Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not get the Mandela effect when it comes to Nelson Mandela

159 replies

cakeorwine · 27/03/2022 20:49

People thinking he died in prison...

His leaving house arrest was a big news event.
Winning the Nobel Peace Prize
The first elections after apartheid
Becoming President.
Presenting the Rugby World Cup to the winning South African team in South Africa
His death in 2013

All massive news events.

I get some people thinking certain people had died before they had and misremembering other stuff and events...

But thinking Nelson Mandela had died in jail in the 80s....Seriously?
Meeting the Queen
His death and funeral in

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
liveforsummer · 30/03/2022 07:48

I'd guess the first news report after their belief that showed he hadn't. Not everyone has access to news all the time so varying times but all likely a long time ago being as the phenomenon, like I said, is not a new one.

cakeorwine · 30/03/2022 07:43

They found out at a significant time when he was making headlines such as on his release

If you read my posts, you will see that that point has been made by me. In fact - that's the whole thread. At what point did they realise he hadn't died in prison......

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 30/03/2022 07:38

@cakeorwine

he Mandela affect isn't a brand new phenomenon, it has been discussed for years

Of course it's not a brand new effect. I posted this in reference to a thread where someone mentioned it in relation to something else.

My point is no one is just finding out now that he didn't die in prison. They found out at a significant time when he was making headlines such as on his release. Or if they missed that as is possible of no access to the news for a variety of reasons, something else shortly after ...
liveforsummer · 30/03/2022 07:33

And it doesn't seem to have happened on a mass scale with anything else.

It has though - maybe less spoken about as not so high profile and because they don't actually have the phenomenon named after them but there are plenty of examples. Things like the monopoly man having a monocle.

cakeorwine · 30/03/2022 07:28

he Mandela affect isn't a brand new phenomenon, it has been discussed for years

Of course it's not a brand new effect. I posted this in reference to a thread where someone mentioned it in relation to something else.

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 30/03/2022 07:22

I thought the whole point is that people are aware of this stuff. The Mandela affect isn't a brand new phenomenon, it has been discussed for years. Prior to his release, career etc some people had thought he'd died but realised when he became headline news again that in fact was not the case.

StartupRepair · 30/03/2022 02:17

What really annoys me about this is that if Mandela had died in prison, South Africa would have completely erupted. There would have been no possibility of a relatively peaceful transition from the apartheid era and the history of the country would have taken a different course. Mandela dying in prison was one of the fears of the old regime.
It annoys me that the Mandela effect discussion never asks people what they think happened next if he died in prison. This might reveal their level of ignorance which is at the root of the whole thing.

LBFseBrom · 30/03/2022 00:44

@Ericaequites

I remember writing letters to Amnesty International for Mandela’s release. Some implied reading my poor handwriting was a form of cruel and unusual punishment.
:-)

I too wrote to Amnesty and campaigned for Mandela's release. I clearly remember the day he came out. It's beyond me how anyone would think he died in prison. He had a distinguished career for many years afterwards. He hasn't been dead that many years and after it happened there was loads of stuff about him on the television for ages.

(Oh and I also remember Spangles, so does Jonathan Ross.)

Ericaequites · 30/03/2022 00:23

I remember writing letters to Amnesty International for Mandela’s release. Some implied reading my poor handwriting was a form of cruel and unusual punishment.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 30/03/2022 00:08

Yes stone

Badgerforbreakfast · 29/03/2022 23:15

Like another poster I also had this with Oscar Pistorius. Was certain I'd heard he'd died in prison.

stonebrambleboy · 29/03/2022 22:53

Does anyone remember Spangles?

JudgeJ · 29/03/2022 22:43

@FriNightBlues

Surely everyone remembers the episode of Only Fools and Horses where he turned up to open Nelson Mandela House?
No, not everyone, I've never seen an episode of this ghastly programme, seen snippets at my mother's house and that was enough. Tin hat at the ready!
cakeorwine · 29/03/2022 22:13

@MargosKaftan

we only know the Mandela Effect is a thing because so many people did realise their mistake and talked about it.
I know.

The point of the OP is - when did they realise their mistake.

If they realised their mistake at the time of his release, then that's one thing.

If they realised their mistake much later, and had somehow missed all the stuff in the news about him, all the key events in his life - and then at some point much later, heard something about him (such as him dying) and then realising their mistake, that's something else. As in how did it take you so long to realise your mistake...

Which is the point of the OP

OP posts:
MargosKaftan · 29/03/2022 22:00

we only know the Mandela Effect is a thing because so many people did realise their mistake and talked about it.

cakeorwine · 29/03/2022 21:24

They remember seeing reports of his death. They also remember seeing him walk out of prison some years later alive and well. They understand these two things can't have happened and yet they remember both

The question is - do they remember the reports of his death - or do they remember reports of someone's death and got confused?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 29/03/2022 21:22

Oh actually OP - have you mixed up what the Mandela Effect actually refers to? It's not lots of people believing he died in prison and therefore not believing he was president of SA, being international treasure afterwards - it refers to people who know they have a memory that can't be true

I haven't said they don't believe he wasn't President.

I know that it refers to people hearing at some point that Nelson Mandela was alive - they heard this at some point such as when he left prison, when he became President, when he actually died or some other newsworthy event - and thinking to themselves 'that's strange, I could have sworn he died in the 80s' - so they recognise they have a false memory.

My point is - if they realised their mistake when he was released from prison, then maybe that's reasonable.

But if they realised their mistake much later, then that means they can't have been paying attention as he achieved so many things in his life that were in the news.

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman · 29/03/2022 20:32

but a whole film and several people having the same fake memory?! Oh thats creepy.

A film with the exact same plot, called Kaazam, was made in 1994. It actually starred Shaquille O’Neal, not Sinbad. However, Sinbad appeared in a series of commercials playing a genie, which is why people are so convinced they can picture him in the role.

WomanStanleyWoman · 29/03/2022 20:30

I find the Shazam example fascinating. For anyone who hasn’t heard of it, the film apparently started a comedian called Sinbad, who used to be in ‘A Different World’ (a Cosby Show spin-off). He has confirmed several times the film doesn’t exist - he’s even provided a lot of evidence for why people are confused - but still people argue it’s real. They even try to claim that he’s had the film ‘suppressed’ somehow because he’s ashamed of it.

The only other thing Sinbad is famous for is being hit with a seven-figure tax bill in the 90s. I can’t help thinking that, if he’s powerful enough to have something entirely wiped from history, he probably should have chosen the tax bill.

MargosKaftan · 29/03/2022 20:28

@Userg1234

Radio 4 did a programme on this a few years ago....but concentrated on a 1980s video film called shazam....not to confused with the recent super hero film. Several hundred people claimed to have watched this film about a genie, even naming the stars and describing the same scenes...all saying the same thing! One guy claimed to have worked in a video shop and rented the film out... Later the stars made a spoof of it.youtube shaman 1980s movie
Oh my thats quite freaky! The Mandela thing could be explained with a news channel putting out a wrong bulletin that he'd died, or a report on the free Mandela concert being mistaken for a memorial concert, but a whole film and several people having the same fake memory?! Oh thats creepy.
Userg1234 · 29/03/2022 20:20

Radio 4 did a programme on this a few years ago....but concentrated on a 1980s video film called shazam....not to confused with the recent super hero film. Several hundred people claimed to have watched this film about a genie, even naming the stars and describing the same scenes...all saying the same thing!
One guy claimed to have worked in a video shop and rented the film out...
Later the stars made a spoof of it.youtube shaman 1980s movie

fourofwands · 29/03/2022 20:10

I've never taken a lot of notice of Britney but I can picture a video where she's wearing a red catsuit and has a headset microphone. Is that the missing headset?

MargosKaftan · 29/03/2022 20:03

Oh actually OP - have you mixed up what the Mandela Effect actually refers to? It's not lots of people believing he died in prison and therefore not believing he was president of SA, being international treasure afterwards - it refers to people who know they have a memory that can't be true.

They remember seeing reports of his death. They also remember seeing him walk out of prison some years later alive and well. They understand these two things can't have happened and yet they remember both.

Singlebutmarried · 29/03/2022 19:58

@OmgIThinkILikeYou

I don't care what anyone or any 'proof' says, Britney Spears absolutely used to have a headset in the Oops I Did It Again video. No I am not thinking of her stage performances, she had it on in the video.
I will back you on this. It’s the sole reason my walk around headset for work is called ‘my Britney’
MargosKaftan · 29/03/2022 19:51

Many people reported believing 100% they had seen news reports he was dead. Most didn't continue to think he was dead after seeing him walk from prison/become the president - although there was a rumour it wasn't the same man and he had died / been killed and replaced, but most were drawn to this from a stance of "i remember something clearly that cant have happened, so why do I have this memory?" And the shock that so many people have the same false memory !

The most likely is for some reason lots of people misinterpreted a news report about him as a death report. Or maybe even a news paper incorrectly published a story of his death (but you'd think that would have been shown up by now). The whole 'parallel universe where he is dead' idea seems bonkers to me, but what is most interesting is I dont think all these people are lying about having the same false memory. And it doesn't seem to have happened on a mass scale with anything else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread