Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if it was my fault..

33 replies

seamonkeys · 28/03/2022 23:40

Where to start. Split with my ex after 10 years a few months ago and me and the kids (5 year old and 6 month old) moved out.
I applied for universal credit, got job interviews, started seeing someone else (who has been nothing but lovely)
Ex said he wanted to talk, so I agreed.
There's were his points why he ended it

  • his tea was never ready for him (he WFH and said he preferred to cook, when I do cook he hovered over me and for the 9 months of pregnancy I had hyperemesis)
  • I gave up work to be a 'housewife' but I wasn't a good housewife. I didn't do much with our eldest apart from sit him in front of the tv while I sat on my phone
  • because he earns a good wage I didn't have to work or worry about bills and I didn't appreciate it
  • I made his parents feel 'outcast' (they chose to move to Cyprus so we barely saw them)
  • when he said he was leaving before I went on tinder and he found out. He said he "can't get over' this and the fact I spoke to other males in messaging sometimes.
  • I wasn't affectionate and he didn't get much sex ( he would sulk if I turned it down)
  • I didn't support his hobbies (he plays paintball at £80 a go once a month)
  • I didn't support his career. I was jealous he had a career and hobbies and I didn't.
  • i didn't care about the kids!

He then cried and said he had nothing as he moved up here for me, but can't be miserable as he was with me and during his this talk I didn't say the "right things" (I think he wanted me to cry say I was sorry and I'd have his tea on the table every night)

I actually felt ok and was enjoying life a bit again and dates with the new guy until this. Now this has messed my head up.

Was I so in the wrong? If he didn't want me why say all this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FangsForTheMemory · 29/03/2022 20:03

@BluebellsGreenbells that's brilliant!

OP, he was hoping to bully you into being a 50s housewife and you've got on with your life instead. You don't owe him explanations or anything else. Next time he starts whining, say 'tough shit'.

Enjoy your life.

Mrsmadevans · 29/03/2022 19:43

He's jealous of you moving on without him and he wants to come back .
Ignore the saddo, he needs to get a life just like you have finally got one .

Iloveyourbracelet · 29/03/2022 19:40

When i left my ex he had a huge long list of all the things that were wrong with me. Made me wonder why he wanted me back so bad if i was such a terrible person!

BluebellsGreenbells · 29/03/2022 19:19

- his tea was never ready for him (he WFH and said he preferred to cook

‘I’m fed up of cooking and didn’t appreciate it’
- I gave up work to be a 'housewife' but I wasn't a good housewife

‘I’ve just found out that housework is hard work and never ending m’

- because he earns a good wage I didn't have to work or worry about bills

‘I still have to pay bills and can’t complain about it to anyone else’

- I made his parents feel 'outcast'

‘My parents complained I never see them and I used to blame you’

- when he said he was leaving before I went on tinder and he found out. He said he "can't get over' this and the fact I spoke to other males in messaging sometimes

‘I’ve just discovered dating is difficult when I used to get sex at home’

- I wasn't affectionate and he didn't get much sex

‘I’m now not getting any sex and it’s still your fault’

- I didn't support his hobbies (he plays paintball at £80 a go once a month)

‘I’ve realized playing paint ball is expensive now I can’t afford it, but I’ll blame you for that as well’

- I didn't support his career. I was jealous he had a career and hobbies and I didn't

I now have to look after myself, cook clean and do washing and shopping, and that’s your fault’

- i didn't care about the kids

‘I’m struggling to have the kids 50/50 but I’ll blame you for that as well’

autienotnaughty · 29/03/2022 12:07

That's his interpretation of your relationship, it doesn't mean it's accurate you have your view and if you are happier single then don't go back. It's usually a mixture of reasons why a relationship fails with fault on both sides and there's always plenty to be learnt from a break up but don't let this define you. You deserve to be happy with the right person.

seamonkeys · 29/03/2022 11:57

I did have days where we would just stay in the house while I did housework or had lazy days on the sofa. But I did also take him to groups, we tried swimming, we'd go for walks or to the park, or just a walk round the shops. When he was 18 months we moved to a really rural area where there wasn't as many classes locally. Then when he was 3 obviously lockdown came in. He's now in reception and his teacher just told me his reading level is the highest in his class and way above average, so it clearly didn't do him any harm.
I maybe didn't have his tea ready when he walked in every night but I did all his washing, ironing (he very rarely re wore stuff, think I ironed 17 shirts in one sitting once) kept the garden nice, picked up the dog muck etc, picked up his clothes he would just leave on the floor, kept the bathrooms clean.. stuff he just didn't see I don't think.

OP posts:
user1471457751 · 29/03/2022 11:37

Only you can know if there is truth in what he said, all these posters calling him names don't actually know what went on in your relationship. If a woman said a man was the sahp but just stuck kids in front of tv all day while playing on his phone posters wouldn't be supporting him.

It's clear the relationship is dead but please be careful about jumping into a new relationship.

JohannSebastianBach · 29/03/2022 11:33

There's no chance anyway dear because you're an arsehole....

Gowithme · 29/03/2022 10:52

It's all irrelevant he's just clutching at straws to make you feel guilty and go back to him.

Crazy that even though you've split up and moved out he still expects you not to see anyone else. If he wants to know just tell him truth, you're doing nothing wrong.

EKGEMS · 29/03/2022 10:43

@seamonkeys Oh dear he's a really manipulative idiot isn't he? If you were 'so awful' as a wife and mother why is he upset you've moved on with your life? He really is a chauvinist pig! Go out to dinner take your mind off him and spend it with an emotionally mature man.

seamonkeys · 29/03/2022 10:31

Thank you Thanks he's made me feel really guilty about seeing the other man (he doesn't know that I am) he's saying he isn't talking to anyone else, isn't interested etc and if I'm seeing anyone then there's no chance at all for us as I "cared even less then he thought if I can move on" I haven't seen the other man for a couple of weeks and he's asking to take me out for a meal tonight while ex has our baby to take my mind off it, but I don't know whether to go or not now.

OP posts:
JohannSebastianBach · 29/03/2022 09:33

I personally wouldn't bother trying to have your say.

He's convinced himself all this is true, probably because it means he doesn't have to examine his own behaviour.

Try not to let it bother you. You sound like you have healthily moved on. Live your life and be happy.

Sprucewillis · 29/03/2022 09:24

You don't have to listen to it OP Thanks

seamonkeys · 29/03/2022 09:11

Thank you all. I should've said even though he's calling it 'housewife' we actually weren't married. The wedding was cancelled due to COVID.
I'll never give up anything because I trust a man again. I wish I had kept my career, because he's keeping the house as he can afford it and I can't.
I admit going on tinder was wrong, but it was after he had told me he was moving out and said he'd had viewings of flats and houses! I know it was a bit of a knee jerk reaction and I had no intention of meeting anyone on there, but he had told me it was over. Then used it months later as a 'reason' why it's over.
I didn't actually ask him to tell me these things, he said he wanted to 'chat to either get closure or see if there is anything salvageable'
It was quite literally just reeling off everything I did wrong. I was that taken aback I didn't really have my say!

OP posts:
Margaretmatcher · 29/03/2022 08:44

He didn't want to talk he wanted to lecture you on how awful you are, which he did. Now you know the error of your ways he would like you to go back and perform better. Now you know what it's like to be free of this knob you can carry on enjoying your new life.

ukborn · 29/03/2022 08:03

So he wanted to discuss his side of things - fair enough (and did you really go on tinder while still living together? You can't have had much invested in this marriage ).
So what - he's entitled to his feelings, and it's rare to actually be able to voice them. Whether they are true doesn't really matter. The relationship is over, he's had his say, you seem happy to have moved on. End of.

DrManhattan · 29/03/2022 08:03

Hes a mess. Dont entertain any more of these conversations. You have moved on

WeCouldBeSpearows · 29/03/2022 08:02

Do you want to go back to a guy that sulks if you don't have sex and wants dinner on the table every night, and has pretty much set out that those are his demands if you get back together? Because if anything, that'd giving him ammunition to be even more of a dick, because he'll say that you agreed to it when you got back together?

You sound better off where you are.

Ponoka7 · 29/03/2022 08:01

"He’s realized that he misses having ‘someone’ at home doing the childcare and house work, and now if he wants a relationship he’ll have to work at it, he’s realized cooking and cleaning and childcare is hard work and wants you back to do those things and sex, because it’s ‘easier’ than starting again."

Yep to that. The on-tap sex with Instagram models that lots of resentful men think is out there, just isn't. Not without a lot of effort and money being spent, that is and still not for most men.

Don't tie yourself to putting someone's tea on the table every night. No woman should be just a housewife, a stay at home mum, yes, but not tied to the house and serving a fully functioning adult.

When you treat your wife like a housekeeper generally they work out that there's better terms and conditions on offer, which you have done. He hasn't left you broken hearted, which says a lot. Don't accept what he is saying. He isn't chatting compromise and meeting in the middle. It's all what he wants, he has stopped seeing you as a person.

RoastedFerret · 29/03/2022 07:57

Is there a reason that you care what he says? It sounds like you were perfectly happy both this time and last to split up and move on so I would just ignore what he says, it seems like you weren't that into him anyway.

Turningpurple · 29/03/2022 07:57

I don't think yiu should worry about it too much, unless you think there's some truth in parts of it. If there is, still just think about it in relation to the next relationship.

That's his point of view, wether he is right or wrong, it's his

You obviously have a different one. Ita just more proof that it being over is a good thing.

Sprucewillis · 29/03/2022 07:56

@JohannSebastianBach

Sounds to me like he has just confirmed that you were 100% right to end this relationship.

He sounds like a 1950's husband.

This... And now he's negging and punishing you for having the audacity to get over him.

Slow down a bit though. Give yourself some time (and your DC) to adjust to the new status quo.

twominutesmore · 29/03/2022 07:50

Did you ask him why he ended it? I am just wondering whether he was responding to questions or just went straight in with his list.

Is there any truth to it?

Do his reasons, even if they are partly true, really matter if you have moved on and enjoying your new life?

It doesn't sound like there will be any sort of reconciliation, certainly not one where you're both suddenly compatible, so I think you should just continue building your new life and he should start to build his.

I guess it is a shame for him if his family are a long way away and he would like to move back, and could do so as he wfh, but his dc are here, but that is something he will have to work out for himself.

JohannSebastianBach · 29/03/2022 07:07

Sounds to me like he has just confirmed that you were 100% right to end this relationship.

He sounds like a 1950's husband.

Totalwasteofpaper · 29/03/2022 06:55

Your new life sounds good.
His expectations for me ... are laughable. I wouldn't be happy living like that.

The accusations about you.notncarong about the kids and being a shit mum. Only you can know.... but it you are so awful and he is so azing why isn't he going to court for gull custody or enhanced shared???

I can't imagine why you would... bit Do you want him.back ? Your post reads like you might. Personally i wouldnt look back

Swipe left for the next trending thread