Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To move DD to another school?

180 replies

AlJalilia · 28/03/2022 01:30

DD is 9 years old and in Year 4. We are not in the U.K. In her class are 17 boys and 5 girls. DD was good friends with 2 of the other girls for years. They were a happy group of 3 and had many play dates, etc. We never expected this to change. The other 2 girls in the class don’t really mix, one plays solely with the boys, the other likes to stay on her own. The boys have their own groups and don’t really mix with the girls.

A few months ago, DD’s 2 friends turned on her. They pushed her out of the group of 3 and now DD is alone. They are ignoring her on their shared online game, they rub DD’s face in it every time they have a sleepover without her, etc.

School are powerless to do anything but have arranged counselling for her. The counsellor said she has “come to terms with the new friendship situation” but I can see it is breaking her heart.

She saw them both out at the weekend and when they saw her, they just started whispering to each other. These two girls used to be her best friends.

DD is a lovely, kind, beautiful child. She doesn’t deserve this.

There is another school locally that we could potentially move her to. However, it is highly selective and DD is an average child. She would need so much tutoring to even stand a chance of being offered a place. However, if she did get in, there would be many other girls who she could be friends with.

I just don’t know what to do. Help me Mumsnet. My heart is breaking for her.

OP posts:
Thereisnolight · 28/03/2022 09:48

@Doona

The other girl likes to stay on her own? So there's this girl wandering around on her own every lunchtime? Why? That's really concerning!
Haven’t read full thread but I agree with this. Your DD may have been as much to blame as anyone in this toxic little class. If it was my DD I would now move her - I’ve been in a similar position and I moved my DD this year and she’s much happier. Hopefully a larger class will be less toxic and every child will have a chance to find a friend.
theemperorhasnoclothes · 28/03/2022 09:44

Unfortunately in my experience this sort of behaviour is quite typical of year 4 girls, but as PP have said it can change VERY quickly. It's only been a couple of months.

The school can and should be ensuring there is no bullying behaviour in school, so keep pushing on this.

I doubt the other girl is on her own through choice - could you invite her for a play date after school? Or the girl who likes playing with the boys? Spending time with the other girls in the class and/ or the boys is the obvious choice here, even if they're not natural play mates for your DD.

My DD went through something similar and it is heartbreaking to see as a parent BUT she learned a lot from the episode. The school were good at making sure the children didn't exclude others at playtime (even the girls who liked to try and exclude others) and they all learned to get along with a wide range of children they perhaps didn't have the most in common with and this has been really helpful for DD in secondary school.

Having said all this if your DD remains really unhappy over a very prolonged period then moving schools is an option, and schools with larger cohorts can be easier I think. I do think it's a big step to take over a 2-3 month falling out though, and I do think this behaviour is quite normal at this age, there is no guarantee it won't happen elsewhere.

Lindy2 · 28/03/2022 09:32

If she did get into the academic school it sounds like it's likely she'll be towards the bottom of the class in ability. That's not going to boost her confidence.

The sporty school with places seems like a much better option. She is more likely to start enjoying some of the sports played that to enjoy being bottom of the class. Sports are good for team building and establishing friendships too.

Alternatively look at state schools. They are usually bigger so a bigger potential friendship pool and have a broader range of abilities.

A school with such few girls in a class isn't great at all. I think a lot of girls would struggle with just being with the same few girls every day for years and years. Especially so as they don't seem very nice. I can't believe what some people pay for with private education.

BuanoKubiamVej · 28/03/2022 09:26

Unless you live in a country where the culture tolerates or encourages selective abortion of female foetuses, there's surely got to be another accessible school where the rest of the girls are.

I wouldn't be trying to tutor an average-ability child to get into a highly selective school. She wouldn't be happy.

She can't have her former friends back. It's not in anyone's power to make that happen. She can try to engage with and get to know the girl who is always alone, or to join the other girl and play with the boys too.

doingmydoodie · 28/03/2022 09:13

@AlJalilia What is the sporty school like in terms of pastoral care etc? Do you have any friends/acquaintances with children there? Schools do quite often have reputations for one particular strength, but - and I assume you're talking about the independent sector here - that generally just means that it's a 'super-strength', and that everything else is pretty good, too. If it's a nice, friendly school with a wide range of girls (and boys) with whom yours could be friends, that might be a good solution. I'd have thought it would be stressful to be coached through an entrance exam if the child then finds it difficult once they are there - I think that might be setting your daughter up for different problems. I'd investigate the sporty school if I were you.

Shockedmama · 28/03/2022 09:13

I would consider giving this a little more time? Is there anyone else in the class you can encourage as a friend? Outside clubs?
As horrible as it is once they stop being able tp affect your daughter they will
Turn on each other and that will be good for your daughter to see! Things can change very quickly and your daughter will
Come out of this the other side stronger wiser and confident to handle toxic friendships.

TabithaHazel · 28/03/2022 09:05

It sounds really hard, but I do wonder about the other two girls in the class - did the little threesome exclude these girls and now it's your daughter's turn for that treatment? I can't really imagine a girl of that age truly being happy to be alone all the time as you've described one of the other two girls in the class.

In terms of moving her to the selective school, if she would need so much tutoring to get in then how would you expect her to cope while she was there - the phrase out of the frying pan into the fire springs to mind!

I think the only thing you can do is to try to build her resilience and move her focus away from the two former friends so they just become background chatter in her mind, not a big gaping hole.

Swayingpalmtrees · 28/03/2022 09:04

Go for the sporty school op!
The entrance exam is potentially going to be a less than positive experience if she doesn't get in. Sporty schools are healthy happy schools, she is only young you might be surprised yet at her talents and abilities.

The other girls were moved for good reason. The girl on her own is unlikely to stay. Eventually all will move, so you may as well get your dd out of there now.

Comedycook · 28/03/2022 08:56

I'd move her. My dds primary class is very boy heavy...very few girls. Thankfully she has a small group of friends but it hasn't been easy and I wish she had never been put in that class

JurassicPerks · 28/03/2022 08:56

Don't rule out the sporty school.

MynameisJune · 28/03/2022 08:54

I too would try the sports school. My eldest seemed uncoordinated and clumsy growing up. But we sent her to ballet, gymnastics and sports club because she wanted to try them. She’s doing amazing at both ballet and gymnastics, as a toddler/preschooler who would could barely walk without falling or injuring herself I was astounded. And her confidence has gone up so much too.

HELLITHURT · 28/03/2022 08:53

Such a difficult situation, the other parents will not try to resolve this as it doesn't bother their child.

Beees · 28/03/2022 08:53

I'm sure it maybe feels like that but please try to remember this other child is also 9 and has lost her friends too. Maybe she could do with a friendly face.

Then I would move her to the sporty school asap preferably after Easter if possible.

AlJalilia · 28/03/2022 08:52

@Geneticsbunny no, none at all. This is definitely something to consider.

OP posts:
Geneticsbunny · 28/03/2022 08:50

In the mean time is your daughter in any out of school clubs where she can make other friends? There will always be fall outs with groups of friends but if she has several sets of friends they are unlikely to all fall out at the same time and therefore it won't feel so overwhelming. Maybe something like brownies or an art club might be good for her?

AlJalilia · 28/03/2022 08:41

@Beees sorry, let me explain about the girl who doesn’t want to be friends... she was good friends with a couple of girls who left last year to go to a new school. The 3 of them were the Year 3 Mean Girls. Since then, DD and the other girls have tried to get her to join them, but she doesn’t want to. I don’t think she’s shy, I think she genuinely believes she’s better than them. I have seen her snort with derision when asked if she wanted to join their game. We have tried invited her for a play date, but she doesn’t want to come.

OP posts:
Beees · 28/03/2022 08:34

I'm guessing there's a reason you're ignoring the very sensible suggestion of her talking to and hopefully becoming friends with the poor girl who spends all her time alone?

If so then surely the sporty school that has spaces is the most sensible move rathe ratherthan a very academic school you will have to heavily tutor her to hopefully getting into. I doubt at 9 she's tried a lot of sports it's entirely possible she thinks she's not actually sporty but would excell at a sporty school.

Polyanthus2 · 28/03/2022 08:30

She's 9 - seems early to write off sports - swimming? Probably the best you could do for a shy girl is help her get good at a sport.

sirensscreech · 28/03/2022 08:21

Is there a state school she could go to?

AlJalilia · 28/03/2022 08:18

@Swayingpalmtrees there are 4 schools in the area: her current school, the selective one, the one with no places and a co-ed that’s very sports oriented (which she isn’t, unfortunately).

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 28/03/2022 08:18

You have to put your child first, it is not your job to work out why the school is down to just five girls or what will happen with the others. Your child is very unhappy and is now being told it is her fault - via counselling. I would move her just about anywhere in your position.

Swayingpalmtrees · 28/03/2022 08:16

Op, I have experience of a small set of girls in a boy heavy environment and the issues are going to be relentless.
Having the choice of one set of two girls or the other two will put a strain on all of them, not just your dd and as they get older this will create more problems not less. Socialising with lots of children is a life skill your child is not learning, because she only has four people to talk to each day - and two of those are now out of the picture. What a lonely sad and long school day it must be for her, and for the other two. Do you have other school options apart from the selective school?

AlJalilia · 28/03/2022 08:13

@JurassicPerks I think once they’re in, the school help the less able children. They take children from age 3 and it only becomes selective at Year 5. So I’m assuming there are quite a lot of average children who started before then.

OP posts:
Underfrighter · 28/03/2022 08:11

I also think you need to talk to the other patents. Not in an accusatory way but in a 'I really need to get to the bottom of this so I know what steps to take next' type way. It doesn't matter if its awkward

JurassicPerks · 28/03/2022 08:07

Just a word of warning, if you tutor heavily to get her in, will she spend the rest of her time there struggling?
Will the school places shuffle when you get to Senior school (I too am guessing International school) or does everywhere go 3-18?

Entrance exam: what format does it take? Look at examples of questions related to that. So maybe maths, English. Maybe verbal and non verbal reasoning.

Yes, I think you should move her, but I'm not sure the heavily selective school is the right place either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread