Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Esther Walker just as bad as Giles Coren?

115 replies

cousingregsgal · 28/03/2022 07:09

There have been lots of threads about Giles Coren already, but I read an article on Ukraine written by his wife, Esther Walker, and I think she’s just as bad as him.

I know this was published last week but I’ve been catching up on news after a big work deadline and was totally shocked at this article Esther wrote about the “emotional labour” of talking about what is happening in Ukraine with her 8 year old. This is a week after Giles’ article about being totally bored of Ukraine. What is The Times thinking? It’s completely tone deaf and the worst sort of first world problem for Esther to complain about her “emotional labour” from the safety of one of the Corens’ multiple residences while Ukranian families are being shelled as they try to escape cities that are being bombed. Can’t she put Newsround on if she finds the “emotional labour” of it all so unbearable? Bloody hell, lady. Go and volunteer for the Red Cross or something rather than whinging on about your “emotional labour”!

Is Esther Walker just as bad as Giles Coren?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Sailorsusan · 28/03/2022 14:32

Nobody is shutting down the thread? Giles Coren has definitely benefitted from nepotism. I thought that was a given. I expect even he admits this.

DaffTheDoggo · 28/03/2022 13:57

@RaquelOak Not trying to shut down discussion, just think it's weird for someone to post screen grabs of what some random strangers on another site think about something, in response to posters not agreeing with you. Who cares? There's a link to the actual article so people can make up their own minds if they wish.

cousingregsgal · 28/03/2022 13:55

This comment about “husband and wife teams” at The Times seems particularly apt in light of all the threads debating whether of not Giles is a beneficiary of nepotism.

Is Esther Walker just as bad as Giles Coren?
OP posts:
RaquelOak · 28/03/2022 13:53

I would call it an attempt to stimulate discussion rather than to "shit stir" by the OP. I am always amazed at all the Mumsnet police who try to shut down any discussion that they disappove of. Why don't you move on to another thread? [Top tip: there was a fascinating one about a woman who used find my iphone to look for her airpods and discovered that her husband was in Spain when he said he was golfing in Portugal.]

DaffTheDoggo · 28/03/2022 13:42

@cousingregsgal

I agreed with the commenters in The Times. I thought it was a pointless and tone deaf article.
Yes, you said that in your first post- not sure what the screen grabs are adding. This whole thread just seems like an attempt to shit stir.
Sailorsusan · 28/03/2022 13:41

Well, these days everything is 'tone deaf'. I do worry about talking to my son who is the same age about it. I can worry about this as well as worrying about refugees who are being bombed and nuclear weapons. Being worried about people is not a finite thing.

NdefH81 · 28/03/2022 13:40

Right

So we are all meant to go

“Wow look at those comments from complete stranger! Ok OP, you’ve persuaded me!”

Grin

You changed your name to stay a bitchy thread, posting a picture from tattle. The act you go on tattle is really all we needed to know op

fridgepants · 28/03/2022 13:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request.

fridgepants · 28/03/2022 13:37

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request.

cousingregsgal · 28/03/2022 13:35

I agreed with the commenters in The Times. I thought it was a pointless and tone deaf article.

OP posts:
DaffTheDoggo · 28/03/2022 13:29

The most liked comments from the Times commenters on the article

So what?

cousingregsgal · 28/03/2022 13:17

The most liked comments from the Times commenters on the article. (For full disclosure these were taken from Tattle).

Is Esther Walker just as bad as Giles Coren?
Is Esther Walker just as bad as Giles Coren?
OP posts:
cousingregsgal · 28/03/2022 13:00

These are some of the most popular Times commenters on the article (taken from the vile cesspit that is Tattle for full disclosure).

Is Esther Walker just as bad as Giles Coren?
Is Esther Walker just as bad as Giles Coren?
OP posts:
DaffTheDoggo · 28/03/2022 12:47

I like Esther and have no issue at all with that column- it's about her life as a mum, she's not comparing herself to someone in Ukraine.

Have only looked at Tattle Life once after reading something Sali Hughes wrote about it and it's the nastiest and most depressing website I've ever seen and the people on there seem obsessive and bitter- definitely not somewhere to hang out if you want to keep a sense of perspective.

Miriam101 · 28/03/2022 12:39

*her

Miriam101 · 28/03/2022 12:39

It's a perfectly reasonable, if slightly "so what-ish", piece. Unfair clickbaity headline which if I were here I'd be pretty pissed about.

MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 28/03/2022 12:35

I don't know much about Esther Coren though I would be wary of anyone who chose to have Giles Coren in their life, never mind their bed. But nice people can be married to shits so I will hold fire on judging her for that.

Victoria Coren pissed me off a couple of weeks ago when simpering about what a nice guy Evgeny Lebedev and what lovely parties he threw.

LittleGwyneth · 28/03/2022 12:30

@NdefH81 It's a fair cop! I will own to the fact that I worked with EW for a while, like her very much and find comments about how awful she is hard to ignore. I should very much leave these things alone, but sometimes can be a bit weak about it.

DuvetHugger · 28/03/2022 12:19

Fact that you are even on tattle OP, speaks volumes

this. vile site

NdefH81 · 28/03/2022 12:19

[quote LittleGwyneth]@RaquelOak It's not unregulated. You can report people to the ASA for all sorts of violations.

Tattle life is honestly the bitterest place I've ever been on the internet - aside from an investigation into incels. The number of posts where women are complaining it's 'not fair' that someone got send a free pram 'they don't need' when they themselves 'really need one' is just madness.

It's all part of this culture where you diagnose someone as 'problematic' because you think they have more than they deserve and you resent it. We're increasingly unable to say 'I just don't like her', it has to be that they're evil and bad.

You might well find the Coren thread funny but imagine if it was you they were writing about. You only have to have 10K followers on any platform to be considered Tattlelife fair game. A couple of viral post and apparently it's okay for anyone to say anything horrible they want about you? A friend of mine ended up quitting her entire career because she couldn't handle having so many horrible things said about her parenting, her face, her body, her friendships, her house - the list goes on.

Honestly, I think the more time you spend in a place like Tattle the worse it is for your soul. Marinating in mutual hatred is never going to make you a happier person.[/quote]
I agree a lot with what you say in principle

But I do wonder why someone so impassioned would even click on this thread title? In fact, there’s a heck of a lot of marinading in mutual hatred on mumsnet full stop!

RaquelOak · 28/03/2022 12:15

Was her career being an influencer?

NdefH81 · 28/03/2022 12:07

@Momicrone

Schools2023 - giles coren - just lols and bants eh? Hmm
Well pretty much, yes
LittleGwyneth · 28/03/2022 11:50

@RaquelOak It's not unregulated. You can report people to the ASA for all sorts of violations.

Tattle life is honestly the bitterest place I've ever been on the internet - aside from an investigation into incels. The number of posts where women are complaining it's 'not fair' that someone got send a free pram 'they don't need' when they themselves 'really need one' is just madness.

It's all part of this culture where you diagnose someone as 'problematic' because you think they have more than they deserve and you resent it. We're increasingly unable to say 'I just don't like her', it has to be that they're evil and bad.

You might well find the Coren thread funny but imagine if it was you they were writing about. You only have to have 10K followers on any platform to be considered Tattlelife fair game. A couple of viral post and apparently it's okay for anyone to say anything horrible they want about you? A friend of mine ended up quitting her entire career because she couldn't handle having so many horrible things said about her parenting, her face, her body, her friendships, her house - the list goes on.

Honestly, I think the more time you spend in a place like Tattle the worse it is for your soul. Marinating in mutual hatred is never going to make you a happier person.

RaquelOak · 28/03/2022 11:09

@LittleGwyneth

Honestly I think it takes a very unhappy, very cruel person to enjoy being on Tattle life. It's just wall-to-wall complaining that certain types of people have more than they 'deserve'.

Pay for journalism. Read the article. Form an opinion based on the actual article, then come back and complain about her if you've still got a problem.

I disagree. I think Tattle life is quite interesting as the whole world of the influencer is like the wild west as far as unregulated advertising goes, and so people are naturally sceptical about whatever influencers are being paid to promote and the way that they market themselves and their families. I think Tattle exists to challenge and debunk the self styled narratives of influencers. It's not actually that different from Mumsnet and the thread about the Corens is very funny.
LittleGwyneth · 28/03/2022 10:48

Honestly I think it takes a very unhappy, very cruel person to enjoy being on Tattle life. It's just wall-to-wall complaining that certain types of people have more than they 'deserve'.

Pay for journalism. Read the article. Form an opinion based on the actual article, then come back and complain about her if you've still got a problem.