Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lazy dd doing minimum work

114 replies

Member786495 · 28/03/2022 21:35

Dd16 is more than capable of 6/7s for her GCSEs but is doing not a jot of revision at home. Predictably she’s now looking at 4/5s.

Her lack of drive is killing me and I need some perspective.

Aibu to keep on at her, driving her mad and possibly stressing her out, just for the sake of some higher grades? Or should I persevere safe in the knowledge that it’ll all be over in 2 months and she’ll be grateful in August.

I’ve tried reasoning, bribing, bought every guide available and past papers and even worked out schedules with her which are ignored. She’s too tired, and ‘doesn’t want to’.

Shall I just give up and leave her to it?

OP posts:
HollowTalk · 29/03/2022 20:02

I think you need to sit down with her with a big sheet of paper and play a game called "play that movie to the end."

She needs to consider two options: one is that she carries on the way she is, has to resit her exams, has to be in with a new group of people, can't resit her strongest exams, is in a class with people who are messing around. She will be watching her friends go to do A-levels or BTECs and make new friends and start their adult lives.

The second route is where she does some work, joins those friends at sixth form and can get onto better apprenticeships or a degree course.

What I used to tell my students though is to think of that moment when you open your results. How does she want to feel in that moment?

clary · 29/03/2022 19:31

I have had to produce certificates to show my O level passes in certain subjects to train to be a teacher. Not for anything else tho, and they only needed to be a pass.

Disagree with pp saying GCSE grades are not important - they are. It depends what you want to do next but higher grades will keep more doors open. If your grades are lower, you are not a failure nor are you doomed, but most sixth firms want 6 in chosen A level subjects and many unis want that sort of grade as well - or at least, may look at GCSE grades for a competitive course. So you need to do as well as you can.

Sorry OP I don't have any good answers fir you sadly. But you may need to step back and leave her to it.

TieBack · 29/03/2022 14:35

Yes, savehannah professional qualifications and two masters degrees.

savehannah · 29/03/2022 13:33

@TieBack

sashh, public sector here and I not only had to state my GCSE grades, I had to provide the certificates.
Do you have any higher qualifications? I'm genuinely not being snooty. It's just that my experience has been that once I had A-levels nobody was interested in my GCSEs and once I had a degree nobody was interested in my A levels. The fact you have a degree proves you must have got adequate gcses and a-levels, or you wouldn't have been accepted onto the course. In fact I don't think I've ever been asked for my degree certificate for a job app.
savehannah · 29/03/2022 13:21

I've given up with mine. At the end of the day there are things I'm more worried about than whether she gets a 5 or a 6.

As long as she gets enough to get onto the college course she wants to do then it doesn't really matter. Obviously I'd love her to work harder and get 7s and 8s but I'm not willing to be the bad guy any more than I already am. It's her life. She's now realised she needs to work at maths because if she doesn't pass she won't get on the course she needs. I'm hoping when she's studying something she's really interested in she'll work harder at it.

Dixiechickonhols · 29/03/2022 13:14

My DD’s choice for A levels need 6 x 6s (high B) and specify grades in some subjects too, I know history needs a 6 to take it at A level think Maths may be a 7. Someone with 4 x 4s would usually not usually be suited to or accepted on A level courses (obviously exceptions a local college took some from a school on lower grades as school was inadequate/now closed and they hadn’t been taught)
Is she automatically going down A levels as that what siblings have done. I’d have a chat at Easter she must have some idea of future.

soootiredddd · 29/03/2022 12:58

Someone else may have asked this but what is she doing when she should be studying? Social media etc?

I have a load of nieces and nephews this age and also teach 18-19 year olds and a huge number of them are academically able but also semi professional time wasters. My 21 year old niece can easily spend ten hours a day on her phone doing zero activities with any productivity (ie she is not busy creating an online business or doing research, she is watching make up tutorials and learning tik tok dances). But she is enabled in her behaviour by my brother and his wife who allow her to live at home rent free, bill free, doesn’t even pay for her own food. I see a lot of my students like this, who struggle with motivation and put in minimum work but who also have parents who do their food shopping for them online and have it delivered to their door for them and send them vouchers for just eat so that they don’t have to do any cooking, and who bail them out left right and centre.

I’m aware I’m sounding very old fashioned. But in my opinion it’s not about how much you go on at them to study. It’s about how much they are allowed to live a life free of responsibility and consequences more generally. Does she do chores? Have a part time job? Have any sort of drive or motivation or requirement to DO anything more generally? Hobbies or interests that she works hard at? If the answer to these is no then the lack of studying is symptomatic of a broader problem.

TeenPlusCat · 29/03/2022 12:51

@Lacedwithgrace

GCSEs rarely mean anything these days. As long as she passes at a 4 or above, she'll likely do just as well as her peers achieving higher grades.
That's really not true. Most colleges have minimum requirements for A levels and specific subjects need higher grades. So only getting 4s when she is capable of more unnecessarily closes doors. GCSEs aren't the be all and end all, but passing them to the best of her capability keeps options open.
zingally · 29/03/2022 12:42

[quote Member786495]@GinInATina yes we had a tutor but she just stopped going...

Has no real idea of what she wants to do post 18, which makes it more difficult. Has been exposed to a whole manner of opportunities and experiences, and is funny, engaging and can be charming.
Just lazy too.

It seems the consensus is to leave her be.[/quote]
To be honest, in my experience, people who are "funny, engaging and charming" get much further in all areas of the life than the nervous little bookworms.

PennyPencils · 29/03/2022 12:41

@Daffodilz

I'm also the owner of one of these lazy 2006 models. It would rather play on the PS5 than do any blinking work. I think August will be hard.

I worked my ass off.

Me too! I swear mine is too lazy to think sometimes

'Mum, what month is it?'

Lacedwithgrace · 29/03/2022 12:36

GCSEs rarely mean anything these days. As long as she passes at a 4 or above, she'll likely do just as well as her peers achieving higher grades.

VagueSemblance · 29/03/2022 12:29

fab crosspoint @DogandMog. Thank you

D0lphine · 29/03/2022 12:18

Honestly I think GCSEs are pretty important for progressing to next level and also in job applications.

However I don't think there is much you can do. You cannot force a 16 year old to work hard, you can only put things in place to enable her success. This could look like a desk in room, quiet time and space to work, encouragement and praise, treats for working hard. You can explain to her that the exams are important for her future and inspire her by saying if you get x grade you could go on to do this cool job.

But if she doesn't want to do it, that's on her.

DogandMog · 29/03/2022 12:09

Ha! cross-post LegMeChicken

DogandMog · 29/03/2022 12:05

VagueSemblance, I think, from reading MN over the years, I'm fairly sure I have inattentive ADHD, but that wasn't known about back then. So, from the context of the time I grew up in, I wish they had listened more, and been more attentive to how I was rather than how they wanted me to be, and to see things from a wellbeing pov, rather than a moral/disciplinarian perspective. They were authoritarian and I wish they'd had an authoritative parenting style instead, based on imparting wisdom, and letting me come to my own decisions and choices of actions with their guidance. I wish I'd been offered help and changed situations/schools, but their attitude was "what has she got to be depressed about, we're a stable, comfortably-off family?".

LegMeChicken · 29/03/2022 11:51

*ADD

LegMeChicken · 29/03/2022 11:51

@DogandMog

No amount of cajoling, chivvying, shouting, punishments, reality chats about exam grades leading to great opportunities and outcomes vs dead end jobs made a jot of difference with me. My parents tried to be strict, but I simply always refused to do any homework/revision, so they cajoled and shouted at me more, making it a million times worse. I didn't refuse to do my work because I was a bad kid, or having too much fun elsewhere. I did it because I had chronically low self esteem, from being bullied by my peers, some awful teachers, and my parents' over strict/punitive parenting style destroying what was left of it. I can never get started on things, so underperformed on university coursework, hobby evening courses, had crappy low paid/temping jobs, housework, sorting the garden, you name it. Had years of therapy of no use, to get to the bottom of my shame/procrastination complex. It's far more than simple "laziness".
At the risk of being an MN armchair diagnoser you sound like you have ADHD...
Dixiechickonhols · 29/03/2022 11:49

I find my 16 year old has best chats with me in car, side by side is less confrontational.
I’m surprised she’d be accepted for A levels at 4/5. Even if she can scrape on course will she cope with them. Or are you setting yourself up for 2 more years of stress. Would an apprenticeship or vocational be better fit?
I know you’ve helped with revision but my DD’s issue was they haven’t covered syllabus so it’s teaching self rather than revising. So if you are going on about revision and she’s thinking I can’t revise I haven’t got anything to revise. She’s 16 and might be burying head in sand rather than saying what issue is.
What are her friends like? Mine wants to go to sixth form with her friends so that helps.

VagueSemblance · 29/03/2022 11:47

@DogandMog I'm sorry to hear this. I hope you have found some peace. How do you think your parents could have best helped you? (Asking for a friend...Smile)

DogandMog · 29/03/2022 11:35

No amount of cajoling, chivvying, shouting, punishments, reality chats about exam grades leading to great opportunities and outcomes vs dead end jobs made a jot of difference with me. My parents tried to be strict, but I simply always refused to do any homework/revision, so they cajoled and shouted at me more, making it a million times worse. I didn't refuse to do my work because I was a bad kid, or having too much fun elsewhere. I did it because I had chronically low self esteem, from being bullied by my peers, some awful teachers, and my parents' over strict/punitive parenting style destroying what was left of it. I can never get started on things, so underperformed on university coursework, hobby evening courses, had crappy low paid/temping jobs, housework, sorting the garden, you name it. Had years of therapy of no use, to get to the bottom of my shame/procrastination complex. It's far more than simple "laziness".

user1471443411 · 29/03/2022 11:12

If she only gets 4s and 5s it may be that her grades aren't enough to study A levels, especially in the subjects she wants to take. Could you take her to look at some other departments in college - hair and beauty, IT, art and design etc? And tell her she needs a back up option just in case.
I don't know what you can do to get her to study, my dd is the same, but I wouldn't give up on her. Could you get her to work through some past papers in the subjects she finds trickiest? Maybe use some bribery as a reward for doing a bit of work.

Supersimkin2 · 29/03/2022 11:06

Talk her through what a life on minimum wage is like. A long life.

That did it for my mate the surgeon.

VagueSemblance · 29/03/2022 11:05

What consequences/outcomes have meaning for her? She clearly isn't bothered about the risk of having to put low grades on her CV when she's 40, so what other angle can you find that means more to her?

Like @teenpluscat I would also be worrying about what will change in Sept to get her re-engaged in her studies. College isn't magically going to re-engage her in a subject she'd checked out of at school. Is it worth looking up some vocational routes that might be needed if she doesn't get the grades, and more importantly might catch her interest more?

Also are you really sure that she has all the study skills she needs? This cohort's confidence is very low, and they might need a bit more handholding in revision techniques, planning etc than previous years. Procrastinate or checking out can easily be hiding a crisis of confidence or unsureness of what to do, especially at this age.

DogandMog · 29/03/2022 11:04

If her problem is recreational laziness, eg hanging out with mates, rehearsing in a band, sport etc, anything that's genuinely meaningful to her, albeit short-term... then bribery... give her a bigger reward than she'd get from doing her activities.

If her problem is psychological laziness, ie task avoidance, you need to look into the deep roots of procrastination from a psychological/neurological perspective and find strategies for dealing with that. Perfectionism can play a big role... if you can never do things perfectly enough for your ideals, you might see that it's not worth doing that at all to avoid the deep sense of shame of being "imperfect". Obviously that thought pattern needs recalibrating. You might be able to get through to her by framing a question such as "What am I saying yes and no to, by choosing to, or not to revise?". Or have a look at this article for ideas

adhdboss.com/adhd-task-avoidance/

OnTheBenchOfDoom · 29/03/2022 11:02

The only thing I will say is you or both of you might want to check the actual grades achieved at A level by the college for the subjects she will possibly be studying. ie if you come in with a grade 4 at GCSE for say History what A level grade do they expect them to achieve? What about the child who was a 7 at GCSE?

It is all well and good saying just get onto the next stage but A levels are harder than GCSEs obviously. If they are getting 4/5s what sort of grades would the sixth form expect that child to get?