Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you believe in 'soul mates'?

80 replies

SummerDays2020 · 29/03/2022 10:32

Influenced by The Wake Up on Headspace this morning.

Do you believe in 'soul mates'?

I don't know if anyone else feels this. But, I believed my ex-husband was my soul mate. I feel that my current partner is my soul mate. Perhaps, as my split from my ex-DH was amicable (although, very painful and still is a bit) and we are still good friends, I still see him as a soul mate. Not sure if that makes sense. But the time I was with him was very precious and our co-parenting relationship is still very important to me. We were together for 17 years. But my current DP I love so much and hope we are together for a very long time. Our relationship is equally precious to me.

OP posts:
incognitoforthisone · 29/03/2022 12:41

Well ... I think it depends how you define 'soul-mate'.

I definitely think DP is my 'soul-mate' in the sense that we completely understand each other and have a connection and an affinity that neither of us have ever had with anyone else.There is nobody in the world I'd rather spend time with.

But I don't believe that were 'destined to meet' or anything like that - it's pure luck. And if we hadn't met, there's nothing to say we wouldn't both have met other people and been happy with them too.

Gotajobthrunepotism · 29/03/2022 12:28

No..: I believe there are lots of people you can be compatible with at different stages of your life. For a life partner: you have to be careful who you choose: but they don’t need to be your “soulmate”. Kindness and mutual respect is much more important to me.

For example; there have been guys I have been strongly attracted to, pre DH. But to marry and have kids with them would have her a complete disaster

Mummyratbag · 29/03/2022 12:28

Not sure what I believe, but there are certain people I have met during my life (not necessarily romantic partners) where I have just thought "I already know you". I'm sure there is a rational explanation, but it feels like instant recognition.

Soffit · 29/03/2022 12:20

Yes, but you don't just have none or one or you can have a few and they are not all based on romantic relationships.

I think it ties into what your beliefs are regarding reincarnation. If you don't believe in some version of reincarnation (there are many) then you cannot believe in a soul that existed in a different physical body before you were born and will transfer into a different living body after your body 'dies' on the physical plane. It is about a memory cycle over many, many years where people may have soul memories regarding having met somebody in a previous incarnation which relates how they relate to the person in this one. Without that belief, it is just about getting along well?

There would be very little point in believing in 'a soul' if it is merely seen as being for the duration of one earthly lifecycle and not on transference of the soul between different incarnations on the physical plane over many lifetimes. That is more like a compatible life partner.

housemaus · 29/03/2022 12:18

No, I don't.

Not in the sense of being someone you're fated to be with or uniquely designed to be perfect together with, anyway - because statistically, as a PP has pointed out, the chances that most people meet that 'soul mate' within a 100 mile radius of where they live is nonsense.

I do think there are people who are very compatible on a kind of indefinable level - my parents are a good example. They've been divorced 20 years but nobody lights them up like each other and they will always adore each other. They are two people who are just... on the same frequency, I guess? (Sounds woo, isn't meant to!).

But even then, I wouldn't call them soulmates, because I think that suggests that that kind of chemistry is more important than the hard, necessary work of a truly good relationship - my parents may still be drawn to one another and clearly very compatible in some sense, but they weren't able to make their marriage work. They couldn't do the daily, weekly, yearly work of loving someone when stuff is hard or you don't like each other much or whatever. The idea of soulmates makes a truly good relationship sound like chance or luck or fate - and I'm firmly of the belief that while that spark and chemistry and compatibility is important, the true beauty of a good relationship is showing up and doing concrete things to make it work. That's romantic to me, not the hard-to-define spark.

Ideally you have both: DH and I are very compatible, he is the person I feel most myself around, I still get excited to see him after he's been at work for the day after almost a decade. But we also put the work in and actively commit to our relationship and that's the bit I'm prouder of, not that we happen to click chemistry-wise.

SummerDays2020 · 29/03/2022 12:11

@Shabtipup

Absolutely. Met him at 16 when we had our first job and started on the same day. It was an INSTANT and UNMISTAKABLE connection, we both noticed it. We were shy teenagers and trust me I've had a lot of crushes before/after that, but it really was something otherworldly the first time I saw him without even speaking to eachother. It was just an overwhelming feeling of "he's the one" and he also told me later on that he was instantly drawn to me too. We did not have a relationship at 16 because his lifestyle was challenging, (drugs, getting kicked out and made homeless etc) and this scared me off. But we remained friends and would check in every couple of years. When I turned 24, I had a strong urge to contact him after a few years of not speaking. We hit it off massively and the chemistry was as strong as it always had been. He was now sober, in a great job, had his own place, life sorted. I left my ex of 5 years for him and now we are together. It feels "right." I have no doubt that he's my soulmate. Weird things happen often like we both say the same thing at the same time and immediately burst out laughing because "it happened again!" We're both just over the moon to have found eachother. I know this all sounds so ridiculous and sappy, but it's true. Soulmates are real and when you meet them it's an unmistakable feeling, you just know. Every cell in your body is saying to you "it's them."
Sounds lovely 😊
OP posts:
SummerDays2020 · 29/03/2022 12:10

@OneTC

I don't believe in anything preordained but in terms of 2 people being ideally matched on many levels (which is actually what it means) then yes I do believe in soulmates. I might not actually call them that but I have several, my OH and my closest friends. To me it means people that I'm so aligned with that meaningful disagreement is almost impossible
I like that definition. I think my 2 best friends would count as soul mates.
OP posts:
SummerDays2020 · 29/03/2022 12:08

@CornishGem1975

Yes, I do. And I don't think there's anything wrong in believing that. Saying that I don't think everyone finds theirs, and it's not saying there's only one person for you. I don't believe that.

My DH is definitely my soulmate. We met when we were younger, went our separate ways and came back together. It's a completely different relationship from anything I've ever experienced. I loved my ex-DH but he was definitely not my soulmate.

I was starting to think everyone was cynical! I'm glad you are happy with your 'soul mate'.
OP posts:
SummerDays2020 · 29/03/2022 12:07

[quote Libertaire]No. ‘Soul mates’ is vacuous nonsense. There are currently 7.9 billion people on this planet (source : Wikipedia). Of those, it is likely that an individual will meet a few thousand during the course of their lifetime, and most of those only fleetingly. The probability of someone meeting their pre-ordained ‘soul mate’ having only met 0.0000001% (or whatever) of humanity is obviously and inherently ridiculous.

I’m very happy with my DP. We have been together for 20+ years and I hope for many more, but (and this is no reflection on him) I can think of at least two other men with whom I could have had happy long-term relationships had we met at different times. Luck plays a massive part in meeting a partner.

Tim Minchin sums it up very well :

m.youtube.com/watch?v=UEyJnwPIr4Q[/quote]
Thank you for that. And yes, I suppose I feel the same. If my ex-DH hadn't become mentally unwell I would still be with him. I suppose it made me feel a bit disloyal to my current DP so I'm glad it is normal to feel like that!

OP posts:
DazzlingDarrenDring · 29/03/2022 11:51

It's absolute nonsense.

If you think you are with your ' soulmate' that's lovely, but you haven't , by an unbelievably random coincidence, found the most ideal person in the world for you.

Shabtipup · 29/03/2022 11:27

Absolutely. Met him at 16 when we had our first job and started on the same day. It was an INSTANT and UNMISTAKABLE connection, we both noticed it. We were shy teenagers and trust me I've had a lot of crushes before/after that, but it really was something otherworldly the first time I saw him without even speaking to eachother. It was just an overwhelming feeling of "he's the one" and he also told me later on that he was instantly drawn to me too. We did not have a relationship at 16 because his lifestyle was challenging, (drugs, getting kicked out and made homeless etc) and this scared me off. But we remained friends and would check in every couple of years.
When I turned 24, I had a strong urge to contact him after a few years of not speaking. We hit it off massively and the chemistry was as strong as it always had been. He was now sober, in a great job, had his own place, life sorted. I left my ex of 5 years for him and now we are together. It feels "right." I have no doubt that he's my soulmate. Weird things happen often like we both say the same thing at the same time and immediately burst out laughing because "it happened again!" We're both just over the moon to have found eachother. I know this all sounds so ridiculous and sappy, but it's true. Soulmates are real and when you meet them it's an unmistakable feeling, you just know. Every cell in your body is saying to you "it's them."

OneTC · 29/03/2022 11:19

I don't believe in anything preordained but in terms of 2 people being ideally matched on many levels (which is actually what it means) then yes I do believe in soulmates. I might not actually call them that but I have several, my OH and my closest friends. To me it means people that I'm so aligned with that meaningful disagreement is almost impossible

Grenlei · 29/03/2022 11:19

No, it's total bollocks.

Goinghome20 · 29/03/2022 11:14

No. Tim minchin is right which is why its soo funny😂

halvahalva · 29/03/2022 11:07

No, don't believe in it. I do believe that people can spend a lifetime together but it's through choice of both parties to opt into that view, not that a different combination couldn't have also worked in the same way.
I'm an all in person, and my partner is equally so, therefore we work. I don't think fate brought us together or that there's no-one else who could have been my husband. I think that kind of thinking doesn't help relationships in general

Jojoanna · 29/03/2022 11:02

Nope ,, you just bond better with certain people

savethatkitty01 · 29/03/2022 11:02

God no. For me it falls into the "everything happens for a reason " crap.

Tonya345 · 29/03/2022 11:01

Not exactly 'soul mate,' which is a way of describing two people who are totally in love with each other.
Life's more complex than that, and the person who might have seemed to be a soulmate, can reveal their faults and idiosyncrasies later on.
In fact both parties often do.
Have a look at the relationship board - I presume all these people thought they had found their own soulmate at one time.

CornishGem1975 · 29/03/2022 10:59

Yes, I do. And I don't think there's anything wrong in believing that. Saying that I don't think everyone finds theirs, and it's not saying there's only one person for you. I don't believe that.

My DH is definitely my soulmate. We met when we were younger, went our separate ways and came back together. It's a completely different relationship from anything I've ever experienced. I loved my ex-DH but he was definitely not my soulmate.

Libertaire · 29/03/2022 10:58

No. ‘Soul mates’ is vacuous nonsense. There are currently 7.9 billion people on this planet (source : Wikipedia). Of those, it is likely that an individual will meet a few thousand during the course of their lifetime, and most of those only fleetingly. The probability of someone meeting their pre-ordained ‘soul mate’ having only met 0.0000001% (or whatever) of humanity is obviously and inherently ridiculous.

I’m very happy with my DP. We have been together for 20+ years and I hope for many more, but (and this is no reflection on him) I can think of at least two other men with whom I could have had happy long-term relationships had we met at different times. Luck plays a massive part in meeting a partner.

Tim Minchin sums it up very well :

m.youtube.com/watch?v=UEyJnwPIr4Q

Gowithme · 29/03/2022 10:56

Well if you just mean 'two people ideally suited' then yes I believe in soul mates I guess (although I wouldn't call it that personally as it's a bit twee to me). If you mean it was destined to happen, written in the stars and your souls will be entwined in heaven forever - then no.

AhhhHereItGoes · 29/03/2022 10:54

No.

Some people fit us better then others but soul mates is fairytale stuff.

SummerDays2020 · 29/03/2022 10:53

@oldwhyno

I think it's just some people's way of describing a particularly close relationship. Not much more to it than that is there?
Yes, I think it is that. I think when I was younger, I believed that could only happen once. But with more life experience, I see that it can happen more than once.
OP posts:
oldwhyno · 29/03/2022 10:42

I think it's just some people's way of describing a particularly close relationship. Not much more to it than that is there?

SprayedWithDettol · 29/03/2022 10:41

No.