Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else hate mother's day???

62 replies

velvet24 · 27/03/2022 18:23

I feel its all a bit ott, stuff everywhere in the shops, most of it tat. It doesnt feel the same when you have to constantly remind your teenage children about it, one gave me stuff later on today other forgot but made me tea and says he appreciates me. Just feel all this pressure to photograph beautiful flowers and gifts and have it all over Fb.
I hate these made up days , made up by card companies to make money, anyone else????
Oh and must be awful for women who cant have children or have lost mothers, or just don't have a relationship with theirs.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SwimmingAgainstTheTides · 20/03/2023 17:33

It's one big pity party.
the solution is simple, take the friggin initiative and buy yourself something. End of.

roarfeckingroarr · 28/03/2022 12:29

I love it now I'm a mother. A lovely card with some thoughtful words, breakfast made and then a lunch out and champagne with family.

incognitoforthisone · 28/03/2022 12:27

I know that if you don't like something or find it hard, it's difficult when you see other people talking about it or observing the day, whether that's Mother's Day or Christmas or Valentine's Day or anything else.

But other people are entitled to enjoy these things if they want to, and they're entitled to talk about it.

Sneering about 'tat' and implying that people who observe Mother's Day are just doing it to make up for doing nothing for the rest of the year is incredibly judgemental. I went to see my mum for the weekend, bought her the new book by her favourite author and took her out for a nice lunch at a place I chose because I know their menu is great for her dietary requirements. My mum was absolutely delighted with everything and it was a special day for her.

However, I also make a fuss of her for the rest of the year. I do stuff for her a lot, help her out with money sometimes, send her little gifts for no reason and tell her I love her.

If you don't like it, you're not obliged to engage with it. Tell your kids you don't want them to observe it and spend the day like any other day. Nobody is going to look at your Facebook and think 'Why hasn't she mentioned Mother's Day?' None of your friends will notice any absence on your social media; nobody is anywhere near as invested in their friends' individual profiles as that.

5128gap · 28/03/2022 11:23

If you hate it, just opt out. Your DC don't sound too fussed, so just tell them next year not to bother. As a general principle, I dislike being told when we have to celebrate someone. While my DC do make an effort, I honestly wouldn't mind if they didn't, because a fuss on the one day of the year you're told to doesn't define a relationship, and if they had to be coaxed and cajoled I'd rather they didn't anyway. Spontaneous and sincere gestures on normal days mean more.

Charmatt · 28/03/2022 10:47

You need to own your own Mother's Day. What should it mean to you?

No card company or retailer is going to tell me what Mother's Day should be.

In our house, for Father's or Mother's Day, the other one cooks breakfast for everyone to enjoy. Then we just have a nice day. No cards, no bought stuff! Just a nice day!

It's suited us for the past 21 years...

...and I don't feel the need to post my lie on social media either - my indiscretions are my own business!

Iamnotin · 28/03/2022 10:46

I love it - my teenage daughter bought me chocolate and i bought us brunch, and i got to give her unlimited hugs and feel happy that i had her, and tell her how happy i am to be her mother. nothing on facebook, no grand gestures but a lovely celebration of motherhood and a day to be positive about being a mother.

as a PP noted, father's aren't supposed to feel guilty or anguished on Father's day because some people have lost their own fathers, or have difficulty becoming fathers, why can't mothers just enjoy the day?

ReadyToMoveIt · 28/03/2022 10:42

We didn't go out for a meal as previous experience has been restaurants full of families who clearly ignore Mum for the rest of the year

How on earth can you make that deduction from sitting in the same room, at a separate table, from some people for a couple of hours? Grin

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 28/03/2022 10:24

sartres

Yeah Grin ds2 has to hug me and look like he enjoys it

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 28/03/2022 10:23

My children give me a card and spend the day with me

Except for the card it's something that happens on a regular basis but will get less and less as the years go on

I think quite often it's about expectations and I pretty much just expect a hug and a card

Though it did take ds1 (23) all day to actually write in the thing Grin

SartresSoul · 28/03/2022 10:22

Well, everyone’s entitled to feel this way and I do understand how painful it is for infertile women, women who have lost children or people who have lost their Mother.

I like it because it’s an excuse to demand everyone in the house be nice to me for the day Grin.

Pinklimey · 28/03/2022 10:15

We didn't go out for a meal as previous experience has been restaurants full of families who clearly ignore Mum for the rest of the year.

Dd made me a lovely card at school and a breakfast, then I made a roast for me, dd and mum.

MabelsApron · 28/03/2022 10:02

@counsellortroi Agree. Reminds me of a recent email I had from Waterstones with their list of best books to read by women for IWD. 2/3 of them were about motherhood. I'd have hated these church services and much preferred a cursory reference to Mothers Day and then moving on.

countrygirl99 · 28/03/2022 09:57

Once my DC got past the age where school make a thing of it I told hhem not to worry about it. It's close to my birthday and March is birthday central in our family so always clashed with mine/my dad/FIL etc so just seemed too much faff

CounsellorTroi · 28/03/2022 09:56

@PurpleDaisies

I've been at a lovely Church service today, when all women were recognised, and it was acknowledged that some had the pain of infertility, or those who had lost a child, or those that had a difficult relationship with their child (or own mother), and many other scenarios were recognised. That some women held a nurturing role without ever being a mother.

I was at one of those too. It was bloody awful. Worse than just a quick mention of Mother’s Day and moving on. Clearly done by someone who wanted to be sensitive to everyone but not thinking what it’s like if you’re actually in that position.

I’m sure it was @PurpleDaisies. It’s just emphasising the mother bit above all else. Woman = mother/nurturer and nothing else. My DH was brought up Catholic, I went to one or two Mothers Day services with his mum and I was generally left feeling very bleak and bereft. Not a source of comfort to me at all.
Winday · 28/03/2022 09:49

It doesn't bother me. I don't really look at Facebook these days, so I don't know what people are putting on there, but i eemember it from previous years. Some people like to have the flowers, cards etc, but I find it quite easy to ignore, and don't bother with them myself. I can appreciate however, that if someone has been used to celebrating it, it must be very difficult if your mother isn't around anymore.

I went to the shops yesterday and did get a laugh at one younger guy who was feverishly writing in a card at 5.30pm. That's the reality of mother's day for most, I reckon. A last minute card and a bunch of flowers. The social media gushing isn't real.

PurpleDaisies · 28/03/2022 09:49

She could have been forgiven for not wanting anything to do with it, but she held a brilliantly inclusive service where we all wrote down examples of other women who had behaved like mothers to us

That sounds even worse than the patronising flowers that got given out to all the women at mine.

MabelsApron · 28/03/2022 09:39

I hate it. My mum weaponised it such that I struggle not to see the day itself as an homage to martyrdom, and I'm now estranged from her and infertile. The day itself feels like a personal insult though clearly I'm sensible enough to know it isn't!

Babdoc · 28/03/2022 09:36

I think going to church would have helped you, OP. I remember a wonderful Mothering Sunday service given by our then minister, who not only was a childless lesbian, but her own mother had just died.
She could have been forgiven for not wanting anything to do with it, but she held a brilliantly inclusive service where we all wrote down examples of other women who had behaved like mothers to us, and reflected on God’s role as our heavenly parent.
I had an abusive mother, and was ambivalent about the day, but being able to write about my DH’s lovely old aunt, who had been a great mother figure to me after he died, was very cathartic.
Mothering Sunday is largely whatever you make it. Raise your DC to respect and love you, let them know you expect them to behave decently towards you and mark your special day. If they are too young, make plain to your DH what is required of him.
Finally, comparison is the thief of joy. Don’t sit enviously looking at other women’s social media posts, often displayed purely to generate envy or boost an insecure ego. Focus on being happy and getting your needs met in your own life.

PurpleDaisies · 28/03/2022 09:29

I've been at a lovely Church service today, when all women were recognised, and it was acknowledged that some had the pain of infertility, or those who had lost a child, or those that had a difficult relationship with their child (or own mother), and many other scenarios were recognised. That some women held a nurturing role without ever being a mother.

I was at one of those too. It was bloody awful. Worse than just a quick mention of Mother’s Day and moving on. Clearly done by someone who wanted to be sensitive to everyone but not thinking what it’s like if you’re actually in that position.

CounsellorTroi · 28/03/2022 09:25

YANBU. We have no children or surviving parents (mum died the week before Mothers Day five years ago and I had already bought a card and gift) so Mothers and Fathers Day are of no relevance to us other than memories. We do however celebrate Valentines Day.

RedHelenB · 28/03/2022 09:23

@velvet24

I feel its all a bit ott, stuff everywhere in the shops, most of it tat. It doesnt feel the same when you have to constantly remind your teenage children about it, one gave me stuff later on today other forgot but made me tea and says he appreciates me. Just feel all this pressure to photograph beautiful flowers and gifts and have it all over Fb. I hate these made up days , made up by card companies to make money, anyone else???? Oh and must be awful for women who cant have children or have lost mothers, or just don't have a relationship with theirs.
I love it, from the first one as a mother. Had a really happy day yesterday, knowing my children like to make it extra special. Mind you, they're the same for Christmas and birthdays.
ReadyToMoveIt · 28/03/2022 09:17

Oh and I don’t have FB or Instagram so have no idea about people posting flower pictures etc. You should try getting rid of yours, it’s good for stress levels!

ReadyToMoveIt · 28/03/2022 09:16

My children made me cards and gifts and then my husband cooked for us all including my mum and his. It was lovely and no money spent except a slightly bigger roast than normal.
Yeah it’s shit if your kids don’t bother and it can be very hard for people who have lost their mother, or who want to be a mother for example. But for me it was a pleasant day where I didn’t have to do anything and my children gave me lovely homemade gifts.

NumberTheory · 28/03/2022 09:12

@MurmuratingStarling

The 'we don't need a special day to know our kids love us - they show us all the time' comments always pop up on here. Usually from the same women who say 'I don't need a poxy card on Valentines day from my DH to show he loves me, he shows me all the time.'

NEWSFLASH! The men (and children) who buy for their wives/mothers for Mothers day and Valentines etc, ALSO show love all year round AS WELL as on the 'special occasions.' The 'we don't need 'TAT' to prove our love' type posts smack of denial.

I don’t think it’s denial. It just all seems performative and generally in a style that I don’t particularly lean towards. I get lunches out and cups of tea and thanks anyway many times a year. I’m really not interested in having a day that’s seen as set aside for it because it tends to be not as good as on the days that are more spontaneous or unprompted.

But even though I’m not interested I can appreciate that other people do like it and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that either.

NumberTheory · 28/03/2022 09:04

I don’t like it either OP. I think we all need basic respect for each other all the time, not put one day aside that’s heavily oversubscribed.

I don’t like going out to lunch on Mother’s Day because places are packed and often more expensive. Ditto the flowers. There seems to be pressure on everyone to perform in a certain way that feels false.

I’m much happier with a lower key and more frequent show of appreciation - like a cup of tea from time to time, or a heartfelt thank you or declaration of love.