Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it my fault dd is like she is?

63 replies

Shitemum79 · 27/03/2022 11:45

Dd is just turned 18. She's always been hard work for want of a better term. I've always tried to be a friend as well as a mum and we are very close. But she is going through a tough time. Recently on anti depressants, struggling at work due to making silly mistakes and not been enthusiastic enough. Life is pretty tough at the moment. She's moody, has meltdowns and I bear the brunt of most of it. It's put immense pressure on mine and her dad's relationship and we walk on eggshells waiting for the next outburst
What upsets me most is how my family are reacting to it. My parents and siblings. They are pretty hard and ignorant to anything mental health related. Probably thinks she needs to get a grip, sort herself out and get on with work and stop causing trouble and upset. I'm far more liberal with my parenting over my sibling and my dd is much more open as a result.
But my mistake is I do everything for her. Always have. She never puts clothes in wash basket or brings dirty plates down. Over the years I've tried several tactics from punishment which makes life harder to begging.
Have found the easiest thing is to just keep on top of it and do it.
She's on the verge of been sacked from work.
I'm questioning her upbringing and wondering if I've caused this by been too lenient or whether it's all mental health related. Or if this is an excuse.
Would appreciate honesty however brutal. No idea how to change things cos it's never worked in the past.
I

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kanaloa · 01/04/2022 04:47

I just mean like if you don’t wash her clothes then why is that a huge worry for you? They’re not your clothes. If you tell her to wash them and she doesn’t why is it your problem? I don’t even collect the washing of my 11 & 10 year olds’ from their bedroom, they bring it down and if it’s their kit for hobbies they put their own wash on. It’s not something you need to do for a late teen.

Kanaloa · 01/04/2022 04:45

@Gowithme

ASD wouldn't surprise me either - problems with executive function are extremely common.

It's not that you've done something wrong, in fact it's likely you've done a huge amount right. It's common for parents of children with ASD to be a lot more involved and helicopter/be an overly involved parent compared to others - but it's actually what has kept their child able to cope and function. My ds's assessor said I must have done a really good job for him to get to secondary school age with no one having previously picked up that he had ASD.

Picking up after her won't have 'made' her lazy or prevented her from learning life skills - how many lessons do you need to learn how to bring your plate downstairs or tidy up - it's not exactly rocket science!

I would wonder if this is the wrong job for her. She is not enthusiastic and one thing I know for sure is that if someone with ASD doesn't want to do something it's very, very unlikely that they're going to do a good job and are likely to be completely miserable doing it. I'd get her to think about why this isn't working and what she could do about it - does she just need to give herself more time? Could she ask for some advice and support? Does she need to write some things down to help her avoid making mistakes? Is she still wanting to do well at this job? Is there anything else she might want to look into doing instead?

I mean most of us are unlikely to do well in something we dislike and will probably feel miserable having to go to a job we hate every day. That’s just a normal reaction to doing things you don’t like.

I think the only way to get round this is talk to her. I realise you do everything for her because it’s easier but what if you just didn’t? If you didn’t wash her clothes? I’d show her how to use the washer then explain from now on she will do her own washing, and can ask you if she isn’t sure which cycle to use. These are life skills she needs and you’re doing her no favours making a baby of her.

nancynoname · 01/04/2022 00:47

@BigYellowTaxiT

Being a spoilt brat does not make someone autistic. I am so sick of every badly behaved kid being labelled as autistic on here.
I agree.

Why is the immediate go-to explanation for bad behaviour attributed to mental health issues and/or a medical diagnosis? Some people just aren't very nice for one reason or another - no medical reason for it.

I've always tried to be a friend as well as a mum

Such an eye rolling and cringy situation.

Regardless of anything else, whether DD has a condition or is just spoilt, being her friend was probably your first mistake.

Children need parents before they need friends. Parents (should) provide boundaries and structure in a way friends never will. Clearly that hasn't happened here.

Wastwater · 28/03/2022 11:21

Also wondering about borderline personality disorder (and depression): the outbursts sound like emotional dysregulation. You say you are close but is this really an emotional dependency on you because she can't manage her own emotions?? does she need a lot of emotional support ?? Does she have completely disproportionate reactions to small disappointment or negative emotions??
Those suggesting she is spoilt or a princess or just needs to learn to tidy up/ operate the washing machine probably have little experience of this type of mental health issue.

ItsMutinyontheBunty · 28/03/2022 10:52

I would recommend The Explosive Child by Ross Greene. It’s really helpful in understanding behaviour and working out strategies to help and support (regardless of diagnosis). It’s particularly helpful for kids who are resistant to change or who have mood swings and meltdowns. My DD is much younger but it really helped us.

Wheniruletheworld · 28/03/2022 09:01

Why do you think you can be her friend and her parent? Children need boundaries, and trying to be friends one minute then discipline/teach them the next is very confusing and potentially harmful

Chonfox · 27/03/2022 23:45

Sounds like permissive parenting had a part to play and she lacks resilience as a result. I was raised similarly and while I had a lovely open relationship with my mum, she was too soft and I similarly struggled at your DDs age. Gentle but tough love approach may work wonders. My mum had to do it with me and it had the desired effect (after my initial outrage waned Grin) sometimes we need a (encouraging but firm) kick up the arse.

Shitemum79 · 27/03/2022 23:30

Thank you everyone so much. I appreciate all answers good and bad.

OP posts:
LakeIsle48 · 27/03/2022 23:28

I have huge sympathy for you and your daughter. I am not a medic in any way at all. My daughter is 24 now but her behaviour was very similar to yours at that age and was, after literally years, diagnosed with bipolar disorder. I never knew it could present in children but it can. That diagnosis helped us understand her behaviour and we could adjust to life accordingly.

I'd just like to reiterate that I am not a medic but my daughter presented with similar issues. She takes medication and things have levelled out to a manageable level.

It would be worth consulting with her GP. I hope it all gets a bit easier for your family. My daughter loves music, maybe your daughter might be able to get a hobby or start some exercise to burn off some energy.

I'm sure she's a lovely girl and just needs time and support. Take care of yourself too, it's tough on parents having a child/young adult with problems. You need support too. Eat well, get some downtime for yourself and exercise, even if it's just a walk around the block. I neglected myself and it did me no good. Its evened out a lot now. Make sure you get support for you!!!

FrownedUpon · 27/03/2022 23:24

Of course parenting impacts on the adults we become. It’s ridiculous to suggest it doesn’t. You’ve taught her that she doesn’t need to take responsibility because an adult always picks up after her. Unsurprisingly she is now struggling to hold down a job.

dipdye · 27/03/2022 23:13

Being a spoilt brat does not make someone autistic. I am so sick of every badly behaved kid being labelled as autistic on here.

^
Have to agree.

Sometimes it's just good old fashioned parenting that's needed.

dipdye · 27/03/2022 23:11

But my mistake is I do everything for her. Always have. She never puts clothes in wash basket or brings dirty plates down.

^

Down from where? Her room?

Is she a princess?

That's your problem right there, not making her accountable. Sorry to sound harsh but it's not surprising that she thinks everything should be handed to her if it always has?

RedScarfJamjar · 27/03/2022 23:09

@BigYellowTaxiT

Being a spoilt brat does not make someone autistic. I am so sick of every badly behaved kid being labelled as autistic on here.
I used to think this!

I don't now.

anotherbrewplease · 27/03/2022 20:25

@Booboobibles

Very well said.

Turningpurple · 27/03/2022 20:01

Its really impossible for anyone to say anything either way.

It could be depression, asd and lots of other things.

Or it absolutely could be that she has never learned to do anything for herself and expectations others to pick up the slack.

If your family are usually good and supportive, then u would seriously think about what they are saying.

A 1000 people could say 'she sounds like me and I have XYZ' doewnr mean that does apply to her.

She sounds a little like my brother. His issue is definitely that mum brought him up with the expectation that he would earn alot of money and only move out when he was settling down and he would marry a woman whose ambition was to be a sahm/house wife.

In his late teens he struggled at work. He often had rages that impacted and ruled the whole household. Wouldn't do basic jobs like bringing plates down and putting washing away. He was a bit of a nightmare and I moved out at 19 (he was 24) because it was such a pain. He then bought his own house and things got slightly better.

But 1000 people can come and say their experience is that it's down to parenting. Doesn't mean in your dds case, it is.

BessieFinknottle · 27/03/2022 19:54

@TheYearOfSmallThings

Suggesting the op's daughter would be in this circumstance regardless of anything the op has done is patent nonsense.

I just disagree. Outright neglect can have marked consequences, but if mildly ineffectual parenting was catastrophic humanity would have died out long ago. The truth is most children develop well if their basic needs are met by loving parents, which seems to be the case here.

Other children don't, even if their parents do everything right. In this case I suspect the parents have been walking on eggshells for years and yes, it wasn't the best way to manage their DD, but I think her underlying issues have shaped their parenting rather than the other way around.

This. Some people have problems with executive function. It's often seen in those diagnosed with autism or ADHD. I have one (very bright, verbal) DS with autism. The difference in life skills between him and his siblings is huge. Same parenting.

I don't know if your daughter is neurodiverse, of course, but those of us who do have ND children find that people do often blame the parents for their behaviour. Usually the people who do this are only familiar with parenting neurotypical children, and don't realise that what works for their child will simply not work for many others. So don't mind those who are being so very hard on you without knowing your DD at all.

You aay you have been walking on eggshells for years and she has depression so there are clearly issues here. Therapy is needed OP. You need to get to the root of her issues and then support her to manage them.

Best of luck with everything Flowers

Gowithme · 27/03/2022 19:48

ASD wouldn't surprise me either - problems with executive function are extremely common.

It's not that you've done something wrong, in fact it's likely you've done a huge amount right. It's common for parents of children with ASD to be a lot more involved and helicopter/be an overly involved parent compared to others - but it's actually what has kept their child able to cope and function. My ds's assessor said I must have done a really good job for him to get to secondary school age with no one having previously picked up that he had ASD.

Picking up after her won't have 'made' her lazy or prevented her from learning life skills - how many lessons do you need to learn how to bring your plate downstairs or tidy up - it's not exactly rocket science!

I would wonder if this is the wrong job for her. She is not enthusiastic and one thing I know for sure is that if someone with ASD doesn't want to do something it's very, very unlikely that they're going to do a good job and are likely to be completely miserable doing it. I'd get her to think about why this isn't working and what she could do about it - does she just need to give herself more time? Could she ask for some advice and support? Does she need to write some things down to help her avoid making mistakes? Is she still wanting to do well at this job? Is there anything else she might want to look into doing instead?

BigYellowTaxiT · 27/03/2022 18:34

Being a spoilt brat does not make someone autistic. I am so sick of every badly behaved kid being labelled as autistic on here.

LowlandLucky · 27/03/2022 18:20

Her behaviour could be a cause of many things
Autism
Adhd
Being a over indulged adult that has no idea how to work because she has had a housemaid to pick up her clothes and wipe her backside.
Take your pick.

Pr1mr0se · 27/03/2022 17:38

She sounds like a normal teenager to me - no need to 'label' her with a diagnosis.

I would start giving her a bit more responsibility around the house too including her laundry.

sweetbellyhigh · 27/03/2022 17:03

Fault is neither here nor there.
What you need to find is a way forward that works for all of you, and this won't happen so long as you all continue to do as you always have.

First of all, ignore your family and anyone else who is critical of you. (I know that's easier said than done!) Criticism is highly unhelpful.

Secondly, enough focus on your daughter, what about you? Would you get some professional support for yourself? It can be difficult to have perspective on a situation when you are deeply involved so an outsider may be able to guide you in a way that can help you all make positive changes.

You list many difficulties. How about starting with just one thing, gentle encouragement to get your daughter to make one small positive change, then tons of praise when she does it.

You say it's easier to do things yourself but parenting is not about finding the easiest way, it's about teaching our children to become independent and useful citizens. And it does take work.

crispmidnightpeace · 27/03/2022 16:58

Why does it matter whether you made mistakes in the past? What matters, surely, is that you do what's needed now?

Yes, she does need to be taught how to manage a home as we all live in homes. She'll be one day caring for a baby quite possibly, of course she needed to be prepared to be responsible for her immediate environment.

What matters now though is that you help her become a functional adult. Ask her to pay rent perhaps? Only a minimal amount? Like £10/week. She probably needs responsibility in her life.

NandorTheRelentlessCleaner · 27/03/2022 16:46

It sounds tough OP

Maybe you are a bit too involved? Around a bit too much? Always there to deal with the fall out, tidy things up, sort it all out?

I find it's been very beneficial to both my teens (17, 19) and myself to not always be av, have my own life and hobbies, I'm out a fair bit but also still there in the background, if that makes sense

Saying that, I am not a model parent Grin, we all make it up as we go along don't we? You parent the way that suits you and your child

So maybe be a little less involved and let her deal with things a bit more by herself? Yea

Booboobibles · 27/03/2022 16:30

I’ve got two neurodiverse children. They're very different and they’ve been parented differently because of this….it’s an interaction and kids can’t be parented exactly the same although I constantly had people telling me that they have been.

There’s absolutely no point coming on here and asking the opinions of people who don’t have neurodiverse children because don’t have a clue and you’ll just feel awful. It’s tempting to listen to them sometimes because they seem so confident and so sure that their methods will work. I can even feel like that about people telling me that I should be able to work full time and do this and that. You have to learn to have faith in yourself.

Someone said that your DD will spend the rest of her life having to learn what you should have taught her. Realistically, washing up and using the washing machine can be taught in a week.

It can be absolutely exhausting parenting autistic/adhd kids and we’re often neurodivergent ourselves. I blame myself all the time because that’s what caring parents do I suppose, but realistically I was just so so tired, depressed and ill that I couldn’t have done any more than I did.

Why ask for brutal criticism on here? There are some extremely harsh people on here. (I hate it but I’m addicted!) Never has parenting been so difficult….kids are brought up in an awful environment, they’re addicted to screens, there’s global warming, little chance of buying a house and yet we as mothers (usually mothers) are blamed. Please stop blaming yourself!

RosesAndHellebores · 27/03/2022 15:42

@HMG107 your post resonated. DD developed anxiety and depression at about 15 which led to self harm. The cause appeared to be self esteem be abuse she always felt she didn't achieve her potential. Very well behaved at school and a high performer but not the cleverest. Your comments about the social side also resonate significantly.

Through a private consultant adolescent psychiatrist dd was diagnosed with ADHD, ADD variant. Once medicated she improved in leaps and bounds, aced her A'Levels and has now graduated from a rated Oxbridge College. She was also diagnosed with some asd traits but not sufficient for a diagnosis.

She will always have a tendency to anxiety and depression but can now manage this. She will always be a little quirky. She is in her first job, teaching in an SEN school and looking to do a sponsored PGCE. She would never have been ready for work at 18 and needed a gap year to steady herself and continue recovering.

Re the cleaning up to be perfectly honest I didn't do a hands turn 45 years ago and nor did my mother before me. My hidden haven't either. A combination of staff in my mother's day, dailies in mine and au-pairs and cleaners for my dc have meant that our expectation through the generations have been high in relation to our homes so when we have become responsible for them we have ensured they are maintained to exacting standards. I do a little cleaning and tidying; I wasn't brought up to but neither was I brought up to live in a dirty or untidy home.