Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that pub roast dinners are crap?

185 replies

ThreeRingCircus · 28/03/2022 15:03

I know I'm being a bit unreasonable as you can't make roast potatoes etc to order so they're always going to have to be reheated at a pub..... probably the same with Yorkshire puddings but we went out for a roast for Mother's Day yesterday and although it was delightful in that I didn't have to cook the food really was disappointing.

Roast potatoes that aren't crispy on the outside, yorkshire puddings that are too soft, weird thin watery gravy and never enough of it. I don't think I've ever had a really decent roast at a pub even when it's a good pub and it's cost a fair bit of money.

I genuinely think I could have saved the £60 pub bill yesterday and bought a load of Aunt Bessie's stuff for a tenner and done it at home for zero hassle and it would have been a lot nicer.

Are there magical pubs out there that do amazing roasts or do I just need to accept that if I want a decent one I have to cook it myself?

OP posts:
SiobhanSharpe · 28/03/2022 17:34

Leathery roast potatoes and underseasoned Yorkshires cooked without enough fat are major problems with pub roasts IMO.
The meat can be ok but the vegetables are underwhelming, unseasonal and dull. This time of year they should be using sprouting broccoli or spring greens, plus root veg like parsnips, carrots or swedes. It's not difficult to have a pan of buttery mashed swede or honey roast parsnips to hand instead of tasteless courgettes, French beans flown in from Kenya or flabby mangetouts. And there's no excuse for the ubiquitous and dull frozen peas in any meal I'm paying for.

thesparkthatbled · 28/03/2022 17:25

Totally agree. There a few things more disappointing than turning up at a pub looking forward to a lovely pub lunch, only to find they're only doing Sunday roast.

Fernandina · 28/03/2022 17:22

Chances are that the pub had been let down by some of its kitchen staff, and they were doing the best they could in the circumstance. it often happens on occasions.

We went for a meal on Valentine's Day once, and the food and service were terrible. We were one of the last to leave the pub later on and the landlord came over and apologised, saying that all three of his waitresses hadn't turned up for work that evening, and nor had one of the two chefs. So he, his wife, and the one remaining chef had been running around like blue-arsed flies trying to cook and serve all the customers. When there should have been 7 staff, they only had 3, and of course being Valentine's Day, the restaurant was fully booked.

SiobhanSharpe · 28/03/2022 17:22

Catering for vegetarians alongside a roast dinner isn't too difficult.
I normally do a mixed mushroom pie of some kind, like large field mushrooms and a few shallots, roasted briefly in butter and garlic and put into a pie dish with puff pastry on top, baked and served with a rich gravy made from red wine, madeira, soaked dried porcini mushrooms and their liquid, a little creme fraiche and splash of soy sauce.
Can all be prepped beforehand and just baked at the same time as the Yorkshires, while the meat rests.
Obviously this wouldn't work for vegans!

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 28/03/2022 17:18

I've only had 2 incredible pub roasts in my life. Now prices are so much higher, I can't see us going for one for a while.

PacificState · 28/03/2022 17:18

Lived in Brighton years ago and came here to say it's the only place I've ever had nice roast dinners in pubs! (Veggie option in my case but still lovely)

I wouldn't class a home cooked roast as an 'easy' meal. It's not technically difficult, but getting seven or eight different things ready-but-not-overcooked at exactly the same time is really stressful, even with a double oven.

knittingaddict · 28/03/2022 17:15

It's nearly always the roast potatoes that are a let down in a pub. Some of them seem to think that saturated fat is the devils own food and roasties are so often dry and unappetising.

Also no roast is complete without cauliflower cheese.

MrsGHarrison87 · 28/03/2022 17:13

I like carveries where you can serve yourself, otherwise you never get enough gravy and it's too dry.

Lockheart · 28/03/2022 17:13

It's always the Yorkshire puddings - pub / hotel ones are always too dry, hard, and cold. It's obviously a side effect of being made in advance of course, not that they're bad chefs per se, but I've never found one that can hold a candle to my mum's (I'm still perfecting mine Grin) which is the perfect combination of hot, crispy and fluffy.

I know what you mean about the roast potatoes too. Often very pale and more boiled than roasted (although still often a bit hard). I can see they've been shown some fat at some point in the process but not nearly for long enough!

I have had some amazing beef at Sunday lunches out, however.

knittingaddict · 28/03/2022 17:11

There's somewhere near where we live that does the most incredible roast dinners. Honestly never had a meal like it. I cook a good roast myself and there's always something not quite right about some elementwhen we eat one in a pub or restaurant. This was perfect in every way. I'm not sharing though as it's hard enough to get a table as it is.

DisforDarkChocolate · 28/03/2022 17:09

There are three great ones near me. Never go on Mother's Day though, it's worse than Valentines Day for eating out.

KirstenBlest · 28/03/2022 17:05

I can't really comment on pub roast dinners as I don't eat meat, but I agree that a meal out is usually disappointing. I prefer to go for a meal that i wouldn't cook at home

It certainly wouldn't be risotto, butternut squash, beetroot, mushroom or goats cheese.

BlingLoving · 28/03/2022 17:04

With a lot of pubs it's about timing I think. A really good restaurant/pub will be able to plan better to serve out portions as they go but a lot of pubs just whack a certain number of joints in the oven at different times and then carve them until they're done, then out comes the next one. I've had fantastic roast dinner at our local.... and some seriously disappointing ones.

The best roast dinner at a pub I ever had was years and years ago when gastro pubs were still sort of new. What I remember most about it was that they'd been quite clever - it was rib of beef so big slabs of meat with decent marbling so I imagine if it had been sitting/resting for longer, no problem (vs thin slices of meat that quickly go grey and overcooked), vegetables that looked like they'd been finished off as we ordered etc.

We were a big table though so it's entirely possible that, for example, all the roasties and yorkshires genuinely were finished off to order as they could probably do a full tray for our table alone and we were certain happy to sit boozing in the meantime!

BloodyloveGeorge · 28/03/2022 16:55

Oh, we do live in Brighton BTW...

BloodyloveGeorge · 28/03/2022 16:54

I can think of 4 pubs off the top of my head where the roasts are so good you would almost weep with happiness eating them! Our city is known for roasts tho...

Whelmed · 28/03/2022 16:54

Yanbu. Worst is when you go to a place that has been recommended by friends and it turns out just meh. Then you have to give a polite answer when they excitedly ask if you loved it and you don't want them to get defensive about it. Pubs are best for those indulgent salty, fatty treat foods.

nomistake · 28/03/2022 16:51

Agree with the first poster - you need to get yourself to Brighton, basically a city sport to make the best roast!

Youdoyoutoday · 28/03/2022 16:50

Id say you're going to the wrong places!

Pub up the road is fully booked months in advance on Sundays for their roasts, because they are just so well done!

However I can do superb roasts at home but do like to go out for meals I can't perfect at home like my favourite greek/turkish coal grilled lamb, Indian and Thai food.

Floods123 · 28/03/2022 16:47

Big chains like Toby Carvery or Harvester are rubbish but here in Devon we are spoit for choice with some amazing independent pubs. Local does 2 for 18 quid and its walking distance! Cheaper and less hassle than cooking

PupInAPram · 28/03/2022 16:46

The Wharf in Manchester. You will not beat those roasties. Nom.

InkySquid · 28/03/2022 16:38

The 'best' pub roast I've had was just ok. The food this pub normally serves is great so it was still a disappointment.

doris9034 · 28/03/2022 16:37

We were only saying the other day how so many people rave about "going for a roast" - but whenever we've had one, even at highly recommended places, we've always been a bit underwhelmed. I'd rather spend my money on a really nice joint from a proper farm shop and get DP to cook at home

Tuala · 28/03/2022 16:35

@YoYoYoYoSup

There is a lot of competition in Brighton and a Facebook page where people rate roasts in Brighton pubs, it’s very popular. Ones I’d recommend would be The Southern Belle, Secret Companions, The Engineer, The Victory Inn. Or look up Brighton Sunday Roast Club on FB to see al the pics with reviews!

iklboo · 28/03/2022 16:33

Ours was really lovely yesterday. Then again, all the food at the place is.

NameChangeCity123 · 28/03/2022 16:30

Completely agree. They do nothing for me I'm afraid