair my dh has a similar situation with his parents. Dh has always had to fund himself whereas sil has been helped along the way. It's got worse not better as they have got older. Sil has them running round after her, babysitting , shopping, gardening etc but when we ask for an odd night babysitting it's like we are putting them out.

LittleOwl153 · 29/03/2022 11:57

Sadly I think your husband will always be the golden child to his scapegoat brother. They are not going to change the way they are.

Personally in his shoes I'd withdraw from them. Sort yourselves out as you always have. Don't be beholden to them - but also don't given them the insta photos either. This favouritism will sadly probably continue with whatever kids you might have between you. Either there will be a favourite of yours or when DB has kids his will take priority. Noone needs to be involved in that crap.

Also if you withdraw you are less likely to get dragged into the elder care. Let DB shoulder that as he has had all the benefits so far.

Ohyesiam · 29/03/2022 11:52

Bring it up with them

CornflakesWithSugar · 29/03/2022 11:52

@whenwilliwillibefamous

OP the phrase, "talk me through why..." may be useful if your DH does decide to talk to his parents. He could say, "one day I'll be raising my own kids, so it's good to understand things like these". As PPs have said it's their money and their choice so there's absolutely no point in him complaining to them, but, that said... once he's heard their side of the story, it's his choice as to how he behaves to them from then on!

If he approaches it thinking there might be a side to it he doesn't appreciate, a positive outcome (or at least not having a huge row) is more likely. Ofc he should then be free to rant and vent to you - I get the people saying it's his business not yours, but to an extent he must be glad you have his back.

@whenwilliwillibefamous exactly, we are a partnership and we talk things through together, I know he would be happy to support me if anything came up from my family etc Smile
OP posts:
TheNameOfTheRoses · 29/03/2022 11:51

@JennySpanner, it's not an issue about coveting other people's money. (interesting in itself that you assume this was what the OP is after even though she is clear that it was NOT).

And I think that the attitude of saying 'don't look at what the dbro gets. It's the parents money to do what they want with' is right either.
Because with that money they are sending a clear message to the dbro and the DP. That the parents are happy to not treat them the same. That they doesn't see them the same.

And that's an important information to have about someone, the fact they are happy to be unfair and treat their own dcs unfairly.

What the DP decides to do with it is another matter. He coud get angry. He could decide to go NC. He could decide to brush it under the carpet. Ignoring it altogether won't be possible because it will pop up again and again.

user1488622199 · 29/03/2022 11:49

@lonelydad2022

Yes, you are. He is a grown-up with his own family and expects his parents to pay for driving lessons.
I don’t think it’s unreasonable to want to be treated fairly in comparison to your siblings.

OP I would be annoyed too and would ask why they were like this. I hope they have no expectations of you both as they get older and need more support, they’ll have golden child for that.

whenwilliwillibefamous · 29/03/2022 11:49

OP the phrase, "talk me through why..." may be useful if your DH does decide to talk to his parents. He could say, "one day I'll be raising my own kids, so it's good to understand things like these".
As PPs have said it's their money and their choice so there's absolutely no point in him complaining to them, but, that said... once he's heard their side of the story, it's his choice as to how he behaves to them from then on!

If he approaches it thinking there might be a side to it he doesn't appreciate, a positive outcome (or at least not having a huge row) is more likely. Ofc he should then be free to rant and vent to you - I get the people saying it's his business not yours, but to an extent he must be glad you have his back.

CornflakesWithSugar · 29/03/2022 11:48

@TheNameOfTheRoses

I would let it go too but not because things change etc... as *@maddy68* said. They clearly havent - the expectations for your DP and his dbro are extremely different just right now (eg for the driving lessons) for whatever reason.

However, if your DP doesn't distance himself and accept that his parents will not treat him the same than his dbro, he will get hurt again and again. I personally think it's a shit attitude to have towards your children (adult or not). But it seems that many parents think they shoud be there to support to one who doesn't do well (even though it's out lazyness/can't be bothered etc...) whilst expecting a lot from the ones who is the hardworking sibling.
I'd expect that behaviour to continue so your DP will have to decide where his boundaries are and what he is or isn't happy to accept for the sake of family 'harmony' (and not making waves)

@TheNameOfTheRoses I guess this is true, thank-you Smile
OP posts:
TheNameOfTheRoses · 29/03/2022 11:46

I would let it go too but not because things change etc... as @maddy68 said.
They clearly havent - the expectations for your DP and his dbro are extremely different just right now (eg for the driving lessons) for whatever reason.

However, if your DP doesn't distance himself and accept that his parents will not treat him the same than his dbro, he will get hurt again and again. I personally think it's a shit attitude to have towards your children (adult or not). But it seems that many parents think they shoud be there to support to one who doesn't do well (even though it's out lazyness/can't be bothered etc...) whilst expecting a lot from the ones who is the hardworking sibling.
I'd expect that behaviour to continue so your DP will have to decide where his boundaries are and what he is or isn't happy to accept for the sake of family 'harmony' (and not making waves)

CornflakesWithSugar · 29/03/2022 11:45

@JennySpanner

They're clearly treating them differently and it's not fair. However you can't tell your in laws how to parent their adult children, there's no point looking at what your brother in law gets and keeping tabs hoping you/ your DH will get the same. It not yours or your DHs - it's your in laws to do with as they see fit.

Your only power in this situation is to react to their decisions as you see fit. Your DH can choose to be angry with them for this, etc but you can't demand financial help you are all adults. The consequences of their actions for them could be that it damages their relationship with you and your DH for example.

Don't covet other people's money. Your DH needs to save up for the driving lessons if he wants them. He's done everything on his own so far why stop now.

@JennySpanner yep the plan was always to save and pay the driving lessons ourselves. DP just happened to mention the expense when speaking to his parents before but wasn't asking/expecting help. I think he was just upset when he later found out his brother was getting driving lessons paid for him and his parents hadn't offered him the same
OP posts:
StanleyGreen · 29/03/2022 11:43

@Aprilx

I also find it weird and grabby that you are sticking your beak in. I would not dream of commenting on how my FIL treats my husband versus his two brothers, I wouldn’t even investigate.
Well, good for you. Hmm
TheNameOfTheRoses · 29/03/2022 11:40

@Aprilx

I also find it weird and grabby that you are sticking your beak in. I would not dream of commenting on how my FIL treats my husband versus his two brothers, I wouldn’t even investigate.
Really? You wouldnt comment in something that clearly is upsetting for your DP? That's strange
maddy68 · 29/03/2022 11:39

I would let it go. Parents change over time. Priorities change. Maybe they were not as well off as you think maybe they had a massive mortgage or debts you know nothing about

How they treat their other son has nothing to do with you. Perhaps he also has issues you know nothing about

CornflakesWithSugar · 29/03/2022 11:39

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

It sounds like they see your dp as a capable adult, and his brother as a child, they are probably trying to help him get independence and a reliable job (which a driving license would help with) so they don't have to look after him anymore.

Yes, I agree with this. People who get on with things and make their own way, however much a struggle, are viewed as being much more capable and even 'privileged' - and 'encouraged' with 'tough love' to persevere, whereas those who simply can't be bothered to even try are seen as helpless victims who will never achieve much.

It will be very interesting to see which son the parents expect to be there to help them when they get elderly and need somebody capable and responsible to advocate for them and help organise their lives.

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll very interesting indeed Grin
OP posts:
CornflakesWithSugar · 29/03/2022 11:37

@Aprilx

I also find it weird and grabby that you are sticking your beak in. I would not dream of commenting on how my FIL treats my husband versus his two brothers, I wouldn’t even investigate.
@Aprilx not really sticking my beak in, partner was looking for some wider views and opinions before he speaks to his parents and he helped me write this post. I know there will be a wide range of different opinions which we will respect however I thought that is what mumsnet was for? To get other perspectives on problems or advice on how to proceed in a situation etc
OP posts:
Brefugee · 29/03/2022 11:35

I'd get your DP to ask his parents why: why he paid digs and brother doesn't, why they're paying for brother's driving lessons.

and then depending on their answer just keep them at arm's length. And never ever do anything for them, just pass them on to brother every time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread