Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘Your mum is fat’

53 replies

Dingalingading · 26/03/2022 12:21

So aibu to not know how to deal with this.

Daughter (10) joined a new school a year ago and generally gets on well with kids and staff. Apart from one it seems. A week ago, ‘I am not coming to your stupid party’ (which I reassured DD was maybe more about the fact that this child does a lot of competitions outside school so couldn’t come because of that) but now this ‘your mum is fat!’. Totally unprompted and DD was

I do know the mum to talk to - tho not well. How do I approach it? I do need to work on my weight - had a baby 9 months ago - but it’s still a shock.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Carpy899 · 26/03/2022 16:45

Kids say horrible things all the time.

YouOKhun · 26/03/2022 16:23

A 10/11 year old knows what is acceptable to say and not say but not always the effect upon someone else. I expect she was casting around for a wounding thing to say to your DD and that was what she drummed up. Personally I might have a quiet word with the school as they might be able to diffuse things. Try and nip this in the bud. Don’t speak to the mother about it.

Who knows whether she is parroting a parent’s comment about your weight specifically or hears one of her parents making remarks about people’s weight in general? You are guessing that it comes from the mother. I think we tend to have a bias about what we think others think based on our own self criticism; it’s that self-criticism you can change. As for the child in question, yes she needs to know it’s not OK to say these things but you need to laugh it off in front of your DD so she can take her cue from you that weight and human value are not correlated.

Bootothegoose · 26/03/2022 16:10

Keep it within school. Contact the teacher and say that these interactions have been taking place and upsetting DD. Let the teacher deal with it.

At home, talk about bullying and instead of going to Mum all guns blazing try to diffuse it.

'Ellie can be quite mean, can't she. She tries to say silly things to upset you because it makes her feel better. We know they're not true...
'Your Mum's fat?'
'Well done Ellie, you've got eyes! I've had a baby - of course, I'm bigger than I was!'

'I'm not coming to your stupid party!'
'She's jealous she couldn't come. Your party wasn't stupid. Didn't we have so much fun!'

If she's getting upset, get her to tell the teacher. If not, get her to reply factually and directly.

'No one wants to be your friend, Emily.'
'Of course they do, you're just trying to upset me.'

'Emily's ugly.'
'That's a really mean thing to say and it's also not true. I've got lovely hair.'

DeeCeeCherry · 26/03/2022 15:52

Notanotherwindow
Just laugh it off. Tell your daughter not to worry about it, its a sad little girl trying to be 'big'

Yep. In the 1st instance.

& OP if bullying escalates don't 2nd guess yourself at all about telling the school to sort it out. ie dont come on here and let anyone talk you out of speaking to the school.

DC was bullied at school I was relentless about getting it sorted. At age 10/11 kids know very well what they should & shouldn't say, theyll just try it on see what they can get away with and Im not having it, even if their precious parents think 'oh its only a child saying stuff '

As if adults dont remember how they were bullied/had mean comments said about their family in their schooldays. Stuff like that impacts.

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 26/03/2022 15:47

It sounds like this is more about YOU then your dd. You need to stop worrying what a 10 year old says about you. You just keep going on about how the little girl is right and you are too fat and now maybe its her mother saying it. I'm fat. It's a descriptive word. If a kid calls me fat (I work with children, so it happens) I just agree with them, because its a fact. If you are bothered by your weight, then you can try to do something about it, but you really need to get thicker skin if a 10 year old is going to upset you so much. Doesnt even seem like its your DD that is upset about it. Only heard about you being upset by it.

Dingalingading · 26/03/2022 15:44

Yes absolutely it has, which this thread has shown me. She kind of shrugged her shoulder and moved on when she realised it hurt me.

OP posts:
EatSleepRantRepeat · 26/03/2022 15:43

Kids used to say this about my parents and their weight problems. As a PP inferred above, I was actually more upset for my parents than myself, and it was the worst form of bullying because I felt I would hurt my parents by talking about it. The main advice I could give would be to reassure your daughter that you really don't care what a ten year old thinks of you - that way she can always come to you if she's been upset by someone. She's at that sensitive age just before puberty where you need to be really careful about what messages you're giving her about weight and self-esteem.

Anotherhealthcondition · 26/03/2022 15:42

[quote BingBangB0ng]@Dingalingading if you’re right that it’s coming from the mum, I just don’t see what confronting her will achieve. She won’t admit it, is unlikely to change her views, and you just show she has power over your feelings.

I really think you shouldn’t give her that.[/quote]
^this. Speaking to the mum is pointless.

Has the comment bothered you more than it’s bothered your DD?

BingBangB0ng · 26/03/2022 15:35

@Dingalingading if you’re right that it’s coming from the mum, I just don’t see what confronting her will achieve. She won’t admit it, is unlikely to change her views, and you just show she has power over your feelings.

I really think you shouldn’t give her that.

Dingalingading · 26/03/2022 15:28

No, I am not saying that she was justified. I am trying to take a message for myself as well - that does not exclude dealing with it for my daughter if I need to.Tho the majority seem to think at this stage just brush it off for her unless more is said, at which point go to the school.

OP posts:
Liverbird77 · 26/03/2022 15:26

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Mummyoflittledragon · 26/03/2022 15:25

If the child keeps on being unkind to your dd, you discuss it with the school. Never with the mum. It will blow up if you try to deal with issues at school in this way.

StaplesCorner · 26/03/2022 15:22

I'm really confused now - so OP you're saying that the child was justified and entirely right to point it out, in account of you actually being fat? That's ok then Hmm

Dingalingading · 26/03/2022 15:20

I care because it’s probably what the mother thinks because to be honest I would be surprised if the child really knew who I was. And for her, yes it will be one of those ‘well she may do x, but she is fat’ people.

And I have never liked being fat - it’s the one thing out of everything (job, finance, family) I never seem to have got a grip of so I don’t like it when my failure is picked on in such a way. As I say, just something I need out clearly.

OP posts:
BingBangB0ng · 26/03/2022 15:20

@MarthaFokker you might not think you look your best but you aren’t the kind of size that has strangers commenting on it. It’s pretty callous to make this thread about you

Ellie56 · 26/03/2022 15:16

I'm a size 10 and at the moment I'm a bit fat. 🤣🤣

Whatever.

CoastalWave · 26/03/2022 15:07

Meh. Kids say things. I really don't understand why you're bothered!

She's picked on the easiest thing. It could have been, Your mum's got big ears, your mum's a weirdo, your mum's ugly.

If you have a little baby weight, yes, you're fat - to a kid.

Who cares what a 10year old thinks??!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/03/2022 15:01

Out of all the crap I had at school, the one thing they couldn't ever get to me about was saying shit about my mother.

'Your Mum's fat'. Why yes, yes she is.

'Your Mum's old'. I know.

'Your Mum's horrible'. OK you don't know the half of it, sunshine.

'You don't have a Dad. You're a bastard'. Uh-huh. That's the technical term for the child of a woman who happily fucked somebody else's husband.

Anyhow, abusive childhood at her hands notwithstanding, what I did notice was that the thing that I didn't particularly care about - my mother - was only tried a couple of times. Naturally, they moved on to things that would bother me instead, but my point is that if they think it doesn't hurt, they don't do it again.

3WildOnes · 26/03/2022 15:00

When my children come and tell me the inking things that their friends have said to them I just say ‘that wasn’t very kind/polite of them’. I try not to give the comments too much importance, kids and teenagers are always going to mean things, they need to learn to brush them off. If they are upset then I’d give them a cuddle and empathise ‘it’s upsetting when our friends aren’t being kind’.

BoredZelda · 26/03/2022 14:56

You have no right to tell me any different because I know my own body. I'm not fat compared to some people but I'm not comparing myself to some people (or to anyone for that matter).

I’ve actually every right to tell you whatever I wish, just as you have a right to respond. Just as you felt you had the right to berate the OP for responding to “are you fat” with her own dress size. Presumably she knows her own body too and can describe it the way she wants to. And actually ot doesn’t matter in this context whether she is overweight or not.

Point is, your response to the OP was completely pointless, was of no help to her in this situation whatsoever and served only for you to be able to tell everyone how very fat you are as a size 10. Take it elsewhere.

BloodyloveGeorge · 26/03/2022 14:52

‘ I'm a size 10 and at the moment I'm a bit fat.

Oh bugger off with this crap.’

Yup! It’s not about you …my work colleague,
A healthy height, weight, exercises, seems to eat well,
Size 10, is always trying to lose 5 pounds, and god is she boring with it. It’s hard not to snap back at her ‘you’re not fat!’ When she bangs on about her ‘belly’ … tho I think the whole office has a some point asked her to STFU about it.

Idroppedthescrewinthetuna · 26/03/2022 14:51

My daughter's response to most things (annoying when said to me) 'did I ask for your input/opinion)
This is usually replied with 'well I gave it anyway'
Her response is 'aww thanks, maybe next time you save it for someone who values what comes out of your mouth'

Works a treat for her.

Another thing she says which again gets pointed towards me sometimes 'aww, you truly believe I care what you think...bless ya'

And one more she does is condescendingly looks you in the eye, gently taps the side of head with her finger and asks 'are you ok, like really, are you alright'

Usually shuts people up.

I know this gives an awful impression of my daughter but honestly although she is a teenager she is very lovely. She just knows how to shut people down quickly.

Notanotherwindow · 26/03/2022 14:49

Just laugh it off. Tell your daughter not to worry about it, its a sad little girl trying to be 'big'

MarthaFokker · 26/03/2022 14:43

@BoredZelda

I'm a size 10 and at the moment I'm a bit fat.

Oh bugger off with this crap.

No I won't bugger off with this crap. My stomach is hanging over my waistband. I am a bit fat. You have no right to tell me any different because I know my own body. I'm not fat compared to some people but I'm not comparing myself to some people (or to anyone for that matter).
BloodyloveGeorge · 26/03/2022 14:29

Ignore it. Kid sounds like a little shit trying to get a reaction so the best thing to do is not react.