Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not contribute

60 replies

narcdad · 28/03/2022 09:32

Got a letter hand delivered this morning from a house in the high street asking for a £200 contribution to resurface the back lane behind a row of houses (mine included).

The houses all have access to this lane and they use it to park their cars in their garages as there is no street parking due to the houses being on a high street.

I am the last house and do not use this lane as it's difficult to get my car in our garage as it's at a right angle, I also have a drive that fits 2 cars (I am not on the high street but adjoining road). Also my part of the back lane is in very good condition as I don't use the lane to drive down, so no pot holes etc.

AIBU to not contribute? They have stated in the letter that the contractor can do the work on Friday 1st & Saturday 2nd April and have included those bank details!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DogInATent · 29/03/2022 13:03

£200 actually sounds cheap for that kind of work

Not really. For a back lane a couple of loads of road planings are ideal and not expensive. But they're generally only available when there's roadworks being done, so the short timescale may reflect availability of the materials.

EllaPaella · 28/03/2022 20:07

£200 actually sounds cheap for that kind of work so I would personally be wanting to know what group discussion had been had and that any work planned would have been after at least two or three different quotes. You have literally no proof that the work will be done or any details of what or who is doing it. I wouldn't be handing any money to anyone without knowing a bit more. If it was legit then I would pay it as just because you never use it doesn't mean that everyone else should pay for your share (if they don't use it either).

Lennybenny · 28/03/2022 19:56

Unless it was completely official with company details, I would think its a scam. Don't pay it either way. What do the neighbours say about it?

Seriously have you thought someone might be trying to scam everyone and then everyone pays £200 and then the work doesn't get done.

BurntEnds · 28/03/2022 18:58

They've not given you much notice! And no, don't just send money to someone who's put their details through your door.

TheRealistBub · 28/03/2022 18:56

Ownership unclear
Not asked beforehand

It's a nope from me.

DogInATent · 28/03/2022 18:45

[quote narcdad]@DogInATent good points, I'll have to go through the deeds as I believe we do have rights of access, our house had an extension by the previous owners and the council said they'd need to create another parking space as the house is now a 5 bed (it's a loft conversation with 2 single rooms)

There is a side ally to gain entrance to the back garden which I share with my neighbours as it's a terrace.[/quote]
The other thing you can do is buy a copy of the Land Registry Title Plan online. You can do this for any property that's registered - it might be worth not just getting your own, but those of a couple of neighbours too (maybe one from the main road) to compare. It only costs £3 per property.

www.gov.uk/search-property-information-land-registry

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/03/2022 17:45

I'm going to compose a reply and I'll post it here before I send

Dont forget to check your deeds first Wink

It really is as simple as "you're responsible for it or you're not", and it's best to find out for sure

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 28/03/2022 16:52

@RiojaRose

I don’t think I’d respond to that at all. No need to.
I agree - I’d wait for the inevitable knock and then be like wtf did u expect to them
balalake · 28/03/2022 16:42

Asking someone to find £200 at five days notice? No-one heard of the cost of living crisis.

Tigerblue · 28/03/2022 16:35

Forgot to say, you do need to know what's in your deeds, but might be worth speaking to your neighbours to find our what's in their deeds. Unless someone has messed up, all deeds for properties in the road should have the same thing in them.

Tigerblue · 28/03/2022 16:32

[quote narcdad]@BarbaraofSeville we own the property and never use the lane at all which is why our part of the lane is immaculate it's all grass which my husband and neighbour mow, the high street part is full of pot holes due to constant use, some useful advice thank you [/quote]
You really need to check your deeds. If your husband is mowing the grass, I think under the law it could be argued you accept responsibility for it (a bit like when it's not clear who owns a fence, often the person who pays for repairs accepts responsibility). If you are responsible for a share of maintaining the lane, you might be able to request the grass bit is left as it is, but you'd still have to pay. What you don't want to do is create a dispute over access, as it could easily put someone off if you come to sell if the situation isn't clear or there's been a dispute.

Do you need to cross over the lane to get access to your garage? If so, there must be something in the needs about a right of way or maintenance.

RiojaRose · 28/03/2022 16:25

I don’t think I’d respond to that at all. No need to.

FairyCakeWings · 28/03/2022 16:13

Who is this person that expects to be able to just drop his bank details through your door and end up £200 better off within a week?

Fuck that, that is not how things work in the real world.

Assuming it is all legit, I wouldn’t pay. If it bothers the other neighbours they can pay. It doesn’t bother you so you have no need to pay.

Good luck with your reply. Keep it short and factual and don’t apologise!

TheHoptimist · 28/03/2022 16:11

Resurfacing may need drain work.

GrolliffetheDragon · 28/03/2022 16:06

I lived somewhere with an unadopted back lane that was in a right state, very overgrown and all sorts dumped there. I would have loved something like this to happen - if it were all done properly and above board. Which means proper meeting with all residents invited, someone from the council there perhaps, or some sort of official communication from them and so on.

thecurtainsofdestiny · 28/03/2022 15:56

Surely it's not ok to do work on land that you don't own!

Canigooutyet · 28/03/2022 15:35

A couple of links that might help find out who owns the road.

www.gov.uk/guidance/highways-england-land-and-property-ownership-enquiries. Takes about 15 working days. Oops so missed their payment demand deadline!

www.manchester.gov.uk/info/500344/roads_and_transport/1954/road_ownership_usage_and_plans/2 this is the link for Manchester but other councils should also have the same info.

ButterfliesAndPancakes · 28/03/2022 13:38

I’d be telling them to jog on. Unless I was formally consulted about this then I wouldn’t even consider it. I mean, firstly how do you know that the work will even take place? Secondly, did the ‘organiser’ of the work properly vet the people doing the work. Did they get quotes or is it their mate down the pub. Stay well away.

MinnieGirl · 28/03/2022 13:31

This sounds very dodgy to me…

First, you need to establish who owns the road. Phone the council and ask them. If it’s a public highway, ie anyone can drive down there, then the council should repair it. If it’s private lane, you need to find the owner. If it’s not in your deeds, I doubt you own it, but it should say something about right of access.

You can’t start work on a road that doesn’t belong to you! And the neighbour who is asking for money is risking getting into very hot water….. there should have been consultations with all the affected neighbours, and then if everyone wanted to proceed, three quotes should have been obtained, and agreement as to who would hold the deposits, who would c0-sign etc etc. you don’t just ask for money to be put into her account!

Have a word with the council they are usually very good at sorting these things out. And they will know who owns the road and if there are rights of access and any planning restrictions.

If the neighbour calls round, I would say you actually thought of calling the police as this sounds so dodgy…. And you are not prepared to proceed without proper consultation and tender process

narcdad · 28/03/2022 13:16

@DogInATent good points, I'll have to go through the deeds as I believe we do have rights of access, our house had an extension by the previous owners and the council said they'd need to create another parking space as the house is now a 5 bed (it's a loft conversation with 2 single rooms)

There is a side ally to gain entrance to the back garden which I share with my neighbours as it's a terrace.

OP posts:
eldora · 28/03/2022 12:56

YANBU, you're right not to pay. Is there anyone else who doesn't use the lane? I'd be speaking to warn them too.

magicstar1 · 28/03/2022 12:49

Surely if your end is grass then you won't want it resurfaced anyway? Let the others pay and finish before your part.

DogInATent · 28/03/2022 12:43

[quote narcdad]@DenholmElliot to be honest I don't know who owns it, it is not on our deeds, it's an access road for access to garages for houses in the high st and the side road, the houses on the side road all have driveways [/quote]
How can your deeds not mention it @narcdad ? You require right of access to cross it to get to your garage.

If it was mine, and you're the end house and will genuinely never use it to access either your garage or garden/property, I'd be wanting to establish who's it is to see if I could fence across it, extend my garden, and bring the garage within the garden area. But I'd be asking myself if I really would never use it - is there access to the rear garden from the front? Would I be creating an awkward situation that might make the property difficult to sell in the future (and whether this would matter to me - it might not depending on your age and future plans)?

narcdad · 28/03/2022 12:40

Such good advice from people, thanks for responding, you've given me some idea of how to respond as I am as a bit shocked when I got the letter.

I'm going to compose a reply and I'll post it here before I send.
Thanks all

OP posts:
billyt · 28/03/2022 12:09

Be careful, Narcdad. Look at what was said after Rod Stewart paid, and helped, resurface the road around his house.

His local council said it shouldn't be done privately due to future issues, claims, etc.

All depends on who owns the lane I suppose, but I certainly would not be contributing anything with a couple of weeks to decide, before thoroughly investigating.