Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School residential is religious

321 replies

Stephthegreat · 26/03/2022 20:05

Dcs school is CofE and as there are four faith schools closest to us we sent dcs to the nearest one. Neither me or dh are religious but we support the values of the faith and the school.

The school used to go to a really fab place for residential and it was full of activities, adventuring, just a really fun weekend. Ds is due to go on camp soon and the new residential the school have chosen looks extremely religious. Ds really doesn’t enjoy this side of school and has his own ideas about faith.

The programme involves daily bible study and ‘getting to know jesus’. There are bible related games and quizzes and prayer sessions. It looks like they do bushcraft and have a bonfire too which is up Ds street. He’s a bit put off by the whole idea and I also think it’s quite serious!

AIBU?

OP posts:
WlNDMlLL · 26/03/2022 21:24

@Tillymintpolo

All state schools are not faith
Wasn't me that said it but they are insofar as they must have a daily act of collective worship. It's not like the US where religion must not be mentioned, we are compelled to worship daily.
MadameGazelleBand · 26/03/2022 21:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on the poster's request

GreenBlueRedYellow · 26/03/2022 21:22

These days it's Christian bad, every other religion or belief system good.

Phineyj · 26/03/2022 21:20

It is wrong to spend taxpayers' money on this when most taxpayers aren't religious (or if they are, they're not Christian). I was brought up by atheists and had to sit (politely) through a great many religious assemblies, church services and circle times at youth clubs. I felt very awkward! I would have been astonished to know at the time that this would still be going on 30 years later.

Kokapetl · 26/03/2022 21:19

YANBU

Such a shame that they have let religion ruin what should be a fun experience. I would not send my DC and hope that enough others would do the same that the school will reconsider for future years. With the parents in my DC's class we'd probably send a joint letter expressing our disappointment with the change.

If schools receive any state funding they should not be allowed to push religion on pupils. The system is ridiculous.

There are several towns and villages near us where the only school is a CofE school and sending kids elsewhere would logistically impossible so I sympathise.

saraclara · 26/03/2022 21:18

@Philisophigal

This has to be a joke. No one can be this stupid.
I think you're the one being stupid. You clearly don't understand the history of such schools. They're not faith schools. They're just partially funded by the church and with usually only a light touch involvement with the local parish church.
PollyPutTheKettleOnKettleOn · 26/03/2022 21:18

I think yabu but I don't think you deserve all the criticism you've received. I get the lack of choice of schools in your area as that was the situation I was in growing up.

Don't faith schools still allow some children to skip the assemblies / religious activities if requested by parents?

You also don't need to send him on the residential obviously. But it could be a good exercise in teaching him tolerance of other beliefs...I'm an atheist who finds religion interesting but a lot of my atheist friends have zero patience for hearing anything religious at all. Seems like the opposite of the tolerance they claim to defend tbh Hmm

Kite22 · 26/03/2022 21:17

@Philisophigal

This has to be a joke. No one can be this stupid.
???
saraclara · 26/03/2022 21:15

The ignorance on this thread is astounding. Many local primary schools, especially in rural and semi rural areas are nominally CofE. They're called CofE aided, because as a pp said, there would have been no school in that area without the church funding it. And though we're going back more than 100 years, historically they remain so. I went to one and the kids in the village I grew up in 60 years ago, still do. Their parents would have a hell of a school run to get to a primary school that wasn't.

In general there's barely any religious element to a primary CofE aided school. They're not like RC schools that have religious pictures all over the place and a very religious ethos.

I'm really surprised at the religious element of this trip, and as a parent I'd not be happy.

This is not about people choosing a faith school. It's just the local school. They're not 'faith schools' like RC and Muslim or Jewish schools. They're simply partially funded by the Anglican church due to their history.

So give OP a break with all the "you chose a faith school" bollocks.

MotherOfCrocodiles · 26/03/2022 21:12

Mad replies on here. Of course you aren't required to embrace Christianity or bus your kid out of town to a non church school or move house

All our local schools are c of e or catholic. Almost none of the kids are religious, in fact dds class has more kids who describe the self as Hindu than Christian (and we are in a very white area!)

I strongly feel that all schools should be secular but in the meantime, I'm sending dd to our local school and I would be objecting to a residential like that

ThePenIsBlue · 26/03/2022 21:10

@Stephthegreat

If he comes back converted to tidying his room up I will praise Jesus.
😆😆😆😆
worriedaboutmoney2022 · 26/03/2022 21:09

I guess if you send kids to a faith school regardless of whether there was no alternative or not, then you have to except this sort of thing to occur - your child doesn't have to attend its optional

Theworldisfullofgs · 26/03/2022 21:08

*are CofE

Theworldisfullofgs · 26/03/2022 21:07

If you live I a rural area there is v little choice. The 3 nearest primary schools where we live is CofE
It's unrealistic to say that 'chose another school' for most people in those circumstances

Faith schools have yo be assessed by their diocese as well as ofsted and there has been a push to increase the theological teaching in schools. However, this does sound a bit full on.

Philisophigal · 26/03/2022 21:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Stephthegreat · 26/03/2022 21:05

If he comes back converted to tidying his room up I will praise Jesus.

OP posts:
Leol · 26/03/2022 21:01

Are you worried he will be converted? Surely he has come across religious teaching already and survived with his atheism intact.

Stephthegreat · 26/03/2022 21:00

@ThePenIsBlue

I’m sorry I can’t stop laughing at your username!

Brilliant! No I don’t think he’ll catch anything, who knows he may really love Hesus afterwards.

OP posts:
Stephthegreat · 26/03/2022 20:59

I don’t think Jesus is a bad role model but ds has been totally put off the idea of religion when they did the full Easter story which they taught in a lot of detail. Ds was very young at the time.

I’m sure Jesus was a lovely man. I’m just not sure my ds imagined his school residential worshipping Jesus. Either did I. I’m wondering now if they got a cheaper deal with the church camp and that’s why the school switched from the previous one.

I’ll let ds decide what he wants to do.

OP posts:
UneFoisAuChalet · 26/03/2022 20:58

My son attends the local CoE secondary which is a five minute bike ride for him and the top school in our area. The next is private at £9k per term so I thank my lucky stars everyday we bought a house on the ‘right’ street (my best friend lives literally across on the next street and her daughter didn’t get in) and that his two brothers will also get to attend this amazing school.

They can throw bible studies, religious camps, prayer sessions at them and I wouldn’t give a shit. My boys are/will be getting the best education - for free - at the best school in my neck of the woods.

If I had such an issue with religion, and some of my friends have, then you have the option of putting those schools as your first choice. It’s all about choice. Don’t ask a faith school to go against their remit. If it offends you so much, remove your child. It’s all about choices.

ThePenIsBlue · 26/03/2022 20:57

🤷‍♀️ I remember going to a summer camp with my friend at 15 in the Lake District. It was so religious. I was not religious. It was still the most incredible amount of fun ever. I still remember it fondly and have great memories with it. If didn’t change my faith or affect me negatively in any way. My parents knew it would be religious when they sent me. I actually think it’s quite sad how many parents seem scared of exposing their kids to religion. Do you think they will catch something? 😆

Tapsaffweather · 26/03/2022 20:57

I can understand why your son isn’t keen. If reassuring, I used to volunteer at Scripture Union camps and they were great fun. Bible teaching was a key part of the day but most of the time was spent doing activities (from kayaking & large outdoor games to shopping in town & crafts). I didn’t grow up as a Christian so I hope I was pretty aware of how kids may be feeling if they didn’t have the same belief or lots of questions. The talks and discussions were open and didn’t assume knowledge or faith. I don’t know where your son’s trip is going but if similar to SU Scotland then I think it could still be a lot of fun. It may help him learn about others faith and if the Bible conversation isn’t for him then it will only be part of an otherwise (hopefully) fun and busy few days.

MissyB1 · 26/03/2022 20:57

@Babdoc

I don’t see how it can possibly harm your DS to be educated about his country’s state established religion while having fun activities. Do you think Christ is a bad role model, or there is something wrong with being asked to love our neighbours?
Totally agree. Don’t be silly OP, no harm will come to him and he might actually have fun! Tell him to stop moaning and be positive about the trip. You are probably putting him off.
Laquila · 26/03/2022 20:56

I agree that a lot of people have no idea how limited the options are for some people in terms of school choice. I've encountered a lot of people who think that if they don't have a problem with catchments and lack of choice, then no-one else can either.

I think OP in your shoes I would ask for more info about the planned daily schedule and about who'll be running the activities. And you can't be the only parent apprehensive about it - have you asked around?

StScholastica · 26/03/2022 20:55

Contact the school, explain that you are atheists and that you do not want him taking part in overtly evangelical events. Maybe if enough people feel the same they might be willing yo put on an alternative activity.
Otherwise explain that he is going to learn about what some Christians believe but that as a family, that isn't what you all believe.
It would be a shame for him to miss out entirely though. Also be prepared that often activities like scouts and even Army cadets can often involve an element of worship.