Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not get the Mandela effect when it comes to Nelson Mandela

159 replies

cakeorwine · 27/03/2022 20:49

People thinking he died in prison...

His leaving house arrest was a big news event.
Winning the Nobel Peace Prize
The first elections after apartheid
Becoming President.
Presenting the Rugby World Cup to the winning South African team in South Africa
His death in 2013

All massive news events.

I get some people thinking certain people had died before they had and misremembering other stuff and events...

But thinking Nelson Mandela had died in jail in the 80s....Seriously?
Meeting the Queen
His death and funeral in

OP posts:
Calandor · 28/03/2022 12:48

It's the point that common consciousness makes people believe something that's not true.

Plus I'm 26 - I wasn't alive for most of those things. I was barely an adult when he died. So why would I remember that?

MoreCraicPlease · 28/03/2022 12:43

@Nicholethejewellery

Video footage and archive "news" can easily be faked. The technology already exists and is getting cheaper all the time. I would expect some people who believe Mandela died in the 80s have seen the "video" of him being released a few years later but either think it's either been digitally manipulated or a lookalike was used.

How effective this is can be shown by another example where faking has definitely convinced a large number of people, the Starburst sweet example. Many people are certain it used to be called Opal Fruits - there are mocked up pictures of alleged "Opal Fruits" labels, the Wikipedia page is full of "Opal Fruits" references, even though it's never actual been the name.

They were Opal Fruits first in many countries - Ireland for instance - just as the Marathon pre-dated Snickers.
JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 28/03/2022 12:10

@dollybird

I remember it going all round college that Freddie Mercury had died, then about a week later he actually did die, and everyone was like 'huh, but he died last week?'.
The news that he had AIDS broke about a week before his death, and was confirmed a few days before he died. In those days AIDS was a death sentence.
Morgan12 · 28/03/2022 12:01

Britney did have a headset.

There is just no evidence of it within this reality. We shifted realities. In this reality she never had the headset.

evilharpy · 28/03/2022 11:57

@Tobacco

You do see the devil's face in Rosemary's baby, but you see it a minute or 2 after she looks in the cot, not at the same time she looks in the cot. Mirror mirror isn't Mandela effect. It's what anyone would think who had read the book not seen the film. I haven't seen the film so never heard "magic mirror"
I've seen Rosemary's Baby far too many times, I'm a bit obsessed with it, but I'm second guessing myself now. As far as I remember you see the devil's face during the rape/ritual scene but not when the baby is involved or at any other time. She says "what have you done to his eyes?" but you don't see them.
WomanStanleyWoman · 28/03/2022 11:45

He was 70 in 1988, not 60 - but that was the year of the Mandela Concert. Maybe people thought it was a tribute concert rather than part of the campaign for his release.

MargosKaftan · 28/03/2022 11:27

Oh wait, my Vera Lynn thing of thinking she was already dead when she died at aged 103 and possibly was i saw the news footage about her 100th birthday and just thought the "look back at a celebs life" news report was about her death - Nelson Mandela turned 60 in 1988 in prison. Most people who were surprised to hear he was still alive being released seem to remember news reports of his death in the late 80s, could it be the news did reports on his 60th birthday that would look like a death announcement report?! Would be even easier back then to not quite take in the correct story as most people would just watch one news bulletin a day.

Did UK /US main news reports cover his 60th birthday?! Or even earlier in 82 when he had served 20 years in prison or 87 when it was 25 years. Could those news reports - not regularly repeated as they are now, be mistaken for a death report by a significant number of people?

sashh · 28/03/2022 11:26

@WomanStanleyWoman

They don't need to explain it. When Mandela was released they thought, "Oh he's not dead, I thought he was, I'm sure it was on the news 20 years ago" and then carried on with their lives. Maybe people who cannot grasp this idea that they stopped believing he was dead when they found out he wasn't should be described as thick?

But the whole theory behind the Mandela Effect is that people don’t just ‘get on with their lives’. They obsess over the idea that they remember it happening and won’t be convinced otherwise. ‘But I remember!! It haaaaappened!!!!!’ If they just realised they had just heard wrongly and that was that, there wouldn’t be a whole phenomenon named after it, would there?

Several times I’ve seen an older celebrity has died and thought ‘Oh, I was sure s/he was dead already’. But they obviously weren’t, and I move on. I haven’t convinced myself that there was a huge conspiracy to cover up Patrick McNee or Eddie Large having died years before it was announced.

I was responding to someone who thought people believed a dead man was president, which no one has ever claimed.

And yes most people did get on with their lives, I've yet to come across someone who is convinced they were right after he was released.

Many people are certain it used to be called Opal Fruits - there are mocked up pictures of alleged "Opal Fruits" labels, the Wikipedia page is full of "Opal Fruits" references, even though it's never actual been the name.

Er yes it was the name and they have made a few limited edition come backs.

MargosKaftan · 28/03/2022 11:19

@Nicholethejewellery

Video footage and archive "news" can easily be faked. The technology already exists and is getting cheaper all the time. I would expect some people who believe Mandela died in the 80s have seen the "video" of him being released a few years later but either think it's either been digitally manipulated or a lookalike was used.

How effective this is can be shown by another example where faking has definitely convinced a large number of people, the Starburst sweet example. Many people are certain it used to be called Opal Fruits - there are mocked up pictures of alleged "Opal Fruits" labels, the Wikipedia page is full of "Opal Fruits" references, even though it's never actual been the name.

Nice try! There was a range of sweets called Opal fruits in the UK. Star burst was a slightly different sweet made in the US and sold across Europe. The US company bought the UK manufacturer and standardise the sweets (effectively rebranded opal fruits to starburst changed the recipe to the starburst at the same time). 2 years ago they did a limited edition in the original name. But was still star burst recipes / flavours.
WomanStanleyWoman · 28/03/2022 11:18

How effective this is can be shown by another example where faking has definitely convinced a large number of people, the Starburst sweet example. Many people are certain it used to be called Opal Fruits - there are mocked up pictures of alleged "Opal Fruits" labels, the Wikipedia page is full of "Opal Fruits" references, even though it's never actual been the name.

I’m assuming this is a joke?

Ilostit · 28/03/2022 11:16

Never read a thread that was such a huge load of bollocks. Mandela effect? It’s just people getting facts wrong. Possibly not people who take time to research etc! Anyone who is actually spending time reading the news/events know when Mandela lived and what he did etc

MargosKaftan · 28/03/2022 11:11

@Notjustanymum - no it tends to be older people who have it. People who felt they had already heard he had died in the 70s/80s. He was in prison from 1962 to 1990, some point in that, lots of people are sure they heard he had died, so were shocked in 1990 to hear he was being released.

Most people who think they had heard he had died seem to agree it was at some point in the late 80s. So it could be a news article about poor health, or rumours about his release they misheard. It could be a different political prisoner who died.

I definitely had a strange moment when I heard the news Vera Lynn had died, I was sure she was already dead. It could well have been a news report about something been named after her, or her being too sick to attend something and I wasn't listening properly so I thought I'd heard she'd died. Now I've looked it up, she was 103 when she died so it was probably news reports about her 100th birthday. The video compilations were probably a bit like the ones they show when a celeb dies.

Nicholethejewellery · 28/03/2022 11:09

Video footage and archive "news" can easily be faked. The technology already exists and is getting cheaper all the time. I would expect some people who believe Mandela died in the 80s have seen the "video" of him being released a few years later but either think it's either been digitally manipulated or a lookalike was used.

How effective this is can be shown by another example where faking has definitely convinced a large number of people, the Starburst sweet example. Many people are certain it used to be called Opal Fruits - there are mocked up pictures of alleged "Opal Fruits" labels, the Wikipedia page is full of "Opal Fruits" references, even though it's never actual been the name.

Couchbettato · 28/03/2022 10:57

My recent Mandela effect story is that I found out that Dunelm mill hasn't been called Dunelm mill since 2013, but every one I know still thinks our local one says Dunelm mill. Drove past the other day and there's a really weathered, old sign that just says Dunelm!

I've been questioning reality ever since.

WomanStanleyWoman · 28/03/2022 10:56

They don't need to explain it. When Mandela was released they thought, "Oh he's not dead, I thought he was, I'm sure it was on the news 20 years ago" and then carried on with their lives. Maybe people who cannot grasp this idea that they stopped believing he was dead when they found out he wasn't should be described as thick?

But the whole theory behind the Mandela Effect is that people don’t just ‘get on with their lives’. They obsess over the idea that they remember it happening and won’t be convinced otherwise. ‘But I remember!! It haaaaappened!!!!!’ If they just realised they had just heard wrongly and that was that, there wouldn’t be a whole phenomenon named after it, would there?

Several times I’ve seen an older celebrity has died and thought ‘Oh, I was sure s/he was dead already’. But they obviously weren’t, and I move on. I haven’t convinced myself that there was a huge conspiracy to cover up Patrick McNee or Eddie Large having died years before it was announced.

Notjustanymum · 28/03/2022 10:48

Another one here who doesn’t know anyone who thought he had died in prison!
I do wonder if this false “memory“ comes, not from those of us old enough to have seen the news reports of his release from prison and followed his subsequent swift trajectory to becoming President, but from those who heard about him (possibly even after his actual death) when memorials were being erected/street names changed in his honour, Etc.

WomanStanleyWoman · 28/03/2022 10:34

@CharityShopChic

It's like the "Walkers changed salt and vinegar crisp packet from blue to green" thing. Despite endless postings from people explaining that different companies used different colours, and how people are probably remembering Golden Wonder which were a more prominent brand in the 80s, and Walkers themselves saying their s&v has always been in green packets, you still get the posters convinced there is some sort of conspiracy of silence because they CLEARLY REMEMBER the change over.

It's crazy.

Unfortunately there are some people who are willing to believe any explanation, no matter how outlandish, other than ‘I was wrong’. It’s just too unpalatable to contemplate - even if the alternative is looking like a loon.

With the crisps one, there isn’t even a potential motive. With the ‘Mandela died in prison’ example, you can at least imagine that a pro-apartheid faction spread misinformation somehow. Even if you take a similar example to crisps - the common misconception that Cadbury’s Crème Eggs used to be a lot bigger - you can at least imagine why Cadbury might want to lie about that (even though they’ve confirmed other products have ‘shrunk’). Why would Walkers be so desperate to hide the fact that they had a packaging redesign 40 years ago?

MichaelAndEagle · 28/03/2022 10:31

@Topseyt

I wonder how people who believe Mandela died in prison explain him becoming President of South Africa afterwards!

Do they think that he became President posthumously, or are they just thick? Or a bit of both?

I don't think people still believe he died in prison. More like when he was released etc. a large enough group of people had the shared false memory that he was already dead. So they were like 'huh but I thought he was dead!'. And because enough people thought that it becomes this story about alternative timelines when it's just a lot of people had the same thing wrong. They didn't continue to believe he was dead obviously.
sashh · 28/03/2022 10:29

@Topseyt

I wonder how people who believe Mandela died in prison explain him becoming President of South Africa afterwards!

Do they think that he became President posthumously, or are they just thick? Or a bit of both?

They don't need to explain it. When Mandela was released they thought, "Oh he's not dead, I thought he was, I'm sure it was on the news 20 years ago" and then carried on with their lives.

Maybe people who cannot grasp this idea that they stopped believing he was dead when they found out he wasn't should be described as thick?

dollybird · 28/03/2022 10:24

I remember it going all round college that Freddie Mercury had died, then about a week later he actually did die, and everyone was like 'huh, but he died last week?'.

Topseyt · 28/03/2022 10:03

I wonder how people who believe Mandela died in prison explain him becoming President of South Africa afterwards!

Do they think that he became President posthumously, or are they just thick? Or a bit of both?

sashh · 28/03/2022 10:00

@ToInverness

Totally totally agree! I can see plenty of other examples of the Mandela effect. But I cannot believe it when it comes to Mandela himself. Being released and becoming president is just such a central part of his story. I don't know how you could follow the news enough to know who he was and that he was in prison, but have the whole being elected president thing pass you by as though you'd been living under a rock! He met the spice girls for christs sake, that's how big news he was!
That's not the Mandela effect.

It comes from his release, no one has any Mandela effect about him being released and becoming president, it's that at the point of release, or when they saw news coverage coming up to release, they thought he was dead and so were surprised.

WomanStanleyWoman · 28/03/2022 09:56

Lots of people witnessed it happening, it's a famous mandela effect. Like I say, there's no explanation for it.

But if you’re acknowledging it as a famous Mandela Effect, you’re acknowledging that it didn’t happen. The whole point is that several people misremember the same thing. It’s not that these things actually happen and are then wiped from history with some cosmic reset button, but some people still remember.

ToInverness · 28/03/2022 09:47

Totally totally agree! I can see plenty of other examples of the Mandela effect. But I cannot believe it when it comes to Mandela himself. Being released and becoming president is just such a central part of his story. I don't know how you could follow the news enough to know who he was and that he was in prison, but have the whole being elected president thing pass you by as though you'd been living under a rock! He met the spice girls for christs sake, that's how big news he was!

CharityShopChic · 28/03/2022 09:45

What's more likely, @fourofwands - that one of the most famous political figures in America sneakily changed the spelling of her name, then changed it back and lied about it, or that you have got it wrong?