Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this is unfair to DP?

80 replies

CornflakesWithSugar · 29/03/2022 10:48

DP & I were having this discussion last night, looking for some wider views. Apologies if this is long:

I'll start off by saying DP's parents were always quite strict with him growing up, he had a lot of chores/work he had to do, rules to follow as they believed in hard work but they were never quite as strict with his brother.

My DP and I bought our house and moved in together a couple of years ago. When DP was staying at home, he paid £400 dig money per month. His parents didn't need the money as they were financially comfortable but I can understand they wanted to teach DP financial responsibilities etc. DP's parents were very much "do it on your own" people so we got no help from them towards deposit or furnishings when buying our house (my mum is worse off financially so would not have been able to help) but this was fine as we had saved ourselves and were proud of getting our house off the back of our own hard work (I took on an additional part-time job around my main full-time job and DP signed up for all the overtime he could get).

However this is where DP's brother comes in. He is 25 yrs old, a few years younger than DP, but very much a free spirit. I've known him since he was 16 and to be honest he hasn't grown up or changed at all since then. He acts like a child, swings back on his seat in restaurants, plays a lot of silly pranks like you would expect from a teenager and does a lot of stupid dares (I think his friends are of a similar mindset).

Anyway DP's brother never did very well at school, failed most of his exams, he didn't like classroom learning, never did homework/studying and he was always the class clown. Since leaving school he has bounced about various jobs as he wouldn't stick them out i.e. working somewhere for 3 weeks then quitting because he didn't like it. He also did a 5 month stint in the Army but didn't like it either. For the last couple of years he's worked part-time in retail and hasn't paid dig money. All the while DP's parents haven't been as strict with him as they would with DP if he had a similar experience.

After DP moved out his brother decided he wanted his own place. So DP's parents helped the brother look for a flat to rent, helped with deposit and first months rent, furnishing the flat etc. Keep in mind DP was told he couldn't move out until he had worked hard and saved enough of his own money.

Now DP doesn't drive and wants to learn, he mentioned this to his parents a few weeks ago how it would be quite expensive for lessons etc with now paying a mortgage, bills and they said well if you can't afford it you'll just need to stick to the bus. Fast forward to last weekend and we found out DP's parents are paying for the brother to get driving lessons.

DP & I feel like this is unfair. DP spent years paying £400 per month dig money and also saving most of the rest of his wages for a mortgage so couldn't really afford driving lessons and now DP's parents are paying for the brother's driving lessons? Bearing in mind the brother never paid digs and they also substitute his living by paying for his weekly shop etc

Are me and my DP being unreasonable to think this is unfair?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PinkSyCo · 29/03/2022 17:00

Maybe your DH’s parents think that it is easier for your DH as there are two of you to pool your money together. That doesn’t take away the fact that the brothers were treated very differently while still at home of course, and I would wonder why that would be and feel quite hard done by if I were your DH.

user1471538283 · 29/03/2022 16:43

My bf has a relative similar to this. Lives at home, pays a pittance and does not support his parent at all. Even though he doesn't receive gifts of money he has had more resources for all his adult life than his siblings.

I would be straight with the parents. You will not be responsible for their care or support. The brother can get on with it.

RedRec · 29/03/2022 16:20

It was the same with my brother and me. I was the responsible, hard working one etc and he was the one who was always bailed out by our parents. I learnt to accept it as realised they thought I was quite capable of looking after myself (I was).
Ps, I would find any grown man who expected his parents to pay for his driving lessons highly unattractive. Ugh.

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 29/03/2022 16:05

I agree with the comments about dp being the adult. We are similar in our family, because i suppose my siblings had their babies much younger than me they got a lot more support. Not in money, but certainly in help with the children etc.
There is no point raising it or being upset about the disparity with your dps parents. Your dp is supporting himself, as he should, his brother is not. You at least can have pride. You could be petty and remember who the favourite was when it comes to elder care, of course!

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 29/03/2022 14:40

I and my brother were like this, he was called no 1 son. They bought him a business, paid for his lesson bought him a car, etc, etc.
I had jack shit.
My dad always said you've always been ok. It used to annoy me a little, but there's nothing I can do about it.
Now I'm just c'est la vie.

esloquehay · 29/03/2022 14:08

Yeah, it's really unfair.
Your DP's bro sounds exactly how I.used to be and I have ADHD.

AKASammyScrounge · 29/03/2022 14:04

I wouldn't raise it with his parents after putting up with their .favouritism. If your DP tackles them about the driving lessons, he'll only come across as childish and demanding. And likely the parents will say that how they spend their money is their own business.Where does that get you?
Either in the middle of a huge row or your DP left feeling pretty and worse than before.
If you:re hoping for the parents to be brought to seeing how awful they have been, you're on a hiding to nothing. Their self justification will be so deeply
entrenched that it cannot be penetrated.
I think you should help your husband to accept then forget it. Don't let a grievance sour him. Cut contact with his parents to a minimum as seeing them and his brother will only stir up old resentments.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/03/2022 14:02

When fil was alive he always said house would be left to 2 sons equally. It would not surprise me if his Mum has changed will so his brother gets house and all contents and DH just gets a bit of money. I know he will be upset/devistated if that were to happen.

Even if it is left equally to them both, that would still be far from fair, considering how much bigger a share of their/her money and resources he has already had.

If he goes out to work, it doesn't sound like he would have been incapable of independent living - just prefers to be a leach all of his life. It's not necessarily an unusual/unreasonable scenario where a 50yo bachelor might live with his widowed mum, but you would fully expect it to be reversed: him to run the house, pay the bills, do the housework and cooking and maybe (grudgingly) accept a very small weekly financial contribution from his elderly mother and the odd cup of tea, i.e. she is the one being looked after, not the other way around.

Unfortunately, even if the will does say that both sons inherit the house equally (or even if it said that your DP gets it all, as his brother has already had his share over the past few decades), actually getting his share would be an entirely different matter.

The brother isn't going to be wanting to move out, and he will see it as 'his home'/'mum and dad's house', so he'll likely expect that the derisory contribution (full service charge) he made before will no longer be due/his DB won't need it or be living in to act as his servant - and would probably even consider your DP the CF to ask for it!!

I suppose he could potentially buy him out with all of that money he's earned and not had to spend over the decades, but even if he would have accepted that as more than fair, I'd guess that he hasn't saved much of it - rather spent the lot on regular treats, the same as any teenager would do if they had started earning but didn't (yet) have their own bills to pay.

Sad to say, I think the best you can hope for is that your children will eventually inherit the house - but even then, he might want to leave his legal half to some random charity or to the young pretty barmaid who always winks at him at the pub.

ImAGummyBear · 29/03/2022 13:50

Absolutely agree with a PP, your DP should ask his parents in a help me understand this way...

The reason being, it will continue, especially after children, more money for this n that then relying more on your DP for help in old age, inheritance etc it will grow n fester however much your DP pulls away unless he goes completely NC. Because they're his parents at the end of the day. And it seems like they have a good relation as you haven't mentioned anything other than them being a bit stricter with him comparatively.

After this talk he can adjust his expectations accordingly. Or he might actually be able to see their view which would help him deal with it.

But some questions are better asked early before they fester.

caringcarer · 29/03/2022 13:24

I understand how you feel. My mother-in-law supports DH brother who is now a 50+ adult who pays a pittance, £50 pw. In doing so she does not qualify for single occupation reduction in council tax. In addition she cooks for him, irons and cleans and pays for his takeaway once a week. He does not lift a finger. You might think as she is 80 if she feels unwell he would be there to help her out but no, if she feels unwell she rings DH. We live over 150 miles away but when she rang DH ordered her an online shop and rushed up at the weekend to clean her house and make a fuss of her. Son who lives at home is odd, he comes home from work and goes straight to his room. He comes down collects his dinner and eats in his room. He barely speaks to anyone including his Mum. I used to get upset for Dh, now I just ignore the behaviour. It is so obvious who her favourite is. I think you will need to learn to do the same and ignore in-laws behaviour. Leave you to DH to either say something to them or not to as he chooses. When fil was alive he always said house would be left to 2 sons equally. It would not surprise me if his Mum has changed will so his brother gets house and all contents and DH just gets a bit of money. I know he will be upset/devistated if that were to happen.

luxxlisbon · 29/03/2022 13:22

The thing is if you had adult children and one was thriving, owned a home with a partner, had a job that earned well and they enjoyed and was on the path for a successful and happy life, then the other struggled with school, struggled to maintain a typical job, despite all your encouragement didn’t seem to thrive in an independent life would you give them both X even though child 2 still fell below the sibling or do you help them both in different ways in order to help them both get to the same end?
Would you help both out with school the same amount even though one is as struggling and the other was flying?

You want both your children to have the same chance at a successful and happy life, but they likely won’t be on the same path to get there.

Would it be more fair for the parents to pay for OPs partners husband even though he owns a home and the brother has little savings or possibly of purchasing a house?

Fair isn’t always equal and different kids need different levels of support.

LagunaBubbles · 29/03/2022 13:15

also find it weird and grabby that you are sticking your beak in. I would not dream of commenting on how my FIL treats my husband versus his two brothers, I wouldn’t even investigate

What a load of pious nonsense, your partner is upset and talks to you about a situation that is really upsetting....and you wouldn't say a thing? Its normal for couples to communicate.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/03/2022 13:12

I think some posters here are going straight for the traditional MN pile-on that usually happens with inheritance threads.

This is nothing whatsoever to do with what you want/expect your parents to provide for you once you've grown up - it's the blatant deliberate unfairness of it all.

We're not talking here about crazy complaints from one able-bodied son that his disabled brother is bought a wheelchair when he doesn't get one too - it's purely like-for-like in scenarios where they both need/would greatly benefit from something equally and one has whatever he asks for handed to him on a plate, his entire life, whilst the other is told that life is tough and he can just get stuffed.

RandomBasic · 29/03/2022 13:11

They're not doing the younger brother any favours. They're making a rod for their own backs and this is where middle aged men who sponge off mummy and daddy come from.

Your husband needs to accept that his parents are not the parents he wishes he had. They are flawed. They will never be able to treat him in a way that is fair. You can't change an adult who doesn't want to change and at some level the parents know they are taking the Mick.

A life lived well is the best revenge.

Don't lend the golden child money or get him out of scrapes. Live your best lives.

luxxlisbon · 29/03/2022 13:09

Fair isn’t always equal. Your partner earned a good full time wage and paid a reasonably low amount for room and board while living at home as an adult compared to moving out. His brother earned less and paid less.

Would it be more “fair” to have made the brother pay £400 if he couldn’t afford it?

It’s weird that he even mentioned to his parents that he wanted to take driving lessons but couldn’t afford it.

passport123 · 29/03/2022 13:05

Life is easier for you now knowing that if his parents need care, you'll be leaving it to the feckless brother to sort out.....

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/03/2022 13:04

This happened with me and my siblings. They still live at home at 26 and 22, rent/keep free. I paid more living there than what I pay now with a mortgage and on my weekly food shop for a family of 4.

My mother totally took the pss out of me.*

It didn't prepare me for independent living, it actually made things really difficult for me emotionally and financially.

However, my sisters have no financial understanding and no desire to move out or home so..:

Your last sentence is key there. Your mother knew that you were strong and capable - albeit not without struggles and hardship along the way - and you were a threat to her dominance. Her answer was to be full-on financially controlling, in a way that she never felt the need to do so with your sisters, as she doesn't see them as a threat to her dominance.

Some terrible parents really do think that their children growing up and gaining independence to live their own adult lives is somehow something to be feared and prevented, rather than the normal way that things should be.

It's no negative reflection on you as a parent when your grown-up children have become strong adults and no longer need you to treat them like toddlers - quite the opposite in fact (obviously not including cases of severe disability and/or learning difficulties in that last bit).

EmpressCixi · 29/03/2022 13:00

The treatment is certainly not equal between the brothers.
However, are you sure there isn’t more going on? Does the younger brother have SEND for example which affects his ability to adult? If not, it could be pure favouritism which is common and most often the youngest child is the spoiled favourite while the oldest child is raised more harshly and is given more responsibility at a younger age.

Gizacluethen · 29/03/2022 12:58

Sounds like it's not fair on DPs brother. Your DP has grown into a mature sensible young man. His brother has been held back and kept a teenager. They've parented your DP better than his brother.

Franklyfrost · 29/03/2022 12:56

People are different, including siblings. The older brother is more able and they have met his abilities. The younger brother obviously has some problems if he can't hold down a job and needs more help. It is unequal but would it be fair if they distributed the money equally and one brother thrived while the other became destitute?

Margaretmatcher · 29/03/2022 12:55

If I were parents to the work shy son I would happily pay for a flat and driving lessons so he is independently living and no longer in my home. Having said that he has no incentive to work harder or become financially independent. Yes it is unfair the way your dh has been treated financially but I think it sounds like your dh has a much better life than his brother after all your dh has achieved has been through his hard work and this was thanks to his parents

BellePeppa · 29/03/2022 12:50

@lonelydad2022

Yes, you are. He is a grown-up with his own family and expects his parents to pay for driving lessons.
I think you’re missing the point. Why is there such a big difference between the treatment of both brothers?
LakieLady · 29/03/2022 12:49

I think it's very common for the oldest child to be treated less favourably than the younger ones.

I had to give my parents a third of my take-home pay as soon as I started work, and I left home at 19. My DB lived with them for nothing, firstly because "He needs the money for driving lessons" then because "He's saving up for a deposit to buy a flat".

My late DP was the oldest of four, and each one was treated more favourably than the one before. I've seen it loads of times with friends, too.

But it definitely isn't fair.

PeachesToday · 29/03/2022 12:40

I imagine they knew the brother would never leave without being pushed.

I feel for your DP though and I would ask them about it.

billy1966 · 29/03/2022 12:37

Sometimes there can be slight differences with children , but the ones you describe are big and ongoing.

Your partner needs to own his upset and not feel bad about it.

He also needs to step back and take some time to reflect on his parents general behaviour towards him.

Favouritism is not good and he doesn't need to be around it if he doesn't wish to be.